CHURCH MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY FOUNDATION INC

Reduce your risk when donating: see where the money actually goes.

Cite this

Plain text CHURCH MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY FOUNDATION INC. furp.org, nonprofit organization profile, tax years 2020–2025. https://furp.org/org/church-mutual-insurance-company-foundation-inc-474690250. Retrieved 2026-11-06.

APA furp.org. (n.d.). CHURCH MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY FOUNDATION INC [Nonprofit organization profile; tax years 2020–2025]. Retrieved November 6, 2026, from https://furp.org/org/church-mutual-insurance-company-foundation-inc-474690250

MLA “CHURCH MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY FOUNDATION INC.” furp.org, tax years 2020–2025, https://furp.org/org/church-mutual-insurance-company-foundation-inc-474690250. Accessed 6 Nov. 2026.

Retrieved 2026-11-06; covers tax years 2020–2025. Data: furp.org, CC BY 4.0.

2025 · Form 990PF · revenue $320K · expenses $472K · assets $172K

Also known as
FOUNDATION INC
EIN
47-4690250
Address
3000 SCHUSTER LN, MERRILL, WI 54452-3863
NTEE code
T20 Private Grantmaking Foundations (Philanthropy, Voluntarism and Grantmaking Foundations) published (IRS Business Master File)
FURP topic
abuse: child · domestic violence · girls boys: boys girls clubs · launch: religious · men: issues · science: research education · shelter: homeless · survivor: suicide · violence: community · women: issues (from its 990 text; the topic index)
Exempt type
501(c)(3): charitable, religious, educational, scientific or literary (corporation)
Ruling date
March 2016 (when the IRS recognized its exemption)
IRS status
Exempt (unconditional) (IRS Business Master File) IRS data ↗
Tax-deductible donations
Yes: listed in IRS Publication 78 (private foundation) Pub 78 ↗
Foundation status
Private non-operating foundation
Cross-check
ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer

Each tax year counts once: when a return was amended, only the latest return for that period is used below (superseded returns stay listed, greyed, under Finances).

People paid by the organization

None of the 33 people listed on these returns reported compensation from the organization. They are listed below.

Officers and directors, no compensation reported

33 people listed on the returns with $0 (or no amount) in every compensation column: current people first. Hours are as filed on the latest return each person appears on.

NameLatest titleYearsHrs/wk (latest)CompensationOrganizations
Alan S Ogilvie PRESIDENT & DIRECTOR2021-2025 0 $0 reported 1
Pamela J Rushing EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT & DIRECTOR2023-2025 0 $0 reported 1
Dwayne A Gantz TREASURER & DIRECTOR2021-2025 0 $0 reported 1
Stephanie I Lynn DIRECTOR2024-2025 0 $0 reported 1
Kevin D Root DIRECTOR2020-2025 0 $0 reported 1
Janet L Selnes DIRECTOR2024-2025 0 $0 reported 1
Pamela W Stampen DIRECTOR2021-2025 0 $0 reported 1
Andrew J Bloechl DIRECTOR2023-2025 0 $0 reported 1
David J Endres SECRETARY & DIRECTOR2025 0 $0 reported 1
Carolyn Schamberger DIRECTOR2025 0 $0 reported 1
Michael M Smith (former) SECRETARY2020-2024 0 $0 reported 1
Elizabeth L Hans (former) FOUNDATION ADMINISTRATOR2020-2024 2 $0 reported 1
Heather A Renzelmann (former) FOUNDATION ADMINISTRATOR2023-2024 2 $0 reported 1
Michael M Smith Beg 1123 (former) SECRETARY2023 0 $0 reported 1
Cynthia M Brandt End 1123 (former) SECRETARY2023 0 $0 reported 1
Alexandra Oles End 423 (former) DIRECTOR2023 0 $0 reported 1
John R Tribble (former) DIRECTOR2023 0 $0 reported 1
Laura E Huggins (former) DIRECTOR2023 0 $0 reported 1
Laurie J Thiel End 1123 (former) DIRECTOR2023 0 $0 reported 1
Neal W Smith End 1123 (former) DIRECTOR2023 0 $0 reported 1
Richard V Poirier (former) DIRECTOR2020-2023 0 $0 reported 1
Robert M Buckley End 1023 (former) DIRECTOR2023 0 $0 reported 1
Scott W Steele End 1023 (former) DIRECTOR2023 0 $0 reported 1
Cynthia M Brandt (former) SECRETARY2020-2022 2 $0 reported 1
Alexandra Oles (former) DIRECTOR2021-2022 0 $0 reported 1
Jeffrey D Steffen End 1122 (former) DIRECTOR2022 0 $0 reported 1
Laurie J Thiel (former) DIRECTOR2020-2022 0 $0 reported 1
Neal W Smith (former) DIRECTOR2022 0 $0 reported 1
Robert M Buckley (former) DIRECTOR2020-2022 0 $0 reported 1
Scott W Steele (former) DIRECTOR2020-2022 0 $0 reported 1
Jeffrey D Steffen (former) DIRECTOR2020-2021 0 $0 reported 1
Angela K Bailey (former) VICE PRESIDENT2020 1 $0 reported 1
Linda L Voelz (former) DIRECTOR2020 2 $0 reported 1

People by year

2025 · 10 people listed · none paid
NameTitleHrs/wkFrom orgFrom relatedOtherTotalOrgs
ALAN S OGILVIE PRESIDENT & DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
PAMELA J RUSHING EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT & DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
DWAYNE A GANTZ TREASURER & DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
DAVID J ENDRES SECRETARY & DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
STEPHANIE I LYNN DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
KEVIN D ROOT DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
JANET L SELNES DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
PAMELA W STAMPEN DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
ANDREW J BLOECHL DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
CAROLYN SCHAMBERGER DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
2024 · 11 people listed · none paid
NameTitleHrs/wkFrom orgFrom relatedOtherTotalOrgs
ALAN S OGILVIE PRESIDENT0 $0-$0 $01
PAMELA J RUSHING EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT0 $0-$0 $01
DWAYNE A GANTZ TREASURER0 $0-$0 $01
MICHAEL M SMITH SECRETARY0 $0-$0 $01
STEPHANIE I LYNN DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
KEVIN D ROOT DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
JANET L SELNES DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
PAMELA W STAMPEN DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
ANDREW J BLOECHL DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
ELIZABETH L HANS FOUNDATION ADMINISTRATOR2 $0-$0 $01
HEATHER A RENZELMANN FOUNDATION ADMINISTRATOR2 $0-$0 $01
2023 · 18 people listed · none paid
NameTitleHrs/wkFrom orgFrom relatedOtherTotalOrgs
ALAN S OGILVIE PRESIDENT0 $0-$0 $01
PAMELA W STAMPEN SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT0 $0-$0 $01
DWAYNE A GANTZ TREASURER0 $0-$0 $01
MICHAEL M SMITH BEG 1123 SECRETARY0 $0-$0 $01
CYNTHIA M BRANDT END 1123 SECRETARY0 $0-$0 $01
ANDREW J BLOECHL DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
ALEXANDRA OLES END 423 DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
JOHN R TRIBBLE DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
KEVIN D ROOT DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
LAURA E HUGGINS DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
LAURIE J THIEL END 1123 DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
NEAL W SMITH END 1123 DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
PAMELA J RUSHING DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
RICHARD V POIRIER DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
ROBERT M BUCKLEY END 1023 DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
SCOTT W STEELE END 1023 DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
ELIZABETH L HANS FOUNDATION ADMINISTRATOR2 $0-$0 $01
HEATHER A RENZELMANN FOUNDATION ADMINISTRATOR2 $0-$0 $01
2022 · 14 people listed · none paid
NameTitleHrs/wkFrom orgFrom relatedOtherTotalOrgs
RICHARD V POIRIER PRESIDENT1 $0-$0 $01
PAMELA W STAMPEN SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT1 $0-$0 $01
DWAYNE A GANTZ TREASURER2 $0-$0 $01
CYNTHIA M BRANDT SECRETARY2 $0-$0 $01
ALAN S OGILVIE DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
ALEXANDRA OLES DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
JEFFREY D STEFFEN END 1122 DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
KEVIN D ROOT DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
LAURIE J THIEL DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
MICHAEL M SMITH DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
NEAL W SMITH DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
ROBERT M BUCKLEY DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
SCOTT W STEELE DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
ELIZABETH L HANS FOUNDATION ADMINISTRATOR3 $0-$0 $01
2021 · 13 people listed · none paid
NameTitleHrs/wkFrom orgFrom relatedOtherTotalOrgs
RICHARD V POIRIER PRESIDENT1 $0-$0 $01
PAMELA W STAMPEN SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT2 $0-$0 $01
DWAYNE A GANTZ TREASURER2 $0-$0 $01
CYNTHIA M BRANDT SECRETARY2 $0-$0 $01
ROBERT M BUCKLEY DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
ALAN S OGILVIE DIRECTOR1 $0-$0 $01
ALEXANDRA OLES DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
KEVIN D ROOT DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
MICHAEL M SMITH DIRECTOR2 $0-$0 $01
SCOTT W STEELE DIRECTOR3 $0-$0 $01
JEFFREY D STEFFEN DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
LAURIE J THIEL DIRECTOR0 $0-$0 $01
ELIZABETH L HANS FOUNDATION ADMINISTRATOR5 $0-$0 $01
2020 · 11 people listed · none paid
NameTitleHrs/wkFrom orgFrom relatedOtherTotalOrgs
RICHARD V POIRIER PRESIDENT1 $0-$0 $01
JEFFREY D STEFFEN TREASURER2 $0-$0 $01
ANGELA K BAILEY VICE PRESIDENT1 $0-$0 $01
CYNTHIA M BRANDT SECRETARY3 $0-$0 $01
ROBERT M BUCKLEY DIRECTOR2 $0-$0 $01
MICHAEL M SMITH DIRECTOR2 $0-$0 $01
SCOTT W STEELE DIRECTOR2 $0-$0 $01
KEVIN D ROOT DIRECTOR2 $0-$0 $01
LAURIE J THIEL DIRECTOR2 $0-$0 $01
LINDA L VOELZ DIRECTOR2 $0-$0 $01
ELIZABETH L HANS FOUNDATION ADMINISTRATOR2 $0-$0 $01

Highest-paid independent contractors

No independent contractors reported.

Other organizations that listed this one among their highest-paid independent contractors. Contractor lists give no EIN, so these are matched on name and address; check the filing.

YearPaid byServicePaidFiling
2018CAZENOVIA RECOVERY SYSTEMS INC$228,773view vendor page

Who the money went to

Grants this organization reported paying: Schedule I Part II of the Form 990, or the grants-paid list on the 990-PF. Open a year for every recipient. Recipients link to their own page when the grant names an EIN we have (990-PF grants list no EIN, so those link only on an exact, unique name and state). Grants to individuals are counted; their names are not shown.

2025 · 256 grants to organizations · $464K
2024 · 192 grants to organizations · $431K
2023 · 194 grants to organizations · $643K
2022 · 167 grants to organizations · $485K
2021 · 193 grants to organizations · $708K · 1 returned · -$8K
2020 · 701 grants to organizations · $1.0M

Negative amounts are returned or refunded grants; they are listed last and left out of the totals of grants paid.

Who gave

Contributors listed on Schedule B of the Form 990-PF: name, city and state as filed (street addresses are not shown), with total and noncash contributions for the year. A link to an organization's page is tagged Fuzzy with its name-similarity score (0 to 1) when it rests on name and state; Schedule B lists no EIN, so no link here is an exact identifier match.

2025 · 1 contributor · $305K
#ContributorTypeCity, stateTotalNoncashSource
1 CHURCH MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY SI Organization or other MERRILL, WI $305,000- Form 990PF Sch. B, 2025 · filing
2024 · 1 contributor · $250K
#ContributorTypeCity, stateTotalNoncashSource
1 CHURCH MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY SI Organization or other MERRILL, WI $250,000- Form 990PF Sch. B, 2024 · filing
2023 · 1 contributor · $250K
#ContributorTypeCity, stateTotalNoncashSource
1 CHURCH MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY SI Organization or other MERRILL, WI $250,000- Form 990PF Sch. B, 2023 · filing
2022 · 1 contributor · $1.1M
#ContributorTypeCity, stateTotalNoncashSource
1 CHURCH MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY SI Organization or other MERRILL, WI $1,140,000- Form 990PF Sch. B, 2022 · filing
2021 · 1 contributor · $1.0M
#ContributorTypeCity, stateTotalNoncashSource
1 CHURCH MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY SI Organization or other MERRILL, WI $1,000,000- Form 990PF Sch. B, 2021 · filing
2020 · 1 contributor · $402K
#ContributorTypeCity, stateTotalNoncashSource
1 CHURCH MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY SI Organization or other MERRILL, WI $402,500- Form 990PF Sch. B, 2020 · filing

Contributors listed here are as reported on the filing. Unusual is not the same as improper. Many of these patterns have ordinary explanations. Check the filing.

Finances

Newest first. Each filing: its name on one row, its figures on the row beneath. Greyed filings are superseded by a later return for the same period and are left out everywhere else on this page.

RevenueExpensesAssetsNet assetsContributionsProgram revenueOfficer payEmployeesVolunteers
2025 · Form 990PF period ending 2025-12-31 · view filing · original 990 ↗
$319,680$472,191 $172,197$172,197 $305,000- $0--
2024 · Form 990PF period ending 2024-12-31 · view filing · original 990 ↗
$268,936$441,787 $324,708$324,708 $250,000- $0--
2023 · Form 990PF period ending 2023-12-31 · view filing · original 990 ↗
$277,815$683,872 $497,559$497,559 $250,000- $0--
2022 · Form 990PF period ending 2022-12-31 · view filing · original 990 ↗
$1,146,657$587,621 $903,616$903,616 $1,140,000- $0--
2021 · Form 990PF period ending 2021-12-31 · view filing · original 990 ↗
$1,000,030$797,036 $344,580$344,580 $1,000,000- $0--
2020 · Form 990PF period ending 2020-12-31 · view filing · original 990 ↗
$405,267$1,170,273 $141,586$141,586 $402,500- $0--

Funders of this organization

Not reported: no grants to this organization appear in the filings we have (tax years 2010 to 2025).

Nearby + Similar BETA

Organizations like this one: what they do and who they are linked to

Same category: NTEE code and revenue

Ranked without any AI: same NTEE code first, then the same NTEE group; then revenue within 2x, 5x or 10x; then the same state; then similar name and mission text. Same state only · More (100)

OrganizationStateNTEELatest revenueLatest expensesTop-paid titleTop payWhy similar
EVERGREEN FOUNDATION INCWIT20 $338,488$334,066 TREASURER$0 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x, same state
PYLE FOUNDATIONWIT20 $339,476$244,589 TRUSTEE$0 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x, same state
TRICORD FOUNDATIONWIT20 $300,763$513,219 VICE PRESIDENT$0 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x, same state
JANET M JOHNSTON FOUNDATIONWIT20 $315,930$373,344 TRUSTEE$60,520 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x, same state
KATHERINE AND JOHN DAVIS FAMILY FOUNDATION INCWIT20 $342,003$321,938 PRESIDENT, SECRETARY$0 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x, same state
FRANK AND LUCILLE PUNCER FOUNDATION LTDWIT20 $320,927$690,115 TREASURER$18,000 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x, same state
DARREL AND AUDREY WEBER FOUNDATIONWIT20 $313,154$53,370 TRUSTEE$0 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x, same state
GUY B RENO FAMILY FOUNDATION 43-1721-01-8WIT20 $326,318$379,267 TRUSTEE$40,458 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x, same state
SHAWANO COUNTY JOB CENTER INCWIT20 $323,039$139,105 BOARD PRESID$18,960 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x, same state
ANDREW F & EDITH M BELL CH TRWIT20 $325,214$97,884 TRUSTEE$25,779 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x, same state
DOROTHY C KRAWCZYK SCHOLARSHIP TRWIT20 $309,336$318,548 TRUSTEE$30,766 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x, same state
MGW FOUNDATION INCNYT20 $320,000$305,375 PRESIDENT$0 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x
CROEN FOUNDATION INCFLT20 $319,284$291,120 PRESIDENT, TREASURER, DIRE$0 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x
FLOW COMPANIES FOUNDATIONNCT20 $335,450$206,530 President$0 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x
MEYER FOUNDATION INCTXT20 $335,544$251,754 SECRETARY/TREASURER$0 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x
MAEVE FOUNDATION INCNJT20 $343,876$148,337 TRUSTEE/TREASURER$0 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x
ACE CHARITABLE FOUNDATION INCNYT20 $300,507$46,014 Director$0 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x
MERLIN FOUNDATION INCMTT20 $307,906$441,287 Chairman$0 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x
A & F FOUNDATION INCCTT20 $339,000$285,892 CHAIR$0 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x
EYA FOUNDATION INCMDT20 $322,597$7,200 DIRECTOR$0 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x
460 FOUNDATION INCCTT20 $316,107$105,901 PRESIDENT &$0 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x
NCM FOUNDATION INCGAT20 $340,968$133,723 OFFICER$0 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x
DIME FOUNDATION INCNYT20 $321,835$363,503 Chairman of Board and President$0 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x
FERRO FOUNDATION INCNYT20 $339,597$393,216 BOARD MEMBER$0 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x
TOSE FOUNDATION INCMDT20 $340,288$306,696 President$0 Same NTEE code T20, revenue within 2x

Who funds organizations like this

Grantors that funded the 100 most similar organizations. Ranked by total given to them. Foundations (990-PF) and donor-advised fund sponsors only. Same matching as Funders above (by EIN, or by name for foundations).

GrantorTypeTotal givenGrantsOrganizations fundedYearsWhich ones
EVERGREEN MANOR PERMANENT ENDOWMENT TRUST Private foundation$305,3664 12021–2024 EVERGREEN FOUNDATION INC
THE OJC FUND DAF sponsor$294,2456 12019–2024 REISMAN FAMILY FOUNDATION INC
GREATER WASHINGTON COMMUNITY FOUNDATION DAF sponsor$150,0001 12024–2024 EYA FOUNDATION INC
PAYPAL CHARITABLE GIVING FUND DAF sponsor$93,0961 12024–2024 FERRO FOUNDATION INC
FIDELITY INVESTMENTS CHARITABLE GIFT FUND DAF sponsor$40,2503 12016–2020 XAVIER FOUNDATION INC
DONOR ADVISED CHARITABLE GIVING DAF sponsor$12,8501 12015–2015 XAVIER FOUNDATION INC
MIGHTYCAUSE CHARITABLE FOUNDATION DAF sponsor$10,6852 12011–2012 XAVIER FOUNDATION INC
THE SEATTLE FOUNDATION DAF sponsor$8,7505 12014–2014 XAVIER FOUNDATION INC
EQUITABLE FOUNDATION INC Private foundation$2,0001 12024–2024 FERRO FOUNDATION INC
BANK OF AMERICA CHARITABLE FOUNDATION INC Private foundation$1,1003 12013–2017 XAVIER FOUNDATION INC
MEH FAMILY FOUNDATION INC Private foundation$7201 12020–2020 REISMAN FAMILY FOUNDATION INC
ALBERT AND JUDITH GOLDBERG FOUNDATION Private foundation$5001 12024–2024 ATJ FAMILY FOUNDATION INC
JPMORGAN CHASE FOUNDATION Private foundation$1501 12015–2015 XAVIER FOUNDATION INC
AMAZONSMILE FOUNDATION Private foundation$953 12021–2023 REISMAN FAMILY FOUNDATION INC

The full list · all similar organizations

Where the money went

Every expense line on each return, biggest first: Form 990 Part IX (with its program, management and fundraising columns), 990-EZ Part I, or 990-PF Part I. Event marks lines the organization itself describes as events. “Events” in each summary adds those lines, conferences and meetings, and the direct costs of fundraising events. Unusual is not the same as improper. Many of these patterns have ordinary explanations. Check the filing.

2025 · Form 990PF · $472,191 spent · pay $0 · grants $462,812 · events $0
LineAs describedTotalShare
Contributions, gifts, grants paid $462,812 98.0%
Other expenses $4,679 1.0%
Fees: accounting $3,950 0.8%
Taxes $750 0.2%
Total$472,191100%

View the filing

2024 · Form 990PF · $441,787 spent · pay $0 · grants $430,331 · events $0
LineAs describedTotalShare
Contributions, gifts, grants paid $430,331 97.4%
Other expenses $6,756 1.5%
Fees: accounting $3,950 0.9%
Taxes $750 0.2%
Total$441,787100%

View the filing

2023 · Form 990PF · $683,872 spent · pay $0 · grants $640,375 · events $0
LineAs describedTotalShare
Contributions, gifts, grants paid $640,375 93.6%
Fees: other professional $35,381 5.2%
Fees: accounting $3,975 0.6%
Other expenses $2,700 0.4%
Printing and publications $1,441 0.2%
Total$683,872100%

View the filing

2022 · Form 990PF · $587,621 spent · pay $0 · grants $485,308 · events $0
LineAs describedTotalShare
Contributions, gifts, grants paid $485,308 82.6%
Fees: other professional $90,945 15.5%
Printing and publications $5,564 0.9%
Fees: accounting $3,975 0.7%
Other expenses $1,829 0.3%
Total$587,621100%

View the filing

2021 · Form 990PF · $797,036 spent · pay $0 · grants $700,156 · events $0
LineAs describedTotalShare
Contributions, gifts, grants paid $700,156 87.8%
Fees: other professional $91,235 11.4%
Fees: accounting $3,975 0.5%
Other expenses $1,670 0.2%
Total$797,036100%

View the filing

2020 · Form 990PF · $1,170,273 spent · pay $0 · grants $1,005,301 · events $0
LineAs describedTotalShare
Contributions, gifts, grants paid $1,005,301 85.9%
Fees: other professional $161,069 13.8%
Fees: accounting $2,175 0.2%
Other expenses $1,728 0.1%
Total$1,170,273100%

View the filing

Comments

Anonymous: no account or email. Up to 2,000 characters, at most one link. Comments are checked automatically; some wait for review.