12TRIBE FILMS FOUNDATION
Reduce your risk when donating: see where the money actually goes.
Reduce your risk when donating: see where the money actually goes.
Cite this
Plain text 12TRIBE FILMS FOUNDATION. furp.org, nonprofit organization profile, tax years 2020–2025. https://furp.org/org/12tribe-films-foundation-208683997. Retrieved 2026-11-18.
APA furp.org. (n.d.). 12TRIBE FILMS FOUNDATION [Nonprofit organization profile; tax years 2020–2025]. Retrieved November 18, 2026, from https://furp.org/org/12tribe-films-foundation-208683997
MLA “12TRIBE FILMS FOUNDATION.” furp.org, tax years 2020–2025, https://furp.org/org/12tribe-films-foundation-208683997. Accessed 18 Nov. 2026.
Retrieved 2026-11-18; covers tax years 2020–2025. Data: furp.org (index © the FURP Alliance; the records are public domain).
2025 · Form 990 · revenue $388K · expenses $401K · assets $25K
- EIN
- 20-8683997
- Address
- 11 RIVERSIDE DR APT 4NW, NEW YORK, NY 10023-2697
- NTEE code
- B12 Fund Raising and/or Fund Distribution (Education) published (IRS Business Master File)
- Exempt type
- 501(c)(3): charitable, religious, educational, scientific or literary (corporation)
- Ruling date
- June 2019 (when the IRS recognized its exemption)
- IRS status
- Exempt (unconditional) (IRS Business Master File) IRS data ↗
- Tax-deductible donations
- Yes: listed in IRS Publication 78 (public charity) Pub 78 ↗
- Foundation status
- Public charity supported by the public (170(b)(1)(a)(vi))
- Principal officer
- AVI ABELOW (its 2019 Form 990-N)
- Form 990-N e-postcards
- 1 filed, 2019 (organizations with gross receipts normally $50,000 or less file this instead of a full Form 990) IRS data ↗
- Cross-check
- ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer
Mission
Production of Educational videos.
Each tax year counts once: when a return was amended, only the latest return for that period is used below (superseded returns stay listed, greyed, under Finances).
People paid by the organization
1 person paid across every filing: current people first, then by total pay from this organization. Organizations counts every nonprofit each person appears on.
| Name | Latest title | Years | Latest year pay | Total pay from here | Organizations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Avi Abelow | Board Member | 2020-2025 | $32,800 | $46,571 | 1 |
Officers and directors, no compensation reported
3 people listed on the returns with $0 (or no amount) in every compensation column: current people first. Hours are as filed on the latest return each person appears on.
| Name | Latest title | Years | Hrs/wk (latest) | Compensation | Organizations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| David Sheer | Board Member | 2020-2025 | 1 | $0 reported | 1 |
| Charles Sheer | Board Member | 2021-2025 | 1 | $0 reported | 1 |
| J Dale Debber (former) | Board Member | 2020 | 1 | $0 reported | 1 |
People by year
2025 · 3 people listed · 1 paid, $33K · 0 employees
| Name | Title | Hrs/wk | From org | From related | Other | Total | Orgs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Avi Abelow | Board Member | 1 | $32,800 | $0 | $0 | $32,800 | 1 |
| David Sheer | Board Member | 1 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | 1 |
| Charles Sheer | Board Member | 1 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | 1 |
2024 · 3 people listed · 1 paid, $14K · 0 employees
| Name | Title | Hrs/wk | From org | From related | Other | Total | Orgs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Avi Abelow | Board Member | 1 | $13,771 | $0 | $0 | $13,771 | 1 |
| David Sheer | Board Member | 1 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | 1 |
| Charles Sheer | Board Member | 1 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | 1 |
2023 · 3 people listed · none paid · 0 employees
| Name | Title | Hrs/wk | From org | From related | Other | Total | Orgs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Charles Sheer | Board Member | 1 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | 1 |
| David Sheer | Board Member | 1 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | 1 |
| Avi Abelow | Board Member | 1 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | 1 |
2022 · 3 people listed · none paid · 0 employees
| Name | Title | Hrs/wk | From org | From related | Other | Total | Orgs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AVI ABELOW | Board Member | 1 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | 1 |
| DAVID SHEER | Board Member | 1 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | 1 |
| CHARLES SHEER | Board Member | 1 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | 1 |
2021 · 3 people listed · none paid · 0 employees
| Name | Title | Hrs/wk | From org | From related | Other | Total | Orgs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AVI ABELOW | Board Member | 1 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | 1 |
| DAVID SHEER | Board Member | 1 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | 1 |
| CHARLES SHEER | Board Member | 1 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | 1 |
2020 · 3 people listed · none paid · 0 employees
| Name | Title | Hrs/wk | From org | From related | Other | Total | Orgs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AVI ABELOW | Board Member | 1 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | 1 |
| DAVID SHEER | Board Member | 1 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | 1 |
| J DALE DEBBER | Board Member | 1 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | 1 |
Highest-paid independent contractors
No independent contractors reported.
Who gave
Contributor names are not public for this form type.
Public charities filing Form 990 or 990-EZ report large donors on Schedule B, but the IRS withholds their names and addresses from public copies. Private foundations (990-PF) are different: their contributors are public.
Finances
Newest first. Each filing: its name on one row, its figures on the row beneath. Greyed filings are superseded by a later return for the same period and are left out everywhere else on this page.
| Revenue | Expenses | Assets | Net assets | Contributions | Program revenue | Officer pay | Employees | Volunteers |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 · Form 990 | ||||||||
| $388,216 | $401,101 | $25,043 | $24,631 | $388,216 | $0 | $32,800 | 0 | - |
| 2024 · Form 990 | ||||||||
| $418,314 | $425,844 | $47,516 | $34,944 | $418,314 | $0 | $13,771 | 0 | - |
| 2023 · Form 990 | ||||||||
| $392,290 | $363,585 | $43,094 | $42,474 | $392,290 | $0 | $0 | 0 | - |
| 2022 · Form 990 | ||||||||
| $164,142 | $168,052 | $16,244 | $13,769 | $164,142 | $0 | - | 0 | - |
| 2021 · Form 990 | ||||||||
| $118,252 | $113,945 | $21,786 | $18,699 | $118,252 | $0 | - | 0 | - |
| 2020 · Form 990 | ||||||||
| $134,059 | $119,994 | $27,132 | $14,422 | $133,729 | $0 | - | 0 | - |
Funders of this organization
5 grantors reported grants to this organization, $718,344 in all, tax years 2019 to 2025. Exact: the grantor wrote this organization's EIN. Fuzzy: the grantor wrote only a name (foundations' 990-PF has no EIN field), matched to the same or a near-identical name in the same state; the name as filed is shown. From the latest return for each grantor and year, so amended returns aren't counted twice. CSV
| Grantor | Total given | Grants | Latest year's amount | Latest year | Years given | Type | Match | Grants |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FIDELITY INVESTMENTS CHARITABLE GIFT FUND | $378,214 | 5 | $127,254 | 2024 | 2019, 2021-2024 | DAF sponsor | Exact | show |
| DONOR ADVISED CHARITABLE GIVING | $180,450 | 5 | $50,100 | 2023 | 2019-2023 | DAF sponsor | Exact | show |
| JEWISH LITERACY FOUNDATION INC | $138,500 | 4 | $31,000 | 2025 | 2022-2025 | Public charity | Exact | show |
| DVASH INC | $18,180 | 1 | $18,180 | 2022 | 2022 | Public charity | Exact | show |
| JOSEPH & FLORENCE MANDEL FAMILY FOUNDATION - WEINBERG FAMILY FUND | $3,000 | 2 | $1,500 | 2024 | 2023-2024 | Private foundation | Fuzzy filed as “12Tribe Films Foundation” | show |
Nearby + Similar BETA
Organizations like this one: what they do and who they are linked to
Same category: NTEE code and revenue
Ranked without any AI: same NTEE code first, then the same NTEE group; then revenue within 2x, 5x or 10x; then the same state; then similar name and mission text. NTEE: the IRS’s code when it lists one, otherwise FURP’s inferred code. Same state only · More (100)
| Organization | State | NTEE | Latest revenue | Latest expenses | Top-paid title | Top pay | Why similar |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GONVILLE & CAIUS COLLEGE-THE CAIUS FOUNDATION | NY | B12 | $631,014 | $623,376 | RESIGNED '24 | $0 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| MAX ALEXANDER FOUNDATION | NY | B12 | $412,448 | $422,339 | PRESIDENT | $0 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| ABANA FOUNDATION INC | NY | B12 | $499,503 | $288,730 | Director | $0 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| LASALLE SCHOOL FOUNDATION | NY | B12 | $466,369 | $618,041 | EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR | $229,346 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| XAVIER FOUNDATION | NY | B12 | $305,000 | $354,340 | SECRETARY | $539,547 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| C G JUNG FOUNDATION FOR ANALYTICAL PSYCHOLOGY INC | NY | B12 | $297,880 | $301,485 | EXECUTIVE DI | $101,331 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| WESTMINSTER SCHOOL FOUNDATION | NY | B12 | $624,713 | $222,673 | DIRECTOR | $0 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| FRIENDS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF STELLENBOSCH FOUNDATION | NY | B12 | $386,260 | $484,365 | RESIGNED '25 | $0 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| TSB FOUNDATION INC | NY | B12 | $247,922 | $115,953 | PRESIDENT | $0 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| SCARSDALE SCHOOLS EDUCATION FOUNDATION | NY | B12 | $663,817 | $2,335,650 | EXECUTIVE DI | $50,000 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| BLOCK INSTITUTE FOUNDATION INC | NY | B12 | $658,385 | $117,871 | EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR | $507,209 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| WOMENS AMERICAN ORT FOUNDATION | NY | B12 | $674,916 | $346,299 | CONTROLLER | $184,784 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| RYE FUND FOR EDUCATION | NY | B12 | $636,030 | $546,051 | VP MARKET/COMM | $0 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| SOUND FOUNDATIONS OF ROCHESTER INC | NY | B12 | $574,930 | $635,276 | CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER | $187,146 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| NIGERIA HIGHER EDUCATION FOUNDATION INC | NY | B12 | $353,294 | $346,826 | DIRECTOR | $0 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| MARIST BROTHERS CENTER AT ESOPUS FOUNDATION | NY | B12 | $337,911 | $5,411 | PRESIDENT | $0 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| FOUNDATION FOR VISION REHABILITATION AND EMPLOYMENT | NY | B12 | $389,030 | $806,085 | President & CEO | $299,793 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| AMERICAN ALBANIAN EDUCATION FOUNDATION | NY | B12 | $252,469 | $0 | Director | $0 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| LT MICHAEL P MURPHY USN MEMORIAL SCHOLARSHIP FOUNDATION | NY | B12 | $237,559 | $198,275 | CHAIRMAN, BOARD OF DIRECTORS | $0 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| EASTSIDE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL PS 267 PARENT TEACHER ASSOCIATION | NY | B12 | $318,483 | $328,992 | President | $0 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| AMERICAN FRIENDS OF VSHACHANTI | NY | B12 | $452,345 | $388,071 | President | $0 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| AMERICAN FRIENDS OF SHLAVIM | NY | B12 | $373,887 | $410,050 | TREASURER | $0 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| JOHN AND MARGARET SINCLAIREFOUNDATION INC | NY | B12 | $403,721 | $236,280 | PRESIDENT | $0 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| FRIENDS OF UTOKYO INC | NY | B12 | $531,580 | $311,638 | PRESIDENT, C | $0 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
| ALBANIAN AMERICAN WOMENS ORGANIZATION MOTRAT QIRIAZI INC | NY | B12 | $233,495 | $391,765 | Director | $0 | Same NTEE code B12, revenue within 2x, same state |
Who funds organizations like this
Grantors that funded the 100 most similar organizations. Ranked by total given to them. Foundations (990-PF) and donor-advised fund sponsors only. Same matching as Funders above (by EIN, or by name for foundations).
The full list · all similar organizations
Where the money went
Every expense line on each return, biggest first: Form 990 Part IX (with its program, management and fundraising columns), 990-EZ Part I, or 990-PF Part I. Event marks lines the organization itself describes as events. “Events” in each summary adds those lines, conferences and meetings, and the direct costs of fundraising events. Unusual is not the same as improper. Many of these patterns have ordinary explanations. Check the filing.
2025 · Form 990 · $401,101 spent · pay $32,800 · grants $36,059 · events $0
| Line | As described | Total | Program | Management | Fundraising | Share |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Information technology | $234,914 | $234,914 | - | - | 58.6% | |
| Fees: other services | $44,426 | - | $44,426 | - | 11.1% | |
| Grants outside the US | $36,059 | $36,059 | - | - | 9.0% | |
| Other employee benefits | $32,800 | - | $32,800 | - | 8.2% | |
| Travel | $29,413 | - | $29,413 | - | 7.3% | |
| Advertising and promotion | $10,684 | - | $10,684 | - | 2.7% | |
| Other (as described) | Mission Expenses | $10,595 | $10,595 | - | - | 2.6% |
| Other (as described) | Miscelaneous | $1,410 | - | $1,410 | - | 0.4% |
| Fees: accounting | $800 | - | $800 | - | 0.2% | |
| Total | $401,101 | 100% |
2024 · Form 990 · $425,844 spent · pay $13,771 · grants $52,596 · events $11,802
| Line | As described | Total | Program | Management | Fundraising | Share |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Information technology | $262,387 | $262,387 | - | - | 61.6% | |
| Grants outside the US | $52,596 | $52,596 | - | - | 12.4% | |
| Fees: other services | $37,943 | - | $37,943 | - | 8.9% | |
| Travel | $21,911 | - | $21,911 | - | 5.1% | |
| Other salaries and wages | $13,771 | - | $13,771 | - | 3.2% | |
| Conferences, conventions and meetings | $11,802 | $11,802 | - | - | 2.8% | |
| Advertising and promotion | $10,559 | - | $10,559 | - | 2.5% | |
| Other (as described) | Commissions | $5,275 | - | $5,275 | - | 1.2% |
| Occupancy | $4,665 | - | $4,665 | - | 1.1% | |
| Other (as described) | Miscelaneous | $2,455 | - | $2,455 | - | 0.6% |
| Other (as described) | Business Registration Fees | $1,680 | - | $1,680 | - | 0.4% |
| Fees: accounting | $800 | - | $800 | - | 0.2% | |
| Total | $425,844 | 100% |
2023 · Form 990 · $363,585 spent · pay $0 · grants $72,978 · events $30,033
| Line | As described | Total | Program | Management | Fundraising | Share |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Information technology | $224,603 | $224,603 | - | - | 61.8% | |
| Grants outside the US | $72,978 | $72,978 | - | - | 20.1% | |
| Conferences, conventions and meetings | $30,033 | $30,033 | - | - | 8.3% | |
| Fees: other services | $19,850 | - | $19,850 | - | 5.5% | |
| Travel | $7,522 | - | $7,522 | - | 2.1% | |
| Occupancy | $3,272 | - | $3,272 | - | 0.9% | |
| Other (as described) | Service Fees | $2,919 | - | $2,919 | - | 0.8% |
| Other (as described) | Business Expenses | $1,658 | - | $1,658 | - | 0.5% |
| Fees: accounting | $750 | - | $750 | - | 0.2% | |
| Total | $363,585 | 100% |
2022 · Form 990 · $168,052 spent · pay $0 · grants $41,359 · events $0
| Line | As described | Total | Program | Management | Fundraising | Share |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Information technology | $106,800 | $106,800 | - | - | 63.6% | |
| Grants outside the US | $41,359 | $41,359 | - | - | 24.6% | |
| Other (as described) | Outside Contract Services | $13,297 | - | $13,297 | - | 7.9% |
| Other (as described) | Business Expenses | $4,484 | - | $4,484 | - | 2.7% |
| Other (as described) | Miscellaneous | $1,362 | - | $1,362 | - | 0.8% |
| Fees: accounting | $750 | - | $750 | - | 0.4% | |
| Total | $168,052 | 100% |
2021 · Form 990 · $113,945 spent · pay $0 · grants $16,038 · events $0
| Line | As described | Total | Program | Management | Fundraising | Share |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Information technology | $84,319 | $84,319 | - | - | 74.0% | |
| Grants outside the US | $16,038 | $16,038 | - | - | 14.1% | |
| Other (as described) | CONTRACT SERVICES | $12,790 | - | $12,790 | - | 11.2% |
| Fees: accounting | $750 | - | $750 | - | 0.7% | |
| Other (as described) | BANK FEES | $48 | - | $48 | - | 0.0% |
| Total | $113,945 | 100% |
2020 · Form 990 · $119,994 spent · pay $0 · grants $52,399 · events $0
| Line | As described | Total | Program | Management | Fundraising | Share |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Grants outside the US | $52,399 | $52,399 | - | - | 43.7% | |
| Information technology | $23,030 | $23,030 | - | - | 19.2% | |
| Other (as described) | CONTRACT SERVICES | $21,768 | - | $21,768 | - | 18.1% |
| Other (as described) | PROJECT FEES | $21,000 | $21,000 | - | - | 17.5% |
| All other expenses | $943 | - | $943 | - | 0.8% | |
| Other (as described) | BANK FEES | $469 | - | $469 | - | 0.4% |
| Other (as described) | CREDIT CARD FEES | $385 | - | $385 | - | 0.3% |
| Total | $119,994 | 100% |
State business registration
- 12TRIBE FILMS FOUNDATION NY, FOREIGN NOT-FOR-PROFIT CORPORATION, Active, formed 2008-08-05
The same business name in the same state, from the state’s official registry data.
Also on this site Fuzzy
| Record | Name as filed | Where | Dataset | Matched by |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Business registration | 12TRIBE FILMS FOUNDATION | NY | State business registries | name and state |
Matched by an identifier (EIN, CIK, CRD), by name and state or city, or by street address; a shared name or address is not proof of the same person or organization. Every link says how it was made; how the cross-referencing works.
Others with the same interests
NTEE code Fund Raising and/or Fund Distribution, NY first:
- JACK ARTUSO FOUNDATION NY
- EAST SYRACUSE-MINOA SPARTAN MARCHING BAND-WINTER GUARD BOOSTER NY
- CHILDRENS LEARNING FOUNDATION INC NY
- MCCARTON FOUNDATION FOR DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES INC NY
- WESTON T HYDE OSWEGO COUNTY EDUCATIONAL FOUNDATION NY
- NIAGARA FALLS EDUCATION FOUNDATION INC NY
- FRIENDS OF PERIMETER INSTITUTE INC NY
- COMPREHENSIVE ACTION MODEL FOR PEEKSKILL INC NY
- THE DIMENNA FOUNDATION INC NY
- DIAGEO NORTH AMERICA FOUNDATION INC NY
In other datasets, the same topic (Education) in NY:
- Lobbying client: ACELERO LEARNING (Federal lobbying (LDA))
Interests: Fund Raising and/or Fund Distribution · Education
The area Census
County outline, the place (blue), the tract (orange) and the ZIP center (dot).
In Census Tract 143, New York County, New York, place (city or town) New York, NY, county New York County, NY, state New York; placed by its ZIP code (county and tract) and city name (place). The tract is the tract holding most of the record's ZIP code (FURP does not geocode street addresses).
- Avi Abelow was paid $32,800, 0.4 times the median household income in New York, NY ($80,483), where 17.9% of residents live in poverty.
- Revenue of $388,216 is $0 per resident of New York, NY (population 8,483,844).
- That revenue equals 0.00% of all household income in New York, NY (3,334,088 households at the median $80,483, about $268,337,404,504).
| Measure | Census tract Census Tract 143, New York County, New York | Place (city or town) New York, NY | County New York County, NY | State New York |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Population B01003 | 0 | 8,483,844 | 1,629,477 | 19,852,366 |
| Population, 2020 census P1 | 129 | 8,804,190 | 1,694,251 | 20,201,249 |
| Median age B01002 | -666666666.0 | 38.2 | 38.9 | 39.8 |
| Under 18 B01001 | - | 20.2% | 13.9% | 20.5% |
| 65 and over B01001 | - | 16.6% | 18.1% | 17.9% |
| Households B11001 | 0 | 3,334,088 | 778,281 | 7,722,646 |
| Foreign born B05002 | - | 36.6% | 28.2% | 22.8% |
| Median household income B19013 | $-666,666,666 | $80,483 | $103,931 | $85,974 |
| Median family income B19113 | $-666,666,666 | $91,707 | $139,097 | $106,873 |
| Per capita income B19301 | $-666,666,666 | $51,844 | $95,980 | $50,712 |
| Poverty rate B17001 | - | 17.9% | 16.5% | 14.0% |
| Unemployment rate B23025 | - | 8.0% | 7.6% | 6.4% |
| Civilian labor force B23025 | 0 | 4,392,297 | 949,329 | 10,171,766 |
| Mean commute (minutes) B08013 | - | 40.3 | 31.2 | 32.6 |
| Bachelor's degree or higher B15003 | - | 41.6% | 64.2% | 40.2% |
| Housing units B25001 | 0 | 3,678,486 | 923,472 | 8,585,241 |
| Owner-occupied B25003 | - | 32.8% | 25.1% | 54.3% |
| Renters B25003 | - | 67.2% | 74.9% | 45.7% |
| Median home value B25077 | $-666,666,666 | $777,600 | $1,090,500 | $423,800 |
| Median gross rent B25064 | $-666,666,666 | $1,821 | $2,197 | $1,621 |
| White, not Hispanic B03002 | - | 31.0% | 45.5% | 52.8% |
| Black B03002 | - | 20.4% | 12.5% | 13.4% |
| Hispanic or Latino B03002 | - | 28.5% | 24.4% | 19.8% |
| Asian B03002 | - | 14.6% | 12.4% | 9.0% |
| American Indian and Alaska Native B03002 | - | 0.2% | 0.1% | 0.2% |
Data: IPUMS NHGIS (ACS 2020-2024 and the 2020 census); each figure links to its table for that area at data.census.gov. Records are placed by ZIP code and city name, not street address. More: everything FURP has in Census Tract 143, New York County, New York.
Comments