PACIFIC LEGAL FOUNDATION: Form 990, tax year 2024

View the entire original 990 at ProPublica ↗

Organization
PACIFIC LEGAL FOUNDATION (EIN 94-2197343)
Tax period
2024-07-01 to 2025-06-30
Filed
2026-05-15
IRS object ID
202621359349301932
Schema version
2024v5.5
Source
Download XML · Original 990 at ProPublica

Every field in the e-filed return. Faint text is the IRS element name, for citing.

Return header ReturnHeader

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Return2026-05-15T07:57:18-05:00ReturnTs
Tax Period End2025-06-30TaxPeriodEndDt

Preparer Firm PreparerFirmGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Preparer Firm EIN582676261PreparerFirmEIN

Preparer Firm Name PreparerFirmName

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Business Name Line1Rogers & Company PLLCBusinessNameLine1Txt

Preparer US Address PreparerUSAddress

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Address Line18300 Boone Boulevard Suite 600AddressLine1Txt
CityViennaCityNm
State AbbreviationVAStateAbbreviationCd
ZIP22182ZIPCd
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Return Type990ReturnTypeCd
Tax Period Begin2024-07-01TaxPeriodBeginDt

Filer Filer

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
EIN942197343EIN

Business Name BusinessName

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Business Name Line1Pacific Legal FoundationBusinessNameLine1Txt
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Business Name ControlPACIBusinessNameControlTxt
Phone9164197111PhoneNum

US Address USAddress

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Address Line1555 Capitol Mall 1290AddressLine1Txt
CitySacramentoCityNm
State AbbreviationCAStateAbbreviationCd
ZIP958144605ZIPCd

Business Officer BusinessOfficerGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
PersonSteven D AndersonPersonNm
Person TitlePresident/CEOPersonTitleTxt
Phone9164197111PhoneNum
Signature2026-05-14SignatureDt
Discuss With Paid PreparerYes (1)DiscussWithPaidPreparerInd
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
IRS Responsible Prty Info CurrYes (1)IRSResponsiblePrtyInfoCurrInd

Preparer Person PreparerPersonGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Preparer PersonAmanda E WaterhousePreparerPersonNm
PTINP02014004PTIN
Phone7038930300PhoneNum
Preparation2026-05-10PreparationDt
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Tax2024TaxYr
Build TS2025-03-06 01:10:19ZBuildTS

Form 990 IRS990

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Principal OfficerSteven D AndersonPrincipalOfficerNm

US Address USAddress

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Address Line1555 Capitol Mall 1290AddressLine1Txt
CitySacramentoCityNm
State AbbreviationCAStateAbbreviationCd
ZIP958144605ZIPCd
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Gross Receipts$58,631,400GrossReceiptsAmt
Group Return For Affiliates0GroupReturnForAffiliatesInd
Organization501c3Yes (X)Organization501c3Ind
Website Addresshttps://pacificlegal.org/WebsiteAddressTxt
Type Of Organization CorpYes (X)TypeOfOrganizationCorpInd
Formation1973FormationYr
Legal Domicile StateCALegalDomicileStateCd
Activity Or MissionTo defend liberty and justice for all. See Schedule O for full mission.ActivityOrMissionDesc
Voting Members Governing Body15VotingMembersGoverningBodyCnt
Voting Members Independent15VotingMembersIndependentCnt
Total Employee180TotalEmployeeCnt
Total Volunteers16TotalVolunteersCnt
Total Gross UBI$0TotalGrossUBIAmt
Net Unrelated Bus Txbl Incm$0NetUnrelatedBusTxblIncmAmt
PY Contributions Grants$44,192,403PYContributionsGrantsAmt
CY Contributions Grants$26,278,130CYContributionsGrantsAmt
PY Program Service Revenue$260,246PYProgramServiceRevenueAmt
CY Program Service Revenue$982,021CYProgramServiceRevenueAmt
PY Investment Income$3,393,415PYInvestmentIncomeAmt
CY Investment Income$4,257,297CYInvestmentIncomeAmt
PY Other Revenue$88,445PYOtherRevenueAmt
CY Other Revenue$81,066CYOtherRevenueAmt
PY Total Revenue$47,934,509PYTotalRevenueAmt
CY Total Revenue$31,598,514CYTotalRevenueAmt
PY Grants And Similar Paid$40,000PYGrantsAndSimilarPaidAmt
CY Grants And Similar Paid$145,000CYGrantsAndSimilarPaidAmt
PY Benefits Paid To Members$0PYBenefitsPaidToMembersAmt
CY Benefits Paid To Members$0CYBenefitsPaidToMembersAmt
PY Salaries Comp Emp Bnft Paid$19,362,073PYSalariesCompEmpBnftPaidAmt
CY Salaries Comp Emp Bnft Paid$25,557,710CYSalariesCompEmpBnftPaidAmt
PY Total Prof Fndrsng Expns$0PYTotalProfFndrsngExpnsAmt
CY Total Prof Fndrsng Expns$0CYTotalProfFndrsngExpnsAmt
CY Total Fundraising Expense$2,522,463CYTotalFundraisingExpenseAmt
PY Other Expenses$7,622,016PYOtherExpensesAmt
CY Other Expenses$9,837,138CYOtherExpensesAmt
PY Total Expenses$27,024,089PYTotalExpensesAmt
CY Total Expenses$35,539,848CYTotalExpensesAmt
PY Revenues Less Expenses$20,910,420PYRevenuesLessExpensesAmt
CY Revenues Less Expenses-$3,941,334CYRevenuesLessExpensesAmt
Total Assets BOY$113,554,835TotalAssetsBOYAmt
Total Assets EOY$118,927,949TotalAssetsEOYAmt
Total Liabilities BOY$7,051,713TotalLiabilitiesBOYAmt
Total Liabilities EOY$8,516,661TotalLiabilitiesEOYAmt
Net Assets Or Fund Balances BOY$106,503,122NetAssetsOrFundBalancesBOYAmt
Net Assets Or Fund Balances EOY$110,411,288NetAssetsOrFundBalancesEOYAmt
Info In Schedule O Part IIIYes (X)InfoInScheduleOPartIIIInd
MissionPacific Legal Foundation (PLF) litigates nationwide to secure all Americans' inalienable rights to live responsibly and productively in their pursuit of happiness. See Schedule O for full mission.MissionDesc
Significant New Program Srvc0SignificantNewProgramSrvcInd
Significant Change0SignificantChangeInd
Expense$28,949,858ExpenseAmt
Grant$145,000GrantAmt
Revenue$982,021RevenueAmt
DescEach year, PLF represents hundreds of Americans, free of charge, who seek to improve their lives but are stymied by government. We give them their day in court to vindicate their rights and set a lasting precedent to protect everyone else. See Schedule O for a complete list of cases litigated during the fiscal year ended June 30, 2025.Desc
Total Program Service Expenses$28,949,858TotalProgramServiceExpensesAmt
Described In Section501c3Yes (1)DescribedInSection501c3Ind
Schedule B RequiredYes (1)ScheduleBRequiredInd
Political Campaign Acty0PoliticalCampaignActyInd
Lobbying ActivitiesYes (1)LobbyingActivitiesInd
Subject To Proxy Tax0SubjectToProxyTaxInd
Donor Advised Fund0DonorAdvisedFundInd
Conservation Easements0ConservationEasementsInd
Collections Of Art0CollectionsOfArtInd
Credit Counseling0CreditCounselingInd
Donor Rstr Or Quasi EndowmentsYes (1)DonorRstrOrQuasiEndowmentsInd
Report Land Building EquipmentYes (1)ReportLandBuildingEquipmentInd
Report Investments Other Sec0ReportInvestmentsOtherSecInd
Report Program Related Invst0ReportProgramRelatedInvstInd
Report Other Assets0ReportOtherAssetsInd
Report Other LiabilitiesYes (1)ReportOtherLiabilitiesInd
Include FIN48 FootnoteYes (1)IncludeFIN48FootnoteInd
Independent Audit Fincl StmtYes (1)IndependentAuditFinclStmtInd
Consolidated Audit Fincl Stmt0ConsolidatedAuditFinclStmtInd
School Operating0SchoolOperatingInd
Foreign Office0ForeignOfficeInd
Foreign Activities0ForeignActivitiesInd
More Than5000 K To Org0MoreThan5000KToOrgInd
More Than5000 K To Individuals0MoreThan5000KToIndividualsInd
Professional Fundraising0ProfessionalFundraisingInd
Fundraising Activities0FundraisingActivitiesInd
Gaming Activities0GamingActivitiesInd
Operate Hospital0OperateHospitalInd
Grants To OrganizationsYes (1)GrantsToOrganizationsInd
Grants To Individuals0GrantsToIndividualsInd
Schedule J RequiredYes (1)ScheduleJRequiredInd
Tax Exempt Bonds0TaxExemptBondsInd
Engaged In Excess Benefit Trans0EngagedInExcessBenefitTransInd
PY Excess Benefit Trans0PYExcessBenefitTransInd
Loan Outstanding0LoanOutstandingInd
Grant To Related Person0GrantToRelatedPersonInd
Business Rln With Org Mem0BusinessRlnWithOrgMemInd
Business Rln With Fam Mem0BusinessRlnWithFamMemInd
Business Rln With35 Ctrl Ent0BusinessRlnWith35CtrlEntInd
Deductible Non Cash ContriYes (1)DeductibleNonCashContriInd
Deductible Art Contribution0DeductibleArtContributionInd
Terminate Operations0TerminateOperationsInd
Partial Liquidation0PartialLiquidationInd
Disregarded Entity0DisregardedEntityInd
Related Entity0RelatedEntityInd
Related Organization Ctrl Ent0RelatedOrganizationCtrlEntInd
Trnsfr Exmpt Non Chrtbl Rltd Org0TrnsfrExmptNonChrtblRltdOrgInd
Activities Conducted Prtshp0ActivitiesConductedPrtshpInd
Schedule O RequiredYes (1)ScheduleORequiredInd
IRP Document136IRPDocumentCnt
IRP Document W2 G0IRPDocumentW2GCnt
Backup Wthld ComplianceYes (1)BackupWthldComplianceInd
Employee180EmployeeCnt
Employment Tax Returns FiledYes (1)EmploymentTaxReturnsFiledInd
Unrelated Bus Incm Over Limit0UnrelatedBusIncmOverLimitInd
Foreign Financial Account0ForeignFinancialAccountInd
Prohibited Tax Shelter Trans0ProhibitedTaxShelterTransInd
Taxable Party Notification0TaxablePartyNotificationInd
Nondeductible Contributions0NondeductibleContributionsInd
Quid Pro Quo Contributions0QuidProQuoContributionsInd
Form8282 Property Disposed Of0Form8282PropertyDisposedOfInd
Rcv Fnds To Pay Prsnl Bnft Cntrct0RcvFndsToPayPrsnlBnftCntrctInd
Pay Premiums Prsnl Bnft Cntrct0PayPremiumsPrsnlBnftCntrctInd
Indoor Tanning Services0IndoorTanningServicesInd
Subj To Tax Rmnrtn Ex Prcht Pymt0SubjToTaxRmnrtnExPrchtPymtInd
Subject To Excs Tax Net Invst Inc0SubjectToExcsTaxNetInvstIncInd
Info In Schedule O Part VIYes (X)InfoInScheduleOPartVIInd
Governing Body Voting Members15GoverningBodyVotingMembersCnt
Independent Voting Member15IndependentVotingMemberCnt
Family Or Business Rln0FamilyOrBusinessRlnInd
Delegation Of Mgmt Duties0DelegationOfMgmtDutiesInd
Change To Org Documents0ChangeToOrgDocumentsInd
Material Diversion Or Misuse0MaterialDiversionOrMisuseInd
Members Or Stockholders0MembersOrStockholdersInd
Election Of Board Members0ElectionOfBoardMembersInd
Decisions Subject To Approva0DecisionsSubjectToApprovaInd
Minutes Of Governing BodyYes (1)MinutesOfGoverningBodyInd
Minutes Of CommitteesYes (1)MinutesOfCommitteesInd
Officer Mailing Address0OfficerMailingAddressInd
Local Chapters0LocalChaptersInd
Form990 Provided To Gvrn BodyYes (1)Form990ProvidedToGvrnBodyInd
Conflict Of Interest PolicyYes (1)ConflictOfInterestPolicyInd
Annual Disclosure Covered PrsnYes (1)AnnualDisclosureCoveredPrsnInd
Regular Monitoring EnfrcYes (1)RegularMonitoringEnfrcInd
Whistleblower PolicyYes (1)WhistleblowerPolicyInd
Document Retention PolicyYes (1)DocumentRetentionPolicyInd
Compensation Process CEOYes (1)CompensationProcessCEOInd
Compensation Process OtherYes (1)CompensationProcessOtherInd
Investment In Joint Venture0InvestmentInJointVentureInd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldALStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldAKStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldAZStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldARStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldCAStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldCOStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldCTStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldDCStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldFLStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldGAStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldHIStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldILStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldKSStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldKYStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldLAStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldMEStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldMDStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldMAStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldMIStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldMNStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldMSStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldMOStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldNHStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldNJStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldNMStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldNYStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldNCStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldNDStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldOHStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldOKStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldORStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldPAStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldRIStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldSCStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldTNStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldUTStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldVAStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldWAStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldWVStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
States Where Copy Of Return Is FldWIStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd
Own WebsiteYes (X)OwnWebsiteInd
Upon RequestYes (X)UponRequestInd

Books In Care Of Detail BooksInCareOfDetail

Business Name BusinessName

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Business Name Line1Steven D AndersonBusinessNameLine1Txt
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Phone9164197111PhoneNum

US Address USAddress

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Address Line1555 Capitol Mall Suite 1290AddressLine1Txt
CitySacramentoCityNm
State AbbreviationCAStateAbbreviationCd
ZIP958144605ZIPCd

Form990 Part VII Section A Form990PartVIISectionAGrp (30 entries)

TitleTitleTxtAverage Hours Per WeekAverageHoursPerWeekRtIndividual Trustee Or DirectorIndividualTrusteeOrDirectorIndOfficerOfficerIndReportable Comp From OrgReportableCompFromOrgAmtReportable Comp From Rltd OrgReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmtOther CompensationOtherCompensationAmtKey EmployeeKeyEmployeeIndHighest Compensated EmployeeHighestCompensatedEmployeeInd
Robert D Connors
Chair of the Board10.00Yes (X)Yes (X)$0$0$0
George Kimball
Vice Chair1.00Yes (X)Yes (X)$0$0$0
Ross Borba Jr
Trustee1.00Yes (X)$0$0$0
Amy Brigham Boulris
Trustee1.00Yes (X)$0$0$0
Brian G Cartwright
Trustee1.00Yes (X)$0$0$0
Greg M Evans
Trustee1.00Yes (X)$0$0$0
David Gerson
Trustee1.00Yes (X)$0$0$0
Carol Platt Liebau
Trustee1.00Yes (X)$0$0$0
April J Morris
Trustee1.00Yes (X)$0$0$0
Bruce C Smith
Trustee1.00Yes (X)$0$0$0
Charles W Trainor
Trustee1.00Yes (X)$0$0$0
Ronald E Van Buskirk
Trustee1.00Yes (X)$0$0$0
Jeffrey E Warren
Trustee1.00Yes (X)$0$0$0
John Yoo
Trustee1.00Yes (X)$0$0$0
John C Harris
Trustee1.00Yes (X)$0$0$0
Robert K Best
Trustee (to 09/24)1.00Yes (X)$0$0$0
Steven Anderson
President & CEO37.50Yes (X)$672,716$0$83,153
John Groen
Exec. VP & General Counsel37.50Yes (X)$360,447$0$75,200
Larry Salzman
Secretary/VP for Lit. & Strategy37.50Yes (X)$300,987$0$76,738
Charles Wilcox IV
Treasurer (to 10/24)/VP of Opp.37.50Yes (X)$288,069$0$25,884
Britany Skipper
Treasurer, CFO (as of 11/24)37.50Yes (X)$33,804$0$1,935
Scott Barton
VP of Comm & Marketing37.50$234,428$0$57,377Yes (X)
Steve Simpson
Director of SOP37.50$279,018$0$38,526Yes (X)
Joshua Thompson
Dir.of Equ & Opp Lit.37.50$238,608$0$71,016Yes (X)
Robert Thomas
Dir.of Prop Rights Lit.37.50$236,676$0$31,952Yes (X)
Jan Breemer
Senior Attorney37.50$217,028$0$39,288Yes (X)
James Burling
Senior Legal Counsel37.50$249,192$0$52,623Yes (X)
Austin Raynor
Senior Attorney37.50$278,545$0$25,911Yes (X)
Mark Miller
Senior Attorney37.50$209,979$0$35,941Yes (X)
Damien Schiff
Senior Attorney37.50$225,275$0$46,975Yes (X)
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total Reportable Comp From Org$3,824,772TotalReportableCompFromOrgAmt
Tot Reportable Comp Rltd Org$0TotReportableCompRltdOrgAmt
Total Other Compensation$662,519TotalOtherCompensationAmt
Indiv Rcvd Greater Than100 K67IndivRcvdGreaterThan100KCnt
Former Ofcr Employees Listed0FormerOfcrEmployeesListedInd
Total Comp Greater Than150 KYes (1)TotalCompGreaterThan150KInd
Compensation From Other Srcs0CompensationFromOtherSrcsInd

Contractor Compensation ContractorCompensationGrp (5 entries)

Address Line1ContractorAddress/USAddress/AddressLine1TxtCityContractorAddress/USAddress/CityNmState AbbreviationContractorAddress/USAddress/StateAbbreviationCdZIPContractorAddress/USAddress/ZIPCdServicesServicesDescCompensationCompensationAmt
Heart and Mind Strategies
5518 Callander DriveSpringfieldVA22151Brand Consulting$255,841
Wilkins Media LLC
PO Box 25008 Dept 591BradentonFL34206Media Specialist$212,772
My Biz Niche LLC
17797 N Perimeter Dr D105ScottsdaleAZ85255Salesforce/Software Customization and Pr$203,592
Morgan Meredith & Associates
22780 Indian Creek Drive Suite 100SterlingVA20166Direct Mail$167,415
InterWorks Inc
501 Main StreetPine BluffAR71601IT Consulting$117,625
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Cntrct Rcvd Greater Than100 K6CntrctRcvdGreaterThan100KCnt
All Other Contributions$26,278,130AllOtherContributionsAmt
Noncash Contributions$338,034NoncashContributionsAmt
Total Contributions$26,278,130TotalContributionsAmt

Program Service Revenue ProgramServiceRevenueGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
DescCourt-awarded attorney feesDesc
Business541100BusinessCd
Total Revenue Column$982,021TotalRevenueColumnAmt
Related Or Exempt Func Income$982,021RelatedOrExemptFuncIncomeAmt
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total Program Service Revenue$982,021TotalProgramServiceRevenueAmt

Investment Income InvestmentIncomeGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total Revenue Column$2,450,541TotalRevenueColumnAmt
Exclusion$2,450,541ExclusionAmt

Gross Amount Sales Assets GrossAmountSalesAssetsGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Securities$28,827,210SecuritiesAmt
Other$12,432OtherAmt

Less Cost Oth Basis Sales Expnss LessCostOthBasisSalesExpnssGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Securities$27,032,886SecuritiesAmt
Other$0OtherAmt

Gain Or Loss GainOrLossGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Securities$1,794,324SecuritiesAmt
Other$12,432OtherAmt

Net Gain Or Loss Investments NetGainOrLossInvestmentsGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total Revenue Column$1,806,756TotalRevenueColumnAmt
Exclusion$1,806,756ExclusionAmt

Other Revenue Misc OtherRevenueMiscGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
DescOther incomeDesc
Business900099BusinessCd
Total Revenue Column$81,066TotalRevenueColumnAmt
Exclusion$81,066ExclusionAmt
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Other Revenue Total$81,066OtherRevenueTotalAmt

Total Revenue TotalRevenueGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total Revenue Column$31,598,514TotalRevenueColumnAmt
Related Or Exempt Func Income$982,021RelatedOrExemptFuncIncomeAmt
Unrelated Business Revenue$0UnrelatedBusinessRevenueAmt
Exclusion$4,338,363ExclusionAmt

Grants To Domestic Orgs GrantsToDomesticOrgsGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total$145,000TotalAmt
Program Services$145,000ProgramServicesAmt

Comp Current Ofcr Directors CompCurrentOfcrDirectorsGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total$3,187,032TotalAmt
Program Services$2,725,444ProgramServicesAmt
Management And General$280,398ManagementAndGeneralAmt
Fundraising$181,190FundraisingAmt

Other Salaries And Wages OtherSalariesAndWagesGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total$17,223,190TotalAmt
Program Services$14,728,701ProgramServicesAmt
Management And General$1,515,316ManagementAndGeneralAmt
Fundraising$979,173FundraisingAmt

Pension Plan Contributions PensionPlanContributionsGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total$1,632,167TotalAmt
Program Services$1,395,775ProgramServicesAmt
Management And General$143,600ManagementAndGeneralAmt
Fundraising$92,792FundraisingAmt

Other Employee Benefits OtherEmployeeBenefitsGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total$2,200,677TotalAmt
Program Services$1,881,946ProgramServicesAmt
Management And General$193,618ManagementAndGeneralAmt
Fundraising$125,113FundraisingAmt

Payroll Taxes PayrollTaxesGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total$1,314,644TotalAmt
Program Services$1,124,240ProgramServicesAmt
Management And General$115,664ManagementAndGeneralAmt
Fundraising$74,740FundraisingAmt

Fees For Services Legal FeesForServicesLegalGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total$290,643TotalAmt
Management And General$290,643ManagementAndGeneralAmt

Fees For Services Accounting FeesForServicesAccountingGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total$95,430TotalAmt
Management And General$95,430ManagementAndGeneralAmt

Fees For Srvc Invst Mgmnt Fees FeesForSrvcInvstMgmntFeesGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total$298,912TotalAmt
Management And General$298,912ManagementAndGeneralAmt

Fees For Services Other FeesForServicesOtherGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total$2,558,351TotalAmt
Program Services$2,282,981ProgramServicesAmt
Management And General$180,252ManagementAndGeneralAmt
Fundraising$95,118FundraisingAmt

Office Expenses OfficeExpensesGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total$971,098TotalAmt
Program Services$496,169ProgramServicesAmt
Management And General$138,919ManagementAndGeneralAmt
Fundraising$336,010FundraisingAmt

Information Technology InformationTechnologyGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total$949,673TotalAmt
Program Services$485,066ProgramServicesAmt
Management And General$136,116ManagementAndGeneralAmt
Fundraising$328,491FundraisingAmt

Occupancy OccupancyGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total$898,312TotalAmt
Program Services$821,117ProgramServicesAmt
Management And General$22,965ManagementAndGeneralAmt
Fundraising$54,230FundraisingAmt

Travel TravelGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total$1,684,258TotalAmt
Program Services$1,305,196ProgramServicesAmt
Management And General$226,702ManagementAndGeneralAmt
Fundraising$152,360FundraisingAmt

Conferences Meetings ConferencesMeetingsGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total$958,567TotalAmt
Program Services$742,831ProgramServicesAmt
Management And General$129,024ManagementAndGeneralAmt
Fundraising$86,712FundraisingAmt

Depreciation Depletion DepreciationDepletionGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total$269,681TotalAmt
Program Services$247,354ProgramServicesAmt
Management And General$5,793ManagementAndGeneralAmt
Fundraising$16,534FundraisingAmt

Insurance InsuranceGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total$190,196TotalAmt
Program Services$94,572ProgramServicesAmt
Management And General$95,624ManagementAndGeneralAmt

Other Expenses OtherExpensesGrp (4 entries)

DescDescTotalTotalAmtProgram ServicesProgramServicesAmtManagement And GeneralManagementAndGeneralAmt
Library and research$284,528$284,528
Registrations/Fees$197,424$197,424
Direct case costs$189,752$188,938$814
Bad debt expense$313$313

Total Functional Expenses TotalFunctionalExpensesGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total$35,539,848TotalAmt
Program Services$28,949,858ProgramServicesAmt
Management And General$4,067,527ManagementAndGeneralAmt
Fundraising$2,522,463FundraisingAmt

Cash Non Interest Bearing CashNonInterestBearingGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY$6,757,191BOYAmt
EOY$5,839,544EOYAmt

Pledges And Grants Receivable PledgesAndGrantsReceivableGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY$2,447,855BOYAmt
EOY$1,813,549EOYAmt

Accounts Receivable AccountsReceivableGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY$0BOYAmt
EOY$256,774EOYAmt

Prepaid Expenses Defrd Charges PrepaidExpensesDefrdChargesGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY$311,049BOYAmt
EOY$666,215EOYAmt
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Land Bldg Equip Cost Or Other Bss$1,295,295LandBldgEquipCostOrOtherBssAmt
Land Bldg Equip Accum Deprec$616,599LandBldgEquipAccumDeprecAmt

Land Bldg Equip Basis Net LandBldgEquipBasisNetGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY$615,634BOYAmt
EOY$678,696EOYAmt

Investments Pub Traded Sec InvestmentsPubTradedSecGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY$98,866,422BOYAmt
EOY$104,998,459EOYAmt

Other Assets Total OtherAssetsTotalGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY$4,556,684BOYAmt
EOY$4,674,712EOYAmt

Total Assets TotalAssetsGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY$113,554,835BOYAmt
EOY$118,927,949EOYAmt

Accounts Payable Accr Expnss AccountsPayableAccrExpnssGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY$1,496,661BOYAmt
EOY$2,897,942EOYAmt

Deferred Revenue DeferredRevenueGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY$17,500BOYAmt
EOY$0EOYAmt

Other Liabilities OtherLiabilitiesGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY$5,537,552BOYAmt
EOY$5,618,719EOYAmt

Total Liabilities TotalLiabilitiesGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY$7,051,713BOYAmt
EOY$8,516,661EOYAmt
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Organization Follows FASB117Yes (X)OrganizationFollowsFASB117Ind

No Donor Restriction Net Assets NoDonorRestrictionNetAssetsGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY$100,146,398BOYAmt
EOY$103,976,149EOYAmt

Donor Restriction Net Assets DonorRestrictionNetAssetsGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY$6,356,724BOYAmt
EOY$6,435,139EOYAmt

Total Net Assets Fund Balance TotalNetAssetsFundBalanceGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY$106,503,122BOYAmt
EOY$110,411,288EOYAmt

Tot Liab Net Assets Fund Balance TotLiabNetAssetsFundBalanceGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY$113,554,835BOYAmt
EOY$118,927,949EOYAmt
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Info In Schedule O Part XIYes (X)InfoInScheduleOPartXIInd
Reconcilation Revenue Expnss-$3,941,334ReconcilationRevenueExpnssAmt
Net Unrlzd Gains Losses Invst$7,295,784NetUnrlzdGainsLossesInvstAmt
Other Changes In Net Assets$553,716OtherChangesInNetAssetsAmt
Method Of Accounting AccrualYes (X)MethodOfAccountingAccrualInd
Accountant Compile Or Review0AccountantCompileOrReviewInd
FS AuditedYes (1)FSAuditedInd

FS Audited Basis FSAuditedBasisGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Separate Basis Fincl StmtYes (X)SeparateBasisFinclStmtInd
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Audit CommitteeYes (1)AuditCommitteeInd
Federal Grant Audit Required0FederalGrantAuditRequiredInd

Schedule A IRS990ScheduleA

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Public Organization170Yes (X)PublicOrganization170Ind

Gifts Grants Contri Rcvd170 GiftsGrantsContriRcvd170Grp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Current Tax Year Minus4 Years$16,892,254CurrentTaxYearMinus4YearsAmt
Current Tax Year Minus3 Years$26,374,951CurrentTaxYearMinus3YearsAmt
Current Tax Year Minus2 Years$21,771,790CurrentTaxYearMinus2YearsAmt
Current Tax Year Minus1 Year$44,192,403CurrentTaxYearMinus1YearAmt
Current Tax Year$26,278,130CurrentTaxYearAmt
Total$135,509,528TotalAmt

Total Calendar Year170 TotalCalendarYear170Grp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Current Tax Year Minus4 Years$16,892,254CurrentTaxYearMinus4YearsAmt
Current Tax Year Minus3 Years$26,374,951CurrentTaxYearMinus3YearsAmt
Current Tax Year Minus2 Years$21,771,790CurrentTaxYearMinus2YearsAmt
Current Tax Year Minus1 Year$44,192,403CurrentTaxYearMinus1YearAmt
Current Tax Year$26,278,130CurrentTaxYearAmt
Total$135,509,528TotalAmt
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Substantial Contributors Tot$14,900,136SubstantialContributorsTotAmt
Public Support Total170$120,609,392PublicSupportTotal170Amt

Gross Investment Income170 GrossInvestmentIncome170Grp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Current Tax Year Minus4 Years$692,541CurrentTaxYearMinus4YearsAmt
Current Tax Year Minus3 Years$1,373,866CurrentTaxYearMinus3YearsAmt
Current Tax Year Minus2 Years$1,646,192CurrentTaxYearMinus2YearsAmt
Current Tax Year Minus1 Year$1,879,186CurrentTaxYearMinus1YearAmt
Current Tax Year$2,450,541CurrentTaxYearAmt
Total$8,042,326TotalAmt

Other Income170 OtherIncome170Grp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Current Tax Year Minus4 Years$299,957CurrentTaxYearMinus4YearsAmt
Current Tax Year Minus3 Years$111,055CurrentTaxYearMinus3YearsAmt
Current Tax Year Minus2 Years$32,006CurrentTaxYearMinus2YearsAmt
Current Tax Year Minus1 Year$88,445CurrentTaxYearMinus1YearAmt
Current Tax Year$81,066CurrentTaxYearAmt
Total$612,529TotalAmt
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total Support$144,164,383TotalSupportAmt
Gross Receipts Rltd Activities$2,826,203GrossReceiptsRltdActivitiesAmt
Public Support CY1700.83660PublicSupportCY170Pct
Public Support PY1700.83400PublicSupportPY170Pct
Thirty Thr Pct Suprt Tests CY170Yes (X)ThirtyThrPctSuprtTestsCY170Ind

Form990 Schedule A Part VI Form990ScheduleAPartVIGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Form And Line ReferenceSchedule A, Part II, Line 10, Explanation of Other Income:FormAndLineReferenceDesc
ExplanationOther Income - 2020 Amount: $ 299,957. 2021 Amount: $ 111,055. 2022 Amount: $ 32,006. 2023 Amount: $ 88,445. 2024 Amount: $ 81,066.ExplanationTxt

Schedule B IRS990ScheduleB

Contributor Information ContributorInformationGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
ContributorRESTRICTEDContributorNum

Contributor Business Name ContributorBusinessName

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Business Name Line1RESTRICTEDBusinessNameLine1

Contributor US Address ContributorUSAddress

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Address Line1RESTRICTEDAddressLine1
Address Line2RESTRICTEDAddressLine2
CityRESTRICTEDCity
StateRESTRICTEDState
ZIP CodeRESTRICTEDZIPCode
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total ContributionsRESTRICTEDTotalContributionsAmt

Schedule C IRS990ScheduleC

Total Grassroots Lobbying TotalGrassrootsLobbyingGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Filing Organizations Total$0FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt

Total Direct Lobbying TotalDirectLobbyingGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Filing Organizations Total$24,550FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt

Total Lobbying Expend TotalLobbyingExpendGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Filing Organizations Total$24,550FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt

Other Exempt Purpose Expend OtherExemptPurposeExpendGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Filing Organizations Total$35,216,386FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt

Total Exempt Purpose Expend TotalExemptPurposeExpendGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Filing Organizations Total$35,240,936FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt

Lobbying Nontaxable Amount LobbyingNontaxableAmountGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Filing Organizations Total$1,000,000FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt

Grassroots Nontaxable GrassrootsNontaxableGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Filing Organizations Total$250,000FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt

Tot Lbbyng Grassroot Mns Non Tx TotLbbyngGrassrootMnsNonTxGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Filing Organizations Total$0FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt

Tot Lbby Expend Mns Lbbyng Non Tx TotLbbyExpendMnsLbbyngNonTxGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Filing Organizations Total$0FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt

Avg Lobbying Nontaxable Amount AvgLobbyingNontaxableAmountGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Current Year Minus3$1,000,000CurrentYearMinus3Amt
Current Year Minus2$1,000,000CurrentYearMinus2Amt
Current Year Minus1$1,000,000CurrentYearMinus1Amt
Current Year$1,000,000CurrentYearAmt
Total$4,000,000TotalAmt
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Lobbying Ceiling$6,000,000LobbyingCeilingAmt

Avg Total Lobbying Expend AvgTotalLobbyingExpendGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Current Year Minus3$384,173CurrentYearMinus3Amt
Current Year Minus2$23,076CurrentYearMinus2Amt
Current Year Minus1$55,382CurrentYearMinus1Amt
Current Year$24,550CurrentYearAmt
Total$487,181TotalAmt

Avg Grassroots Nontaxable AvgGrassrootsNontaxableGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Current Year Minus3$250,000CurrentYearMinus3Amt
Current Year Minus2$250,000CurrentYearMinus2Amt
Current Year Minus1$250,000CurrentYearMinus1Amt
Current Year$250,000CurrentYearAmt
Total$1,000,000TotalAmt
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Grassroots Ceiling$1,500,000GrassrootsCeilingAmt

Schedule D IRS990ScheduleD

CY Endwmt Fund CYEndwmtFundGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Beginning Year Balance$94,275,209BeginningYearBalanceAmt
Contributions$5,866,755ContributionsAmt
Investment Earnings Or Losses$10,989,418InvestmentEarningsOrLossesAmt
Other Expenditures$11,583,562OtherExpendituresAmt
Administrative Expenses$219,664AdministrativeExpensesAmt
End Year Balance$99,328,156EndYearBalanceAmt

CY Minus1 Yr Endwmt Fund CYMinus1YrEndwmtFundGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Beginning Year Balance$70,185,116BeginningYearBalanceAmt
Contributions$20,529,729ContributionsAmt
Investment Earnings Or Losses$10,652,468InvestmentEarningsOrLossesAmt
Other Expenditures$6,904,545OtherExpendituresAmt
Administrative Expenses$187,559AdministrativeExpensesAmt
End Year Balance$94,275,209EndYearBalanceAmt

CY Minus2 Yr Endwmt Fund CYMinus2YrEndwmtFundGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Beginning Year Balance$61,204,043BeginningYearBalanceAmt
Contributions$8,031,016ContributionsAmt
Investment Earnings Or Losses$7,587,380InvestmentEarningsOrLossesAmt
Other Expenditures$6,478,296OtherExpendituresAmt
Administrative Expenses$159,027AdministrativeExpensesAmt
End Year Balance$70,185,116EndYearBalanceAmt

CY Minus3 Yr Endwmt Fund CYMinus3YrEndwmtFundGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Beginning Year Balance$67,085,450BeginningYearBalanceAmt
Contributions$4,482,861ContributionsAmt
Investment Earnings Or Losses-$8,705,901InvestmentEarningsOrLossesAmt
Other Expenditures$1,495,905OtherExpendituresAmt
Administrative Expenses$162,462AdministrativeExpensesAmt
End Year Balance$61,204,043EndYearBalanceAmt

CY Minus4 Yr Endwmt Fund CYMinus4YrEndwmtFundGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Beginning Year Balance$53,198,337BeginningYearBalanceAmt
Contributions$1,411,631ContributionsAmt
Investment Earnings Or Losses$14,233,204InvestmentEarningsOrLossesAmt
Other Expenditures$1,613,764OtherExpendituresAmt
Administrative Expenses$143,958AdministrativeExpensesAmt
End Year Balance$67,085,450EndYearBalanceAmt
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Board Designated Balance EOY0.98088BoardDesignatedBalanceEOYPct
Prmnnt Endowment Balance EOY0.01836PrmnntEndowmentBalanceEOYPct
Term Endowment Balance EOY0.00076TermEndowmentBalanceEOYPct
Endowments Held Unrelated Org0EndowmentsHeldUnrelatedOrgInd
Endowments Held Related Org0EndowmentsHeldRelatedOrgInd

Leasehold Improvements LeaseholdImprovementsGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Other Cost Or Other Basis$737,408OtherCostOrOtherBasisAmt
Depreciation$455,735DepreciationAmt
Book Value$281,673BookValueAmt

Equipment EquipmentGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Other Cost Or Other Basis$529,497OtherCostOrOtherBasisAmt
Depreciation$160,864DepreciationAmt
Book Value$368,633BookValueAmt

Other Land Buildings OtherLandBuildingsGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Other Cost Or Other Basis$28,390OtherCostOrOtherBasisAmt
Book Value$28,390BookValueAmt
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total Book Value Land Buildings$678,696TotalBookValueLandBuildingsAmt

Other Liabilities Org OtherLiabilitiesOrgGrp (3 entries)

DescDescAmtAmt
Liability to beneficiaries$3,801,341
Lease liabilities - operating leases$905,603
Deferred compensation liabilities$911,775
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total Liability$5,618,719TotalLiabilityAmt
Footnote TextYes (X)FootnoteTextInd
Total Rev Etc Audited Fincl Stmt$39,149,102TotalRevEtcAuditedFinclStmtAmt
Net Unrealized Gains Invst$7,295,784NetUnrealizedGainsInvstAmt
Other Revenue$553,716OtherRevenueAmt
Revenue Not Reported$7,849,500RevenueNotReportedAmt
Revenue Subtotal$31,299,602RevenueSubtotalAmt
Investment Expenses Not Incld$298,912InvestmentExpensesNotIncldAmt
Revenue Not Reported Fincl Stmt$298,912RevenueNotReportedFinclStmtAmt
Total Revenue Per Form990$31,598,514TotalRevenuePerForm990Amt
Tot Expns Etc Audited Fincl Stmt$35,240,936TotExpnsEtcAuditedFinclStmtAmt
Expenses Not Reported$0ExpensesNotReportedAmt
Expenses Subtotal$35,240,936ExpensesSubtotalAmt
Investment Expenses Not Incld2$298,912InvestmentExpensesNotIncld2Amt
Expenses Not Rpt Fincl Stmt$298,912ExpensesNotRptFinclStmtAmt
Total Expenses Per Form990$35,539,848TotalExpensesPerForm990Amt

Supplemental Information Detail SupplementalInformationDetail (3 entries)

Form And Line ReferenceFormAndLineReferenceDescExplanationExplanationTxt
Part V, Line 4:The Organization's endowments include both donor-restricted endowment funds and funds designated by the Board of Trustees to function as endowments. Interest and dividends are to be used for operating or other purposes as designated by the Board of Trustees. Board quasi-endowments have been designated to provide annual income that is predictable and reliable to assure the ability of the Organization to meet long-term professional obligations inherent in the nature of its litigation services.
Part X, Line 2:Management evaluated the Organization's tax positions and has concluded that the Organization has taken no uncertain tax positions that require either recognition or disclosure in the accompanying financial statements.
Part XI, Line 2d - Other Adjustments:Change in value of split-interest agreements 553,716.

Schedule I IRS990ScheduleI

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Grant Records MaintainedYes (1)GrantRecordsMaintainedInd

Recipient Table RecipientTable (9 entries)

Address Line1USAddress/AddressLine1TxtAddress Line2USAddress/AddressLine2TxtCityUSAddress/CityNmState AbbreviationUSAddress/StateAbbreviationCdZIPUSAddress/ZIPCdRecipient EINRecipientEINIRC SectionIRCSectionDescCash GrantCashGrantAmtNon Cash AssistanceNonCashAssistanceAmtPurpose Of GrantPurposeOfGrantTxt
Talent Market
1367 Connecticut Avenue NW Suite200WashingtonDC20036521928321501c3$25,000$0Program Support
Pelican Institute for Public Policy
400 Poydras St Suite 900New OrleansLA70130261704791501c3$15,000$0Program Support
Platte Insitute for Economic Research
6910 Pacific St 216OmahaNE68106208809060501c3$15,000$0Program Support
The John Locke Foundation
4800 Six Forks Road 220RaleighNC27609561656943501c3$15,000$0Program Support
Mountain States Policy Center Inc
PO Box 2639Coeur DaleneID83816882607055501c3$15,000$0Program Support
Georgia Public Policy Foundation
3200 Cobb Galleria Pkwy Ste 214AtlantaGA30339581943161501c3$15,000$0Program Support
Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty
330 E Kilbourn 725MilwaukeeWI53202451606079501c3$15,000$0Program Support
The James Madison Institute
100 North Duval StreetTallahasseeFL32301592811908501c3$15,000$0Program Support
Iowans for Tax Relief
PO Box 39WaukeeIA50263421105304501c4$15,000$0Program Support
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total501c3 Org8Total501c3OrgCnt
Total Other Org1TotalOtherOrgCnt

Supplemental Information Detail SupplementalInformationDetail

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Form And Line ReferencePart I, Line 2:FormAndLineReferenceDesc
ExplanationThe Organization requires grantees' grant reports through the year and the funds could only be used for education purposes.ExplanationTxt

Schedule J IRS990ScheduleJ

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Compensation CommitteeYes (X)CompensationCommitteeInd
Independent ConsultantYes (X)IndependentConsultantInd
Form990 Of Other OrganizationsYes (X)Form990OfOtherOrganizationsInd
Written Employment ContractYes (X)WrittenEmploymentContractInd
Compensation SurveyYes (X)CompensationSurveyInd
Board Or Committee ApprovalYes (X)BoardOrCommitteeApprovalInd
Severance Payment0SeverancePaymentInd
Supplemental Nonqual Rtr Plan0SupplementalNonqualRtrPlanInd
Equity Based Comp Arrngm0EquityBasedCompArrngmInd
Comp Based On Revenue Of Flng Org0CompBasedOnRevenueOfFlngOrgInd
Comp Bsd On Rev Related Orgs0CompBsdOnRevRelatedOrgsInd
Comp Bsd Net Earns Flng Org0CompBsdNetEarnsFlngOrgInd
Comp Bsd Net Earns Rltd Orgs0CompBsdNetEarnsRltdOrgsInd
Any Non Fixed Payments0AnyNonFixedPaymentsInd
Initial Contract Exception0InitialContractExceptionInd

Rltd Org Officer Trst Key Empl RltdOrgOfficerTrstKeyEmplGrp (13 entries)

TitleTitleTxtBase Compensation Filing OrgBaseCompensationFilingOrgAmtCompensation Based On Rltd OrgsCompensationBasedOnRltdOrgsAmtBonus Filing OrganizationBonusFilingOrganizationAmountBonus Related OrganizationsBonusRelatedOrganizationsAmtOther Compensation Filing OrgOtherCompensationFilingOrgAmtOther Compensation Rltd OrgsOtherCompensationRltdOrgsAmtDeferred Compensation Flng OrgDeferredCompensationFlngOrgAmtDeferred Comp Rltd OrgsDeferredCompRltdOrgsAmtNontaxable Benefits Filing OrgNontaxableBenefitsFilingOrgAmtNontaxable Benefits Rltd OrgsNontaxableBenefitsRltdOrgsAmtTotal Compensation Filing OrgTotalCompensationFilingOrgAmtTotal Compensation Rltd OrgsTotalCompensationRltdOrgsAmtComp Report Prior990 Filing OrgCompReportPrior990FilingOrgAmtComp Report Prior990 Rltd OrgsCompReportPrior990RltdOrgsAmt
Steven Anderson
President & CEO$577,841$0$94,875$0$0$0$69,905$0$13,248$0$755,869$0$0$0
John Groen
Exec. VP & General Counsel$345,447$0$15,000$0$0$0$55,359$0$19,841$0$435,647$0$0$0
Larry Salzman
Secretary/VP for Lit. & Strategy$287,987$0$13,000$0$0$0$51,238$0$25,500$0$377,725$0$0$0
Steve Simpson
Director of SOP$264,018$0$15,000$0$0$0$25,278$0$13,248$0$317,544$0$0$0
Charles Wilcox IV
Treasurer (to 10/24)/VP of Opp.$288,069$0$0$0$0$0$16,668$0$9,216$0$313,953$0$0$0
Joshua Thompson
Dir.of Equ & Opp Lit.$238,608$0$0$0$0$0$45,530$0$25,486$0$309,624$0$0$0
Austin Raynor
Senior Attorney$78,545$0$200,000$0$0$0$17,042$0$8,869$0$304,456$0$0$0
James Burling
Senior Legal Counsel$244,192$0$5,000$0$0$0$33,084$0$19,539$0$301,815$0$0$0
Scott Barton
VP of Comm & Marketing$234,428$0$0$0$0$0$44,169$0$13,208$0$291,805$0$0$0
Damien Schiff
Senior Attorney$222,275$0$3,000$0$0$0$21,509$0$25,466$0$272,250$0$0$0
Robert Thomas
Dir.of Prop Rights Lit.$236,676$0$0$0$0$0$12,150$0$19,802$0$268,628$0$0$0
Jan Breemer
Senior Attorney$217,028$0$0$0$0$0$13,844$0$25,444$0$256,316$0$0$0
Mark Miller
Senior Attorney$209,979$0$0$0$0$0$17,297$0$18,644$0$245,920$0$0$0

Schedule M IRS990ScheduleM

Securities Publicly Traded SecuritiesPubliclyTradedGrp

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Non Cash CheckboxYes (X)NonCashCheckboxInd
Contribution25ContributionCnt
Noncash Contributions Rpt F990$338,034NoncashContributionsRptF990Amt
Method Of Determining RevenuesFair Market ValueMethodOfDeterminingRevenuesTxt
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Any Property That Must Be Held0AnyPropertyThatMustBeHeldInd
Review Process Unusual NC GiftsYes (1)ReviewProcessUnusualNCGiftsInd
Third Parties Used0ThirdPartiesUsedInd

Supplemental Information Detail SupplementalInformationDetail

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Form And Line ReferencePart I, Column (b):FormAndLineReferenceDesc
ExplanationThe number in column (b) reflects the number of contributions.ExplanationTxt

Schedule O IRS990ScheduleO

Supplemental Information Detail SupplementalInformationDetail (27 entries)

Form And Line ReferenceFormAndLineReferenceDescExplanationExplanationTxt
Form 990, Part III, Line 1, Description of Organization Mission:Pacific Legal Foundation (PLF) litigates nationwide to secure all Americans' inalienable rights to live responsibly and productively in their pursuit of happiness. PLF combines strategic and principled litigation, communication, and research to achieve landmark court victories enforcing the Constitution's guarantee of individual liberty.
Form 990, Part III, Line 4aPLF attorneys directly represented clients in the following cases furthering the Foundation's overarching mission to protect and enhance individual liberty. The cases further the goals of individual rights and liberty in the realms of property rights, separation of powers, equality under the law, and economic opportunity. In all cases, actions attributed to PLF were done by PLF attorneys properly admitted to each jurisdiction. Property Rights: A society cannot flourish and individuals cannot advance their private interests without individual rights to create and productively use property. PLF litigates to secure the right to the productive and ordinary use of land; prevent governments from taking property; fight unconstitutional or unlawful regulatory requirements; promote balance in environmental laws; and stop unreasonable searches and seizures. 835 Hinesburg Road LLC v. South Burlington, Vermont. 835 Hinesburg Road, LLC, is challenging a city's designation of a portion of its land as open space "Habitat Blocks." The ordinance that created the Habitat Blocks categorically classifies some of the owner's land as unbuildable, and the city rejected the owner's development proposal. Yet when the owner sued the city for regulatory taking, the district court dismissed the case on the theory that the case is not ripe because the city retains discretion to approve some development in the future. PLF represented the owner on appeal to the Second Circuit to argue that federal courts should be as receptive to civil rights claims based on property ownership as they are with other types of civil rights claims. The Second Circuit affirmed. PLF filed a petition for writ of certiorari. The Court denied PLF's petition, thus attorneys fees cannot be awarded. Beeman, et al. v. Muskegon County Treasurer. PLF represents multiple victims of tax foreclosure, arguing that Muskegon County violated the state and federal constitutions by denying former property owners the surplus proceeds from the auction of their tax-foreclosed properties. The County refuses to pay the surplus proceeds because the owners missed an administrative deadline for submitting a claim form, despite filing timely judicial motions for return of their surplus. The case seeks to secure due process for property owners when they claim the surplus equity value of their tax-foreclosed homes, which PLF's Supreme Court victory in Tyler v. Hennepin County entitles them to receive. The Takings Clause affirmatively requires government to pay for what it takes; it cannot avoid that duty by creating a claim process designed to minimize payment of just compensation for taken property. PLF petitioned the Michigan Supreme Court to hear the case, and the court denied the petition. PLF petitioned the United States Supreme Court where it is fully briefed and awaits a conference date. Because the litigation is ongoing, it is premature to seek fees. Benedetti v. County of Marin, California. Before they may build a family home on the rural property they have owned for years, the Marin County's land use plan requires the Benedetti family-brothers Arron and Arthur who inherited the estate of their father, Willie-to agree that they will be "actively and directly engaged in agriculture and to record a restrictive covenant that they and all future owners of the home will be farmers or ranchers forever. These requirements place unconstitutional conditions on the Benedettis liberty and property rights. PLF filed a lawsuit on their behalf in state court, survived a demurrer, and litigated on the merits. The trial court held in favor of the county. PLF appealed to the Ninth Circuit where the case has been briefed and argued and awaits a decision. Because litigation is ongoing, it is premature to seek fees. Bordelon v. Baldwin County, Alabama. PLF represents Mike Bordelon and Breezy Shores, LLC, who are developers who intended to build a three-story, 14-unit residential rental building. After obtaining the necessary permits and starting construction, the county bowed to community pressure and issued a Stop Work Order. The revocation of the building permit caused economic harm and destroyed the owner's reasonable investment-backed expectations, and the character of the government action differed little from a physical invasion. As such, the order caused a regulatory taking for which the county must pay just compensation. The developers won in the trial court and the county appealed. PLF looks to preserve their victory in the Eleventh Circuit. Victory! The appellate court upheld the district court decision in all respects, such that the developers will receive just compensation for the taking of their property. It denied the county's petition for rehearing, leaving the victory intact. The County filed a petition for writ of certiorari, which was later denied. PLF sought $61,718 in attorneys' fees in a pending motion. Chinook Landing v. United States. PLF represents Chinook Landing LLC in a quiet title action against the federal government. The late John Lund (who owned Chinook Landing, which took title under Lund's probate) brought a quiet title and takings case against the Bonneville Power Association, a federal power marketing agency in the Pacific Northwest. The district court dismissed the case, holding that the case was filed outside the applicable statute of limitations. PLF took over the case on appeal in the Ninth Circuit to argue that the Quiet Title Act's statute of limitations is not triggered by the recording of an easement, the federal government does not have an implicit access easement when the governing deed allows for an explicit easement on another portion of the property, and the Tucker Act's statute of limitations does not begin to run until after title has been quieted in the government's favor. Prevailing on these arguments will open the courthouse doors to more property owners. After oral argument, the Ninth Circuit transferred the case to the Federal Circuit for decision. Another oral argument was held in the Federal Circuit and the court issued an adverse decision. PLF plans to file a petition for writ of certiorari in this case, thus it is premature to seek fees. Clear Sky Holdings, LLC v. Estate of Gaston Powell. PLF represents the Powell Family in a suit challenging the District of Columbia's confiscatory tax foreclosure law and its excessive penalties under the city's vacant and blighted property tax law. The Powell Family has owned their Florida Avenue home for a century. After losing the patriarch of the family in 2000, the Powells' surviving heirs attempted to navigate the complex estate process in D.C. while managing outstanding property taxes, with Gaston Powell, Jr. serving as the personal representative of the estate. After Mr. Powell's passing in 2022, his widow was unable to keep up with the complicated legal proceedings and tax debt as the personal representative of the estate. After the family's tax woes were compounded by the District's regressive property tax system, the District of Columbia reclassified the home as "vacant and sold the property at a tax lien auction, transferring the tax debt to a private investor. The following year, as the family was working together to pay off the back taxes, the District reclassified the property as "blighted", which caused the tax burden to balloon dramatically from $41,000 to $181,594.87. The family was told that the balance would continue to increase by more than $30,000 every six months until it is paid in full. DC law permits homeowners to redeem properties sold at tax sales by paying off the debt within six months. But now, the extreme financial burden created by the city's unfair tax scheme has made redemption utterly impossible for the Powell Family. The U.S. Constitution and the Supreme Court's decision in Tyler v. Hennepin County are clear that taking more than what is owed is home equity theft and it's illegal. This case also addresses the unconstitutional excessive fine imposed on the Powell Family. PLF filed an answer and counterclaims to the amended complaint and the case is awaiting action. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees.
Form 990, Part III, Line 4aCoalition for Fairness in Soho and Noho, Inc. v. City of New York. The Coalition for Soho-Noho is a non-profit community-based organization representing artists, residents, and several homeowners impacted by the rezoning program through which the City of New York is exacting the arts fee. In December 2021, the City of New York amended its law to include a rezoning art exaction fee which requires property owners undergoing rezoning to pay a fee to an "Arts Fund" as a condition of the permit. This fee would be an upfront payment of $100 per square foot of the space to be rezoned. In trial court, the Coalition argued that the fee exaction was an unconstitutional condition on a proposed use of land and it failed constitutional scrutiny under the essential nexus and rough proportionality tests of Nollan/Dolan/Koontz. The trial court upheld the art fee, the Coalition appealed, and the appellate division reversed the trial court, ruling that the art fee was subject to Nollan, Dolan, Koontz, and Sheetz. The City appealed to the New York Court of Appeals, which granted review, and at which point PLF began representing the Coalition. The City filed their opening brief and PLF responded. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. DiPietro v. Town of Bolton, Massachusetts. The Town of Bolton took Alan DiPietro's home, farm, and land worth at least $370,000 as payment for a debt of approximately $60,000. Bolton not only confiscated DiPietro's title and equity, it also thwarted his attempts to pay his debt and save his farm from foreclosure. Bolton's theft of DiPietro's home equity, above and beyond the amount of the debt, violated the state and federal constitutional prohibitions on takings of property without just compensation and imposition of excessive fines as well as the common law that forbids unjust enrichment. The case was stayed pending resolution of Tyler v. Hennepin County in the Supreme Court, and after PLF's victory in Tyler, litigation resumed and the Town filed a motion for summary judgement and a motion to proceed with the foreclosure sale. PLF responded to both motions and filed a motion for protective order, which was then denied. The magistrate judge issued an adverse proposed ruling granting the town's summary judgement motion, which PLF plans to object. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. DJB Rentals v. City of Largo, Florida. In September 2013, DJB Rentals purchased a small, multi-unit rental property in the City of Largo, Florida. The property was an investment for PLF's client, who was the sole manager of DJB. At the time of purchase, there were no known code violations on the property and DJB prepared to take on most of the work to update the place himself. Within a month of purchasing the property, DJB obtained a permit to replace the roof and began to do the work himself. The City then revoked the permit because ordinances require DJB to hire a licensed third-party contractor to complete the work. Two years later, the City issued DJB a code enforcement notice for several violations related to various deficient structures and systems on the property, including roof repairs and lack of heating for the units in a notably tropical part of Florida. DJB was unable to cure the violations before the City's deadline for various reasons, including that the notice did not identify the specific violations or indicate how much of the total fine was attributable to each violation. So, starting in September 2015, DJB received a daily $250 fine from the City. As he started to do work on the property to bring it into compliance, a code enforcement officer for the City assured DJB that the fines would be forgiven and the lien removed if he continued to make progress on correcting the violations. Nevertheless, the City allowed the daily fines to continue and balloon for nearly six years to an astounding $552,50, waiting until June 2021 to foreclose on the property. By the time the City foreclosed on the enormous lien, DJB had remedied all of the code violations. DJB filed an answer with affirmative defenses of unclean hands, estoppel, and doctrine of avoidable consequences in response to the foreclosure action. The City then moved for summary judgment and two weeks before the hearing date, DJB moved for a continuance of the hearing and leave to add counterclaims against the City and its Municipal Enforcement Board, alleging violations of DJB's rights under the Florida Constitution. The added claims include violations of the Excessive Fines Clause and Due Process Clause, and that the code enforcement officer's statement to DJB should have estopped the City from foreclosing on the property. The trial court rejected the request to add counterclaims and granted the City's summary judgment. Florida's Second District Court of Appeal then affirmed the judgment on appeal, due to the fact that DJB didn't bring constitutional claims during the 30 day administrative order period. PLF represented DJB in filing a brief seeking discretionary review by the Florida Supreme court, which was denied. Now, PLF represents DJB before the Middle District of Florida to argue that the Constitution bars municipal governments like the City of Largo from deploying their code enforcement powers as money-making schemes. The complaint was filed and awaits action by the court, thus it is premature to seek fees. Fair v. Continental Resources. Kevin and Terry Fair fell behind on their property taxes after medical problems caused severe financial hardship. When they failed to pay $5,200 in taxes, interest, penalties, and costs by the deadline, Scotts Bluff County extinguished the Fairs' entire interest in their $60,000 home and conveyed it to an investor who paid the tax debt. Unlike other types of debt collection, the Fairs' foreclosed home was not sold after competitive bidding, leaving no opportunity for the Fairs to be paid for their equity from the proceeds remaining after paying the debt. After Terry Fair died, PLF represented Kevin Fair in a petition asking the U.S. Supreme Court to review the statutes authorizing home equity theft. The Court granted the petition, vacated the Nebraska Supreme Court decision, and remanded for reconsideration in light of PLF's victory in Tyler v. Hennepin County. On remand, PLF filed supplemental briefs and orally argued in the Nebraska Supreme Court. A favorable decision was issued and PLF filed a motion for attorneys fees. The government also filed a petition for rehearing, which was denied, along with PLF's motion for attorneys fees. Gerlach v. Rokita. Indiana's Unclaimed Property Act gives the state authority to take custody of unclaimed property such as unclaimed wages, unclaimed insurance proceeds, and uncashed checks held by banks and insurance companies after a specified period of dormancy. Pursuant to the Act, the Indiana attorney general took custody of two separate pieces of dormant property owned by Ms. Gerlach. Both are valued at over $100. Ms. Gerlach submitted the necessary paperwork to reclaim one of those pieces of property valued at $100.93, and after approving her claim, Indiana returned precisely that amount. The state did not compensate her for interest accrued on the property while the state retained custody, which goes against Seventh Circuit case law, violating the Takings Clause. Ms. Gerlach sued several current and former state officials in federal court for violating the Fifth Amendment Takings Clause, seeking just compensation and declaratory and injunctive relief. Ms. Gerlach also sought compensatory relief under 42 U.S.C. 1983 for alleged constitutional violations by the Indiana attorney general and the two attorney generals who precede the current. The district court held that Ms. Gerlach's claims for prospective relief were moot and the state's sovereign immunity under the Eleventh Amendment bars any claim for compensation against state employees. The Seventh Circuit affirmed the district court's decision in a published decision, violating the Supreme Court rules in Devillier. PLF represents Ms. Gerlach in her petition for writ of certiorari before the US Supreme Court on the issue that the Eleventh Amendment presents no bar to takings claims against the states. The petition was later denied, thus PLF cannot seek attorneys fees.
Form 990, Part III, Line 4aHadian v. California Coastal Commission. San Luis Obispo County imposed a moratorium on new development in 2001, based on the limited water supply available, that was later incorporated into the Local coastal Plan. However, some existing customers had already obtained water meters and could not be denied the right to develop. PLF represents Al Hadian and Ralph Bookout in state court. Both men obtained water meters before 2001 and development permits from the County. The Coastal Commission then stepped in and denied the permits because it views any additional water use as a per se adverse impact. The Commission's rewriting of the county's program undermines the rule of law to deny individuals their property rights. The state trial court issued a favorable ruling. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Hamann v. Heart Mountain Irrigation District. The Hamanns' own a 100 acre property in rural Wyoming. They are members of the Heart Mountain Irrigation District, which is a ditch company with governmental powers organized under the laws of Wyoming. The Hamanns' pay taxes and assessments to receive water from the irrigation district. In 2016, the Hamanns' learned that the District plans to build a road through their property and immediately began to correspond with the District. The District claimed an unrecorded easement along both sides of the canal, which is where they plan to build the road, and the Hamanns' disagreed with claim of an unrecorded easement. In 2018, the District requested to move equipment on the Hamann property which provided irrigation water to a neighbor's property. When the District's manager, Mr. Watts, and Mr. Hamann got in a dispute regarding the scope of access given to the District, Mr. Watts started to damage the Hamann property with an excavator and struck Mr. Hamann with the bucket of the machine. Mr. Hamann sued under 42 U.S. 1983 that predicated on violations of the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment. The District argued that the District's employees were not given permission to do what they did to the Hamanns' property, while Mr. Watts argued the opposite. The district court then ruled in favor of the District, when PLF stepped in to represent Mr. Hamann in his appeal to the Wyoming Supreme Court. The case has been fully briefed and argued before the Court. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Haney v. Town of Mashpee, Massachusetts. PLF represents Matthew Haney, the trustee overseeing 4-acre Gooseberry Island in Popponesset Bay, Massachusetts. For ten years, Haney attempted to obtain permission to develop the island with one single-family residence. Various agencies forced Haney to play regulatory whack-a-mole, preventing Haney from building one home on his own land until he obtained permission from multiple agencies. When the Town refused to grant zoning variances necessary to build, Haney sued for a taking. Lower federal courts claimed his case was not ripe for decision and refused to rule on the merits. To support property owners' access to courts, PLF filed a petition for writ of certiorari urging the Court to consider whether a regulatory takings claim is ripe when a landowner has received a flat "no" on any one of three necessary permits required to build a home. The petition was denied. PLF did not seek or recover fees. Mr. Haney then filed new litigation in the federal district court, again alleging takings claims under both Lucas and Penn Central, and the Town filed a motion to dismiss. At this point, PLF represented Mr. Haney in his second suit against the Town and filed a response to the Town's motion to dismiss. The court denied the Town's motion to dismiss. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Heights Apartments, LLC v. Walz. PLF represents Heights Apartments, LLC, in the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals on the question of whether sovereign immunity defeats plaintiff's claim that Minnesota's COVID-related eviction ban violated the Takings Clause. The federal district court held that Eleventh Amendment sovereign immunity principles bar Heights' takings claim. PLF's appeal seeks to secure federal court review of claims against state entities under the federal Takings Clause. An adverse decision was issued in this case, thus PLF cannot seek attorneys fees. HomeRoom, Inc. v. City of Shawnee, Kansas. PLF represent HomeRoom, Inc. (a property management company) and Val French in a federal lawsuit challenging Shawnee's "co-living ban ordinance, which regulates the occupancy of homes on the basis of family relationships by prohibiting four or more unrelated persons from living together. When the ordinance was adopted, Val lived with her husband, their two adult sons, and the girlfriend of one of the sons. Fearing enforcement, the son and girlfriend moved out. Homeowners and individuals have a fundamental right to establish a household that meets their personal needs without undue government interference. The ordinance violates the due process and equal protections of the U.S. Constitution as well as state land use statutes. The trial court ruled in favor of the city. PLF appealed to the Tenth Circuit where the case has been fully briefed and argued. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Hood v. Officers of the California Department of Agriculture. In 2024, the California Department of Food and Agriculture (CFDA) applied to the local superior court for a warrant to enter properties in San Bernardino to inspect them for pests. The court then issued the permit, which authorizes the CDFA to enter any private property within a 554-square-mile area with no further judicial scrutiny. This type of general warrant fails to comply with the Fourth Amendment's Particularity and Oath or Affirmation Clauses. PLF represents Mr. Hood who lives within the 554-square-mile radius for the general permit. The area in which he resides is historically known for its voluminous citrus trees, which grow on residential and public properties alike throughout the area. In early 2024, Mr. Hood received a notice from CDFA requesting permission to search his property for oriental fruit flies, and Mr. Hood responded withholding his consent. The CDFA then placed another notice on Mr. Hood's property that he was to call the Department in the next three days to schedule a removal of the trees from his property. Then in early April 2024, the CDFA, the California State Police, and the San Bernardino Police Department arrived at Mr. Hood's property to execute a general warrant to search his property, forcing him to let them search his property without his consent. A core guarantee of the Fourth Amendment is the right of all property owners to be secure in their property; this includes the right of all property owners to be secure in their property. PLF filed a complaint in district court and the Department moved to dismiss the case, which PLF opposed, and a hearing was held, which received an adverse outcome for Mr. Hood. PLF filed a second amended complaint, and the case is awaiting a second hearing on the motion to dismiss. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Idaho Conservation League v. Poe. PLF represents Shannon Poe in the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals to challenge a district court decision that, in deferring to EPA regulations, held that Poe's suction dredge mining "added" pollutants to a "water of the United States and thus required a permit under section 402 of the Clean Water Act. Because suction dredge mining does not in fact add pollutants to regulated waters, it does not require a permit under section 402. At most, the discharge of "dredged or fill material" might have required a permit under section 404. The Ninth Circuit issued an adverse decision. PLF petitioned for rehearing en banc, which was denied. PLF filed a petition for writ of certiorari, which was denied. PLF cannot seek attorneys fees.
Form 990, Part III, Line 4aIten v. County of Los Angeles. Howard Iten is a retired auto mechanic who depends on rental income from a single commercial property in Lawndale, California. His current tenant is an auto repair franchisee who refused to fully pay his rent during the COVID-19 pandemic, even though his business remained open the entire time. He owes Iten thousands of dollars in back rent but Iten cannot evict him under Los Angeles County's commercial eviction moratorium. The franchisee can avoid paying any current or back-rent until a full year after the moratorium expires and need never pay interest or fees. The moratorium undermines the lease contract without accomplishing anything to curb the emergency that supposedly justified its enactment. PLF represents Iten in a federal lawsuit to assert his rights under the federal Constitution's Contract Clause. The court dismissed the lawsuit. PLF appealed to the Ninth Circuit, which issued a favorable decision and remanded for litigation on the merits. The district court again dismissed the lawsuit. PLF appealed and the case was briefed and argued before the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. The Ninth Circuit ruled against Mr. Iten and PLF petitioned the United States Supreme Court. The petition was denied, and PLF cannot seek attorneys fees. Johnson v. City of East Orange, New Jersey. In 2014, Lynette Johnson purchased commercial property in East Orange for two of her children to run a business out of the location. She spent $55,000 to purchase the property and another $16,000 getting architectural plans and permits for renovations. The City sent notices of tax assessments and eventual tax lien and foreclosure only to that property, and not to her nearby residential address in Newark where she has lived (and paid taxes) for nearly thirty years. By the time her tax lien was foreclosed in 2018, she owed a little under $20,000. The City sold the property to a private investor for $101,000 and kept it all. PLF represents Johnson in a state court lawsuit arguing that the city's foreclosure and keeping of the surplus effected a taking requiring just compensation. The parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment and supplemental briefs regarding PLF's victory in Tyler v. Hennepin County and other home equity theft cases. The court ruled for the city on procedural grounds. PLF appealed and a favorable decision was issued. The city filed a notice of petition for certification with the state Supreme Court and PLF plans to file a cross-petition for certification. Because this case is ongoing, it is premature to seek fees. KOGAP Enterprises, Inc. v. City of Medford, Oregon. KOGAP Enterprises is a fourth-generation family-owned Oregon corporation which operated a sawmill for several decades on the southern outskirts of Medford, Oregon. In the 1990s, changes in the wood products industry required a restructuring of the company's business, which culminated in the plan to develop its 121-acre sawmill site into a mixed-use planned unit development (PUD).Since approval in 2007, KOGAP has sought and obtained numerous permits related to the PUD. In 2022, KOGAP requested a few modifications to the PUD and the City approved the requests as long as KOGAP dedicate and construct a road and bridge that would connect to an existing roadway on a separate development. The Supreme Court has repeatedly said that singling out some property owners to pay a disproportionate share of the cost of public roads and bridges is unconstitutional. After losing its administrative appeal, KOGAP filed a takings case in Oregon state court and the City removed to federal district court. In federal court, KOGAP lost the cross motions for summary judgment at which point PLF stepped in to represent KOGAP in their appeal to the Ninth Circuit. In this case, the district court's rough proportionality analysis was wrong. The case is briefed and awaiting oral argument before the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, thus it is premature to seek fees. Masucci v. Judy's Moody. Judy's Moody LLC is a company owned by Keith Dennis that holds title to his coastal home in Maine. For over 400 years, coastal property owners in Maine have held title to the intertidal zone (land between the mean high tide line and the low tide line). In 2021, activists unhappy with this settled law filed a lawsuit seeking a judicial declaration that all intertidal zones on Maine's coastline are public property. PLF represents Judy's Moody to argue that the right to control access to private property is an essential property right and that changing hundreds of years of settled private property rights raises serious Takings Clause concerns. The court ruled in favor of Judy's Moody that private property owners, not the state, own the intertidal zone, but allowed one part of the activists' lawsuit to continue. PLF filed a motion for reconsideration on that last issue. Litigation continues on the scope of the public easement and the parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment. Victory! The property owners continue to hold title to their land in the intertidal zone. The activists appealed and PLF cross-appealed, and oral argument was held on the matter. The case is awaiting decision. Because this case is ongoing, it is premature to seek fees. Medeiros v. Virginia Dept. of Wildlife Resources. James Medeiros's property is posted with "No Trespassing" signs yet has been overrun frequently by hunting dogs and their owners. PLF represents James and other property owners with posted land to challenge the Commonwealth's so-called "right to retrieve" law, which allows sportsmen to enter private property any time of day, any time of year, to retrieve their hunting dogs, without the landowner's consent. The state court lawsuit argues that this law effects a per se physical taking without just compensation. The trial court granted the government's motion to dismiss and the appellate court affirmed. PLF's petition for rehearing was denied. PLF appealed to the Virginia Supreme Court, which agreed to hear the case. The case was briefed and argued before the Virginia Supreme Court and an adverse decision was issued, thus attorneys fees cannot be awarded. Mendelson v. County of San Mateo, California. PLF represents Felix Mendelson in the Ninth Circuit, challenging the County's prohibition on development in designated sensitive habitat as a taking. Felix filed a coastal development permit to build a single family home on property that all parties know is a designated riparian corridor where all construction is prohibited. Rather than condemning the land or denying Mendelson's permit so he could file an inverse condemnation claim, the government simply sat on the application and refused to issue a response. PLF argues that local government cannot avoid rendering a final decision as a means to avoid liability for a taking. The case was briefed and argued before the Ninth Circuit, which later issued an adverse decision. PLF cannot seek attorneys fees in this case. Montanans Against Irresponsible Densification v. State of Montana. PLF represents Habitat for Humanity of Missoula, Montana, and Chris Chitty, a homeowner and Missoula architect, as intervenors defending against a lawsuit challenging a Montana state law that requires local governments to allow accessory dwelling units (ADUs) and duplexes on all residentially zoned parcels. The intervenors are defending their right under state law to build a second residential unit or ADU on lots zoned "single-family." PLF urges a rule that allows a state to recognize and enforce existing homeowners' contract and property rights in voluntary use restrictions in the context of a general upzoning scheme. The Montana Eighteenth Judicial District in Gallatin County ruled in favor of our motion to intervene and a cross-motion for summary judgment was filed. The court granted in part the cross-motion and the state appealed the decision to the Supreme Court of Montana. PLF plans to file an answering brief on cross-appeal. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees.
Form 990, Part III, Line 4aNieveen v. TAX 106. When Sandra Nieveen failed to pay property taxes on her home, the county treasurer sold the tax certificate (a lien on the property) to a private firm, TAX 106, that buys tax certificates then flips the property and retains the profits. TAX 106 bought the tax certification on Nieveen's home for approximately $3,500 owed in taxes. Three years later, TAX 106 notified Nieveen that she had three months to pay all taxes, interest, penalties, and costs, or she would lose her property. Nieveen did not pay. The county treasurer issued the tax deed to the property to the private firm, granting it full title to the property. Nieveen lost her entire property, worth nearly $62,000. The Nebraska Supreme Court rejected Nieveen's statutory and constitutional claims, and PLF filed a petition for writ of certiorari on her behalf. The Court granted the petition, vacated the Nebraska Supreme Court decision, and remanded for reconsideration in light of PLF's victory in Tyler v. Hennepin County. On remand, PLF filed briefs and orally argued in the Nebraska Supreme Court. The court issued a favorable decision and the county's motion for rehearing was later denied. PLF did not seek attorneys fees in this case. O'Connor v. Eubanks. PLF represents Dennis O'Connor before the U.S. Supreme Court to challenge Michigan state officials who kept the interest income that accrued on O'Connor's property that had been deemed abandoned and taken into state custody until O'Connor filed the paperwork to reclaim it. The State's retention of the interest income was a taking without just compensation. The lower appellate court barred O'Connor's lawsuit on the grounds of sovereign immunity and qualified immunity. PLF filed a petition for writ of certiorari to pursue O'Connor's takings claim and seek a ruling that states and officials cannot hide behind immunity doctrines to avoid paying just compensation after taking private property. The State filed a cross-petition and PLF filed a reply. The petitions were denied, thus PLF cannot seek attorneys fees. Oom Living, LLC v. City of Seattle. PLF represents Oom Living in a state court challenge to Seattle's imposition of a water main extension requirement on the development of a housing project. PLF seeks to extend the principle that legislative exactions are subject to heightened constitutional review showing that the exactions have a clear nexus and are roughly proportional to the impact of the project. Without nexus and proportionality, the exactions are unconstitutional conditions and violate the Fifth Amendment. Singling out some property owners to pay a disproportionate share of the cost of public amenities that are used by everyone is unfair and unconstitutional. These costs and arbitrary obstacles to development also drive up the cost of housing. PLF filed for summary judgement in the King County Superior Court. A hearing was held on the matter and the court granted PLF's motion for summary judgment. The government then filed a motion for partial summary judgment, which PLF opposed, and a hearing was held before the Superior Court. The court then denied the government's motion and issued a favorable decision on the 42 U.S. Code 1983 claim, which the city has appealed. PLF awaits a briefing schedule from the Washington Court of Appeals. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Pilling v. City of Healdsburg, California. Ms. Pilling owns an existing duplex in Healdsburg, CA. She recently subdivided the lot and now plans to build a new single-family residence on the second lot with an attached ADU. The City indicated that her project is subject to the City's "inclusionary housing" program, under which she would have to either dedicate land to the City to be used for "affordable housing purposes or else pay a fee of around $20,000 into the City's inclusionary housing fund. The City has different fee schedules depending on the purpose of the property, and because Ms. Pilling was planning to put one single-family home for herself and an ADU to use as a rental property, she didn't believe the program applied to her. PLF represents Ms. Pilling in a suit in federal district court against the City's unconstitutional inclusionary zoning policies which lack both an essential nexus with and a rough proportionality to the expected impact of housing development. The City and PLF filed a joint notice of dismissal in district court after coming to an agreement to refund Ms. Pilling the inclusionary housing fee, plus interest. Attorney fees were awarded in the amount of $5,000. PPI Enterprises v. Town of Windham. PLF represents Robert Peterson, owner of PPI Enterprises, who applied twice to the Town of Windham for a permit to develop a vacant, limited industrial"-zoned property that sits sixty feet above the adjacent road. The Town twice denied the application based on its aversion to PPI's grading plan that requires blasting rock, a routine process in the Granite State. PPI pursued every possible appeal, to no avail. Left with an inaccessible vacant lot, PPI alleged a federal takings claim that reached the New Hampshire Supreme Court. The court never reached the merits, instead deeming the case unripe due to the Town's assertion that it might grant a third application that includes new unidentified mitigation measures. Based solely on the Town's assertion, the court below held that the two application denials did not present a final decision and made the lawsuit unripe for adjudication. PLF filed a petition for writ of certiorari asking the Supreme Court to decide if two final denials of development applications suffice to ripen a regulatory takings claim, where the government asserts that it might grant a third application if modified in some unspecified way. The Supreme Court denied PLF's petition, thus attorneys fees cannot be recovered. redT Homes v. City and County of Denver, Colorado. redT Homes is a residential real estate development firm in Denver, Colorado whose mission is to develop sustainably built and attainably priced homes. PLF represents redT Homes in a suit against Denver's Expanded Housing Affordability (EHA) program. The EHA is an inclusionary zoning policy that includes a mandatory affordable housing set-aside for projects of more than ten units and a mandatory affordable housing linkage fee for projects less than ten units, as well as for all commercial development projects. PLF argues in federal district court that the EHA is an unconstitutional condition in violation of Nollan and Dolan. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Rimmer v. City of Edmonds, Washington. Pursuant to a local ordinance, the City of Edmonds is compelling Nathan Rimmer to dedicate land for the installation and preservation of trees in exchange for permission to build a family home on his own vacant lot, which requires the removal of a single dogwood tree. Had the condition been placed on the building permit, then the Supreme Court decisions in Nollan v. California Coastal Commission and Dolan v. City of Tigard would require the city to prove that the condition was related and roughly proportional to the building project. Because the condition is imposed by a legislative enactment however, there is a split among courts as to whether the Nollan/Dolan analysis applies. PLF represents Rimmer in a state court challenge to the ordinance's "legislative exaction and filed a motion for summary judgment. The court ruled that the requirement was an unconstitutional taking, but litigation continues on other claims. The city appealed the ruling to the Washington Court of Appeals, where the case is being briefed. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Ringenberg v. United States. Dr. Gregory Ringenberg owns rural land near the Great Smoky Mountains in Tennessee, on which he seeks to build a private family retreat. The U.S. Forest Service, however, asserts the right to build a public road along his property based on a disputed deed that was never recorded. PLF filed a federal lawsuit on behalf of Dr. Ringenberg seeking to quiet title to his property from the Foret Service's assertion of an easement and establish the boundary line of the property. PLF further argues that the Fifth Amendment's takings clause forbids the Forest Service from acquiring an interest in real property by prescription. The district court denied the motion for judgment on the pleadings and the case continues in district court. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees.
Form 990, Part III, Line 4aSabey v. Massachusetts Department of Children & Families. When married couple Joshua Sabey and Sarah Perkins took their infant son to the hospital for a high fever, the staff x-rayed the infant to rule out pneumonia. Spotting a healed broken rib, the hospital detained Perkins and the baby for three days while they were questioned and ultimately released. At 1:00 a.m. the next night, the police arrived without a warrant, issuing threats, and demanding to take the children. After three months, the Sabeys were exonerated of all wrongdoing and the case against them permanently dismissed. PLF represents the family in federal district court in a lawsuit to challenge the agency's warrantless seizure of the children when there was no imminent risk of harm, in violation of the Fourth Amendment. PLF defeated motions to dismiss and qualified immunity. Litigation continues. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Sanchez v. Torrez. PLF attorneys represents Lucia Sanchez and other landowners in a federal court challenge to New Mexico's taking of their right to exclude trespassers from walking and wading in their non-navigable streams. The lawsuit seeks to enjoin the New Mexico Attorney General and members of the state Game & Fish Commission from enforcing a state supreme court decree guaranteeing public access to previously private non-navigable streambeds. A State cannot transform private property into public property without just compensation, whether through a judicial decree or executive action. PLF filed a complaint in the District Court of New Mexico and the court dismissed the complaint. The case was appealed to the Tenth Circuit where the case is fully briefed and awaiting oral argument. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Sarkisian v. City of the Village of Douglas, Michigan. The Village of Douglas requires a permit to raise chickens, but unlike anywhere else, adjacent landowners have the right to veto a chicken permit for any or no reason. According to town ordinance, once a permit is received, all adjacent landowners are notified and if there is an objection to the issuance of the permit, the permit will not be granted and there is no right of appeal. In this case, the Village granted Ms. Sarkisian's permit application without providing notice to neighbors. So, six months after receiving her permit, building a coop, and bonding with her birds, the City provided neighbors notice and one of the neighbors who lives in their home for three months out of the year objected to Ms. Sarkisian's already built and previously approved chicken permit. The government can't give ones neighbors an unreviewable veto over reasonable and legal uses of what you can and cannot do on your own property. The government also cannot take away your property rights without informing you and giving you a chance to object. Representing Ms. Sarkisian, PLF filed a complaint in district court and after PLF filed for a temporary restraining order, the court denied the order but converted the motion to an ex parte relief. Because the case is ongoing, it is premature to seek fees. Schafer v. Kent County, Michigan. PLF took over representation of Michigan property owners who seek retroactive application of PLF's victory in Rafaeli v. Oakland County. Rafaeli held that property owners who lost their home equity in tax foreclosure proceedings may state a claim for an unconstitutional taking without just compensation under the Michigan Constitution. The Schafers and other homeowners who lost their property prior to the Rafaeli decision seek to recover their surplus equity. PLF filed briefs and argued in the Michigan Supreme Court and a favorable decision was issued by the court. PLF did not seek attorneys fees in this case. Scharp v. Teton County, Wyoming. After living in the Town of Jackson for most of their adult lives, the Scharps sold the home they first bought in Jackson and bought their current home and five-acre property. The couple planned to rent out the existing older cabin and build a single-family home on the five-acre property, but the County notified the Scharps about an ADU regulation that requires the ADU to be 1,000 sq. ft. or smaller. The Scharps decreased the habitable floor area of the cabin, but the County came back and said that they would have to fill the uninhabitable basement with gravel or the like so it wouldn't be counted against the floor area maximum. The family then registered the cabin on the County's registry of historically significant buildings so the ADU regulation wouldn't apply, and they were able to apply for a building permit for their home. The County came back to the Scharps with several issues with their property and after going back and forth several times, Teton County approved their modified plans that first required the Scharps to pay a total of $33,471.05 in mitigation fees to receive their permit. The Scharps paid the fee and PLF represents them in a federal district court challenge to the County's so-called workforce housing policies which lack an essential nexus as required by the Fifth Amendment. Governments cannot force homebuilders to foot the bill for problems they do not create. Nor can they hold the right to use your property hostage to extract exorbitant fees. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. SCLS Realty, LLC and Sixty Three Johnston, LLC v. Town of Johnston, Rhode Island. SCLS Realty and Sixty Three Johnston are real estate businesses owned by two well known families in Johnston, Rhode Island. The owners of both businesses are respected landlords in the community and have tenants who have been with them for over a decade. Around 1985, the businesses bought property in town and slowly started buying the surrounding property to one day turn it into a safe and affordable rental property. In 2024, the State of Rhode Island announced that it would streamline the approval process for the development of new affordable housing statewide, so the businesses saw this as the perfect time to start building a 252-unit complex on their property. After holding a required pre-land development and subdivision application submission meeting, the mayor of Johnston made it known that he did not want the affordable housing development to be put on that property. The mayor then took the businesses property using eminent domain, saying that he now wants to construct a new municipal complex on all 31 acres; the government cannot take property through eminent domain simply because it doesn't like an owner's lawful use. The Town held a special meeting and adopted the resolution to take the property, violating the Public Use Clause. PLF filed a complaint in federal district court and a week later filed a motion for preliminary injunction and a temporary restraining order. SCLS Realty and Sixty Three Johnston were granted the temporary restraining order against the Town and it was then converted to a preliminary injunction order. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Shands v. City of Marathon, Florida. The City of Marathon sought to take the Shands family's property and avoid liability for just compensation by promising credits towards some possible building permit somewhere else in the county at some indeterminate time in the future, perhaps to be enjoyed by some third party. Representing the Shands family, PLF filed a state court lawsuit challenging the city's taking of the family's property without payment of just compensation. "Transferable development rights" do not allow a government to avoid a finding of a taking, and, moreover, "just compensation" means financial compensation, not a chit to be traded for hard-to-define value. The trial court issued an adverse decision. PLF appealed. Victory! The court held that the city unconstitutionally took the Shands' property without just compensation. The city petitioned for rehearing en banc that PLF opposed, and the court denied. The city filed a motion for certification that PLF opposed and the court issued a favorable decision. The city petitioned the Florida Supreme Court for review, where the case is fully briefed and awaiting order. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees.
Form 990, Part III, Line 4aShear Development Co., LLC v. California Coastal Commission (CCC). PLF represents Shear Development Co. in the California Supreme Court to challenge the CCC's unlawful denial of a building permit on grounds not contained within, or inconsistent with, a certified Local Coastal Program (LCP). Local governments are the primary permitting authority under the Coastal Act once the CCC certifies an LCP. The Commission's proper role on appeal from a local government permit approval is to determine whether the local government acted inconsistently with the certified LCP. Its role is not to redefine or amend certified LCPs under the guise of its adjudicatory/appellate powers. PLF filed a petition for review, which was granted. The case is fully briefed before the Supreme Court of California and awaiting a date for oral argument. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Sheetz v. County of El Dorado, California. PLF co-represents George Sheetz, who was charged a roughly $24,000 fee for "traffic mitigation" as a condition of getting a permit to build a small manufactured home on his rural lot in Placerville, California. He sought a refund of the fee because it unfairly imposed on him costs for road building and maintenance that had nothing to do with his project. California courts denied his claim. The Supreme Court agreed to decide whether ordinances or other legislation imposing building permit fees like those charged to George are subject to the "unconstitutional conditions" tests established in PLF's victory in Nollan v. California Coastal Commission, and subsequent decisions. Victory! The Supreme Court unanimously held that property owners may challenge legislative exactions that violate the Takings Clause and unconstitutional conditions doctrine. After remand, the case was fully briefed and argued before the California Court of Appeals, Third Appellate District. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. State of Hawaii v. Williams. Don Williams is an elderly single father, raising a young son. He purchased property in Maui in 1994 by his own resourcefulness and initiative and then rented it to the State, intending to use the income from the property to provide for his son's future. The Hawaii Harbors Division exercised its eminent domain power to take Williams' property, which the State was already leasing from Williams. Then the state improperly used the "undivided fee" rule when it appraised William's property at $2.67 million and excluded information about the property's income-generating potential. As the result of two trial court rulings, Williams may owe the state more than $1 million for the taking of his own property. PLF represented Don in the Hawaii Court of Appeals. Victory! The court rejected the trial court's gatekeeping that prevented Don's evidence of valuation and remanded. PLF filed a motion for summary judgement, a hearing was held, and a judgment was issued in favor of Mr. Williams. We await notice from the government of their appeal. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Stavrianoudakis v. California Department of Fish and Wildlife. PLF represents falconers and a falconry conservancy organization to challenge state and federal rules requiring warrantless inspection of their homes (a Fourth Amendment violation) and prohibiting photography or filming of falcons for commercial purposes (a First Amendment violation). The lawsuit also challenges the promulgation of these rules by a sub-level bureaucrat as a violation of the Constitution's Appointments Clause. PLF filed a federal complaint and a motion for preliminary injunction. The state filed motions to dismiss. The court dismissed the Fourth Amendment claims but held that the First Amendment claims are likely to succeed and denied the motion to dismiss on that basis. The parties settled the First Amendment claims, which included $178,000 in fees for PLF. PLF continued to litigate the Fourth Amendment claims on appeal to the Ninth Circuit, which then affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded the case back to the Eastern District of California for consideration of the attorneys fees motion. The California Department of Fish and Wildlife moved to stay the case until the state's administrative process is completed, and PLF opposed. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek attorneys fees. Stilts, LLC v. Rhode Island. PLF represents Stilts, LLC, which owns four residential lots in Charleston Beach in a state court challenge to Rhode Island's new law resetting the public beach boundary on private property at a point located 10 feet inland of the "recognizable high tide line," e.g., the debris or seaweed line created at high tide. PLF argues that a new law that imposes a public beach easement inland onto private beachfront land without a mechanism for compensation or compliance with state law rules requiring that easements be proven in court effects an unconstitutional taking or seizure of property. If the government wants to expand public beaches, it must pay for them. The government moved to dismiss the complaint, which the court treated as a motion for summary judgment, and the Rhode Island Superior Court held a hearing on the matter. The case is now before the Rhode Island Supreme Court, where the state filed a memorandum of law in support of a petition for leave of certiorari. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Varela v. City of El Paso, Texas. After fire partially damaged Luis Varela's home, the city declared it a nuisance and ordered Varela to fix his home, warning it could be demolished if he did not. Varela immediately spent $30,000 for renovations, but the city refused to grant him permits and eventually ordered demolition. When Varela sued, claiming demolition would be an unconstitutional taking of his property, Texas courts held his takings claim was barred because he did not judicially challenge the original nuisance determination. PLF petitioned the Texas Supreme Court for review and the Court ordered briefing on the merits. The Court denied the petition for review, and PLF cannot seek or recover attorneys fees. Vondra v. City of Billings, Montana. Billings passed an ordinance requiring all licensed massage therapy business owners, including home-practitioners, to agree to warrantless, unannounced searches and seizures as a condition of doing business. Refusal of even one such invasive search could result in fines, loss of license, or jail. Enforcement officers can open any containers or cupboards they please, including employee and client lockers, to look for evidence that anyone broke any law or regulation, civil or criminal. This includes client records, which often contain sensitive medical and insurance information that is normally protected under federal law. PLF represents Theresa Vondra, a licensed massage therapist, in a federal lawsuit arguing that governments cannot pursue social goals like fighting crime through warrantless fishing expeditions at the expense of livelihoods and property rights. The parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment. The trial court issued a mixed decision. It enjoined warrantless searches of home practitioners' private homes and properties, but not searches of businesses in a commercial district. PLF appealed the latter ruling to the Ninth Circuit and received attorneys' fees of $137,511 for the partial victory in district court. The appeal is briefed before the Ninth Circuit and oral argument is scheduled. Because the case is still pending, PLF cannot seek attorneys fees for the remainder of the case. Wall v. Ainsworth. In 2018, the Wall family wanted to build a swimming pool next to their home on their property in Hollister Ranch, California. Like all landowners within the 14,500-acre, century-old working cattle ranch, the Walls needed a permit. Santa Barbara County approved the project; however, the California Coastal Commission denied the permit. The Commission said the construction would violate the Coastal Act's public access rules, even though the Walls' property is nearly a mile from the shoreline and no one has ever used their property to get to the coast. PLF filed a federal lawsuit challenging the Commission's arbitrary and unlawful permit denial. After defeating a motion to dismiss, litigation is ongoing. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees.
Form 990, Part III, Line 4aWilkins v. United States. PLF represents Montana residents Larry Wilkins and Jane Stanton, both of whom own property adjacent to the Bitterroot National Forest. The government invaded their property interests by advertising a public access road across their land, resulting in trespassing, illegal hunting, and other injuries. They sued in a quiet title action to determine the scope of an easement held by the United States over their private land. Rejecting favorable findings and recommendations by a magistrate, the trial court ordered dismissal of the case on statute of limitations grounds. The court denied PLF's motion to alter or amend the judgment but also clarified its ruling for appeal. PLF appealed to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, which affirmed. PLF filed a petition for rehearing, which was denied. PLF then filed a petition for writ of certiorari, which was granted. Victory! The Supreme Court ruled that Wilkins and Stanton may pursue their case against the federal government. PLF filed for summary judgment in district court and the court later denied the motion. PLF appealed the case to the Ninth Circuit, where the case is being briefed. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Williams v. Alameda County. PLF represents John Williams and other owners of residential rental properties in Oakland, California, as well as a housing provider trade association. The owners' respective tenants violated the terms of their leases in numerous respects, including the refusal to pay rent, the harassment of other tenants, and destruction and damage to the rental premises. The inability to evict these tenants due to a local eviction moratorium is a physical taking contrary to the Fifth Amendment and caused financial, physical, and emotional distress to the owners. PLF filed a lawsuit in federal court, followed by a motion for summary judgment. The district court rejected the facial claim and allowed the as-applied claim to move forward. PLF sought certification for immediate appeal to the Ninth Circuit, which was denied. PLF filed two amended complaints before the Northern District of California, where the case awaits decision from the judge. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Yim v. City of Seattle. PLF represents owners of several small rental properties to challenge the constitutionality of Seattle's "Fair Chance Housing Ordinance," which restricts a residential landlord from considering a tenant applicant's criminal history when deciding to whom he or she will rent the property. PLF filed the complaint in Washington state court and Seattle removed it to federal court. The parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment. While these were pending, Seattle successfully moved to certify the question of what standard of review is appropriate to the Washington Supreme Court and the federal litigation was subsequently stayed. After the Washington Supreme Court's ruling, the case returned to federal court, which granted the city's motion for summary judgment. PLF appealed to the Ninth Circuit, which struck down part of the law as violating the First Amendment, but upheld other parts. The city petitioned for rehearing en banc, and PLF filed a conditional cross-petition. Both petitions were denied. PLF filed a cert petition on the due process issue, which was denied. The case continued on remand to determine severability and the parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment. The court ruled in favor of the government so PLF appealed to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. The case was submitted on briefs for disposition and is awaiting order. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Separation of Powers: The Constitution's very structure was designed to protect liberty. It is a charter of enumerated powers, limiting the scope of federal authority and establishing a separation of legislative, executive, and judicial powers. PLF fights to end the modern administrative state, including limiting judicial deference to legislative and administrative judgments; restore separation of powers against improper delegation of authority to bureaucrats and accountability when those bureaucrats exceed their authority; defining the limited scope of federal power under the Commerce Clause; reviving the doctrine of enumerated powers; and ensuring due process of law. 3484, Inc. & 3486, Inc. v. National Labor Relations Board. PLF represents 3484, Inc. and 3486, Inc., production companies for two Hallmark movies, in a federal court challenge to a final decision by the National Labor Relations Board. They challenge the "independent" administrative agency's authority to exercise judicial power on a variety of constitutional grounds including due process, the Seventh Amendment right to a jury trial, and the non-delegation doctrine, as well as other claims under administrative law. Labor disputes should be treated like any other legal dispute: in a court of law, in front of a neutral judge and jury of peers, not in an agency tribunal where the normal rules of due process are suspended. PLF fully briefed the case before the Tenth Circuit, where a petition for rehearing has been filed. Because litigation is pending, it is premature to seek fees. ATS Tree Services LLC v. Federal Trade Commission (FTC). PLF represents ATS Tree Services LLC in a federal lawsuit challenging the statutory and constitutional authority of the FTC to ban all non-compete agreements. The ban, implemented without congressional authority, remakes employment relationships nationwide. Agencies must operate within their statutory and constitutional bounds to avoid unnecessarily harming Americans and their businesses. ATS Tree Services provides good jobs and valuable training. Those efforts are undermined by the FTC's unilateral decision to ban all non-compete agreements that are critical to the success of ATS. The case was voluntarily dismissed, thus PLF cannot seek attorney fees. Bell v. Lutnick. PLF represents Karen Bell and Steven Rash in a federal lawsuit challenging an amendment to the Gulf of Mexico Fishery Management plan on the grounds that Gulf of Mexico Fishery Management Council controlling the issuance of the plan is unconstitutionally structured with members appointed in violation of the Appointments Clause. Bell is a fish-seller and Rash a fisherman. The challenged plan amendment significantly reduces the commercial Greater Amberjack fishing quota, harming Bell's and Rash's businesses. PLF moved to consolidate with a related case. The trial court ruled in favor of the government and PLF appealed to the Fifth Circuit. The case continues in the Fifth Circuit and is awaiting argument. Because this case is pending, it is premature to see fees. Bikeyah v. Trump. Representing landowners, hunters, outdoor sportsmen, and ranchers, PLF attorneys successfully moved to intervene in this case brought by environmentalists to challenge the President's authority to rescind or reduce previously designated national monuments and filed briefs in the case. Litigation is ongoing. Because this case is pending, it would be premature to seek fees. Black v. FINRA/SEC. PLF represents Frank Black and Southeastern Investments, N.A., Inc. (a North Carolina based securities broker-dealer), in a federal lawsuit to stop an ongoing and unlawful enforcement action brought by the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA). The FINRA adjudicatory process is unconstitutional because the corporation is acting as a government agency, but the officers responsible for the adjudicatory process are not appointed by the government. The lawsuit challenges FINRA's ability to make and enforce rules that have the force and effect of federal law. Moreover, the Securities and Exchange Commission exercises insufficient control over FINRA's lawmaking and enforcement functions, such that Congress has delegated away too much power to the private company. PLF sought a preliminary injunction. The SEC vacated its order constraining Black and remanded to FINRA. PLF filed a petition for review of the SEC opinion in the Fourth Circuit and filed briefs, and an adverse decision was issued. The case went back to the district court, where it is fully briefed and awaiting decision. A petition for review from NAC has also been filed. Because this case is pending, it would be premature to seek fees.
Form 990, Part III, Line 4aBradford v. US Department of Labor. Duke Bradford owns and operates opened Arkansas Valley Adventures (AVA), a Colorado company employing 250 people who provide a full slate of outdoor experiences that stretch throughout the year, including guided, multi-day river rafting wilderness trips. With atypical workweeks during the rafting season, guides earn a flat fee per trip based on the federal minimum wage plus a fixed wage above that rate, and gratuities from customers. Because Colorado's rivers flow through federal land, rafting businesses must obtain special use permits permitted by federal law, for which they pay service fees. The U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) ordered all federal contractors to pay a $15-per-hour minimum wage, plus overtime. The rule's definition of "contractors" includes 45,000 private firms that provide concessions or recreational services-like rafting outfitters-whose only ties to the federal government are special land use permits or licenses. PLF represents Duke, and the nonprofit Colorado River Outfitters Association, in a federal lawsuit challenging the executive order mandating workers' pay structure and sought a preliminary injunction. PLF's petition for writ of certiorari was denied and the case was remanded back to trial court. The case is currently before the district court on a renewed motion for summary judgement. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Bunjes v. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. Journey 80, LLC, owns a vessel that was captained by Daniel Bunjes when it exceeded a boating speed limit regulation promulgated by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) and fined $22,500. PLF represents Bunjes and Journey 80, LLC, in an administrative hearing before the NOAA to challenge the citation. PLF argues that NOAA can't issue a speed limit for all ship traffic, punishable by massive fines and even terms of imprisonment, merely because it deems the limits "appropriate" to help a broad conservation effort. NOAA is authorized only to govern the taking of protected marine mammals and designate and protect endangered species. It cannot bypass these limits to impose additional substantive restrictions, such as the speed limits here, as a means of "carrying out" its statutory mission. The case was settled between NOAA and Mr. Bunjes, and attorneys fees were not awarded or part of the settlement. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau v. Townstone Financial, Inc. PLF represents Townstone Financial, Inc. and its CEO and principal shareholder, Barry Sturner, in a civil action brought by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) in U.S. District Court in the Northern District of Illinois and in any related appeals. CFPB alleges that discussions on a Townstone-sponsored radio show and podcast concerning crime, policing, and real estate in economically depressed neighborhoods in Chicago had the effect of discouraging loan applicants based on race. The case includes statutory and First Amendment claims. Victory! The Court dismissed CFPB's complaint with prejudice on the grounds that the challenged regulation is not authorized by law and that the agency's decision to the contrary is entitled to no deference. The agency appealed and the case was settled favorably. The CFPB reached out to Mr. Sturner months after settlement to jointly move to vacate the settlement and return the fine paid by Townstone, as a result of an internal CFPB investigation that concluded that the lawsuit against Townstone was legally and factually baseless and staff unfairly targeted Townstone for speech. A federal judge rejected the motion. As litigation is pending, it is premature to seek fees. CTM Holdings v. U.S. Dept. of Agriculture. PLF represents CTM Holdings, LLC, in a federal court challenge to the constitutionality of the Erodible Land and Wetland Conservation and Reserve Program ("Swampbuster") alleging Commerce Clause, unconstitutional conditions, and an uncompensated taking under the Fifth Amendment. PLF argues that Congress's commerce power is limited to regulation of the channels and instrumentalities of interstate commerce, as well as activities with a substantial effect on interstate commerce. Swampbuster, which regulates land, does not fit into either of those categories. Moreover, Congress may not condition the distribution of benefits on the recipient waiving a constitutional right, including those rights protected by the commerce clause. The federal trial court denied PLF's motion for summary judgment and granted the government's summary judgment, dismissing all claims with prejudice. PLF did not seek attorneys fees for this case. Doe v. U.S. Dept. of Justice. PLF represents John Doe and the Alliance for Constitutional Sex Offense Laws in a federal lawsuit to challenge a final rule issued by the U.S. Department of Justice imposing registration requirements under the Sex Offense Registration and Notification Act on those previously convicted of certain offenses. Doe's prior misdemeanor offense was expunged under California law, and he has no obligation to register as a sex offender under state law. In fact, it is impossible for him to do so. Nevertheless, the U.S. Attorney General, claiming unlimited discretion, asserted the authority to require Doe to register and presumes his guilt for a federal crime if he fails to do so. PLF filed a complaint and moved for an injunction. Victory! The court granted the injunction and declared the registration requirement unconstitutional. The case continued on the merits in district court, where it is fully briefed but stayed. Because litigation is pending, it is premature to seek fees. EFG America, LLC v. Arizona Corporation Commission. In April 2024, after an investigation, the Arizona Corporation Commission filed a complaint against EFG America, LLC alleging violations of the Arizona Securities Act and requesting monetary penalties for each violation. PLF represents EFG in the Supreme Court of Arizona to vindicate the due process and jury-trial rights of EFG and to incorporate the Seventh Amendment against the states. The right to a jury trial is a fundamental guarantee of the U.S. Constitution and it cannot be ignored just because a state government is the one bringing charges. PLF filed a petition for review in the Arizona Supreme Court and awaits a decision from the Court. Because this is a pending matter, it is premature to seek fees. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) v. Credit Bureau Center, LLC/FTC v. Consumer Defense, LLC/FTC v. Elite IT Partners. After the Supreme Court ruled that the FTC cannot obtain disgorgement as a remedy under one provision of its authorizing statute, the Commission moved to achieve the same remedy under a different provision (Section 19). Because Section 19 plainly does not permit such a remedy, PLF took over representation of defendants in the Seventh Circuit and district courts, solely to challenge the FTC's authority to impose disgorgement as a remedy for regulatory violations. The Seventh Circuit issued an adverse opinion in the Credit Bureau Center case, creating a Circuit split. PLF filed a petition for rehearing en banc, which was denied, and then filed a petition for writ of certiorari. The court ruled against Elite IT Partners and PLF appealed to the Tenth Circuit, which affirmed. PLF filed a petition for rehearing en banc, which was denied. PLF then filed a petition for writ of certiorari in the Supreme Court, which was denied. The district court ruled in Consumer Defense's favor and limited relief to the payment of refunds to harmed customers. The case is closed and PLF did not seek attorneys fees. Foster v. EPA. PLF represents Foster in a dispute with the EPA over whether intermittent and ephemeral drainages on Foster's private property are regulated by the Clean Water Act (CWA). PLF has represented Foster before the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals and the U.S. Supreme Court over this dispute, and the case is now back in the Fourth Circuit. Courts must now abide by the U.S. Supreme Court's ruling in Sackett II which was an unequivocal rejection of the agencies' previous approach to regulating private land. The appeal is held in abeyance. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees.
Form 990, Part III, Line 4aFoster v. U.S. Department of Agriculture. Arlen and Cindy Foster are third-generation farmers in Miner County, South Dakota. They have long engaged in responsible land conservation, including planting a tree line to prevent erosion. In the winter, deep snow drifts pile in the tree belt and come Spring, the melting snow collects in a farm field. A federal agency ruled that the resulting mud puddle is a federally protected wetland, thus forcing the Fosters to choose between farming their property and maintaining eligibility for federal benefits such as crop insurance. PLF represents the Fosters in federal court to challenge the Natural Resources Conservation Service's refusal to review whether one of the Fosters' farm fields contains a federally regulated wetland. The parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment. The trial court ruled in favor of the government. PLF appealed to the Eighth Circuit, which affirmed. PLF filed a petition for writ of certiorari. After the Loper Bright argument, this case was remanded to the Eighth Circuit and then again to district court. The district court asked PLF to provide a letter brief on the impact of Loper Bright on this case, and the case is now awaiting a decision from district court. Because this case is pending it is premature to seek fees. Ghost Golf v. Newsom. At Ghost Golf in Fresno, California, the weeks leading up to Halloween mark the peak season for the haunted house-themed miniature golf center, earning enough money for owner Daryn Coleman and his family to weather the springtime slowdown. However, Ghost Golf was closed by Governor Gavin Newsom's COVID-related business shutdown orders, leaving the owners with no income while still facing rental obligations and other business expenses. Newsom implemented his complex, arbitrary scheme with neither legislative authority nor an expiration date. With their livelihoods-and life savings-on the line, PLF represents Ghost Golf and another California small business owner in a state court lawsuit. The court denied a motion for preliminary injunction and PLF appealed. The appellate court affirmed. Back in the trial court, PLF moved for summary judgment. The court ruled for the government and PLF appealed. The appellate court held the case was moot. PLF sought review from the California Supreme Court and the petition was denied. PLF cannot seek attorneys fees in this case. Green v. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA). PLF represents Frank Green and Robert Conrad, New England area fishermen, in a federal lawsuit challenging NOAA's regulation implementing President Biden's commercial fishing ban included in a Proclamation under the Antiquities Act that designated 3.2 million acres of ocean as the Northeast Canyons and Seamounts Marine National Monument. This drastically exceeds the limits of the Act which allows for the preservation of limited historical objects and the designations significantly restrict the productive use of natural resources without Congressional authorization. NOAA ignored the statutory process that governs implementation of such regulations. Because the Proclamation is unlawful, NOAA's regulation is also unlawful and cannot be enforced by any other agency or government official, including the President. The case is awaiting Congress to restore lapse to DOJ and all deadlines are stayed. Because litigation is ongoing, it is premature to seek fees. Heaton v. Biden. PLF represents Chris Heaton in a federal lawsuit challenging President Biden's Proclamation under the Antiquities Act designating the Baaj Nwaavjo I'tah Kukveni-Ancestral Footprints of the Grand Canyon National Monument. PLF argues that (1) the Proclamation's designation of landscapes, species, and other non-designatable "objects" is ultra vires and violates the major-questions doctrine; (2) the million-acre designation is not the smallest area compatible with protecting the monument; and (3) the lack of any meaningful limiting principle under the statute violates the Constitution's nondelegation doctrine. Presidents have abused their power under the Antiquities Act by declaring multi-million-acre monuments, drastically exceeding the limits of the Act which allows for preservation of limited historical objects. Their designations significantly restrict the productive use of private and public lands. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. H.R. Ewell, Inc. v. EPA. PLF represents H.R. Ewell, Inc., a trucking company in Pennsylvania in a challenge to the constitutionality of provisions of the Clean Air Act that prospectively incorporate California law into the Clean Air Act's federal regulatory scheme. This is a clear violation of the private nondelegation doctrine to incorporate prospective state law into a federal statutory scheme. PLF petitioned the Ninth Circuit to ask the court to vacate the EPA's recent decision approving new California emission standards for heavy diesel engines, which makes those standards effective and federally enforceable in other states under the Clean Air Act. The petition has been docketed and awaits an answer from the government. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Hiran Management, Inc. d/b/a Hungry Like The Wolf v. National Labor Relations Board (NLRB). After purchasing the Hungry Like the Wolf diner in Houston in July 2022, Hiran Management hired a new manager for the restaurant and its 15 employees. Relations between the manager and some staff quickly became strained over workplace responsibilities, tip distribution, and management style. The manager ended up holding an in-person mandatory meeting to resolve the conflict, but the meeting did not end well. One employee texted the manager a list of demands and invoked workers' rights under the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA). The NLRB General Counsel quickly filed charges and a hearing was held before an NLRB-employed administrative law judge. After the hearing, the ALJ ruled that the restaurant violated the NLRA by, among other things, terminating employees for engaging in protected union activities. The Seventh Amendment guarantees everyone the right to a fair trial in a court of law, before a neutral judge and a jury of one's peers, with rules for a fair process. The NLRB entered a final decision on November 4, 2024, at which point PLF took over and filed a petition for review in the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals. The case is now fully briefed before the Fifth Circuit and awaits oral argument. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek attorneys fees. Iliamna Natives Limited v. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). PLF represents Iliamna Natives Limited and the Alaska Peninsula Corporation in a federal lawsuit to contest the EPA's Clean Water Act "veto" of the Pebble mine permit as a violation of the non-delegation doctrine. The lawsuit challenges EPA's nearly unlimited statutory authority to nix natural resource development requiring a Clean Water Act permit on behalf of native Alaskan groups who desperately need the jobs and other benefits of the Pebble mine's development to sustain their local village economies. EPA is running roughshod over local native communities in blind pursuit of the administration's agenda to block off as much land from useful development as possible. EPA claims Congress gave it a blank check to veto any projects it doesn't like, but Congress cannot give away unchecked power without clear direction on how to use it. This case was consolidated with Northern Dynasty Minerals, et al. v. EPA. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Inside Passage Electric Cooperative (IPEC) v. U.S. Dept. of Agriculture. PLF represents IPEC, which provides power-at cost-to several small, predominantly indigenous communities located within Alaska's Tongass National Forest. IPEC seeks to build several hydroelectric and geothermal projects to replace the expensive diesel generation that these communities currently rely on. PLF filed a federal lawsuit challenging the U.S. Department of Agriculture's "Roadless Rule," which prevents the creation of roads that serve isolated communities in the Tongass. The USDA's prohibition on roads-including gravel and dirt roads-makes construction and maintenance of these energy projects infeasible by making them accessible only by helicopter. The agency exceeded its authority; only Congress can make the law. Both parties moved for summary judgment, and the case is stayed, awaiting Congress to restore lapse to DOJ. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees.
Form 990, Part III, Line 4aJake's Fireworks, Inc. v. Consumer Product Safety Commission. PLF represents Jake's Fireworks, a Kansas-based importer and distributor of small reloadable aerial shell fireworks. The Commission asserts that its regulations apply to Jake's and sent Notices of Noncompliance; Jake's disagrees. However, the Commission refuses to label its decisions applying the regulations to Jake's as a "final agency action" that would allow Jake's to seek judicial review under the Administrative Procedure Act. After a loss in trial court, PLF took over the appeal to the Fourth Circuit, arguing that due process and the rule of law require government agencies to be clear with regulated parties and that they must not evade judicial review by refusing to take final agency action. The Fourth Circuit issued an adverse opinion and PLF petitioned the US Supreme Court to take up the case. The Court directed a response from the respondent, but ultimately denied PLF's petition for writ of certiorari. The case is not eligible for attorneys fees. Kansas Natural Resource Coalition, et al. v. U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service. PLF represents Kansas landowners in a federal court challenge to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service's Endangered Species Act Section 4(d) rule for the threatened Northern Distinct Population Segment of the lesser prairie-chicken. The Service deliberately shut down productive and responsible land use with no corresponding benefits to the lesser prairie-chicken. In doing so, the Service violated the ESA, the Administrative Procedure Act, and the Regulatory Flexibility Act by ignoring the effects of the rule on private landowners and small businesses. The parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment and the court granted PLF's motion for summary judgement. The government filed an appeal but later moved to dismiss the appeal. PLF will receive $43,520.40 in attorneys fees. KC Transport v. Secretary of Labor. PLF represents KC Transport, Inc., a small trucking company that occasionally hauls coal for nearby mines. When the trucks break down, KC repairs them at its truck-repair shop some four miles away from the nearest mine. PLF is asking the U.S. Supreme Court to review the D.C. Circuit's divided decision concluding that a truck or truck-repair shop could be a "mine and giving the Secretary of Labor deference to determine how far beyond the physical confines of a mine its regulations extend. PLF argues that (1) neither a truck nor a truck-repair shop is a mine, (2) the Court should grant certiorari, vacate the decision below, and remand in light of a forthcoming decision that is likely to cabin agency deference. Federal courts have a duty to interpret the meaning of statutes-a duty they can neither outsource nor delegate to the litigant agency. Oral argument was held in federal appellate court and the case is awaiting decision. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Krueger al. v. Arizona Department of Agriculture. PLF represents Grant Krueger, a Tucson restaurateur, and his restaurant group, Union Hospitality Group, in a state court challenge to Arizona regulations that require egg-laying hens to be housed in a cage-free manner. The cage-free egg rule will increase prices at a time when restaurants and consumers are already struggling with inflated food prices. PLF's lawsuit argues that (1) the rule is not authorized by statute; (2) the rule is not reasonably necessary to advance the purpose of the authorizing statute; and (3) the rule was promulgated pursuant to an unconstitutional delegation of legislative power. The legislature cannot cede its power to unaccountable bureaucrats whose rules benefit regulators and the regulated industry, at the expense of everyone else. PLF moved for summary judgment. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Latham v. US Department of Agriculture. On June 12, 2024, the Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS), which is housed within the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA), field a complaint against Mr. David Latham in its internal adjudication process alleging multiple violations at two horse shows involving six horses that were purportedly sore. According to US Statute, sore means that the horses legs are injured through devices or chemicals in order to exaggerate the horse's gait for advantage in competitions. Mr. Latham operates a successful walking-horse stable in Alabama and is a respected figure in the Tennessee Walking Horse Industry, along with his father. He loves caring for his horses and always treats them with respect. PLF represents Mr. Latham, who is deeply concerned about the USDA's enforcement approach under the Horse Protection Act (HPA), particularly that horses can be disqualified from shows without an adequate opportunity to contest the inspectors' findings. PLF's involvement in this case is to challenge in federal court the constitutionality of the USDA adjudication process in which Mr. Latham is defending himself. All Americans are entitled to a neutral judge and jury when the government seeks to financially penalize one for alleged violations of the law. PLF filed a complaint on behalf of Mr. Latham in district court. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Leachco, Inc. v. Consumer Products Safety Comm'n. PLF represents Leachco, Inc., a family-owned manufacturer based in Oklahoma. The Commission filed an in-house administrative action against Leachco alleging that its infant-lounging pillow (the "Podster") contains defects creating a substantial risk of injury. The allegation is baseless. Leachco has sold 180,000 Podsters with explicit instructions and warnings that the Podster should be used only for awake and supervised infants. Tragically, two babies died when their parents disregarded instructions and warnings and placed them in danger. PLF filed a federal lawsuit in Oklahoma seeking a stay of the administrative proceedings and challenging the proceedings on constitutional grounds; as well as defending Leachco against the "defect" allegations. After an adverse decision in trial court, PLF filed a motion to enjoin agency action pending appeal and when the district court failed to act, sought emergency relief in the Tenth Circuit, which declined to enjoin and PLF filed an emergency application to the Supreme Court, which denied it. The Tenth Circuit affirmed denial of the injunction. PLF filed a petition for writ of certiorari in the Supreme Court. Awaiting a decision on the writ of certiorari, Leachco received a favorable decision before the CPSC, which the Commission then appealed. Leachco's petition for writ of certiorari was denied and a joint status report is to be filed in district court. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Lofstad v. Raimondo. PLF represents Raymond Lofstad and Gus Lovgren, commercial fishermen who operate in federal waters in the Atlantic Ocean managed by the Mid-Atlantic Fisheries Council. The Council issued new regulations significantly restricting the fishing of flounder, scup, and Black Sea bass. With their livelihoods imperiled, Lofstad and Lovgren filed a federal lawsuit against the Secretary of Commerce and an agency within the department, the National Marine Fisheries Service, on the grounds that the Council is structured in violation of the Constitution's Appointments Clause and, therefore, its regulations are void. Proper appointments are important to ensure accountability. The district court ruled in favor of the government. PLF appealed to the Third Circuit and filed briefs. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Manis v. U.S. Dept. of Agriculture. PLF is defending Joe Manis in a USDA internal adjudication that claims he violated the Horse Protection Act. PLF is challenging the structure of that adjudication, arguing that agency adjudication decisions must be made by properly appointed principal officers. PLF urges the court to end agency adjudication of civil money penalties entirely by reviving the Seventh Amendment right to a jury trial in an Article III court. All Americans are entitled to a neutral judge and jury when the government seeks to penalize them for alleged violations of the law. PLF moved for a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction, which were denied. PLF appealed to the Fourth Circuit, where oral argument was held. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees.
Form 990, Part III, Line 4aMayfield v. U.S. Dept. of Labor (DOL). PLF represents Texas-based restauranteur Robert Mayfield in a federal court challenge to DOL's one-size-fits-all compensation rule that limits his ability to offer his managers the kinds of compensation packages he thinks best. The DOL's regulations are intended to shove more workers into the hourly box. Regardless of their preferences. The lawsuit argues that the DOL has no authority to dictate salary level and overtime requirements for management-level employees that Congress exempted from hourly pay requirements. On cross-motions for summary judgment, the district court ruled in favor of the DOL. PLF appealed to the Fifth Circuit, where the court ruled against Mr. Mayfield. PLF decided not to petition the Supreme Court, thus PLF cannot seek attorneys fees in this matter. Moats v. National Credit Union Administration Board. PLF represents Jeffrey Moats, the former CEO of Edinburgh Teachers Credit Union for 25 years. When he sued the Credit Union for about $1 million in post-termination benefits it owed him, NCUA, the Credit Union's insurer, filed an in-house administrative complaint against Moats accusing him of comingling personal and Credit Union assets during his tenure. It seeks $5 million in restitution and penalties, and a lifetime ban on Moats working in the banking industry. Moats filed this parallel federal-court action against NCUA, its board of directors, and the administrative law judge (ALJ) assigned to the administrative proceeding. PLF is asking the court to end NCUA agency adjudication because the NCUA is unconstitutionally structured; the ALJ enjoys unconstitutional multi-level for-cause removal protections; and administrative adjudication violates both the Seventh Amendment right to jury and the Fifth Amendment's Due Process Clause. PLF filed a motion for summary judgment. The court dismissed the case on jurisdictional grounds. PLF moved to amend the findings, then appealed to the Fifth Circuit. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. MOSenecaManufaturer, LLC, et al. d/b/a American Tripoli v. Mine Safety and Health Review Commission (MSHA). In the small town of Seneca, Missouri, a father-daughter team purchased American Tripoli, a 150-year mining company that has produced silicon dioxide, or "tripoli," since 1869. The Mine Act prohibits mine owners from retaliating against miners for talking to mine inspectors. Months after purchasing the mine, American Tripoli had a disagreement over facts with a fired miner, which was brought to the attention of MSHA. The Secretary of Labor sought and the ALJ awarded five-figure civil penalties for these violations. PLF filed suit in the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals on behalf of American Tripoli for a Jarkesy-style, Seventh Amendment right to a jury trial violation, among others. The opening brief has been filed in the Eighth Circuit and PLF awaits response from the government. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) v. M/V Michele My Belle. PLF represents Joseph Urbinati, Jr., in an enforcement action brought against him as the owner of the ship M/V Michele My Belle. Even though he wasn't piloting the ship, Mr. Urbinati was fined $22,500 because his ship slightly exceeded 10 miles/hour in a restricted zone. NOAA has no power to impose the fine, however, because it has no power to set speed limits in coastal waters. PLF challenges NOAA's reliance on a statutory delegation to make rules "necessary and appropriate to carry out" protections on taking marine mammals as an unlimited grant of authority to create any substantive restriction on conduct that could theoretically protect certain species. PLF also argues that a $22,500 speeding ticket violates the Excessive Fines clause. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. New Mexico Cattle Growers Association v. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. In 2015, PLF submitted to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service a petition to delist the Southwestern willow flycatcher as an endangered species because a recent scientific study showed that the flycatcher should not be considered a separate subspecies. The Service denied the petition and refused to define the standards necessary for a population to qualify as a listable entity under the Endangered Species Act. This "we know when we see it" approach to taxonomy is arbitrary and capricious. PLF represents the New Mexico Cattle Growers Association, whose members are heavily burdened by critical habitat designations, and filed a federal court complaint challenging the flycatcher listing. The district court ruled in favor of the government. PLF appealed to the D.C. Circuit where the case has been fully briefed and argued. Because this case is ongoing, it is premature to seek fees. Peters Brothers, Inc. v. Pennsylvania Dept. of Environmental Protection. PLF represents Peters Brothers and other small trucking companies and trade associations in a state court lawsuit challenging a Pennsylvania regulation that automatically incorporates any changes to California's regulations governing heavy diesel vehicles. The incorporation of California's regulations makes it more costly for trucking and busing companies to update their fleets, causing customers to respond by buying and registering trucks in other states. Only Pennsylvania's elected representatives can make laws for Pennsylvania residents; a state that outsources its lawmaking authority to another state violates both statutory law and the nondelegation doctrine. The case is stayed. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Redondo Auto Spa, LLC v. California Labor Commissioner's Office. PLF represents Redondo Auto Spa, LLC, Rock N Roll Car Wash, LLC, and Chris McKenna challenging the California Labor Commissioner's Office (LCO) for claiming $150,000 surety bonds without prior notice or hearing, triggering bond cancellation and business shutdowns of both car wash locations. The LCO cannot act as investigator, prosecutor, and judge, and when the government effectively regulates you out of your business, you have a right to a hearing or compensation according to the California Constitution. PLF filed a complaint in the Los Angeles County Superior Court. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Skipper, et al. v. U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service, et al. The Skipper family has owned forestland in Clarke County, Alabama since 1902, which it manages for timber production and conservation. In 1956 they voluntarily opened their land for the state's wildlife conservation efforts and outdoor recreation. In 2020, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service designated the Skipper family's land as critical habitat for the black pinesnake based on a single sighting of one snake over a 25-year period. The designation reduces the land's value, triggers burdensome regulatory requirements, and penalizes the Skippers for their past conservation activities. It also sidestepped mandated cost-benefit requirements. On behalf of the Skipper family, Forest Landowners Association, and Goodloe family, PLF sued the Service in federal court. The parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Texas Alliance of Energy Producers v. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). PLF represents the Texas Alliance of Energy Producers and Domestic Energy Producers Alliance (DEPA) to challenge the SEC's authority to require public companies to make disclosures about Greenhouse Gas (GHG) emissions and related matters. The trade associations represent many energy industry companies that may face lawsuits if they underestimate their GHG emissions. They also represent small and independent businesses that will be injured by a rule that requires larger corporations to collect and report sensitive information from smaller nonreporting firms with whom they do business. The SEC must be confined to its congressionally-authorized power to require public disclosures. The GHG rule strays far from SEC's mission, which is to protect investors, allows the SEC improperly to play politics and publicly shame companies for business practices the SEC doesn't like. PLF filed a petition for review in the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals and the case was then transferred to the Eighth Circuit. The case is currently held in abeyance. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees.
Form 990, Part III, Line 4atheDove Media, Inc. v. Federal Communications Commission (FCC). PLF represents Dove Media in a challenge to a FCC rule that (1) requires broadcasters to collect and report annually information related to the broadcasters' equal opportunity employment efforts, and (2) makes that information available to the public. PLF's petition to the Ninth Circuit argues that FCC lacks statutory authority to regulate radio broadcasters' equal opportunity employment efforts by requiring extensive reporting and, alternatively, that the rules application to radio stations violates the nondelegation doctrine, due process, and the First Amendment by compelling speech. Moreover, the rule advances no valid interest other than indirectly pressuring broadcasters to take race/sex into account when making employment decisions. Congress never gave the FCC the power to enforce race and sex quotas, and by forcing disclosure of hiring practices and relying on public pressure and lawsuits, the agency seeks to accomplish indirectly what it cannot accomplish directly. PLF filed a petition for review and the case was transferred to the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals. The case was fully briefed and then voluntarily dismissed when the FCC changed the policy in question and dropped the prosecution of our client. Because PLF voluntarily dismissed the case, attorneys fees were not awarded. United States v. Valentine. PLF represents Val Valentine, Skip Valentine, and Indiantown Farm LLC in federal court, to defeat the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers' civil enforcement claims under the Clean Water Act (CWA) and the Rivers and Harbors Act. The Valentines purchased forestland to produce high-quality Atlantic white cedar and cypress timber, and managed the property to sustain hunting, fishing, and eco-tourism. The Corps seeks to halt development by the Valentines and other landowners under an expansive interpretation of the CWA. PLF argues that (1) the wetlands at issue are clearly distinguishable from any plausible navigable water and not subject to the CWA under PLF's Supreme Court victory in Sackett II; (2) the Valentines' alleged illegal discharge of dredged or fill material falls within the CWA's exemption for forest road construction and maintenance; and (3) the CWA does not authorize a civil enforcement action alleging unpermitted discharge of dredged or fill material. PLF moved for partial judgment, which the federal trial court denied on the pleadings. The case is stayed. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Walmsley v. Federal Trade Commission. PLF represents Bill Walmsley, John Moss, and the Iowa Horsemen's Benevolent and Protective Association, who are subject to the federal Horse Integrity and Safety Act of 2020, which created the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Authority to regulate racetrack safety and horse doping nationwide. The Authority requires anyone in the horse industry to register and pay yearly fees. Burdensome rules and regulations make it difficult for independent horse owners like Walmsley to continue in the horse business. In a federal lawsuit, PLF charges that the Authority suffers from multiple constitutional violations because it is a private nonprofit corporation making nationwide rules with no accountability to Congress or the people. PLF sought a preliminary injunction, which was denied. PLF appealed to the Eighth Circuit, which ruled in favor of the government and PLF petitioned the Supreme Court. The Court granted PLF's petition and remanded the case back to the Eighth Circuit for further consideration. Because the case is ongoing, it is premature to seek fees. White v. Environmental Protection Agency. PLF represents Robert White in a federal lawsuit challenging the "adjacent wetlands" provisions of the United States Environmental Protection Agency and the United States Army Corps of Engineers' 2023 rule interpreting the term "navigable waters" for purposes of the Clean Water Act. White invested in real property in coastal North Carolina, made improvements to prevent flooding, and seeks to engage in agricultural uses. Because White's flood control activities occurred in wetlands purportedly "adjacent" to covered waters, the government forced him to cease productive activity on his property and is prosecuting a civil enforcement action. PLF filed a complaint arguing that the "adjacent wetlands" regulations are overbroad and do not conform with PLF's Supreme Court victory in Sackett II that jurisdictional wetlands must be "indistinguishable" from covered waters, and moved for a preliminary injunction. The court denied the preliminary injunction. PLF appealed the denial of preliminary injunction in the Fourth Circuit while continuing litigation on the merits in district court. Litigation in both the district court and federal appellate court are stayed. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Wille v. Raimondo. PLF represents Hawaii residents involved in the local swim-with-dolphins industry as boat captains, dolphin guides, or therapists to challenge a rule issued by the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) that prohibits swimming with or approaching spinner dolphins. People approached by dolphins must swim away. This regulation destroys an entire industry without regard for the value individuals receive from interacting with the playful animals. PLF filed a federal lawsuit arguing that the rule violates the Appointments Clause because it was issued by a NMFS career civil servant who is neither nominated by the President and confirmed by the Senate, nor appointed by a head of department or other entity competent to appoint "inferior" officers. PLF defeated the government's motion to dismiss but the court ruled in favor of the government on the merits. PLF appealed to the Fourth Circuit. The court held argument on the matter and the case is awaiting decision. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Equality and Opportunity: PLF seeks to halt the reemergence of governmental discrimination based on race, sex, or group entitlement and to advance a positive vision of civil rights with individual liberty at its core, centered on a demand to remove legal barriers that separate people from opportunity. PLF's goal is to free individuals to rise based on their choices, character, and ability. We therefore demand removal of state-imposed barriers to opportunity, leading from the principles of equal protection and due process that guided the architects of the Fourteenth Amendment. While overt racial barriers have largely been removed from our society, economic regulations continue to pervasively impede the pursuit of one's livelihood, especially for those of lesser means. Aerospace Solutions, LLC v. Hegar. Based on a 2009 disparity study, the state of Texas set statewide annual utilization goals to align with the state's historically underutilized business (HUB) program. These goals are used as a starting point for establishing state agency-specific goals, which can be higher or lower than the statewide goal. If a state agency determines that subcontracting opportunities are probably under any contract for $100,000 or more, the bid solicitation must require a completed HUB subcontracting plan to be considered. Aerospace Solutions, LLC was founded in 2004 and provides support to the aerospace industry. The company is owned by two white males who each have a 50% share in the company. While searching for new opportunities to expand their business into Texas, they ran up against the HUB program and the annual 26% goal applied to services contracts. Government contracts shouldn't be handed out on the basis of race. These programs that assign benefits or burdens based on the race of a company's owner violates the constitutional promise of equality before the law. Representing Aerospace Solutions, LLC, PLF filed a federal lawsuit, to which Texas filed a motion to dismiss. The state's motion was partially granted when PLF dismissed Gov. Gregory Abbott from the case. The defendant filed a motion to dismiss, PLF filed a response, and the case is awaiting order. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees.
Form 990, Part III, Line 4aAmerican Alliance for Equal Rights v. Ivey. The Alabama Real Estate Appraisers Board (AREAB) has nine members, seven property appraisers, one appraisal management company representative, and one member of the public who does not work in the industry. Under state law, at least two members must be racial minorities. The public member position on the AREAB has been vacant since November 2021. Interested Alabamians include at least one member of the American Alliance for Equal Rights who applied for the open AREAB seat but is excluded from consideration because of race. Representing the Alliance, PLF filed a federal lawsuit challenging the race requirement as violating the Equal Protection Clause. No government official should use an individual's race or ethnicity to determine who gets the opportunity to serve the public. PLF sought a temporary restraining order, which was denied. PLF moved for judgment on the pleadings, which was denied. After opening discovery, PLF moved for a stipulation for dismissal, which was granted. Because the case was voluntarily dismissed, PLF cannot seek fees. American Alliance for Equal Rights v. Pritzker. In 1993, the Illinois legislature enacted the Minority Teachers of Illinois Scholarship Program (Scholarship Program). The Scholarship Program awards scholarships of up to $7,500 per year to pay tuition, fees, room & board, and commuter allowances for up to four academic years of full-time college enrollment. Scholarship winners must commit to full-time teaching in a nonprofit Illinois public, private, or parochial preschool, elementary school, or secondary school where the Illinois State Board of Education has determined that no less than 30 percent of the enrolled students are Black, Hispanic, Asian American, or Native American. One of the many eligibility requirements for the Scholarship Program is that the applicant be a minority student - American Indian or Alaska Native, Asian, Black or African American, Hispanic or Latino, or Native Hawaiian or other Pacific Islander. PLF filed a federal lawsuit representing the Alliance challenging the race requirement as violating the Equal Protection Clause. Defendants filed a motion to dismiss, to which PLF filed an opposition. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. American Alliance for Equal Rights v. Walz. PLF represents the American Alliance for Equal Rights, a nationwide organization dedicated to eliminating racial preferences, in a federal court challenge to a Minnesota racial quota for membership on the Minnesota Board of Social Work. Racial mandates on government boards violate the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The Minnesota Legislature cannot require appointing authorities to disqualify individuals from public service because of their race. Race quotas are unjust, demeaning, and unconstitutional. A joint voluntary dismissal was filed. Because the case was voluntarily dismissed, PLF cannot seek fees. Art and Antique Dealers v. Seggos. The federal Endangered Species Act allows for the sale of certain antiques containing ivory, as well as non-antiques containing a de minimis amount of ivory, in interstate and international commerce. New York State limits intrastate sales of items containing ivory to only antiques containing no more than 20% ivory. Although it cannot ban items authorized by federal law, New York has burdened the sale of ivory antiques by prohibiting their display in New York antique dealers' stores. Dealers may show photographs of the antiques to prospective interstate buyers who visit their stores with a disclaimer that the item is not for sale in New York." The dealers alleged a First Amendment right to display the actual items with that same disclaimer but were rejected by a federal trial court. Representing two antique dealers, PLF received a favorable decision in November 2024, after an oral argument was held before the Second Circuit in March 2022. PLF filed for bill of costs. PLF's petition for writ of certiorari on the question of whether the Endangered Species Act's (ESA) preemption provision protects all activities enjoying an exception under the ESA was filed and later denied. Because this case is pending it is premature to seek fees. Association For Education Fairness v. Montgomery County Public Schools. PLF represents Association for Education Fairness, a group of mostly Asian-American parents whose children are shut out of the Montgomery County (Maryland) magnet school program because of changing criteria designed to make the magnet schools reflect the County's racial demographics. PLF's federal lawsuit challenges the county's admissions policy as unconstitutional racial discrimination. Racial balancing is unconstitutional whether done through overt or covert means. School districts shouldn't consider race when determining who gets into the best schools. PLF defeated the school board's motion to dismiss and filed an amended complaint. The school board again moved to dismiss and the court granted the motion. PLF sought relief from judgment based on new information. When that was denied, PLF appealed to the Fourth Circuit, where the case awaits a decision. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. B.B. v. Capistrano Unified School District. PLF represents B.B., a first-grade student, and her mother Chelsea Boyle, in a First Amendment challenge to discipline imposed on B.B. for giving a drawing to a classmate that included the phrase "any life" along with "Black Lives Mater" (sic) and depictions of her friends. PLF seeks to protect children from school officials who impose rigid race-focused progressive orthodoxy. Specifically, disciplining a first grader for giving an innocuous drawing to a classmate that neither disrupted the school nor caused offense to the receiving student, violated the B.B.'s First Amendment rights and was impermissible retaliation for the exercise of those rights. The school's massive overreaction reflects a worldview that requires censure of even innocent and inoffensive speech about race that departs from progressive orthodoxy. PLF fully briefed the case at the Ninth Circuit, and the Ninth Circuit held oral argument. Because litigation is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Boston Parent Coalition for Academic Excellence v. School Committee of Boston. PLF represents a group of students, parents, alumni, and future applicants to Boston's Exam Schools. The group promotes merit-based admissions while supporting diversity by improving the K-6 pipeline in Boston public schools. They sued in federal court to challenge Boston's decision to overhaul admissions to pursue racial balance by imposing quotas based on applicants' postal zip codes. The parent coalition lost in district court and PLF took over representation on appeal to the First Circuit and argued that it violates the Constitution to manipulate admissions processes to obtain desired racial outcomes. The First Circuit affirmed. PLF filed petition for writ of certiorari in the U.S. Supreme Court, and the petition was denied. PLF cannot seek attorneys fees. Californians for Equal Rights Foundation (CFER) v. Fresno Unified School District. In 2017, Fresno Unified School District created the Office of African American Academic Acceleration (A4 Office) to remedy racial disparities among its students in reading, math, and other subjects. The purpose of the A4 Office is to "identify and address the fundamental causes for the discrepancy in academic outcomes between African American students and other demographic groups". The A4 Office runs 13 programs that are funded with public money, but nothing on their website makes it clear that these programs are available to all. To that effect, CFER has several members who are parents to non-African American students in the Fresno Unified School District and were never told about the A4 Office. It is unfair and unconstitutional to gate access to valuable youth programs based on a child's race - regardless of whether that gate is explicit or implicit. PLF is representing CFER in an Equal Protection challenge to Fresno Unified School District's A4 Program. The case is currently pending at the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California. Since litigation is ongoing, it is premature to seek attorneys fees in this matter.
Form 990, Part III, Line 4aCalifornians for Equal Rights Foundation v. City of San Diego. PLF represents Californians for Equal Rights Foundation, a California nonprofit dedicated to the principle of equal rights in a federal lawsuit challenging a San Diego program that confers housing benefits on the basis of race. Specifically, to be eligible for the program which grants up to $40,000 towards a down payment or closing costs, borrowers must "self-identify as black, indigenous or other person of color," including those who "self-identify as Hispanic/Latinx and any race other than white." San Diego's program violates the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. Government cannot use race to decide who gets public benefits and burdens. After filing the case and going through discovery, PLF and the City of San Diego came to a settlement and the court granted the joint motion to dismiss. The San Diego Housing Commission repealed the race-based condition of its First-Time Homebuyer Program and the Commission paid one of our clients $2,000 in recompense for breaching the protective order in the case and violating the client's privacy. PLF cannot seek attorneys fees in this case. Californians for Equal Rights Foundation v. County of Alameda. Alameda County, California, requires prime contractors to subcontract 15% of applicable government construction contracts to minority-owned businesses or show "good faith efforts" that they attempted to do so. The set-asides force general contractors to discriminate against subcontractors just because they are not minority-owned. PLF represents the Californians for Equal Rights Foundations and several individuals, including a longtime California contractor, to challenge these set-asides in federal court as violating the federal and state constitutional guarantees of equal protection under the law. The county moved for judgment on the pleadings, which was granted, on the grounds that the lawsuit was barred by the statute of limitations. PLF prevailed on appeal in an unpublished opinion. PLF requested publication, which was denied. The case was remanded for litigation on the merits, and the case was voluntarily dismissed with prejudice. Because PLF voluntarily dismissed the case, we cannot seek fees. Chinese American Citizens Alliance of Greater New York v. Adams. New York City operates eight specialized high schools that are among the best in the city, public or private. State law offers a path to admission for low-income students who score below the Admissions Test cutoff, up to 5% of the available ninth-grade seats. The City changed the admissions criteria to reserve 20% of the ninth-grade seats for low-income students, explicitly for the purpose of increasing the percentage of black and Hispanic students while decreasing the percentage of Asian-American students. PLF represents parents of Asian-American students in a federal lawsuit challenging this change as violating the Equal Protection Clause. The district court granted the City's motion for summary judgment and PLF appealed to the Second Circuit, where a favorable opinion was issued. The case is now back in the U.S. Southern District Court of New York and undergoing discovery. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Chiong v. Henry McMaster. South Carolina law establishes a Commission for Minority Affairs, with its overall purpose being "to study the causes and effects of the socio-economic deprivation of minorities in the State and to implement programs necessary to address inequities confronting minorities in the State. The Commission is comprised of nine members and the Governor ex officio. The governor is required to appoint one person from each of the state's seven congressional districts, as well as two at-large persons, upon the advice and consent of the Senate. In addition, a majority of the members of the Commission must be African American. The Commission currently has six members, meaning there are three vacancies. Of these six members, five are African American, but two of those members terms have expired, so there are at least two African American vacancies on the Commission that must be replaced. PLF represents Sandy Chiong, who is of Chinese and Cuban descent and is therefore disadvantaged by the quota for a majority of the membership on the Commission to be African American. South Carolina cannot deny individuals the opportunity to serve on public boards due to their race. Racial quotas are unjust and unconstitutional. The case was dismissed after the legislature passed a law that changes the makeup of the Commission to comply with the US Constitution. Because the case was dismissed, PLF cannot seek attorneys fees. Chu v. Rosa. PLF represents Yiatin Chu, a parent and education advocate, Chinese American Citizens Alliance of Greater New York, and the Inclusive Education Advocacy Group, New York City-based organizations who advocate for equal educational opportunity for all students regardless of race in a federal lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of the New York State Science and Technology Entry Program (STEP) law requiring participating institutions to discriminate against applicants based upon their race or ethnicity. Students have a right to compete equally for publicly-funded programs without regard to race. The STEP law violates the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment by imposing a socioeconomic threshold for white and Asian-American applicants that is not required for black, Hispanic, Native American, or Alaskan Native applicants. The case is currently stayed. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Chubb v. Boyd. PLF represents Katie Chubb and Augusta Birth Center in a federal lawsuit challenging Georgia's Certificate of Need regulations for freestanding birth centers. These regulations require any new childbirth services to seek the cooperation of their direct competitors to secure a license to operate. The regulations unconstitutionally restrict both Chubb's right to provide critical childbirth care and the right of Georgia mothers to access those services. Mothers, not the state, should be able to choose the safe and comfortable circumstances under which they give birth. The district court granted the government's motion to dismiss on standing grounds. PLF filed a motion for reconsideration or leave to amend the complaint, which was denied. PLF appealed. The GA legislature passed Certificate of Need reform legislation, which then rendered our case unripe, so the case was voluntarily dismissed. Attorneys fees were not awarded. Des Moines Midwife Collective v. Iowa Health Facilities Council. PLF represents Des Moines Midwife Collective, founded by registered nurses Emily Zambrano-Andrews and Caitlin Hainley. The Collective supports homebirth practice that honors the wishes of women of all income levels to give birth safely and comfortably outside of a hospital setting. They want to accommodate their growing clientele and broaden their range of childbirth options by opening a freestanding birth center but Iowa's Certificate of Need law requires permission from their competitors-namely, hospitals. PLF filed a state court lawsuit seeking to alleviate the burden on Iowa's childbirth system and provide a safe, new choice for expecting mothers. The council removed the case to federal court. PLF defeated a motion to dismiss and the council appealed the decision to the circuit court. The Eighth Circuit granted PLF's dismissal and the district court's judgment was vacated pursuant to United States v. Munsingwear. Attorneys fees were not awarded in this matter. Diemert v. City of Seattle. Joshua Diemert worked for the City of Seattle for 8 years, receiving good reviews and awards. Recently, however, he was subjected to racially-motivated harassment under the city's "Race and Social Justice Initiative" (RSJI) that is so severe and pervasive to create a racially-hostile work environment. PLF filed a complaint on behalf of Joshua with the Equal Employment Opportunities Commission, arguing that the city violated Title VII of the Civil Rights Act by requiring him to complete RSJI training, segregating staff meetings by race, offering and requiring race-based programming, promoting race-based affinity groups, and maintaining a commitment to making racial distinctions among City staff. The EEOC granted Joshua the right to sue. PLF then filed a federal lawsuit to vindicate Joshua's right to workplace equality and protect everyone's right to be judged by the content of their individual character and work product, rather than being labeled and classified through the lens of discriminatory workplace equity initiatives. PLF defeated a motion to dismiss and the City appealed the motion. Briefing in the case is ongoing. Because this matter is pending, it is premature to seek fees.
Form 990, Part III, Line 4aDo No Harm (DNH) and The Foundation Against Intolerance & Racism (FAIR) v. Sarah Sanders. PLF represented both DNH and FAIR in a Fourteenth Amendment Equal Protection Clause challenge to the Arkansas state law that mandates the governor appoint at least one racial minority to the Arkansas State Occupational Therapy Examining Committee and the Arkansas Board of Examiners in Counseling. According to AR statute, the Committee must have at least one racial minority and since the quota was not fulfilled, members of DNH & FAIR were put at a disadvantage in the application process. FAIR has a member who satisfies the prerequisites and would like to be considered for the public representative seat on the Counseling Board, but again because they are not a racial minority, they are at a disadvantage in the application process. PLF filed a complaint in district court that was later voluntarily dismissed due to Arkansas updating their law to abide by the U.S. Constitution. Attorneys fees were not awarded in this matter. Do No Harm v. Dr. Brooke Cunningham. In 2018, the Minnesota Department of Health created the Minnesota Health Equity Advisory and Leadership (HEAL) Council. The HEAL Council serves in an advisory role to the Department of Health and makes recommendations to implement the Department's Advancing Health Equity strategic plan, which aims to eliminate health disparities in the state. According to statute, members of the HEAL Council can serve a maximum of three two-year terms and there are no prerequisites for the members aside from the mandate for representation from various social, ethnic, and racial groups. PLF represents members of Do No Harm who would like to be considered for a position on the HEAL Council. Members of the organization are at a significant disadvantage for any openings because they are not from a preferred race, ethnicity, or class according to the HEAL Council's statutory requirements. Minnesota cannot use race to disqualify or disfavor individuals from public service; this is a clear violation of the Equal Protection Clause. PLF filed suit in the district court and the case was later dismissed with prejudice. PLF cannot seek attorneys fees in this case. Do No Harm v. Edwards. PLF represents Do No Harm, an organization of over 6,000 physicians, healthcare professionals, medical students, patients, and policymakers committed to ensuring that healthcare is protected from "a racial, divisive, and discriminatory ideology," in a federal lawsuit challenging a Louisiana racial quota for membership on the Louisiana State Board of Medical Examiners. A state statute requires the governor to appoint members to the Louisiana State Board of Medical Examiners on the basis of race. Such racial mandates on government boards are unjust, demeaning, and violate the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The case is fully briefed in district court and awaiting a decision. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Do No Harm v. Gianforte. PLF represents Do No Harm, an organization of over 6,000 physicians, healthcare professionals, medical students, patients, and policymakers committed to ensuring that healthcare is protected from "a racial, divisive, and discriminatory ideology," in a federal lawsuit challenging a Montana statute granting race- and sex-based preferences for membership on the Board of Medical Examiners. The Montana legislature cannot require appointing authorities like the governor to disqualify individuals from public service because of their race or sex. A statutory requirement for the governor to attain race-based proportionality and sex-based balance in making appointments to public boards violates the Equal Protection Clause. This case was voluntarily dismissed due to legislative action to amend the law. PLF cannot seek attorneys fees. Do No Harm v. Lee. PLF represents Do No Harm, an organization of over 6,000 physicians, healthcare professionals, medical students, patients, and policymakers committed to ensuring that healthcare is protected from "a racial, divisive, and discriminatory ideology." PLF filed a federal lawsuit on behalf of Do No Harm to challenge a Tennessee racial quota for membership on the Board of Podiatric Medical Examiners because racial mandates on government boards violate the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The Tennessee Legislature cannot require appointing authorities to disqualify individuals from public service because of their race. Race quotas are unjust, demeaning, and unconstitutional. After losing in district court, PLF appealed to the Sixth Circuit. The appeal was then voluntarily dismissed by PLF because of legislative action to change the racial requirements in the statute. PLF cannot seek attorneys fees in this case. Do No Harm v. Lee (II). In 1923, the Tennessee legislature created the Board of Chiropractic Examiners. According to the law, the Board is comprised of 7 members, with one member of a racial minority. PLF represents Do No Harm in a Fourteenth Amendment Equal Protection Clause challenge to the racial mandate. Tennessee cannot deny individuals the opportunity to serve on public boards due to their race. PLF filed the case in district court and the case was later voluntarily dismissed because of legislative action to change the racial mandate statute. PLF cannot seek attorneys fees in this case. Foundation Against Intolerance & Racism (FAIR) v. Steve Walker. On July 1, 2024, the Washington State Housing Finance Commission implemented the Covenant Homeownership Program, which offers downpayment and closing cost assistance for first-time homebuyers in the form of a zero-interest secondary mortgage loan. PLF represents FAIR challenging Washington's discriminatory housing program to restore equal treatment for all first-time homebuyers, regardless of race. The case is currently before the district court. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek attorneys fees. Foundation Against Intolerance & Racism v. West Virginia State Bar. The West Virginia State Bar is an agency of the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia. The Board of Governors manages the agency and administers its affairs, and consists of twenty-five voting members and one non-voting member. According to its bylaws, one of the twenty-five voting Board members must be an African American lawyer who is voted in by African Americans. The seat is currently filled and is set to be open to election in 2026. PLF represents FAIR in bringing a Fourteenth Amendment challenge to the race-based criterion for membership as well as the Fifteenth Amendment's prohibition on abridging the right to vote on the basis of race. The West Virginia State Bar cannot deny individuals the opportunity to serve on public boards due to their race. The case is currently before the district court. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek attorneys fees. Urban Artifact v. Col. Christopher Paris. After Prohibition's repeal, Pennsylvania created a standard three-tier system of alcohol distribution, meaning the manufacturer of alcohol must be separate from the distributor (wholesaler) and the retailer. Alcohol must pass through each tier before it can be sold to consumer. Pennsylvania makes an exception to the three-tier system for in-state breweries, allowing them to ship beer of an unlimited quality and of any volume ordered via the internet, over the phone, or in-person directly to consumers. Conversely, out-of-state breweries cannot ship more than 90 oz. a month directly to a single consumer. Urban Artifact is an Ohio brewery that is currently the largest dedicated fruit brewery in the world and they would like to sell in the Pennsylvania market. The brewery was issued a direct beer shipping license in 2021, but Urban Artifact let it expire given that the quantity restrictions make developing a direct-to-consumer business unprofitable. Due to these restrictions, PLF brought a dormant Commerce Clause challenge to Pennsylvania's discriminatory law against out-of-state breweries. Subjecting out-of-state small business to additional, burdensome regulation simply because of their geographic location is discriminatory. The case is currently pending in district court, making it premature to seek attorneys fees.
Form 990, Part III, Line 4aHaltigan v. University of Santa Cruz. Many universities employ Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) statement requirements as job screening tools. The University of California system uses them to screen for applicants from minority backgrounds and those committed to a certain view of racial justice. PLF represents J.D. Haltigan in a federal court challenge to a Diversity Statement Requirement in a job posting at the University of Santa Cruz. The requirement forces prospective professors to espouse particular beliefs about race, fairness, and other subjects as a condition of employment. Haltigan wants to be assessed on merit and qualifications, not an ideological litmus test. The case challenges the constitutionality of the diversity statements under the Equal Protection Clause and First Amendment. The university successfully moved to dismiss the case. PLF filed an amended complaint and the university again moved to dismiss. The Ninth Circuit then dismissed and vacated the district court's judgment after the matter was mooted when UC Board of Regents Chair Janey Reilly announced the decision to eliminate any required diversity statements for new hires. Because the case was mooted, PLF cannot seek attorneys fees. Helgason and Sorenson v. Loretta Melby. Nurse practitioners (NPs) are advanced practice registered nurses. In California, NPs possess a master's or doctoral degree and a national certification as an NP in their competency area. NPs are qualified and prepared to provide primary healthcare. An NP's primary care practice typically allows them to diagnose patients, interpret diagnostic tests, manage treatments, and prescribe certain medications. In over half of the states, NPs can perform all elements of primary care practice without physician supervision, typically referred to as "independent practice or "full practice authority." In 2020, California passed a law that creates two new categories of NPs: the "103 NP", which is an NP who can work without standardized procedures in one of six group settings, and the "104 NP", who may operate without standardized procedures outside of group settings. To become a 103 NP, one must be licensed by the California Board of Registered Nursing (Board) and have completed a "transition to practice" of at least 4,600 hours, which is equivalent to three full-time years. The requirements to become a 104 NP are identical to that of a 103 NP, but requires an additional three years of practical experience as an NP "in good standing." This means any 104 NP applicant must have at least six years total of practice to be eligible for independent licensure. PLF represents two experienced NPs specializing in mental health. These professionals bring forty-plus years of experience as licensed psychiatric NPs and under the Board's new regulations, they would have to close their existing practices, find a job in one of dix eligible group settings, and work there for three years before returning to their own private practices, respectively. These requirements not only exceed the authority of the Board by impeding an NPs path to independent practice, but it also violates California law for the CA Board of Registered Nursing to issue regulations that run contrary to legislative intent. California NPs should be allowed to provide the care they are fully educated and trained to provide, including operating in an independent practice, without being forced to enter into a collaborative agreement with a physician. The case is currently before the San Diego County Superior Court, therefore it is premature to seek fees. Hierholzer v. Loeffler. PLF represents Marty Hierholzer and his business, MJL Enterprises, a small business with 20 employees that contracts with federal agencies to provide maintenance products and equipment to VA hospitals and military facilities. PLF filed a federal lawsuit to challenge the Small Business Act's set-aside program for disadvantaged businesses, which authorizes racial preferences in establishing program eligibility. The SBA's use of race as the decisive factor in determining whether a small business is disadvantaged violates this constitutional promise of equality before the law. The lawsuit also challenges the agency's decisions-in the absence of congressional authorization-as to which racial groups are on the preferred list as violating the separation of powers. The district court granted the government's motion to dismiss. PLF appealed and the Fourth Circuit held an oral argument in the case. The panel ruled against PLF, so PLF will be filing a petition of certiorari at the United States Supreme Court on the matter. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Hill v. Town of Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina. PLF represents Ami Hill, owner of #Bus252, a mobile art gallery, and the Muse Markets, which feature local artists and artisans selling their wares, filed a lawsuit challenging a North Carolina town ordinance that requires itinerant vendors to donate 100% of their profits to charity in exchange for the right to sell during the summer tourism season. Alternatively, vendors can undergo an arbitrary and unduly burdensome process to request a permit to operate from the Board of Commissioners. The town also created a market in direct competition with the Muse Market; town-sponsored vendors can sell year-round and keep their profits. The town rejected #Bus252's application to participate in First Flight Market. PLF filed a lawsuit in state court because the town cannot condition an itinerant vendor's right to earn a living on surrendering profits or seeking permission to sell. A hearing on the motion for summary judgement was held and the court denied PLF's summary judgement. PLF filed a notice of appeal, thus it is premature to seek fees. Hooley v. Regents of the University of California and UCSF Benioff Children's Hospital Oakland. UCSF Benioff Children's Hospital Oakland is a pediatric acute care hospital that is part of the University of California's system. The Hospital offers a Community Health and Adolsecent Mentoring Program for Success (CHAMPS) internship, which is a three-year internship offered to minority high school students who are interested in health professions. The founders of CHAMPS hoped that the program could help remove barriers to entering medicine for persons of color, but California's university hospital system cannot deny students the opportunity to access valuable education programs based on their race. Race-based discrimination is unfair and unconstitutional under the Equal Protection Clause. PLF represents Ms. Hooley on behalf of her minor child who applied to be part of CHAMPS class of 2027. The case is currently before the district court. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek attorneys fees. Khatibi v. Lawson. PLF represents Dr. Azadeh Khatibi, an ophthalmologist in Los Angeles who has taught continuing medical education courses, and Do No Harm, a medical nonprofit that embraces the principles of individualism and whose members teach continuing education classes. They filed a federal lawsuit against the Medical Board of California and its officials in a First Amendment challenge to a state law that requires providers of medical education classes to discuss implicit bias. California's required "implicit bias" training injects race into every interaction between doctors and patients, violating Dr. Khatibi's First Amendment right to teach without being compelled to recite the government's favored viewpoint on racial issues. The court granted the government's motion to dismiss. PLF appealed to the Ninth Circuit, where the case is fully briefed. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Landscape Consultants of Texas v. Houston. PLF represents Landscape Consultants and Metropolitan Landscape Management-two companies owned by Jerry and Theresa Thompson-in an equal protection challenge to the City of Houston's Minority Business Enterprise program for public contracting. When bidding on Houston contracts, Landscape Professionals is disadvantaged by Houston's MBE program, which requires non-minority owned businesses to give away a portion of the contract value to MBE subcontractors. This subcontracting requirement does not apply to Landscape Professionals' minority-owned competitors. Houston's MBE program violates the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment because it imposes different standards on bidders for public contracts based solely on the race of the bidding company's owner. PLF defeated motions to dismiss and moved on to the merits, filing a motion for summary judgment. The City then adopted a new ordinance to which they filed a motion to dismiss. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees.
Form 990, Part III, Line 4aLandscape Consultants v. Harris County. Harris County is the largest county in Texas by population. In 2020, the Harris County Commissioners Court (the county's governing body) established an MWBE program with a 30% annual aspirational goal. The program preferences women and individuals who are black, Hispanic, Native American, and Asian American. In order to participate in the MWBE program, a business must be a certified MWBE, operate within Harris County, and be at least 51% owned, managed, and controlled on a day-to-day basis by a "socially disadvantaged" individual (which Harris County equates with being a minority or woman). The Harris County Department of Economic Equity and Opportunity also sets contract-specific goals for county contracts, with recent goals ranging from 24.18% on a drainage improvement project to 10.40% for landscape and irrigation maintenance services. Landscape Consultants is a family company owned by Jerry and Theresa Thompson. Landscape Consultants employs around 50 landscapers, almost all of whom are Hispanic, and approximately 80 to 90% of their business comes from winning large, multi-year government contracts with Harris County, the City of Houston, and other local government entities. In recent years, the Thompsons have lost out on many opportunities, even ones where they are the lowest, most qualified bidder, because Jerry, the principal owner, is white. The government should select contractors for public contracts based on their ability to perform the work needed, rather than on the race of their owners. PLF filed suit on behalf of the Thompsons and Landscape Consultants against Harris County for violating the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The case is currently before the US District Court for the Southern District of Texas, therefore it is premature to seek fees. MacDonald v. Sabando. PLF represents Shannon MacDonald, M.D., Paul Gardner, M.D., and their patients Jun Abell and Hank Jennings in a federal court challenge to New Jersey's requirement that out-of-state physician-specialists be licensed in New Jersey prior to engaging in telemedicine with patients in New Jersey. The requirement violates the U.S. Constitution's Dormant Commerce Clause and Article IV's Privileges and Immunities Clause because the burdens far exceed any benefits; and requiring out-of-state physician-specialists to be licensed in New Jersey before engaging in conversations with patients located in New Jersey via telemedicine violates the First Amendment. New Jersey's limits on telemedicine prevent patients from accessing specialty cancer care that their local doctors have no expertise in or resources to treat. These outdated rules were suspended during COVID to no ill-effect and should be permanently removed. After the district court granted the government's motion to dismiss, PLF appealed the case to the Third Circuit. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. McBride v. Hawkins. PLF represents Dr. Sean McBride and Shellye Horowitz, a medical patient requiring specialized care, in a federal court challenge to California's requirement that physician-specialists be licensed in California before consulting or following up with patients located in California via telehealth technology. Horowitz lives in a remote area of northern California and depends on telemedicine to obtain care for her condition. The case challenges antiquated and anticompetitive rules that limit access to specialized healthcare and are unconstitutional under the Commerce Clause and the U.S. Constitution's Privileges and Immunities Clause, and the First Amendment. California's limits on telehealth prevent Californians from accessing necessary, specialized medical care that their local doctors have no expertise in or resources to treat. The district court granted the government's motion to dismiss and PLF appealed to the Ninth Circuit, where the case is currently being briefed. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Meland v. Padilla. In 2018, California enacted a woman quota law that requires all publicly traded companies that are incorporated or headquartered in the state to have a certain number of females on their boards of directors. This law ignores that women are making great strides in the boardroom without a government mandate, perpetuating the myth that women can't make it to the boardroom without government help and treating potential board members as members of a sex-based group, rather than individuals. PLF's lawsuit on behalf of Creighton Meland challenges the state law as violating the Constitution's Equal Protection guarantee. The district court granted the state's motion to dismiss and PLF appealed to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. The Ninth Circuit reversed and remanded to the district court for consideration of the merits. PLF sought $552.10 in costs and recovered $47.10. On remand, PLF moved for a preliminary injunction, which was denied. PLF appealed to the Ninth Circuit and the case is stayed pending the result of related litigation. Litigation is ongoing, so it is premature to seek fees. Miall v. City of Asheville. PLF represents John Miall and other Asheville residents in an equal protection challenge to the Human Relations Commission of Asheville's race-based membership preferences. John Miall, Robyn Hite, David Shaw, Willa Grant, and Danie Johnson each applied to the Human Relations Commission and were rejected because of their race. Their federal lawsuit asserts the right of individuals to compete equally for membership to a city advisory board without regard to their race. PLF moved for a temporary restraining order, preliminary injunction, and class certification, which were denied. After going through discovery and holding depositions, the court denied the government's motion to dismiss. PLF filed a second amended complaint, which is currently before the district court. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Murchison v. City of Newport Beach. In 2012, the City of Newport Beach, California has adopted a statute that prohibits an individual from giving any instructional activity for money in a park, park facility, or on a beach without first obtaining a written agreement from the Director of the Recreation and Senior Services Department for the City. City code does not provide any criteria for obtaining this written agreement. PLF represents Jason Murchison, who is a veteran Navy diver and law school graduate, and has twice attempted to obtain an agreement for his business to give surfing lessons at Newport Beach. He was told that the City did not need any additional instructors. Jason continued his business despite what the City told him and in 2016, the City enforced its ban against Jason's business, reaching a court settlement in 2017. Even the California Coastal Commission has said that the City cannot regulate private activities on public beaches, unless there are impacts to coastal resources, such as setting up infrastructure on the public beach. It is unconstitutional and unjust for Newport Beach to ban instructors from teaching others how to surf at public beaches in exchange for a fee. The district court issued a favorable decision in the matter, denying in part the City's motion to dismiss. The case is still pending in district court, thus it is premature to seek fees. National Center for Public Policy Research v. Weber. PLF represents NCPPR, a nonprofit that advocates against radical shareholder activism and in favor of basic principles like selecting board members of the merits and not based on their race, in a challenge to California's Boardroom Race Quota law. After the court's adverse ruling on standing, PLF voluntarily dismissed the claims related to race and sexual orientation quotas and appealed the order as to the woman quota to the Ninth Circuit. PLF opposed the government's motion to stay this case, but the court granted it, and it is in abeyance. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees.
Form 990, Part III, Line 4aNoland v. Montana Public Service Commission. After Parker Noland was medically discharged from the U.S. Army, he bought a few small dumpsters and a specialized truck and set out to become a hauler of construction debris. The Montana Public Service Commission issued a cease-and-desist order, saying he needed a certificate of public convenience and necessity (CON) before opening for business. After Noland filed for his certificate, the two largest waste companies protested his application. After a lengthy and costly legal battle, Noland withdrew his application. PLF represents Noland in a constitutional challenge to Montana's CON law for "junk haulers"-or Class D motor carriers-that allows entrenched companies to stop his business. His lawsuit, filed in state court, seeks to vindicate his right under both the Montana and U.S. Constitutions to earn an honest living without undue government interference. The court permitted an existing hauler to intervene, over PLF's objections. The court ruled in favor of the state. PLF appealed to the Supreme Court of Montana, where the case is fully briefed and awaiting a decision. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Nourish Our Neighbors v. City of Dayton, Ohio. According to Dayton City Ordinance 137.21(A), a single-use permit is required to distribute food in public places in the City of Dayon. On April 7, 2024, Nourish Our Neighbors was distributing food when a police officer approached and ordered the volunteers to stop, as they were in violation of the City Ordinance. During this incident, a homeless man approached volunteer Mitchell Moran to ask for food, and even though the police officer was watching, Mitchell handed the man a burrito. The officer then confronted Mitchell about disobeying his order and Mitchell stood firm in his beliefs but remained compliant. After some back and forth, the police officer arrested Mitchell and detained him for at least half an hour before he was released without charges. In the wake of Mitchell's detention, Nourish Our Neighbors has struggled to attract both community volunteers and the homeless to its food distribution events; most volunteers are not willing to risk arrest for handing out food and the homeless avoid law enforcement entirely. PLF represents Nourish Our Neighbors in a First and Fourteenth Amendment challenge to this Dayton City Ordinance. The ordinance is unconstitutional, morally suspect, and actively limits resources for the city's most vulnerable residents. The case is currently being briefed in the US District Court for the Southern District of Ohio. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek attorneys fees. Palmer v. Bonta. PLF represents nursing practitioners, each with a Doctorate in Nursing Practice, in a federal lawsuit challenging California Business & Professions Code 2054, to vindicate their First Amendment right to truthfully use the title "Dr." so long as they clarify that they are not physicians. Plaintiffs face the threat of fines and loss of their licenses and livelihoods if the state enforces 2054 against them. The state cannot appropriate a commonly used term and reserve it for a narrow range of practitioners. Many professionals commonly use the title "Dr."-beyond physicians-and should be able to truthfully do so in describing their profession or accomplishments. Government censorship of professional titles is a thinly veiled attempt to protect well-connected industry insiders. PLF sought preliminary injunctive relief. PLF defeated a motion to dismiss and proceeded to the merits. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Pomeroy v. Utah State Bar. PLF directly represents Amy Pomeroy in the limited capacity of local counsel to the Goldwater Institute in their legal challenge to the Utah mandatory bar as violating the First Amendment rights of free speech and association. The trial court ruled in favor of the Bar. Pomeroy appealed. Because litigation is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Schultz v. Washington State Veterinary Board of Governors. PLF represents equine teeth floaters Jennifer Schultz and Ceanna Johnston in a state court lawsuit challenging a Washington law that forbids anyone but licensed veterinarians and veterinary technicians to engage in the practice of equine teeth floating. PLF argues that the Washington Constitution's Privileges or Immunities Clause and related "right to carry on business" protects the right to earn a living in a lawful occupation without undue governmental interference. By preventing many horses from receiving adequate care, Washington's overly restrictive law harms the health of horses and denies trained individuals their right to earn a living. PLF defeated the government's motion to dismiss. Litigation on the merits is ongoing. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Swanson v. Hilgers. PLF represents Certified Nurse Midwife (CNM) Heather Swanson and Oneida Health LLC in a federal lawsuit to defend the right of midwives to provide midwifery services and the right of Nebraska mothers to receive them. Nebraska's bans CNMs attending home births and requires physician supervision of midwives, burdening the right of expecting mothers to choose the manner and circumstances of giving birth as well as the right of CNMs to provide services free of arbitrary restriction in violation of the Fourteenth Amendment. CNM restrictions severely limit the availability of midwifery services to Nebraska mothers and render it essentially impossible to have a formally trained medical professional attend home births in many areas. After the district court granted in part and denied in part the government's motion to dismiss, PLF appealed to the Eighth Circuit. The case is fully briefed and awaiting a decision. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. The Obscure Distillery v. Lily Fan. Recently, the state of New York passed a law creating an exception to the standard three-tier system of alcohol distribution for craft in-state distilleries. This law allows craft distilleries to ship spirits ordered via the internet, over the phone, or in-person directly to consumers. One caveat to the law is that any out-of-state distillery that wants to ship to New York consumers must be located in a state that provides New York distillers "reciprocal shipping privileges". The Obscure is a craft distillery that manufactures spirits and sells them in its tasting room in downtown Los Angeles. New York law bans The Obscure from shipping spirits directly to New York consumers because California does not extend reciprocity to New York distillers. Representing The Obscure, PLF filed a federal lawsuit bringing a Commerce Clause challenge to New York's restrictions on out-of-state distilleries shipping to New York consumers. Businesses deserve the right to compete on equal footing with their competitors. New York filed a motion to dismiss. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Tilt Vision Studios, LLC, et al. v. City of Waller, Texas. PLF represents Tilt Vision Art, LLC, and its owners, Brad and Kay Ray, in a federal lawsuit challenging the City of Waller's mural ordinance. Tilt Vision Art sells Brad's art and contracts with other artists to create murals for businesses and individuals. Small businesses use Tilt's murals to attract customers. The Rays relocated their business when a Waller-based development firm contracted for the creation of 13 murals for $200,000, and other businesses also sought Tilt's services. When a Waller resident complained about the colors on a finished mural, the city council enacted an ordinance that bans: (1) murals on residential buildings; (2) murals on the primary faade of commercial buildings; (3) murals that function as advertisements; and (4) murals that contain any type of "commercial messaging." Tilt's business is throttled by this ordinance that violates the First Amendment as an unconstitutional content-based restriction on speech and a prior restraint on protected expression. During the briefing on the motion to dismiss, the City filed supplemental exhibits that mooted our case in favor of our client, so the case was voluntarily dismissed. PLF cannot seek attorneys fees in this case.
Form 990, Part III, Line 4aValencia Ag, LLC v. Alexander. PLF represents Valencia Ag, a small business owned by brothers Emmet and William Purcell, in a federal lawsuit raising an equal protection challenge against New York's race- and sex-based preferences in the licensure of cannabis businesses (which are legal in New York). The Purcells do not fall into any preferred applicant category. Entrepreneurs have a right to engage in business free from government discrimination in business licensure on unconstitutional grounds that are wholly irrelevant to ensuring competent and safe businesses. Race or sex shouldn't determine anyone's fundamental right to pursue a living of his or her choosing. A hearing was held on this matter, in which the court ruled in favor of the Defendant. PLF filed a notice of appeal. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Warren v. U.S. Department of Labor. PLF represents Karon Warren and other freelance writers and editors to challenge the Department of Labor's rule on Independent Contractor Classification that makes it more difficult for freelancers to work as independent contractors. Their livelihoods depend on them being able to work as freelancers, and their clients do not risk having to pay them overtime and track their hours. Independent contracting allows people to be their own boss, but the Department of Labor's new classification rules put the law's thumb on the scales against contractors, by muddying the distinction between contracting and employment. PLF filed a lawsuit in federal court and the parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment. The judge ruled in favor of the Defendants, so PLF filed an appeal in the Eleventh Circuit. The case is fully briefed and held in abeyance. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Wildern v. Michigan Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs. In July 2020, Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer issued an executive directive ordering the Michigan Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs (LARA) to begin promulgating rules to establish implicit bias training as part of the skills and knowledge necessary for licensure, registration and the renewal of licenses and registrations of health professionals in the state. In June 2021, LARA promulgated a rule that requires the completion of two hours of implicit bias training by license applicants and requires more than 400,000 licensed healthcare professional to complete the same number of training hours that corresponds with the number of years in the renewal cycle (i.e. two hours for a two-year renewal cycle). It is unconstitutional for administrative agencies to enact ideological requirements for professional licensure, and LARA does not have statutory authority to enact ideological training requirements. PLF represents Dr. Kent Wildern in a challenge to LARA's authority to require implicit bias training for licensed healthcare professionals. The case is currently being briefed before the Michigan Court of Claims. Because the case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Yoder v. Lott. PLF represents Mike Yoder, Drone Deer Recovery Media, Inc. (DDR), and Jeremy Funke in a First Amendment challenge to a Michigan statute that prohibits them from using drones to collect, communicate, and receive information to locate downed game. Yoder owns DDR, and Funke is a prospective customer. Under the Michigan law, Yoder cannot communicate information that his customers want, nor can he expand his business by training and certifying other drone location entrepreneurs to operate in the state. Michigan is stifling Yoder's business without any legitimate reasons related to health, safety, or public welfare. PLF filed a lawsuit in federal court to vindicate their First Amendment rights. The court granted the government's motion to dismiss. PLF appealed to the Ninth Circuit, where the case is fully briefed and awaiting a decision. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Zip Kombucha LLC v. Wilson. The Alaska legislature has restricted breweries and wineries from hosting live entertainment. The law also prohibits arguably non-expressive forms of entertainment (such as board games) in breweries and wineries but not in bars. PLF represents Zip Kombucha and other breweries and wineries in a state court challenge to Alaska's restrictions on entertainment and games for such establishments as violating the First Amendment to the United States and the Alaska Constitution's Rewards of Industry Clause. These entertainment restrictions unconstitutionally prevent wineries and breweries from fairly competing for customers. PLF argues that if bars can host games and entertainment, breweries should be able to as well. Alaska cannot stack the deck against some businesses in favor of others with greater political pull. The case is fully briefed and awaiting order from the court. Because this case is pending, it is premature to seek fees. Amicus cases: PLF filed amicus briefs in the following cases, furthering the objectives described above. 257-261 20th Ave. Realty, LLC v. Alesandro Roberto (New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate Division) CF Homes, LLC v. Department of Development Services for the City of North Canton (Ohio Supreme Court) Christine Searle v. John Allen, et al. (Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals) D. Allen Blankenship v. FINRA (Third Circuit Court of Appeals) Deborah E. Barron, et al. v. United States & 4023 Sawyer Road I LLC v. United States (consolidated) (U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit) Elizabeth Niblock, et al. v. University of Kentucky, et al. (Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals) Faytima Howard v. Macomb County, Michigan (Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals) Federal Communications Commission v. Consumers' Research (U.S. Supreme Court) Garland v. Cargill (U.S. Supreme Court) GHP Management v. City of Los Angeles (U.S. Supreme Court) Hedrick v. City of Holiday Island (Arkansas Supreme Court) Idaho Power v. 516 Ranch (Oregon Court of Appeals) James Harper v. Daniel Werfel (U.S. Supreme Court) Joseph A Fortin v. Commissioner of Social Security (U.S. Supreme Court) Kaley Chiles v. Patty Salazar (U.S. Supreme Court) Louis Jackson, et al. v. Southfield Neighborhood Revitalization Initiative, et al. (Michigan Supreme Court) Marfil v. City of New Braunfels (Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals) Marlean A. Ames v. Ohio Department of Youth Services (U.S. Supreme Court) Mendocino Railway v. Jack Ainsworth (U.S. Supreme Court) Monroe County Board of Zoning Appeals v. Bedford Recycling, Inc. (Supreme Court of Indiana) Nuclear Regulatory Commission v. State of Texas (U.S. Supreme Court) PennyMac Loan Services, LLC v. Roosevelt Associates, RIGP (U.S. Supreme Court) Pierre Riley v. Merrick Garland (U.S. Supreme Court) Properties of the Villages Inc. v. FTC (Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals) Reed Havel v. Kent Board of Zoning Appeals, City of Kent, OH (Ohio Supreme Court) Robert Holman v. Brooke Rollins (U.S. Supreme Court) Robert F. Kennedy Jr. v. Braidwood Management, Inc. (U.S. Supreme Court) Ryan, LLC v. Federal Trade Commission (Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals) San Luis Obispo Coastkeeper v. County of San Luis Obispo (Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals) Snyder v. City of Luckey, Ohio (Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals) State of Utah v. United States (U.S. Supreme Court) States of Kentucky et al v. EPA (U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit) Stuart Reges v. Cauce (Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals)
Form 990, Part III, Line 4aTexas Top Cop Shop, Inc. v. Garland (Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals) United States ex rel. Clarissa Zafirov v. Florida Medical Association (Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals) United States v. Gregory Pheasant (Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals) United States v. Jamarr Smith (Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals) Vicki Baker v. City of McKinney, Texas (U.S. Supreme Court) Waples Mobile Home Park Limited Partnership v. Reyes (U.S. Supreme Court) Western States Land Reliance Trust v. Linn County (Oregon Court of Appeals)
Form 990, Part VI, Section B, line 11bThe tax preparer and PLF financial management provide the Form 990 to the Audit Committee, along with each trustee, giving them the opportunity to raise any concerns and/or ask questions prior to the filing date. A deadline is given to the trustees to insure a timely filing of the tax return.
Form 990, Part VI, Section B, line 12cPLF bylaws provide that any self-dealing transaction must be approved by a majority of the board, with the interested trustee(s) excluded from voting. The board must also conduct reasonable investigation and determine it could not have obtained a more advantageous arrangement. The Governance and Nominating Committee is charged with annual review of trustees including securing any disclosure of potential conflicts of interest with a written form signed annually by each trustee. Employees are required by our conflicts of interest policy to disclose to the Director of Human Resources any actual or potential conflict of interest which are then resolved by the President.
Form 990, Part VI, Section B, line 15CEO compensation is reviewed annually by the Governance and Nominating Committee which makes recommendations to the full board to determine compensation. Job descriptions for the CEO and other key executives are evaluated against independent market sources and compensation data. PLF's independent board applies the "rebuttable presumption of reasonableness procedures in its evaluation of the compensation arrangements of key employees.
Form 990, Part VI, Section C, line 19Copies are available on the organization's website or upon request.
Form 990, Part XI, line 9:Change in value of split-interest agreements 553,716.

Comments

Anonymous: no account or email. Up to 2,000 characters, at most one link. Comments are checked automatically; some wait for review.