EARTHJUSTICE: Form 990, tax year 2012

View the entire original 990 at ProPublica ↗

Organization
EARTHJUSTICE (EIN 94-1730465)
Tax period
2012-07-01 to 2013-06-30
Filed
2014-02-14
IRS object ID
201430459349301248
Schema version
2012v2.1
Source
Download XML · Original 990 at ProPublica

Every field in the e-filed return. Faint text is the IRS element name, for citing.

Return header ReturnHeader

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Timestamp2014-02-14T13:12:50-06:00Timestamp
Tax Period End Date2013-06-30TaxPeriodEndDate

Preparer Firm PreparerFirm

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
EIN910189318EIN

Preparer Firm Business Name PreparerFirmBusinessName

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Business Name Line1MOSS ADAMS LLPBusinessNameLine1

Preparer Firm US Address PreparerFirmUSAddress

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Address Line13121 WEST MARCH LANE SUITE 100AddressLine1
CitySTOCKTONCity
StateCAState
ZIP Code95219ZIPCode
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Return Type990ReturnType
Tax Period Begin Date2012-07-01TaxPeriodBeginDate

Filer Filer

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
EIN941730465EIN

Name Name

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Business Name Line1EARTHJUSTICEBusinessNameLine1
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Name ControlEARTNameControl
Phone4152172000Phone

US Address USAddress

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Address Line150 CALIFORNIA STREET SUITE 500AddressLine1
CitySAN FRANCISCOCity
StateCAState
ZIP Code94111ZIPCode

Officer Officer

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
NameJAY SCHWARTZName
TitleVP FINANCETitle
Phone4152172000Phone
Date Signed2014-02-12DateSigned
Authorize Third Party1AuthorizeThirdParty

Preparer Preparer

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
NameTRACY S PAGLIAName
PTINP00366884PTIN
Phone2099556100Phone
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Tax Year2012TaxYear
Build TS2015-11-30 17:44:51ZBuildTS

Form 990 IRS990

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Name Of Principal Officer PersonDONNELL VAN NOPPENNameOfPrincipalOfficerPerson

Address Principal Officer US AddressPrincipalOfficerUS

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Address Line150 CALIFORNIA STREET SUITE 500AddressLine1
CitySAN FRANCISCOCity
StateCAState
ZIP Code94111ZIPCode
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Gross Receipts65416927GrossReceipts
Group Return For Affiliates0GroupReturnForAffiliates
Organization501c3XOrganization501c3
Web SiteWWW.EARTHJUSTICE.ORGWebSite
Type Of Organization CorporationXTypeOfOrganizationCorporation
Year Formation1970YearFormation
State Legal DomicileCAStateLegalDomicile
Activity Or Mission DescriptionWE USE THE LAW TO PROTECT NATURAL HERITAGE, SAFEGUARD HEALTH AND PROMOTE A CLEAN ENERGY FUTURE.ActivityOrMissionDescription
Nbr Voting Members Governing Body22NbrVotingMembersGoverningBody
Nbr Independent Voting Members22NbrIndependentVotingMembers
Total Nbr Employees252TotalNbrEmployees
Total Nbr Volunteers10TotalNbrVolunteers
Total Gross UBI0TotalGrossUBI
Net Unrelated Business Txbl Income0NetUnrelatedBusinessTxblIncome
Contributions Grants Prior Year32386669ContributionsGrantsPriorYear
Contributions Grants Current Year32609428ContributionsGrantsCurrentYear
Program Service Revenue Prior Year5079648ProgramServiceRevenuePriorYear
Program Service Revenue CY4109785ProgramServiceRevenueCY
Investment Income Prior Year763901InvestmentIncomePriorYear
Investment Income Current Year1178529InvestmentIncomeCurrentYear
Other Revenue Prior Year113742OtherRevenuePriorYear
Other Revenue Current Year67013OtherRevenueCurrentYear
Total Revenue Prior Year38343960TotalRevenuePriorYear
Total Revenue Current Year37964755TotalRevenueCurrentYear
Grants And Similar Amnts Prior Year54650GrantsAndSimilarAmntsPriorYear
Grants And Similar Amnts CY314700GrantsAndSimilarAmntsCY
Benefits Paid To Members Prior Year0BenefitsPaidToMembersPriorYear
Benefits Paid To Members CY0BenefitsPaidToMembersCY
Salaries Etc Prior Year21571574SalariesEtcPriorYear
Salaries Etc Current Year23733459SalariesEtcCurrentYear
Total Prof Fundrsng Exp Prior Year252529TotalProfFundrsngExpPriorYear
Total Prof Fundrsng Exp CY383467TotalProfFundrsngExpCY
Total Fundrsng Exp Current Year5073148TotalFundrsngExpCurrentYear
Other Expense Prior Year11338032OtherExpensePriorYear
Other Expenses Current Year10479670OtherExpensesCurrentYear
Total Expenses Prior Year33216785TotalExpensesPriorYear
Total Expenses Current Year34911296TotalExpensesCurrentYear
Revenues Less Expenses Prior Year5127175RevenuesLessExpensesPriorYear
Revenues Less Expenses CY3053459RevenuesLessExpensesCY
Total Assets BOY53908481TotalAssetsBOY
Total Assets EOY58945673TotalAssetsEOY
Total Liabilities BOY7791128TotalLiabilitiesBOY
Total Liabilities EOY8244593TotalLiabilitiesEOY
Net Assets Or Fund Balances BOY46117353NetAssetsOrFundBalancesBOY
Net Assets Or Fund Balances EOY50701080NetAssetsOrFundBalancesEOY
Info In Schedule O Part IIIXInfoInScheduleOPartIII
Mission DescriptionEARTHJUSTICE IS A NON-PROFIT PUBLIC INTEREST LAW FIRM DEDICATED TO PROTECTING THE MAGNIFICENT PLACES, NATURAL RESOURCES, AND WILDLIFE OF THIS EARTH AND TO DEFENDING THE RIGHT OF ALL PEOPLE TO A HEALTHY ENVIRONMENT. WE BRING ABOUT FAR-REACHING CHANGE BY ENFORCING AND STRENGTHENING ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS ON BEHALF OF HUNDREDS OF ORGANIZATIONS AND COMMUNITIES.MissionDescription
Significant New Program Services0SignificantNewProgramServices
Significant Change0SignificantChange
Expense18930264Expense
Grants314700Grants
Revenue4109785Revenue
DescriptionPROVIDE FREE LEGAL REPRESENTATION, WORKING THROUGH THE COURTS ON BEHALF OF CITIZEN GROUPS, SCIENTISTS, ENVIRONMENTAL AND OTHER ORGANIZATIONS TO ENSURE THAT GOVERNMENT AGENCIES AND PRIVATE INTERESTS FOLLOW THE LAW.Description

Activity2 Activity2

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Expense8326642Expense
DescriptionPROVIDE INCREASED PUBLIC, MEDIA AND POLICY MAKER AWARENESS OF ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES AND THE ROLE OF LAW IN RESOLVING THEM.Description
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total Program Service Expense27256906TotalProgramServiceExpense
Described In501 C31DescribedIn501C3
Schedule B Required1ScheduleBRequired
Political Activities0PoliticalActivities
Lobbying Activities1LobbyingActivities
Subject To Proxy Tax0SubjectToProxyTax
Donor Advised Funds0DonorAdvisedFunds
Conservation Easements0ConservationEasements
Collections Of Art0CollectionsOfArt
Credit Counseling1CreditCounseling
Term Or Permanent Endowments1TermOrPermanentEndowments
Report Land Bldg Equip1ReportLandBldgEquip
Report Invest Oth Securities0ReportInvestOthSecurities
Report Prog Rel Invest0ReportProgRelInvest
Report Other Assets0ReportOtherAssets
Report Other Liabilities1ReportOtherLiabilities
Report Fin48 Footnote1ReportFin48Footnote
Independent Audit Financial Stmt1IndependentAuditFinancialStmt
Consolidated Audit Financial Stmt0ConsolidatedAuditFinancialStmt
School0School
Foreign Office1ForeignOffice
Foreign Activities1ForeignActivities
More Than5000 K To Organizations0MoreThan5000KToOrganizations
More Than5000 K To Individuals0MoreThan5000KToIndividuals
Professional Fundraising1ProfessionalFundraising
Fundraising Activities0FundraisingActivities
Gaming0Gaming
Hospital0Hospital
Grants To Organizations1GrantsToOrganizations
Grants To Individuals0GrantsToIndividuals
Schedule J Required1ScheduleJRequired
Tax Exempt Bonds0TaxExemptBonds
Excess Benefit Transaction0ExcessBenefitTransaction
Prior Excess Benefit Transaction0PriorExcessBenefitTransaction
Loan To Officer Or DQP0LoanToOfficerOrDQP
Grant To Related Person0GrantToRelatedPerson
Bsnss Rltnshp With Organization0BsnssRltnshpWithOrganization
Bsnss Rltnshp Thru Family Member0BsnssRltnshpThruFamilyMember
Officer Entity With Bsnss Rltnshp0OfficerEntityWithBsnssRltnshp
Deductible Non Cash Contributions1DeductibleNonCashContributions
Deductible Contributions Of Art0DeductibleContributionsOfArt
Terminated0Terminated
Partial Liquidation0PartialLiquidation
Disregarded Entity0DisregardedEntity
Related Entity1RelatedEntity
Related Org Controlled Entity1RelatedOrgControlledEntity
Transaction Related Entity0TransactionRelatedEntity
Transfers To Exempt Non Chrtbl Org0TransfersToExemptNonChrtblOrg
Activities Conducted Partnership0ActivitiesConductedPartnership
Schedule O Required1ScheduleORequired
Number Forms Transmitted With1096355NumberFormsTransmittedWith1096
Number W2 G Included0NumberW2GIncluded
Compliance With Backup Witholding1ComplianceWithBackupWitholding
Number Of Employees252NumberOfEmployees
Employment Tax Returns Filed1EmploymentTaxReturnsFiled
Unrelated Business Income0UnrelatedBusinessIncome
Foreign Financial Account0ForeignFinancialAccount
Prohibited Tax Shelter Trans0ProhibitedTaxShelterTrans
Taxable Party Notification0TaxablePartyNotification
Non Deductible Contributions0NonDeductibleContributions
Quid Pro Quo Contributions0QuidProQuoContributions
Form8282 Property Disposed Of0Form8282PropertyDisposedOf
Funds To Pay Premiums0FundsToPayPremiums
Premiums Paid0PremiumsPaid
Indoor Tanning Services0IndoorTanningServices
Info In Schedule O Part VIXInfoInScheduleOPartVI
Nbr Voting Governing Body Members22NbrVotingGoverningBodyMembers
Number Independent Voting Members22NumberIndependentVotingMembers
Family Or Business Relationship0FamilyOrBusinessRelationship
Delegation Of Management Duties0DelegationOfManagementDuties
Changes To Organizing Docs0ChangesToOrganizingDocs
Material Diversion Or Misuse0MaterialDiversionOrMisuse
Members Or Stockholders0MembersOrStockholders
Election Of Board Members0ElectionOfBoardMembers
Decisions Subject To Approval0DecisionsSubjectToApproval
Minutes Of Governing Body1MinutesOfGoverningBody
Minutes Of Committees1MinutesOfCommittees
Officer Mailing Address0OfficerMailingAddress
Local Chapters1LocalChapters
Policies Reference Chapters1PoliciesReferenceChapters
Form990 Provided To Governing Body1Form990ProvidedToGoverningBody
Conflict Of Interest Policy1ConflictOfInterestPolicy
Annual Disclosure Covered Persons1AnnualDisclosureCoveredPersons
Regular Monitoring Enforcement1RegularMonitoringEnforcement
Whistleblower Policy1WhistleblowerPolicy
Document Retention Policy1DocumentRetentionPolicy
Compensation Process CEO1CompensationProcessCEO
Compensation Process Other1CompensationProcessOther
Investment In Joint Venture0InvestmentInJointVenture
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledALStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledAKStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledAZStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledARStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledCAStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledCTStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledFLStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledGAStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledILStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledKSStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledKYStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledLAStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledMDStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledMAStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledMIStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledMNStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledMSStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledNHStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledNJStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledNMStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledNYStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledNCStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledOHStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledOKStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledORStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledPAStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledRIStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledSCStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledTNStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledUTStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledVAStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledWAStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledWVStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledWIStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledHIStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledMOStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
States Where Copy Of Return Is FiledNDStatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFiled
Own WebsiteXOwnWebsite
Upon RequestXUponRequest

The Books Are In Care Of TheBooksAreInCareOf

Name Business NameBusiness

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Business Name Line1JAY SCHWARTZ VP FINANCEBusinessNameLine1
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Telephone Number4152172000TelephoneNumber

Address US AddressUS

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Address Line150 CALIFORNIA STREET SUITE 500AddressLine1
CitySAN FRANCISCOCity
StateCAState
ZIP Code94111ZIPCode

Form990 Part VII Section A Form990PartVIISectionA (40 entries)

TitleTitleAverage Hours Per WeekAverageHoursPerWeekAverage Hours Per Week RelatedAverageHoursPerWeekRelatedIndividual Trustee Or DirectorIndividualTrusteeOrDirectorReportable Comp From OrganizationReportableCompFromOrganizationReportable Comp From Related OrgsReportableCompFromRelatedOrgsOther CompensationOtherCompensationOfficerOfficerKey EmployeeKeyEmployeeHighest Compensated EmployeeHighestCompensatedEmployee
REGINALD BRACK
TRUSTEE1.000.00X000
SUSAN BRITTON
TRUSTEE, SECRETARY1.000.00X000X
PETER CARSON
TRUSTEE, CHAIR1.000.00X000X
DAVID COX
TRUSTEE1.000.00X000
STEVE DAETZ
TRUSTEE1.000.00X000
RUSSELL DAGGATT
TRUSTEE THROUGH 6/131.000.00X000
TONY DEFALCO
TRUSTEE1.000.00X000
CARMEN G GONZALEZ
TRUSTEE1.000.00X000
M CHRIS KILLINGSWORTH
TRUSTEE1.000.00X000
DAVID KLIPSTEIN
TRUSTEE1.000.00X000
ED LEWIS
TRUSTEE THROUGH 6/131.000.00X000
GEORGE MARTIN
TRUSTEE1.000.00X000
WILLIAM NEWSOM
TRUSTEE1.000.00X000
DAN OLINCY
TRUSTEE1.000.00X000
BRADLEY PARKER
TRUSTEE1.000.00X000
MARCIA RIKLIS
TRUSTEE1.000.00X000
BETTY SCHAFER
TRUSTEE1.000.00X000
FERN SHEPARD
TRUSTEE1.000.00X000
PATRICE SIMMS
TRUSTEE, VICE CHAIR AT LARGE1.000.00X000X
THEODORE M SMITH
TRUSTEE THROUGH 9/121.000.00X000
MICHAEL SONNENFELDT
TRUSTEE1.000.00X000
DIANNE STERN
TRUSTEE, VICE CHAIR DEVELOPMENT1.000.00X000X
ELIZABETH SUTHERLAND RINEY
TRUSTEE1.000.00X000
KEVIN TONER
TRUSTEE1.000.00X000
STEPHEN M UNFRIED
TRUSTEE, TREASURER1.000.00X000X
G MARC WHITEHEAD
TRUSTEE THROUGH 6/131.000.00X000
DONNELL VAN NOPPEN
PRESIDENT40.000.00351537043577X
BRUCE NEIGHBOR
VICE PRESIDENT40.000.00157127048591X
WILLIAM CURTISS
GENERAL COUNSEL40.000.00164872061891X
KRISTINE STRATTON
SR. VICE PRESIDENT40.000.00225437013847X
PATTI GOLDMAN
VICE PRESIDENT40.000.00217370057598X
MELINDA CARMACK
VICE PRESIDENT THROUGH 5/1340.000.00201901046420X
MARTIN HAYDEN
VICE PRESIDENT40.000.00183902052859X
GEORGIA MCINTOSH
VICE PRESIDENT40.000.00183856051748X
CHRISTA BROTHERS
VICE PRESIDENT40.000.0015608200X
PAUL ACHITOFF
MANAGING ATTORNEY40.000.00149997028821X
DOUG HONNOLD
MANAGING ATTORNEY40.000.00154874027959X
DAVID GUEST
MANAGING ATTORNEY40.000.00147110026973X
DAVID BARON
MANAGING ATTORNEY40.000.00147854046779X
DEBORAH REAMES
MANAGING ATTORNEY THROUGH 10/1240.000.00171361031378X
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total Reportable Comp From Org2613280TotalReportableCompFromOrg
Total Reportable Comp Frm Rltd Orgs0TotalReportableCompFrmRltdOrgs
Total Other Compensation538441TotalOtherCompensation
Number Individuals GT100 K49NumberIndividualsGT100K
Formers Listed0FormersListed
Total Comp GT150 K1TotalCompGT150K
Compensation From Other Sources0CompensationFromOtherSources

Contractor Compensation ContractorCompensation (5 entries)

Address Line1AddressOfContractor/AddressUS/AddressLine1CityAddressOfContractor/AddressUS/CityStateAddressOfContractor/AddressUS/StateZIP CodeAddressOfContractor/AddressUS/ZIPCodeDescription Of ServicesDescriptionOfServicesCompensationCompensation
SKYLINE CONSTRUCTION
71 SANSOME STREET 4TH FLOORSAN FRANCISCOCA94111BUILDING CONSTRUCTION1766228
MAL WARWICK ASSOCIATES
2650 9TH STREET SUITE 103BERKELEYCA94710DIRECT MAIL CONSULTING1764848
MEDIA STRATEGIES & RESEARCH
11350 RANDOM HILLS RD SUITE 670FAIRFAXVA22030MEDIA PLACEMENT620176
IMAGE X
6150 STONERIDGE MALL ROAD SUITE 20PLEASANTONCA94588REPRODUCTION & PRINTING443310
CHANGEORG INC
64 FULTON ST SUITE 1001NEW YORKNY10038EMAIL ACTIVIST LISTINGS168300
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Number Of Contractors GT100 K11NumberOfContractorsGT100K
All Other Contributions32609428AllOtherContributions
Noncash Contributions1139784NoncashContributions
Total Contributions32609428TotalContributions

Program Service Revenue ProgramServiceRevenue (3 entries)

DescriptionDescriptionBusiness CodeBusinessCodeTotal Revenue ColumnTotalRevenueColumnRelated Or Exempt Function IncomeRelatedOrExemptFunctionIncome
COURT AWARDS54110039709143970914
CLIENT COST RECOVERIES541100138174138174
PRODUCT SALES900099697697
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total Program Service Revenue4109785TotalProgramServiceRevenue

Investment Income InvestmentIncome

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total Revenue Column867250TotalRevenueColumn
Exclusion$867,250ExclusionAmount

Gross Amount Sales Assets GrossAmountSalesAssets

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Securities27763451Securities

Less Cost Oth Basis Sales Expenses LessCostOthBasisSalesExpenses

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Securities27452172Securities

Gain Or Loss GainOrLoss

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Securities311279Securities

Net Gain Or Loss Investments NetGainOrLossInvestments

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total Revenue Column311279TotalRevenueColumn
Exclusion$311,279ExclusionAmount

Other Revenue Misc OtherRevenueMisc (2 entries)

DescriptionDescriptionBusiness CodeBusinessCodeTotal Revenue ColumnTotalRevenueColumnExclusionExclusionAmount
MAILING LIST RENTAL90009961999$61,999
OTHER MISC INCOME9000995014$5,014
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total Other Revenue67013TotalOtherRevenue

Total Revenue TotalRevenue

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total Revenue Column37964755TotalRevenueColumn
Related Or Exempt Function Income4109785RelatedOrExemptFunctionIncome
Unrelated Business Revenue0UnrelatedBusinessRevenue
Exclusion$1,245,542ExclusionAmount

Grants To Domestic Orgs GrantsToDomesticOrgs

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total314700Total
Program Services314700ProgramServices

Comp Current Officers Directors CompCurrentOfficersDirectors

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total2346115Total
Program Services1696474ProgramServices
Management And General224416ManagementAndGeneral
Fundraising425225Fundraising

Other Salaries And Wages OtherSalariesAndWages

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total16079420Total
Program Services13475110ProgramServices
Management And General793880ManagementAndGeneral
Fundraising1810430Fundraising

Pension Plan Contributions PensionPlanContributions

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total1155269Total
Program Services1019053ProgramServices
Management And General37761ManagementAndGeneral
Fundraising98455Fundraising

Other Employee Benefits OtherEmployeeBenefits

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total2850626Total
Program Services2385288ProgramServices
Management And General128437ManagementAndGeneral
Fundraising336901Fundraising

Payroll Taxes PayrollTaxes

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total1302029Total
Program Services1088144ProgramServices
Management And General62026ManagementAndGeneral
Fundraising151859Fundraising

Fees For Services Legal FeesForServicesLegal

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total664Total
Management And General664ManagementAndGeneral

Fees For Services Accounting FeesForServicesAccounting

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total135281Total
Management And General135281ManagementAndGeneral

Fees For Services Prof Fundraising FeesForServicesProfFundraising

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total383467Total
Fundraising383467Fundraising

Fees For Services Invst Mgmnt Fees FeesForServicesInvstMgmntFees

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total36897Total
Management And General36897ManagementAndGeneral

Fees For Services Other FeesForServicesOther

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total749664Total
Program Services603594ProgramServices
Management And General86600ManagementAndGeneral
Fundraising59470Fundraising

Advertising Advertising

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total1364174Total
Program Services1302809ProgramServices
Fundraising61365Fundraising

Office Expenses OfficeExpenses

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total2241661Total
Program Services624968ProgramServices
Management And General239968ManagementAndGeneral
Fundraising1376725Fundraising

Information Technology InformationTechnology

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total465359Total
Program Services372697ProgramServices
Management And General41074ManagementAndGeneral
Fundraising51588Fundraising

Occupancy Occupancy

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total2043600Total
Program Services1657833ProgramServices
Management And General262256ManagementAndGeneral
Fundraising123511Fundraising

Travel Travel

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total797648Total
Program Services568897ProgramServices
Management And General155296ManagementAndGeneral
Fundraising73455Fundraising

Conferences Meetings ConferencesMeetings

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total140710Total
Program Services100354ProgramServices
Management And General27397ManagementAndGeneral
Fundraising12959Fundraising

Depreciation Depletion DepreciationDepletion

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total626107Total
Program Services388341ProgramServices
Management And General152239ManagementAndGeneral
Fundraising85527Fundraising

Insurance Insurance

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total81297Total
Program Services71573ProgramServices
Management And General5363ManagementAndGeneral
Fundraising4361Fundraising

Other Expenses OtherExpenses (4 entries)

DescriptionDescriptionTotalTotalProgram ServicesProgramServicesManagement And GeneralManagementAndGeneralFundraisingFundraising
DIRECT CASE COSTS942869942869
OTHER CONTRACTED SVCS47248347248300
BAD DEBT EXPENSE162135162135
RESEARCH441873306276843441

All Other Expenses AllOtherExpenses

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total174934Total
Program Services138657ProgramServices
Management And General21868ManagementAndGeneral
Fundraising14409Fundraising

Total Functional Expenses TotalFunctionalExpenses

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total34911296Total
Program Services27256906ProgramServices
Management And General2581242ManagementAndGeneral
Fundraising5073148Fundraising

Cash Non Interest Bearing CashNonInterestBearing

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY967094BOY
EOY291859EOY

Savings And Temp Cash Investments SavingsAndTempCashInvestments

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY8550556BOY
EOY9939372EOY

Pledges And Grants Receivable PledgesAndGrantsReceivable

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY8769526BOY
EOY4426206EOY

Accounts Receivable AccountsReceivable

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY573672BOY
EOY717105EOY

Prepaid Expenses Deferred Charges PrepaidExpensesDeferredCharges

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY796040BOY
EOY968347EOY
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Land Buildings Equipment Basis5719715LandBuildingsEquipmentBasis
Land Bldg Equipment Accum Deprec3179536LandBldgEquipmentAccumDeprec

Land Buildings Equipment Basis Net LandBuildingsEquipmentBasisNet

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY2559740BOY
EOY2540179EOY

Investments Pub Traded Securities InvestmentsPubTradedSecurities

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY31253240BOY
EOY39523283EOY

Other Assets Total OtherAssetsTotal

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY438613BOY
EOY539322EOY

Total Assets TotalAssets

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY53908481BOY
EOY58945673EOY

Accounts Payable Accrued Expenses AccountsPayableAccruedExpenses

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY2390177BOY
EOY2429195EOY

Escrow Account Liability EscrowAccountLiability

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY160968BOY
EOY463934EOY

Other Liabilities OtherLiabilities

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY5239983BOY
EOY5351464EOY

Total Liabilities TotalLiabilities

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY7791128BOY
EOY8244593EOY
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Follow SFAS117XFollowSFAS117

Unrestricted Net Assets UnrestrictedNetAssets

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY25918484BOY
EOY34700416EOY

Temporarily Restricted Net Assets TemporarilyRestrictedNetAssets

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY18751036BOY
EOY14552831EOY

Permanently Restricted Net Assets PermanentlyRestrictedNetAssets

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY1447833BOY
EOY1447833EOY

Total Net Assets Fund Balances TotalNetAssetsFundBalances

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY46117353BOY
EOY50701080EOY

Total Liab Net Assets Fund Balances TotalLiabNetAssetsFundBalances

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
BOY53908481BOY
EOY58945673EOY
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Info In Schedule O Part XIXInfoInScheduleOPartXI
Reconcilation Revenue Expenses3053459ReconcilationRevenueExpenses
Reconciliation Unrealized Invest1223632ReconciliationUnrealizedInvest
Reconcilation Other Changes306636ReconcilationOtherChanges
Info In Schedule O Part XIIXInfoInScheduleOPartXII
Method Of Accounting AccrualXMethodOfAccountingAccrual
Accountant Compile Or Review0AccountantCompileOrReview
FS Audited1FSAudited

FS Audited Basis FSAuditedBasis

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Financial Statement SeparateXFinancialStatementSeparate
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Audit Committee1AuditCommittee
Federal Grant Audit Required0FederalGrantAuditRequired

Schedule A IRS990ScheduleA

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Publicly Supported Org170b1 AviXPubliclySupportedOrg170b1Avi

Gifts Grants Contrib Received170 GiftsGrantsContribReceived170

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Current Tax Year Minus4 Years25712988CurrentTaxYearMinus4Years
Current Tax Year Minus3 Years21101486CurrentTaxYearMinus3Years
Current Tax Year Minus2 Years29629520CurrentTaxYearMinus2Years
Current Tax Year Minus1 Year32386669CurrentTaxYearMinus1Year
Current Tax Year32609428CurrentTaxYear
Total141440091Total

Total170 Total170

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Current Tax Year Minus4 Years25712988CurrentTaxYearMinus4Years
Current Tax Year Minus3 Years21101486CurrentTaxYearMinus3Years
Current Tax Year Minus2 Years29629520CurrentTaxYearMinus2Years
Current Tax Year Minus1 Year32386669CurrentTaxYearMinus1Year
Current Tax Year32609428CurrentTaxYear
Total141440091Total
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Amounts Subst Contributors Total14805073AmountsSubstContributorsTotal
Public Support Total170126635018PublicSupportTotal170

Gross Investment Income170 GrossInvestmentIncome170

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Current Tax Year Minus4 Years744412CurrentTaxYearMinus4Years
Current Tax Year Minus3 Years606200CurrentTaxYearMinus3Years
Current Tax Year Minus2 Years810261CurrentTaxYearMinus2Years
Current Tax Year Minus1 Year682413CurrentTaxYearMinus1Year
Current Tax Year867250CurrentTaxYear
Total3710536Total

Other Income170 OtherIncome170

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Current Tax Year Minus4 Years64343CurrentTaxYearMinus4Years
Current Tax Year Minus3 Years114453CurrentTaxYearMinus3Years
Current Tax Year Minus2 Years105821CurrentTaxYearMinus2Years
Current Tax Year Minus1 Year113742CurrentTaxYearMinus1Year
Current Tax Year67013CurrentTaxYear
Total465372Total
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total Support145615999TotalSupport
Gross Receipts From Admissions Etc18371491GrossReceiptsFromAdmissionsEtc
Public Support Pertcentage1700.86970PublicSupportPertcentage170
Public Support Pertcent Prior Year0.86200PublicSupportPertcentPriorYear
Thirty Three Percnt Tests CY170XThirtyThreePercntTestsCY170
General ExplanationSCHEDULE A, PART II, LINE 10, EXPLANATION OF OTHER INCOME: MISCELLANEOUS - 2008 AMOUNT: $ 6,561. 2009 AMOUNT: $ 50,273. 2010 AMOUNT: $ 6,633. 2011 AMOUNT: $ 13,778. 2012 AMOUNT: $ 5,014. MAILING LIST RENTAL - 2008 AMOUNT: $ 57,782. 2009 AMOUNT: $ 64,180. 2010 AMOUNT: $ 99,188. 2011 AMOUNT: $ 99,964. 2012 AMOUNT: $ 61,999.GeneralExplanation

Schedule B IRS990ScheduleB

Contributor Info ContributorInfo

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Contributor NumberRESTRICTEDContributorNumber

Contributor Name Business ContributorNameBusiness

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Business Name Line1RESTRICTEDBusinessNameLine1

Contributor Address US ContributorAddressUS

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Address Line1RESTRICTEDAddressLine1
Address Line2RESTRICTEDAddressLine2
CityRESTRICTEDCity
StateRESTRICTEDState
ZIP CodeRESTRICTEDZIPCode
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Aggregate ContributionsRESTRICTEDAggregateContributions

Schedule C IRS990ScheduleC

Total Grassroots Lobbying TotalGrassrootsLobbying

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Filing Organizations Totals46965FilingOrganizationsTotals

Total Direct Lobbying TotalDirectLobbying

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Filing Organizations Totals908080FilingOrganizationsTotals

Total Lobbying Expenditures TotalLobbyingExpenditures

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Filing Organizations Totals955045FilingOrganizationsTotals

Other Exempt Purpose Expenditures OtherExemptPurposeExpenditures

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Filing Organizations Totals33956251FilingOrganizationsTotals

Total Exempt Purpose Expenditures TotalExemptPurposeExpenditures

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Filing Organizations Totals34911296FilingOrganizationsTotals

Lobbying Nontaxable LobbyingNontaxableAmount

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Filing Organizations Totals1000000FilingOrganizationsTotals

Grassroots Nontaxable GrassrootsNontaxableAmount

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Filing Organizations Totals250000FilingOrganizationsTotals

Tot Lobbying Grassroot Minus Non Tx TotLobbyingGrassrootMinusNonTx

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Filing Organizations Totals0FilingOrganizationsTotals

Tot Lobby Expend Mns Lobbying Nontx TotLobbyExpendMnsLobbyingNontx

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Filing Organizations Totals0FilingOrganizationsTotals

Lobbying Nontaxable Amount2 LobbyingNontaxableAmount2

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Current Year Minus31000000CurrentYearMinus3
Current Year Minus21000000CurrentYearMinus2
Current Year Minus11000000CurrentYearMinus1
Current Year1000000CurrentYear
Total4000000Total
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Lobbying Ceiling$6,000,000LobbyingCeilingAmount

Total Lobbying Expenditures2 TotalLobbyingExpenditures2

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Current Year Minus3287776CurrentYearMinus3
Current Year Minus2606708CurrentYearMinus2
Current Year Minus1743718CurrentYearMinus1
Current Year955045CurrentYear
Total2593247Total

Grassroots Nontaxable Amount2 GrassrootsNontaxableAmount2

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Current Year Minus3250000CurrentYearMinus3
Current Year Minus2250000CurrentYearMinus2
Current Year Minus1250000CurrentYearMinus1
Current Year250000CurrentYear
Total1000000Total
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Grassroots Ceiling$1,500,000GrassrootsCeilingAmount

Grassroots Lobbying Expenditures GrassrootsLobbyingExpenditures

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Current Year Minus352422CurrentYearMinus3
Current Year Minus2188709CurrentYearMinus2
Current Year Minus192887CurrentYearMinus1
Current Year46965CurrentYear
Total380983Total

Schedule D IRS990ScheduleD

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Agent Trustee Etc0AgentTrusteeEtc
Included On FS1IncludedOnFS
Explanation In Part XIIIXExplanationInPartXIII

Current Year CurrentYear

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Beginning Of Year Balance1486951BeginningOfYearBalance
Investment Earnings Or Losses137363InvestmentEarningsOrLosses
Other Expenditures72468OtherExpenditures
End Of Year Balance1551846EndOfYearBalance

Current Year Minus1 Year CurrentYearMinus1Year

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Beginning Of Year Balance1544635BeginningOfYearBalance
Investment Earnings Or Losses12384InvestmentEarningsOrLosses
Other Expenditures70068OtherExpenditures
End Of Year Balance1486951EndOfYearBalance

Current Year Minus2 Years CurrentYearMinus2Years

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Beginning Of Year Balance1367639BeginningOfYearBalance
Investment Earnings Or Losses251288InvestmentEarningsOrLosses
Other Expenditures74292OtherExpenditures
End Of Year Balance1544635EndOfYearBalance

Current Year Minus3 Years CurrentYearMinus3Years

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Beginning Of Year Balance1273350BeginningOfYearBalance
Investment Earnings Or Losses173131InvestmentEarningsOrLosses
Other Expenditures78842OtherExpenditures
End Of Year Balance1367639EndOfYearBalance

Current Year Minus4 Years CurrentYearMinus4Years

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Beginning Of Year Balance1447835BeginningOfYearBalance
Investment Earnings Or Losses-174485InvestmentEarningsOrLosses
End Of Year Balance1273350EndOfYearBalance
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Permanent Endowment EOY Balance1.00000PermanentEndowmentEOYBalance
Endowments Held By Unrelated Orgs0EndowmentsHeldByUnrelatedOrgs
Endowments Held By Related Orgs0EndowmentsHeldByRelatedOrgs

Land Land

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Other Cost Or Other Basis232880OtherCostOrOtherBasis
Book Value232880BookValue

Buildings Buildings

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Other Cost Or Other Basis450468OtherCostOrOtherBasis
Depreciation97435Depreciation
Book Value353033BookValue

Leasehold Improvements LeaseholdImprovements

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Other Cost Or Other Basis1093009OtherCostOrOtherBasis
Depreciation355740Depreciation
Book Value737269BookValue

Equipment Equipment

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Other Cost Or Other Basis3485854OtherCostOrOtherBasis
Depreciation2315051Depreciation
Book Value1170803BookValue

Other Land Buildings OtherLandBuildings

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Other Cost Or Other Basis457504OtherCostOrOtherBasis
Depreciation411310Depreciation
Book Value46194BookValue
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total Of Book Value Land Buildings2540179TotalOfBookValueLandBuildings

Other Liabilities OtherLiabilities (2 entries)

DescriptionDescriptionAmountAmount
LIABILITIES RELATING TO SPLIT INTEREST GIFT AGREEMENTS$5,138,673
DEFERRED COMPENSATION LIABILITY$212,791
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total Of Amounts5351464TotalOfAmounts
Footnote In Part XIIIXFootnoteInPartXIII
Tot Revenue Etc Audited Fincl Stmt46644916TotRevenueEtcAuditedFinclStmt
Net Unrealized Gains Investments1223632NetUnrealizedGainsInvestments
Donated Srvc And Use Of Facilities7173479DonatedSrvcAndUseOfFacilities
Other Revenues283050OtherRevenues
Revenue Not Rptd F9908680161RevenueNotRptdF990
Revenue Subtotal37964755RevenueSubtotal
Revenue Not Rptd On Fin Stmt0RevenueNotRptdOnFinStmt
Total Revenue Per Form99037964755TotalRevenuePerForm990
Tot Expenses Etc Audited Fincl Stmt42061189TotExpensesEtcAuditedFinclStmt
Donated Services Use Of Facilities7149893DonatedServicesUseOfFacilities
Expenses Not Rptd F9907149893ExpensesNotRptdF990
Expenses Subtotal34911296ExpensesSubtotal
Expenses Not Rptd On Fin Stmt0ExpensesNotRptdOnFinStmt
Total Expenses Per Form99034911296TotalExpensesPerForm990

Form990 Schedule D Part XIII Form990ScheduleDPartXIII (4 entries)

Return ReferenceReturnReferenceExplanationExplanationIdentifierIdentifier
PART IV, LINE 2B:AS A LAW FIRM, WE ARE REQUIRED TO HOLD MONEY RECEIVED FOR THE BENEFIT OF CLIENTS IN STATE-SPECIFIC ATTORNEY CLIENT TRUST ACCOUNTS, UNTIL THE FUNDS ARE APPROPRIATELY IDENTIFIED AND EITHER REFUNDED TO THE CLIENTS OR TRANSFERRED INTO OPERATING FUNDS. AS OF 6/30/13, THE TOTAL BALANCE IN OUR CLIENT TRUST FUND ACCOUNTS TOTALED $463,934.
PART V, LINE 4:THE ENDOWMENT FUNDS ARE SEPARATED INTO FOUR CATEGORIES, EACH BASED ON A DIFFERENT SPENDING RESTRICTION AS STIPULATED BY THE DONOR. UP TO 4% OF THE ENDOWMENT FUNDS ARE USED EACH YEAR TO SUPPORT LITIGATION PROGRAMS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE SPENDING RESTRICTIONS ASSOCIATED WITH EACH OF THE FOUR CATEGORIES.DESCRIPTION OF INTENDED USE OF ENDOWMENT FUNDS:
PART X, LINE 2:EARTHJUSTICE ADOPTED THE PROVISIONS OF ACCOUNTING FOR UNCERTAIN TAX POSITIONS ON JULY 1, 2009. EARTHJUSTICE HAD NO UNRECOGNIZED TAX BENEFITS AT JUNE 30, 2013 OR 2012. EARTHJUSTICE FILES EXEMPT ORGANIZATION RETURNS AND, IF APPLICABLE, UNRELATED BUSINESS INCOME TAX RETURNS IN THE U.S. FEDERAL AND CALIFORNIA JURISDICTIONS.DESCRIPTION OF UNCERTAIN TAX POSITIONS UNDER FIN 48:
CHANGE IN SPLIT INTEREST AGREEMENTS 283,050.PART XI, LINE 2D - OTHER ADJUSTMENTS:

Schedule F IRS990ScheduleF

Accts Actvs Out US Table AcctsActvsOutUSTable

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
RegionEUROPERegion
Number Of Offices0NumberOfOffices
Number Of Employees1NumberOfEmployees
Type Of Activities ConductedPROGRAM SERVICESTypeOfActivitiesConducted
Specific Services ProvidedADVOCACY AT UNSpecificServicesProvided
Total Expenditures35428TotalExpenditures
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Subtotal Number Of Offices0SubtotalNumberOfOffices
Subtotal Number Of Employees1SubtotalNumberOfEmployees
Cont Number Of Offices0ContNumberOfOffices
Cont Number Of Employees0ContNumberOfEmployees
Total Number Of Offices0TotalNumberOfOffices
Total Number Of Employees1TotalNumberOfEmployees
Subtotal Amount Spent35428SubtotalAmountSpent
Cont Amount Spent0ContAmountSpent
Total Amount Spent35428TotalAmountSpent
Transfer To Foreign Corp0TransferToForeignCorp
Interest In Foreign Trust0InterestInForeignTrust
Own Foreign Corp0OwnForeignCorp
Passive Foreign Invest Co0PassiveForeignInvestCo
Foreign Partnership0ForeignPartnership
Boycott Countries0BoycottCountries

Schedule G IRS990ScheduleG

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Mail SolicitationsXMailSolicitations
Email SolicitationsXEmailSolicitations
Phone SolicitationsXPhoneSolicitations
In Person SolicitationsXInPersonSolicitations
Solicitation Of Non Govt GrantsXSolicitationOfNonGovtGrants
Special Fundraising EventsXSpecialFundraisingEvents
Agreement Ref Fundraising1AgreementRefFundraising

Fundraiser Activity Information FundraiserActivityInformation (3 entries)

Address Line1AddressUS/AddressLine1CityAddressUS/CityStateAddressUS/StateZIP CodeAddressUS/ZIPCodeActivityActivityFundraiser Control Of FundsFundraiserControlOfFundsGross ReceiptsGrossReceiptsAmount Retained By ContractorAmountRetainedByContractorNet To OrganizationNetToOrganization
MAL WARWICK ASSOCIATES
2550 NINTH STREET SUITE 103BERKELEYCA94710DIRECT MAIL CONSULTANT038528702576253595245
DONOR SERVICES GROUP LLC
6715 SUNSET BLVDLOS ANGELESCA90028TELEMARKETING01179731083309643
GORDON & SCHWENKMEYER INC
360 NORTH SEPULVEDA BLVD SUITE 105EL SEGUNDOCA90245TELEMARKETING01828917512777
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total Gross Receipts3989132TotalGrossReceipts
Total Retained By Contractors383467TotalRetainedByContractors
Total Net To Organization3605665TotalNetToOrganization
Licensed StatesALLicensedStates
Licensed StatesAKLicensedStates
Licensed StatesAZLicensedStates
Licensed StatesARLicensedStates
Licensed StatesCALicensedStates
Licensed StatesCTLicensedStates
Licensed StatesFLLicensedStates
Licensed StatesGALicensedStates
Licensed StatesHILicensedStates
Licensed StatesILLicensedStates
Licensed StatesKSLicensedStates
Licensed StatesKYLicensedStates
Licensed StatesLALicensedStates
Licensed StatesMDLicensedStates
Licensed StatesMALicensedStates
Licensed StatesMELicensedStates
Licensed StatesMILicensedStates
Licensed StatesMNLicensedStates
Licensed StatesMSLicensedStates
Licensed StatesNHLicensedStates
Licensed StatesNJLicensedStates
Licensed StatesNMLicensedStates
Licensed StatesNYLicensedStates
Licensed StatesNCLicensedStates
Licensed StatesOHLicensedStates
Licensed StatesOKLicensedStates
Licensed StatesORLicensedStates
Licensed StatesPALicensedStates
Licensed StatesRILicensedStates
Licensed StatesSCLicensedStates
Licensed StatesTNLicensedStates
Licensed StatesUTLicensedStates
Licensed StatesVALicensedStates
Licensed StatesWALicensedStates
Licensed StatesWILicensedStates
Licensed StatesMOLicensedStates
Licensed StatesCOLicensedStates
Licensed StatesDELicensedStates
Licensed StatesIDLicensedStates
Licensed StatesINLicensedStates
Licensed StatesIALicensedStates
Licensed StatesMTLicensedStates
Licensed StatesNELicensedStates
Licensed StatesNVLicensedStates
Licensed StatesNDLicensedStates
Licensed StatesSDLicensedStates
Licensed StatesTXLicensedStates
Licensed StatesVTLicensedStates
Licensed StatesGULicensedStates
Licensed StatesDCLicensedStates

Schedule I IRS990ScheduleI

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Records Maintained1RecordsMaintained

Recipient Table RecipientTable (4 entries)

Address Line1AddressUS/AddressLine1CityAddressUS/CityStateAddressUS/StateZIP CodeAddressUS/ZIPCodeEIN Of RecipientEINOfRecipientIRC SectionIRCSectionAmount Of Cash GrantAmountOfCashGrantPurpose Of GrantPurposeOfGrant
ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE FUND
257 PARK AVENUE SOUTHNEW YORKNY10010521379661501(C)(3)6000MEMBERSHIP DUES
LEAGUE OF CONSERVATIONS VOTERS EDUCATION FUND
1920 L STREET SUITE 800WASHINGTONDC20036116107128501(C)(3)10000EVENT SPONSORSHIPS
PARTNERSHIP PROJECT INC
1615 M STREET NWWASHINGTONDC20036810606786501(C)(3)6000MEMBERSHIP DUE
MICHIGAN ENERGY MICHIGAN JOBS
1501 N SHORE DR STE BEAST LANSINGMI48823455220103501(C)(4)275000RENEWABLE ENERGY DIRECT LOBBYING
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total Nbr Of501 C3 And Govt Grants3TotalNbrOf501C3AndGovtGrants
Total Nbr Of Other Organizations1TotalNbrOfOtherOrganizations

Form990 Schedule I Part IV Form990ScheduleIPartIV

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
IdentifierPROCEDURE FOR MONITORING GRANTS IN THE U.S.:Identifier
Return ReferencePART I, LINE 2:ReturnReference
ExplanationSCHEDULE I, PART I, LINE 2: GRANTS AND/OR ASSISTANCE ARE USUALLY PROVIDED TO OTHER ORGANIZATIONS WITH WHICH EARTHJUSTICE WORKS CLOSELY AND IS FAMILIAR, FOR PURPOSES RELATED TO COMMON INTERESTS AND ENDEAVORS ON PARTICULAR ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES. THOSE PURPOSES ARE CONSISTENT WITH THE MISSION OF EARTHJUSTICE AND THE RESTRICTIONS ON 501(C)(3) ORGANIZATIONS, WHETHER OR NOT THE RECIPIENT IS A 501(C)(3) ORGANIZATION. THE RECIPIENTS' USE OF FUNDS IS MONITORED AS PART OF EARTHJUSTICE'S INVOLVEMENT IN THE ISSUES OF SHARED INTEREST.Explanation

Schedule J IRS990ScheduleJ

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Independent ConsultantXIndependentConsultant
Compensation SurveyXCompensationSurvey
Board Or Committee ApprovalXBoardOrCommitteeApproval
Severance Payment1SeverancePayment
Supplemental Nonqual Retire Plan0SupplementalNonqualRetirePlan
Equity Based Comp Arrangement0EquityBasedCompArrangement
Comp Based On Revenue Of Filing Org0CompBasedOnRevenueOfFilingOrg
Comp Based On Revenue Related Orgs0CompBasedOnRevenueRelatedOrgs
Comp Based Net Earnings Filing Org0CompBasedNetEarningsFilingOrg
Comp Based Net Earnings Relate Orgs0CompBasedNetEarningsRelateOrgs
Any Non Fixed Payments1AnyNonFixedPayments
Initial Contract Exception0InitialContractException

Form990 Schedule J Part II Form990ScheduleJPartII (14 entries)

TitleTitleBase Compensation Filing OrgBaseCompensationFilingOrgComp Based On Related OrgsCompBasedOnRelatedOrgsBonus Filing OrgBonusFilingOrgBonus Related OrgsBonusRelatedOrgsOther Compensation Filing OrgOtherCompensationFilingOrgOther Compensation Related OrgsOtherCompensationRelatedOrgsDeferred Comp Filing OrgDeferredCompFilingOrgDeferred Comp Related OrgsDeferredCompRelatedOrgsNontaxable Benefits Filing OrgNontaxableBenefitsFilingOrgNontaxable Benefits Related OrgsNontaxableBenefitsRelatedOrgsTotal Compensation Filing OrgTotalCompensationFilingOrgTotal Compensation Related OrgsTotalCompensationRelatedOrgsComp Report Prior990 Filing OrgCompReportPrior990FilingOrgComp Report Prior990 Related OrgsCompReportPrior990RelatedOrgs
DONNELL VAN NOPPEN
PRESIDENT326537025000000297300138470395114000
BRUCE NEIGHBOR
VICE PRESIDENT1570200107000193120292790205718000
WILLIAM CURTISS
GENERAL COUNSEL1647650107000207020411890226763000
KRISTINE STRATTON
SR. VICE PRESIDENT20743701800000000138470239284000
PATTI GOLDMAN
VICE PRESIDENT21737000000284260291720274968000
MELINDA CARMACK
VICE PRESIDENT THROUGH 5/1320190100000267860196340248321000
MARTIN HAYDEN
VICE PRESIDENT17890205000000236870291720236761000
GEORGIA MCINTOSH
VICE PRESIDENT18385600000224690292790235604000
CHRISTA BROTHERS
VICE PRESIDENT149216068660000000156082000
PAUL ACHITOFF
MANAGING ATTORNEY14999700000176010112200178818000
DOUG HONNOLD
MANAGING ATTORNEY15487400000178730100860182833000
DAVID GUEST
MANAGING ATTORNEY1471100000017221097520174083000
DAVID BARON
MANAGING ATTORNEY14785400000176070291720194633000
DEBORAH REAMES
MANAGING ATTORNEY THROUGH 10/1271361000100000073730240050202739000

Form990 Schedule J Part III Form990ScheduleJPartIII (2 entries)

Return ReferenceReturnReferenceExplanationExplanation
PART I, LINE 4ATHE OTHER REPORTABLE COMPENSATION PAYMENT REPORTED IN COLUMN B(III) WAS FINAL COMPENSATION PAYMENT TO THE FORMER MANAGING ATTORNEY.
PART I, LINE 7ONE-TIME PERFORMANCE BONUSES IN THE AMOUNTS SHOWN IN PART II, COLUMN B(II) WERE PAID IN CALENDAR YEAR 2012. THE AMOUNT PAID TO THE PRESIDENT WAS APPROVED BY THE BOARD; THE AMOUNTS PAID TO THE OTHERS WERE APPROVED BY THE PRESIDENT. NONE WERE DETERMINED BY A FORMULA.

Schedule M IRS990ScheduleM

Securities Publicly Traded SecuritiesPubliclyTraded

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Non Cash CheckboxXNonCashCheckbox
Number Of Contributions91NumberOfContributions
Noncash Contribs Rptd F9901139784NoncashContribsRptdF990
Method Of Determining RevenuesFMV AT DONATION DATEMethodOfDeterminingRevenues
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Number Of8283 Received0NumberOf8283Received
Any Property That Must Be Held0AnyPropertyThatMustBeHeld
Review Process Unusual NC Gifts1ReviewProcessUnusualNCGifts
Third Parties Used1ThirdPartiesUsed

Form990 Schedule M Part II Form990ScheduleMPartII

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
IdentifierTHIRD PARTY USE:Identifier
Return ReferencePART I, LINE 32B:ReturnReference
ExplanationSECURITIES BROKERS WILL SELL STOCK GIFTS ON BEHALF OF EARTHJUSTICE; FROM TIME TO TIME, DONORS HAVE CONTRIBUTED REAL PROPERTY, USUALLY INTO A CHARITABLE REMAINDER TRUST. WHEN THIS HAPPENS, A REAL ESTATE AGENT WILL BE HIRED TO ASSIST IN SELLING THE PROPERTY.Explanation

Schedule O IRS990ScheduleO

General Explanation GeneralExplanation (13 entries)

Return ReferenceReturnReferenceExplanationExplanationIdentifierIdentifier
FORM 990, PART VI, SECTION B, LINE 11A FULL COPY OF FORM 990 IS POSTED ON A SECURE WEB PORTAL ACCESSIBLE BY THE TRUSTEES AT LEAST ONE WEEK PRIOR TO FILING. THE TRUSTEES ARE NOTIFIED OF THE FORM 990 POSTING AND ENCOURAGED TO REVIEW AND COMMENT ON IT PRIOR TO FILING.
FORM 990, PART VI, SECTION B, LINE 12CTHE CONFLICT OF INTEREST PREVENTION POLICY REQUIRES AN ANNUAL DISCLOSURE BY TRUSTEES AND SENIOR STAFF OF ENTITIES IN WHICH THEY HAVE PERSONAL, FINANCIAL OR PROFESSIONAL INTERESTS. THE RESULTS OF THOSE DISCLOSURES ARE COMPILED INTO A SCREENING LIST OF ENTITIES USED BY THE BOARD CHAIR, CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER AND GENERAL COUNSEL WHEN REVIEWING POTENTIAL TRANSACTIONS BETWEEN EARTHJUSTICE AND OUTSIDE ENTITIES. THE SCREENING LIST IS USED TO CHECK TO ASSURE THAT INDIVIDUAL DECISION-MAKERS RECUSE THEMSELVES FROM ANY PARTICIPATION IN DECISIONS AFFECTING THE ENTITIES IN WHICH THEY HAVE INTERESTS.
FORM 990, PART VI, SECTION B, LINE 15WE GET COMPETITIVE DATA FROM AN OUTSIDE COMPENSATION CONSULTANT FOR OUR CEO. IN ADDITION OUR VP-HR COLLECTS SALARIES OF CEOS FROM OTHER NON-PROFIT ENVIRONMENTAL ORGANIZATIONS TO OBTAIN ADDITIONAL DATA FOR THE KEY NATIONAL NON-PROFIT ENVIRONMENTAL ORGANIZATIONS. THIS INFORMATION IS PASSED ALONG TO THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE OF OUR BOARD OF DIRECTORS WHO REVIEWS THE DATA AND MAKES THE APPROPRIATE RECOMMENDATION FOR OUR CEO SALARY. WE DO A BI-ANNUAL REVIEW OF ALL POSITIONS IN THE ORGANIZATION INCLUDING THE CEO AND ALL STAFF. WE UPDATE ALL POSITION DESCRIPTIONS AND USE AN OUTSIDE COMPENSATION CONSULTANT TO DETERMINE SALARIES THAT MATCH THE JOB RESPONSIBILITIES IN THE NON-PROFIT SECTOR IN THE SPECIFIC GEOGRAPHIC AREAS IN WHICH OUR JOBS ARE LOCATED. OUR VP-HR ALSO CONTACTS OTHER ENVIRONMENTAL NON-PROFIT COMPANIES TO OBTAIN ADDITIONAL COMPETITIVE INFORMATION. FOR NON-ATTORNEY JOBS, EACH JOB IS ASSIGNED A GRADE. EACH GRADE HAS A MINIMUM, MIDPOINT, AND MAXIMUM SALARY. WE CONSIDER MID-POINT OF THE GRADE THE APPROPRIATE SALARY TO BE AN EMPLOYEE FULLY COMPETENT IN THE JOB. OUR VP-HR THEN WORKS WITH MANAGERS, BASED ON PERFORMANCE TO DETERMINE WHAT THE APPROPRIATE SALARY SHOULD BE WITHIN THIS RANGE. SINCE THIS PROCESS IS QUITE TIME INTENSIVE, WE DO THIS EVERY OTHER YEAR. IN THE YEAR WE DON'T GO THROUGH THIS PROCESS, WE GET COMPETITIVE DATA ABOUT WHAT THE AVERAGE RAISE WILL BE AND USE THIS AS A GUIDELINE FOR OUR BUDGETING PROCESS. OUR ATTORNEYS' PAY IS BASED ON YEAR OF GRADUATION FROM LAW SCHOOL, TO WHICH WE ADD A GEOGRAPHIC ADJUSTMENT BASED ON THE OFFICE LOCATION, E.G. BOZEMAN, MONTANA VS. NEW YORK, NY. WE CONTACT OTHER CONSERVATION ORGANIZATIONS LIKE THE SIERRA CLUB AND ALSO GOVERNMENT ENTITIES LIKE THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE TO DETERMINE THE APPROPRIATE PAY FOR OUR ATTORNEYS.
FORM 990, PART VI, SECTION C, LINE 19THE AUDITED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS, THE GOVERNING/ORGANIZING DOCUMENTS AND THE CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY ARE MADE AVAILABLE TO THE PUBLIC BY EMAIL REQUEST: EAJUS@EARTHJUSTICE.ORG. THE ORGANIZATION'S AUDITED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS ARE ALSO AVAILABLE ON THE ORGANIZATION'S WEBSITE.
FORM 990, PART XI, LINE 9:CHANGE IN SPLIT INTEREST AGREEMENTS 283,050. DONATED SOFTWARE AND SERVICES CAPITALIZED FOR BOOK 23,586.CHANGES IN NET ASSETS OR FUND BALANCES:
990, PART XII, LINE 2CTHERE HAVE BEEN NO CHANGES TO THIS PROCESS FROM PRIOR YEAR.AUDIT COMMITTEE AND OVERSIGHT
FORM 990, PART IIIEARTHJUSTICE IS THE PREMIER NON-PROFIT PUBLIC INTEREST LAW FIRM DEDICATED TO PROTECTING THE MAGNIFICENT PLACES, NATURAL RESOURCES, AND WILDLIFE OF THIS EARTH AND TO DEFENDING THE RIGHT OF ALL PEOPLE TO A HEALTHY ENVIRONMENT. FOR MORE THAN FOUR DECADES, EARTHJUSTICE HAS EMPOWERED CITIZENS BY REPRESENTING THEM IN COURT AT NO CHARGE TO HOLD POLLUTERS AND THE GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTABLE TO OUR ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS. THIS PAST YEAR, EARTHJUSTICE HAS CONTINUED TO MAKE THE PROMISE OF OUR ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS A REALITY AND TACKLE THE MOST PRESSING THREATS TO THE FUTURE WE WANT FOR THE PLANET AND FUTURE GENERATIONS.
FORM 990, PART IIIPROMOTING A CLEAN ENERGY FUTURE: MAKING A DRAMATIC SHIFT AWAY FROM FOSSIL FUELS TO CLEAN ENERGY REDUCING CLIMATE POLLUTION: WITH CONGRESS UNABLE TO PASS CLIMATE LEGISLATION, WE AND OUR COLLEAGUES HAVE MADE THE CLEAN AIR ACT THE PRINCIPAL TOOL FOR REINING IN CLIMATE POLLUTION. FOUR YEARS AFTER THE SUPREME COURT UPHELD THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY'S (EPA'S) AUTHORITY TO REGULATE CLIMATE POLLUTION, THE EPA FINALIZED THE FIRST REGULATIONS LIMITING CARBON EMISSIONS FROM CARS AND LIGHT TRUCKS AND CREATE A PERMITTING SCHEME FOR NEW POWER PLANTS AND OTHER POLLUTING INDUSTRIAL FACILITIES. AFTER LOSING IN THE D.C. CIRCUIT, MORE THAN 100 INDUSTRY GROUPS AND ALLIED STATES HAVE TAKEN THEIR CHALLENGE TO THE U.S. SUPREME COURT. (FORTUNATELY, THE SUPREME COURT HAS DECLINED TO REVISIT IMPORTANT ASPECTS OF THE D.C. CIRCUIT'S DECISION AFFIRMING EPA'S THRESHOLD FINDING THAT GREENHOUSE GASES ENDANGER HUMAN HEALTH AND THE ENVIRONMENT AND ITS CARBON STANDARD FOR MOTOR VEHICLES BASED ON THAT FINDING. HOWEVER, THE COURT HAS AGREED TO HEAR ARGUMENT REGARDING EPA'S AUTHORITY TO REGULATE GREENHOUSE GASES UNDER SEPARATE PERMITTING PROVISIONS, AND WE WILL BE PART OF THE TEAM OF LAWYERS BRIEFING THE CASE ON BEHALF OF THE CONSERVATION COMMUNITY.) MEANWHILE, PRESIDENT OBAMA HAS COMMITTED TO EXPANDING REGULATION OF CLIMATE POLLUTION TO ENCOMPASS ADDITIONAL REGULATION OF EMISSIONS FROM NEW AND EXISTING POWER PLANTS, AND IN ADDITION TO STRONG STANDARDS FOR THE POWER SECTOR, ONCE THE POWER PLANT RULE IS IN PLACE WE ARE PRESSING FOR REGULATION OF THE OTHER BIGGEST EMITTERS OF CARBON: REFINERIES, OIL AND GAS, CEMENT KILNS, AND AIRCRAFT. REDUCING RELIANCE ON COAL FOR ENERGY GENERATION AND THE HARM TO PEOPLE AND COMMUNITIES FROM BURNING COAL: EARTHJUSTICE IS LEADING THE LITIGATION TO OBTAIN STRONG NATIONAL STANDARDS TO LIMIT TOXIC AIR, WATER, AND WASTE POLLUTION FROM COAL-FIRED POWER PLANTS FORCING RETIREMENTS WHEN CLEAN-UPS DO NOT MAKE ECONOMIC SENSE. AS THE DOMESTIC COAL MARKET SHRINKS AND COAL COMPANIES TURN TO FOREIGN MARKETS, WE ARE ALSO WORKING TO PREVENT COAL EXPORTS TO ASIA FROM THE WEST COAST. THIS YEAR, WE MADE GREAT STRIDES ON ALL FRONTS. OBTAINING STRONG NATIONAL STANDARDS TO LIMIT AIR POLLUTION FROM COAL-FIRED POWER PLANTS: AFTER LITIGATING TO FORCE THE EPA TO MEET ITS OBLIGATIONS UNDER THE CLEAN AIR ACT, EARTHJUSTICE LAWSUITS ARE DRIVING FUNDAMENTAL CHANGE, REQUIRING THE INSTALLATION OF MODERN POLLUTION CONTROLS AT COAL-FIRED POWER PLANTS, NOTORIOUSLY DIRTY FACILITIES THAT HAVE LONG EVADED POLLUTION LIMITS. IN RESPONSE TO A SERIES OF LAWSUITS OVER 17 YEARS, EPA HAS AT LAST FINALIZED FIRST-EVER STANDARDS TO LIMIT THE EMISSION OF HAZARDOUS AIR POLLUTANTS SUCH AS MERCURY FROM POWER PLANTS. EPA ESTIMATES THAT THIS NEW RULE WILL SAVE UP TO 11,000 LIVES EACH YEAR, PREVENT THOUSANDS OF HEART ATTACKS, CASES OF ASTHMA AND OTHER RESPIRATORY ILLNESSES EVERY YEAR, AND ADDRESS THE GREATEST SOURCE OF MERCURY EMISSIONS IN THE COUNTRY, MEANING THAT WE WILL BE ADDRESSING THE ROOT CAUSE OF MERCURY CONTAMINATED FISH IN RIVERS AND LAKES ACROSS THE COUNTRY. NUMEROUS INDUSTRIES HAVE CHALLENGED THE RULE SO WE HAVE INTERVENED TO DEFEND IT. OUR LITIGATION HAS ALSO FORCED EPA TO ACCOUNT FOR SCIENTIFIC DATA ESTABLISHING THAT NATIONAL AIR STANDARDS HAVE NOT BEEN STRINGENT ENOUGH TO PROTECT PUBLIC HEALTH AND TO ISSUE NEW, PROTECTIVE AMBIENT AIR-QUALITY STANDARDS FOR SOOT, SULFUR DIOXIDE, AND NITROGEN DIOXIDE. THESE NEW STANDARDS ARE ALSO DRIVING COAL PLANT CLEAN-UPS AND RETIREMENTS. FURTHER, AS EPA STRENGTHENS THE NATIONAL AMBIENT AIR-QUALITY STANDARDS, THERE IS STILL WORK TO DO TO ATTAIN COMPLIANCE EVEN WITH THE CURRENT OZONE STANDARD AND WITH THE WEAKER STANDARDS FOR SOOT AND SULFUR DIOXIDE THAT WERE PREVIOUSLY IN PLACE. EPA HAS DEVELOPED TWO SUCCESSIVE EMISSIONS TRADING PROGRAMS FOR POWER PLANTS TO ENFORCE THE CLEAN AIR ACT'S SO-CALLED "GOOD NEIGHBOR" PROVISION, WHICH REQUIRE STATES TO CURB POLLUTION THAT IS PREVENTING ATTAINMENT OF AIR-QUALITY STANDARDS IN DOWNWIND STATES. EPA'S LATEST GOOD NEIGHBOR RULE HAS BEEN AN IMPORTANT DRIVER OF COAL PLANT CLEAN-UPS AND RETIREMENTS, BUT IT WAS SUCCESSFULLY CHALLENGED BY INDUSTRY IN THE D.C. CIRCUIT. WE ARE PART OF THE LEGAL TEAM REPRESENTING ENVIRONMENTAL GROUPS BEFORE THE SUPREME COURT SEEKING TO REINSTATE THE RULE. OUR LITIGATION IS ALSO FORCING THE STATES AND EPA TO IMPLEMENT THE CLEAN AIR ACT'S REGIONAL HAZE MANDATES TO RESTORE VISIBILITY AND HEALTHY AIR QUALITY IN OUR NATIONAL PARKS AND PUBLIC LANDS. CLEAN-UP PLANS ARE NOW REQUIRED IN 40 STATES AS A RESULT OF AN EARTHJUSTICE LAWSUIT. BECAUSE COAL PLANTS ARE THE LEADING CULPRIT IMPAIRING VISIBILITY IN MANY REGIONS, WE ARE ADVOCATING AND LITIGATING AS NECESSARY TO ENSURE THESE PLANS INCLUDE STRONG EMISSION LIMITS FOR COAL PLANTS, AND IN TURN, THESE LIMITS ARE COMPELLING THE CLEAN-UP AND RETIREMENT OF AGING, HIGHLY POLLUTING COAL UNITS. THIS PAST YEAR, WE WERE ACTIVELY ENGAGED IN SECURING STRONG HAZE PLANS IN ARIZONA, FLORIDA, MINNESOTA, MONTANA, NEBRASKA, NEVADA, NEW MEXICO, NEW YORK, NORTH DAKOTA, PENNSYLVANIA, TEXAS, UTAH, AND WYOMING. WE ALSO HAVE BROUGHT NATIONAL LITIGATION TO CHALLENGE EPA EFFORTS TO CREATE BROAD HAZE EXEMPTIONS FOR COAL PLANTS IN THE EASTERN HALF OF THE UNITED STATES. OBTAINING STRONG NATIONAL STANDARDS TO LIMIT WATER POLLUTION FROM COAL-FIRED POWER PLANTS: WE ARE SEEKING TO REDRESS WHOLESALE REGULATORY FAILURES WITH RESPECT TO WATER POLLUTION AND WASTE FROM COAL PLANTS. WHILE COAL PLANTS ARE THE SINGLE LARGEST DISCHARGERS OF TOXIC WATER POLLUTION NATIONWIDE, CONTRIBUTING 60 PERCENT OF THE TOXINS THAT ENTER U.S. WATERWAYS EVERY YEAR, THERE ARE NO NATIONAL LIMITS ON THE TOXIC POLLUTANTS IN COAL PLANT WASTEWATERS. SIMILARLY, COAL PLANTS GENERATE THE BIGGEST WASTE STREAM IN THE COUNTRY, SECOND ONLY TO HOUSEHOLD GARBAGE, BUT THERE ARE NO STANDARDS TO REQUIRE SAFE DISPOSAL OF THIS WASTE, WHICH IS LADEN WITH MERCURY, ARSENIC, AND OTHER TOXIC METALS PRESENT IN COAL. EARTHJUSTICE LAWSUITS AND ADVOCACY HAVE FORCED EPA TO UNDERTAKE A RULEMAKING TO LIMIT TOXIC WASTEWATER DISCHARGES FROM COAL PLANTS AND PRODUCED THE FIRST PROPOSED REGULATION OF COAL ASH DUMPS AND IMPOUNDMENTS, WHICH ARE LEACHING TOXIC METALS AND OTHER CONTAMINANTS INTO WATER SUPPLIES AROUND THE COUNTRY. IN RESPONSE TO THESE PROPOSALS, WE HAVE WORKED WITH EXPERTS TO PROVIDE EPA WITH COMPELLING EVIDENCE THAT THE STRONG NEW STANDARDS ARE WARRANTED. FORCING DIRTY COAL PLANTS TO CLEAN UP OR SHUT DOWN: EARTHJUSTICE WORKS CLOSELY WITH OUR CLIENTS IN A WIDE ARRAY OF PERMITTING AND ENFORCEMENT CASES AROUND THE COUNTRY TO FORCE INDIVIDUAL COAL PLANTS EITHER TO COMPLY WITH ENVIRONMENTAL STANDARDS OR SHUT DOWN, AND WE ARE ACTIVELY ENGAGED AT SEVERAL PUBLIC UTILITY COMMISSIONS TO PREVENT UNECONOMIC INVESTMENTS IN RETROFITTING OLD PLANTS. THESE EFFORTS WERE ONGOING THIS PAST YEAR IN KENTUCKY, OHIO, MICHIGAN, MISSOURI, INDIANA, PENNSYLVANIA, TEXAS, NEW MEXICO, TENNESSEE, AND FLORIDA. AMONG THE SIGNIFICANT GAINS MADE WAS A SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT BETWEEN CITIZEN GROUPS, STATES, EPA, AND AMERICAN ELECTRIC POWER (AEP) REQUIRING AEP TO STOP BURNING COAL BY 2015 AT THREE POWER PLANTS IN INDIANA, OHIO AND KENTUCKY-A RESULT THAT WILL REDUCE CLIMATE-DISRUPTING CARBON POLLUTION BY 12 MILLION TONS AND PREVENT MORE THAN 200 DEATHS, 300 HEART ATTACKS, AND 3,000 ASTHMA ATTACKS EACH YEAR. AEP ALSO AGREED TO REPLACE A PORTION OF THIS RETIRING COAL GENERATION WITH NEW WIND AND SOLAR INVESTMENTS IN INDIANA AND MICHIGAN, BRINGING MORE CLEAN ENERGY ON LINE TO MEET THE REGION'S ELECTRICITY NEEDS. WITH ANOTHER MAJOR VICTORY AT THE KENTUCKY PUBLIC UTILITY COMMISSION, WE MADE FURTHER PROGRESS IN SHRINKING AEP'S FLEET IN KENTUCKY WHEN WE DERAILED ITS EFFORT TO SADDLE RATEPAYERS WITH THE COSTS OF A $1 BILLION RETROFIT OF ITS BIG SANDY COAL PLANT. THE BIG SANDY PLANT IS NOW SLATED FOR RETIREMENT. IN TEXAS, IN ONGOING FEDERAL COURT LITIGATION OVER AIR PERMIT VIOLATIONS AT LUMINANT'S MARTIN LAKE POWER PLANT, THE SINGLE GREATEST SOURCE OF CARBON EMISSIONS IN THE COUNTRY AND ALSO ONE OF THE TOP TEN EMITTERS OF MERCURY EVERY YEAR, WE OBTAINED A DECISION FROM THE MAGISTRATE JUDGE RECOMMENDING THAT THE COURT REJECT LUMINANT'S BID TO DISMISS OUR LAWSUIT, AND WE ARE NOW PREPARING FOR TRIAL.CASE SUMMARIES
FORM 990, PART IIISTOPPING NEW CONSTRUCTION OF POWER PLANTS: THANKS IN PART TO OUR EFFORTS IN COLLABORATION WITH A NETWORK OF ALLIED ADVOCATES AROUND THE COUNTRY, THE RUSH TO BUILD NEW COAL PLANTS APPEARS TO BE OVER, BUT WE HAVE BEEN BATTLING THE LAST FEW LIVE PROPOSALS, MOST PROMINENTLY, THE PROPOSED SUNFLOWER PLANT IN KANSAS. THIS YEAR, WE HAVE HAD TWO MAJOR VICTORIES THAT ARE LIKELY TO BLOCK THE PLANT PERMANENTLY. IN MAY 2013, THE D.C. CIRCUIT DISMISSED SUNFLOWER'S APPEAL OF OUR VICTORY BLOCKING ANY FURTHER APPROVALS OF THE SUNFLOWER COAL PLANT UNTIL THE RURAL UTILITIES SERVICE PREPARES AN ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT ON THE PLANT, CREATING A SUBSTANTIAL OBSTACLE TO MOVING FORWARD WITH THIS PLANT. (AND IN OCTOBER 2013, WE WON OUR APPEAL OF THE SUNFLOWER AIR PERMIT BEFORE THE KANSAS SUPREME COURT.) MOUNTAINTOP REMOVAL MINING: MOUNTAINTOP REMOVAL MINING EPITOMIZES THE COAL INDUSTRY'S DETERMINATION TO PROFIT AT ANY COST TO THE ENVIRONMENT AND THE HEALTH OF COMMUNITIES IN APPALACHIA. BUILDING ON YEARS OF LITIGATION AND ADVOCACY, WE HAD A STUNNING VICTORY IN OUR CHALLENGE TO THE U.S. ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS' PERMIT FOR THE SPRUCE MINE, ONE OF THE LARGEST MOUNTAINTOP REMOVAL MINES EVER PROPOSED. IN JANUARY 2011, EPA VETOED THAT PERMIT, HIGHLIGHTING CONCERNS ABOUT DOWNSTREAM WATER QUALITY, HEALTH, AND ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE. IN A CHALLENGE TO THE VETO BY THE MINGO LOGAN COAL COMPANY, A DISTRICT COURT HELD THAT EPA HAD NO AUTHORITY TO VETO AN ALREADY ISSUED PERMIT, BUT IN APRIL 2013, THE D.C. CIRCUIT UNANIMOUSLY REVERSED. THIS VICTORY HELPS BUILD MOMENTUM FOR FURTHER ACTION FROM EPA AT A TIME WHEN IT FACES EXTREME PRESSURE FROM INDUSTRY TO ALLOW MOUNTAINTOP REMOVAL TO GO FORWARD WITHOUT NEEDED REGULATION. PROGRESS IN STOPPING COAL EXPORTS FROM THE WEST COAST: WE ARE THE LEGAL ARM OF A BROAD-BASED CAMPAIGN TO PREVENT NEW WEST COAST TERMINAL FACILITIES THAT WOULD ALLOW FOR A MAJOR RAMP-UP IN THE EXPORT OF COAL TO ASIA. OUR FIGHT BEGAN WHEN IT WAS REVEALED THAT THE WEST COAST COAL EXPORT FACILITY WOULD BE FIVE TIMES AS LARGE AS THE REPRESENTATIONS MADE TO THE REGULATORS. WITH ITS CREDIBILITY SEVERELY UNDERMINED, THE COMPANY WITHDREW THE PERMIT APPLICATION SHORTLY BEFORE THE TRIAL WAS SCHEDULED TO BEGIN, ALTHOUGH IT PLANS TO SEEK APPROVAL FOR THE WHOLE PROJECT IN THE FUTURE. SINCE THEN, THREE OF THE SIX PROPOSED WEST COAST COAL EXPORT FACILITIES HAVE BEEN ABANDONED, AND WE ARE LAYING THE GROUNDWORK FOR CHALLENGING FUTURE PROPOSALS. PROMOTING CLEAN ENERGY: EARTHJUSTICE IS COMMITTED TO PROMOTING ENERGY CONSERVATION AND CLEAN ENERGY BY: (1) PUSHING FOR NATIONAL STANDARDS THAT WILL FORCE INNOVATION TO MAKE OUR APPLIANCES AND EQUIPMENT MORE ENERGY EFFICIENT; AND (2) ADVOCATING FOR RULES AND DECISIONS AT STATE UTILITY COMMISSIONS AND THE FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION THAT INCENTIVIZE RELIANCE ON CLEAN ENERGY AND REMOVE THE BARRIERS TO A NATIONAL SCALE-UP OF CLEAN ENERGY RESOURCES THROUGH STATE UTILITY COMMISSIONS. FEDERAL ENERGY EFFICIENCY RULES: OUR ADVOCACY TO OBTAIN NATIONAL ENERGY EFFICIENCY STANDARDS CONTINUES TO PRODUCE RESULTS. THIS YEAR, THE DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY (DOE) ISSUED ONLY TWO FINAL RULES UPDATING ENERGY EFFICIENCY STANDARDS-FOR MICROWAVE OVENS AND ELECTRICITY DISTRIBUTION TRANSFORMERS, THE LATTER EXPEDITED BY A SCHEDULE NEGOTIATED TO SETTLE A 2007 EARTHJUSTICE LAWSUIT. DOE ALSO COMPLETED TEST-PROCEDURE UPDATES FOR, AMONG OTHER ITEMS, CLOTHES DRYERS, MICROWAVE OVENS, FURNACES AND BOILERS, AND WATER HEATERS. OVER THE SPRING AND SUMMER OF 2013, DOE CONVENED A NEGOTIATED RULEMAKING COMMITTEE TO PROPOSE REGULATIONS ESTABLISHING CERTIFICATION AND ENFORCEMENT REQUIREMENTS GOVERNING COMMERCIAL HEATING, AIR-CONDITIONING, WATER HEATING, AND REFRIGERATION EQUIPMENT. A REPRESENTATIVE FROM EARTHJUSTICE SERVED ON THIS COMMITTEE, WHICH REACHED CONSENSUS ON A SUITE OF REQUIREMENTS THAT WILL BE PROPOSED THROUGH A SERIES OF RULEMAKINGS OVER THE NEXT YEAR. IN JANUARY 2013, THE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION (FTC) FINALLY UPDATED ITS ENERGY LABELING RULE TO MAKE IT EASIER FOR ONLINE CONSUMERS TO COMPARE THE ENERGY CONSUMPTION OF NEW APPLIANCES. RETAILERS WILL DISPLAY THIS INFORMATION NEXT TO THE PRODUCT PHOTO AND PURCHASE PRICE, AND MANUFACTURERS WILL MAKE IT AVAILABLE ON THEIR OWN WEBSITES. WE HAD PETITIONED THE FTC TO MAKE THIS CHANGE SO THAT ONLINE CONSUMERS WOULD HAVE THE SAME ACCESS TO INFORMATION AS SHOPPERS AT BRICK-AND-MORTAR STORES. STATE PROMOTION OF EFFICIENCY AND CLEAN ENERGY RESOURCES: IN CALIFORNIA, EARTHJUSTICE AND ALLIES HAVE BEEN WORKING TO MAKE ENERGY STORAGE A KEY OPERATIONAL COMPONENT OF CALIFORNIA'S ENERGY SYSTEM. (IN OCTOBER 2013, THE CALIFORNIA PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION MADE A GROUND-BREAKING DECISION TO REQUIRE 1,325 MEGAWATTS OF STORAGE BY 2020 WITH INTERMEDIATE PROCUREMENT TARGETS BEGINNING IN 2014. CALIFORNIA IS THE FIRST STATE TO REQUIRE UTILITIES TO DEVELOP ENERGY STORAGE SYSTEMS, WHICH ARE ESSENTIAL TO LARGE-SCALE DEPLOYMENT OF INTERMITTENT RENEWABLE ENERGY RESOURCES.) IN HAWAI'I, WE HAVE BEEN WORKING ON BEHALF OF THE SOLAR INDUSTRY TO ELIMINATE BARRIERS TO SCALING UP DISTRIBUTED GENERATION OF SOLAR ENERGY, AND THE STATE HAS BECOME A NATIONAL TRENDSETTER IN MARKET PENETRATION OF ROOFTOP SOLAR. IN LATE JANUARY, HAWAIIAN ELECTRIC AGREED TO A PROACTIVE APPROACH TO PLANNING THAT WILL CONTINUE TO ACCOMMODATE MORE ROOFTOP SOLAR, THANKS IN PART TO OUR ADVOCACY ON BEHALF OF THE SOLAR INDUSTRY IN A STAKEHOLDER PROCESS ESTABLISHED BY THE HAWAI'I PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION. JUST THREE YEARS AGO, THE UTILITY HAD PROPOSED A MORATORIUM ON NEW SOLAR INSTALLATIONS. NOW THE UTILITY IS PROACTIVELY CONDUCTING STUDIES TO DETERMINE HOW TO ELIMINATE GRID CONSTRAINTS TO CONTINUED GROWTH OF THE SOLAR SECTOR. IN JUNE 2013, THE WASHINGTON UTILITIES AND TRANSPORTATION COMMISSION APPROVED A DECOUPLING PLAN THAT WE DEVELOPED WITH PUGET SOUND ENERGY TO ENCOURAGE MAXIMUM INVESTMENT IN ENERGY EFFICIENCY. THE PLAN WILL DECOUPLE THE PROFITS THE UTILITY RECEIVES FROM THE AMOUNT OF ENERGY SOLD, REMOVING A STRUCTURAL DISINCENTIVE FOR THE UTILITY TO ESTABLISH EFFECTIVE ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CONSERVATION PROGRAMS. FINALLY, IN THE MIDWEST, WE HAVE LEVERAGED SETTLEMENTS REGARDING THE RETIREMENT OF COAL-FIRED UNITS TO OBTAIN ENFORCEABLE COMMITMENTS TO RAMP UP CLEAN ENERGY. OUR FEBRUARY 2013 SETTLEMENT WITH AEP, WHICH IS DISCUSSED ABOVE, REQUIRES AEP TO DEVELOP 200 MEGAWATTS OF WIND OR SOLAR ENERGY BY 2015. PROTECTING PEOPLE, COMMUNITIES, AND WILDLANDS FROM THE IMPACTS OF NATURAL GAS DEVELOPMENT: THIS YEAR, EARTHJUSTICE ADVANCED PROTECTION OF NATIONAL PARKS, WILDLIFE HABITAT, ROADLESS AREAS, AND OTHER PUBLIC LANDS FROM RAMPANT OIL AND GAS DEVELOPMENT AND CONTINUED TO MAKE PROGRESS TO REIN IN THE ENVIRONMENTAL THREATS POSED BY GAS FRACKING WITH LITIGATION AND ADVOCACY: TO LIMIT AIR AND WATER POLLUTION; TO PROMOTE THE PUBLIC'S RIGHT TO KNOW ABOUT THE CHEMICALS IN FRACKING FLUIDS; AND TO DEFEND THE LOCAL AUTHORITY OF COMMUNITIES TO ENACT EFFECTIVE ZONING RESTRICTIONS TO PREVENT FRACKING WITHIN THEIR TOWN LIMITS. RESCISSION OF BUSH ADMINISTRATION OIL AND GAS LEASES NEAR NATIONAL PARKS AND WILDLANDS: IN SEPTEMBER 2012, THE 10TH CIRCUIT REJECTED AN INDUSTRY CHALLENGE TO SECRETARY OF THE INTERIOR SALAZAR'S RESCISSION OF OIL AND GAS LEASES IN UTAH AND WYOMING NEAR NATIONAL TREASURES SUCH AS ARCHES AND CANYONLANDS NATIONAL PARKS AND DESOLATION CANYON. UNJUSTIFIABLY, THE BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT HAD AUCTIONED THE LEASES BEFORE RESOLVING ENVIRONMENTAL CHALLENGES. THE FULL 10TH CIRCUIT DENIED REHEARING AND THE SUPREME COURT REJECTED INDUSTRY'S REQUEST TO HEAR THE CASE ON OCTOBER 7, 2013. OIL SHALE DEVELOPMENT: AS A RESULT OF DUAL LAWSUITS CHALLENGING BUSH-ERA DECISIONS, THE DEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR HAS HALVED THE ACREAGE OPEN TO OIL SHALE DEVELOPMENT ON WESTERN PUBLIC LANDS AND HAS PROPOSED RULES THAT RAISE ROYALTY RATES. THE PROPOSED RULES WOULD ALSO REQUIRE OIL SHALE AND TAR SANDS DEVELOPERS TO DEMONSTRATE THROUGH RESEARCH PROJECTS THAT THEIR TECHNOLOGIES CAN WORK TO PRODUCE OIL IN AN ENVIRONMENTALLY SOUND MANNER BEFORE BEING ALLOWED TO PROCEED WITH COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT. ROAN PLATEAU: LAST YEAR, WE PREVAILED IN OUR LONGSTANDING LAWSUIT CHALLENGING THE BUSH ADMINISTRATION'S MASSIVE OIL AND GAS LEASING OF COLORADO'S ROAN PLATEAU. THE COURT SENT THE LEASING PLAN BACK TO THE BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT, DIRECTING THE AGENCY TO CONSIDER RESTRICTING DESTRUCTIVE DRILLING ON THE TOP OF THE PLATEAU-THE MOST ENVIRONMENTALLY SENSITIVE HABITAT-AND TO ADDRESS THE CUMULATIVE AIR POLLUTION FROM ALL THE DRILLING IN THE AREA. ALTHOUGH ONE OF THE COMPANIES HAS APPEALED, THE BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT IS COMPLYING WITH THE DECISION AND HAS INITIATED A SUPPLEMENTAL ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW. WE ARE URGING THAT THE BUREAU CANCEL THE LEASES AND FORBID ALL DRILLING WHILE IT RE-EVALUATES ITS APPROACH TO ENERGY DEVELOPMENT IN THE REGION.CASE SUMMARIES CONTINUED
FORM 990, PART IIITHOMPSON DIVIDE: IN THE SPRING, THE BUREAU EXTENDED THE LIFE OF 25 OIL AND GAS LEASES ON COLORADO'S THOMPSON DIVIDE, A BIOLOGICALLY RICH AREA ON THE WHITE RIVER AND GRAND MESA UNCOMPAHGRE NATIONAL FORESTS. ON THE PLUS SIDE, THE BUREAU COMMITTED TO CONDUCT FURTHER ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW AND CANCEL OR MODIFY THE LEASES BASED ON THE REVIEW. IN MAY 2013, WE APPEALED THE LEASE EXTENSIONS, ARGUING THAT THE LEASES SHOULD HAVE EXPIRED SINCE THEY HAVE SAT UNUSED FOR TEN YEARS. DRILLING THESE OLD, UNUSED LEASES WOULD HARM ROADLESS AREAS AND A PRIZED WILDLIFE REFUGE. REINING IN AIR POLLUTION FROM OIL AND GAS DEVELOPMENT: IN APRIL 2012, OUR LITIGATION PRODUCED NEW NATIONAL AIR POLLUTION STANDARDS FOR OIL AND GAS PRODUCTION AFTER YEARS OF DELAY. EPA'S RULE IS THE FIRST STANDARD TO CURB AIR POLLUTION FROM FRACKING AND WILL LEAD TO EFFICIENCIES THAT REDUCE CLIMATE POLLUTION. WE ARE DEFENDING THE RULE AGAINST INDUSTRY CHALLENGES IN ADDITION TO REQUIRING THE EPA TO FILL THE KEY GAPS IT LEFT, INCLUDING THE AGENCY'S FAILURE TO LIMIT RELEASES OF METHANE, A POTENT CLIMATE POLLUTANT. A VICTORY FOR LOCAL AUTHORITY TO REGULATE FRACKING: IN MAY 2013, A NEW YORK APPEALS COURT UPHELD THE RIGHT OF THE TOWNS OF DRYDEN AND MIDDLEFIELD TO BAN FRACKING AND OTHER OIL AND GAS ACTIVITIES WITHIN TOWN LIMITS, ALTHOUGH THIS RULING HAS BEEN APPEALED TO NEW YORK'S HIGHEST COURT, WHERE WE WILL AGAIN REPRESENT THE TOWN OF DRYDEN. MORE THAN 150 MUNICIPALITIES IN NEW YORK HAVE ADOPTED BANS OR MORATORIA ON FRACKING, SO THIS PRECEDENT WILL HAVE WIDE-RANGING IMPACT ACROSS NEW YORK IF IT IS UPHELD ON APPEAL. UNSEALING FRACKING LITIGATION RECORDS: A PENNSYLVANIA COURT UNSEALED THE COURT RECORDS FROM A FAMILY'S LAWSUIT AGAINST GAS COMPANIES FOR HARM CAUSED BY FRACKING NEAR THEIR DREAM HOME, REJECTING THE COMPANIES' CLAIM THAT UNSEALING THE RECORDS WOULD INFRINGE THEIR RIGHT TO PRIVACY. WE REPRESENTED HEALTH PROFESSIONALS WHO SOUGHT THE RECORDS ALONGSIDE TWO NEWSPAPERS. THE COURT RECORDS ARE NOW AVAILABLE ON THE INTERNET. PRESERVING OUR NATURAL HERITAGE: PROTECTING BIODIVERSITY AND A SUSTAINABLE PLANET FOR FUTURE GENERATIONS IN AN ERA OF CLIMATE CHANGE PRESERVING ROADLESS AREAS IN OUR NATIONAL FORESTS FOR FUTURE GENERATIONS: EARTHJUSTICE HAD A VICTORY WHEN THE 10TH CIRCUIT UNANIMOUSLY UPHELD NATIONWIDE PROTECTION FOR NEARLY 50 MILLION ACRES OF ROADLESS AREAS IN OUR NATIONAL FORESTS, AND THE SUPREME COURT REFUSED TO DISTURB THAT RULING IN OCTOBER 2012. EARTHJUSTICE HAS BEEN THE LAW FIRM DEFENDING ROADLESS AREA PROTECTION FOR MORE THAN A DOZEN YEARS. WE CONTINUE TO FACE ONE REMAINING CHALLENGE BY THE STATE OF ALASKA, WHICH RESURRECTED ITS LAWSUIT WHEN WE SUCCEEDED IN STRIKING DOWN THE BUSH ADMINISTRATION'S "TEMPORARY" EXEMPTION OF THE TONGASS NATIONAL FOREST IN MARCH 2011, A DECISION THAT IS UP ON APPEAL. IN MARCH 2013, A DISTRICT JUDGE IN WASHINGTON D.C. THREW OUT ALASKA'S LAWSUIT FOR BEING TOO LATE, BUT ALASKA AND VARIOUS INDUSTRIES HAVE APPEALED THAT RULING. DUAL VICTORIES FOR WILD BISON IN THE GREATER YELLOWSTONE ECOSYSTEM: IN JUNE 2013, WE, ALONG WITH THE ASSINIBOINE AND SIOUX TRIBES, DEFENDED THE RELOCATION OF WILD BISON LEAVING YELLOWSTONE NATIONAL PARK TO THE FORT PECK AND BELKNAP RESERVATIONS. THE TRIAL COURT HAD BLOCKED FURTHER RELOCATIONS, BUT THE MONTANA SUPREME COURT HELD THAT NONE OF THE STATUTORY REQUIREMENTS CITED BY THE CHALLENGERS APPLIED AND REVERSED THE INJUNCTION. IN JANUARY 2013, A MONTANA JUDGE REJECTED ATTEMPTS TO STOP WILD BISON FROM ROAMING OUTSIDE THE NORTHERN BOUNDARY OF YELLOWSTONE NATIONAL PARK. THE RULING REBUFFS DEMANDS BY SOME LIVESTOCK PRODUCERS AND THEIR ALLIES TO REQUIRE AGGRESSIVE HAZING AND SLAUGHTERING OF BISON THAT ENTER THE GARDINER BASIN AREA FROM YELLOWSTONE NATIONAL PARK IN THE WINTER AND EARLY SPRING IN SEARCH OF THE FORAGE THEY NEED TO SURVIVE. THE MONTANA FARM BUREAU AND PARK COUNTY STOCKGROWERS ASSOCIATION HAVE APPEALED. WOLVERINES: THREE LEGAL ACTIONS SPANNING MORE THAN A DECADE FINALLY PRODUCED A FEDERAL PROPOSAL TO LIST THE WOLVERINE IN THE LOWER 48 STATES AS A THREATENED SPECIES UNDER THE ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT. BIOLOGISTS ESTIMATE THERE ARE FEWER THAN 300 WOLVERINES IN THE CONTIGUOUS UNITED STATES, PRIMARILY IN MONTANA, IDAHO, WYOMING, AND NORTH-CENTRAL WASHINGTON. DUE TO CLIMATE CHANGE AND INCREASING HUMAN ENCROACHMENT, WOLVERINES ARE LIKELY BECOMING INCREASINGLY ISOLATED IN THEIR MOUNTAIN STRONGHOLDS. PROTECTING WOLVERINES FROM OTHER HAZARDS SUCH AS TRAPPING WILL BE CRITICAL TO ENABLE THEM TO PERSIST IN THEIR SCATTERED HABITATS AND MOVE SAFELY ACROSS THE LANDSCAPE. NORTHWEST OLD-GROWTH FORESTS: EARTHJUSTICE SPENT A DECADE IN THE 1980S-1990S SUCCESSFULLY LITIGATING TO STOP THE LIQUIDATION OF OLD-GROWTH FORESTS IN THE PACIFIC NORTHWEST AND OBTAIN PROTECTIONS FOR THE FORESTS AS AN ECOSYSTEM. WE SUBSEQUENTLY DEFENDED THOSE PROTECTIONS AGAINST A CONCERTED EFFORT BY THE BUSH ADMINISTRATION TO DISMANTLE THEM. THE TIMBER INDUSTRY CONTINUES TO PURSUE LITIGATION SEEKING TO STRIP AWAY NORTHWEST OLD-GROWTH FOREST PROTECTIONS. IN APRIL 2013, A D.C. DISTRICT COURT RULED AGAINST THE INDUSTRY IN ITS ATTEMPTS TO ELIMINATE ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT PROTECTIONS FOR THE MARBLED MURRELET, A SMALL SEABIRD THAT NESTS IN THE BRANCHES OF COASTAL OLD-GROWTH TREES. THE FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE HAD AGREED TO ELIMINATE ALL CRITICAL HABITAT PROTECTIONS FOR THE MURRELET (3.7 MILLION ACRES IN ALL) FOR AT LEAST THE NEXT SIX YEARS, BUT THE DISTRICT COURT REFUSED TO APPROVE THIS LONG GAP IN PROTECTION. AS PART OF ITS ATTACK ON ECOSYSTEM PROTECTIONS FOR OLD-GROWTH FORESTS IN THE PACIFIC NORTHWEST, THE TIMBER INDUSTRY HAS LONG ARGUED THAT THE BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT IS REQUIRED TO MEET THE TIMBER PRODUCTION TARGETS IN ITS MANAGEMENT PLANS. NO COURT HAD ACCEPTED THIS ARGUMENT UNTIL JUNE 2013, WHEN A D.C. DISTRICT JUDGE CONSTRUED THESE TARGETS TO BE MANDATORY. WE ARE APPEALING THIS RULING. SIERRA NEVADA: AS PART OF OUR STRATEGY TO OBTAIN STRONG ECOSYSTEM PROTECTIONS IN THE SIERRA NEVADA, WE BROUGHT A SERIES OF LAWSUITS YEARS AGO TO COMPEL THE U.S. FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE TO AFFORD VARIOUS SIERRA SPECIES PROTECTION UNDER THE ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT. IN APRIL THE SERVICE PROPOSED TO LIST BOTH THE MOUNTAIN YELLOW-LEGGED FROG AND THE YOSEMITE TOAD, AND IN MARCH 2013, A CALIFORNIA SUPERIOR COURT DIRECTED THAT THE PACIFIC FISHER BE PROTECTED AS A CANDIDATE SPECIES UNDER THE CALIFORNIA ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT, WHILE THE STATE OBTAINS AN INDEPENDENT PEER REVIEW AND DETERMINES WHETHER THE FISHER WARRANTS PERMANENT PROTECTION. OVER THE YEARS, WE WERE SUCCESSFUL IN CHALLENGING THE BUSH ADMINISTRATION'S REVISIONS OF THE SIERRA NEVADA FRAMEWORK TO INCREASE OLD-GROWTH LOGGING FIVEFOLD. IN PARTICULAR, THE 9TH CIRCUIT CHASTISED THE FOREST SERVICE FOR LOGGING LARGE TREES TO PAY FOR FUEL REDUCTION PROJECTS WITHOUT CONSIDERING ALTERNATIVE SOURCES OF FUNDING. IN APRIL 2013, A DISTRICT COURT ORDERED THE FOREST SERVICE TO CONSIDER SUCH ALTERNATIVES, BUT REFUSED TO VACATE THE FRAMEWORK REVISION OR ENJOIN LOGGING OF OLD-GROWTH TREES IN THE INTERIM. IN JANUARY 2013, A DISTRICT COURT RULED IN OUR FAVOR AND SENT THE TRAVEL MANAGEMENT PLAN FOR THE STANISLAUS NATIONAL FOREST IN THE SIERRA NEVADA BACK TO THE FOREST SERVICE. SPECIFICALLY, THE FOREST SERVICE MUST ENSURE THAT OFF-ROAD VEHICLES WOULD MINIMIZE DAMAGE TO THE ENVIRONMENT AS REQUIRED BY GOVERNING REGULATIONS. PRESERVING NATIONAL GEMS: OVER THE COURSE OF THE YEAR, WE HAD SEVERAL VICTORIES THAT PRESERVED NATIONAL GEMS: YOSEMITE NATIONAL PARK: THE 9TH CIRCUIT PUT AN END TO A DEVELOPER'S QUEST TO BUILD A NEW ROAD INTO YOSEMITE NATIONAL PARK FROM A PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT. LAKE TAHOE: IN JANUARY 2013, A FEDERAL JUDGE BLOCKED CONSTRUCTION OF A PROPOSED EXPANSION OF A LAKE TAHOE SKI RESORT UNTIL THE COUNTY AND THE TAHOE REGIONAL PLANNING AGENCY CONSIDER THE FEASIBILITY OF A SMALLER EXPANSION. DEFENDING A MORATORIUM ON URANIUM MINING AROUND THE GRAND CANYON: IN MARCH 2013, A DISTRICT COURT REJECTED A KEY PART OF THE INDUSTRY CHALLENGE TO THE 20-YEAR WITHDRAWAL FROM MINING OF MORE THAN ONE MILLION ACRES OF FEDERAL LAND AROUND THE GRAND CANYON. THE COURT UPHELD THE SECRETARY OF INTERIOR'S AUTHORITY TO WITHDRAW LANDS FROM MINING. WE EXPECT AN APPEAL. RESTORING THE EVERGLADES: WE CONTINUE TO FORCE PROGRESS TO RESTORE THE EVERGLADES UNDER THE HISTORIC 1992 CONSENT DECREE BETWEEN FLORIDA, THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT, AND CONSERVATIONISTS REPRESENTED BY EARTHJUSTICE. THE LATEST ROUND OF NEGOTIATIONS BETWEEN THE STATE AND FEDERAL GOVERNMENTS HAS PUT THE ACQUISITION OF THOUSANDS OF ACRES OF TREATMENT MARSHES ON THE TABLE, BUT WE ARE PRESSING TO MAKE THE POLLUTION GOALS OF THE SETTLEMENT CONCRETE AND ENFORCEABLE.CASE SUMMARIES CONTINUED
FORM 990, PART IIIPROTECTING AMERICA'S ARCTIC FROM OIL DRILLING: MUCH OF THE RECENT ACTION IN THE ARCTIC HAS TAKEN PLACE OUTSIDE THE COURTROOM. -FIRST, IN FEBRUARY 2013, SHELL ANNOUNCED THAT IT WOULD NOT SEEK TO DRILL IN THE ARCTIC IN 2013, AFTER AN EMBARRASSING STRING OF ACCIDENTS AND VIOLATIONS OF ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS. CONOCOPHILLIPS FOLLOWED SUIT IN APRIL 2013 AFTER LEARNING THAT ITS OIL SPILL RESPONSE PLAN WOULD NOT SAIL THROUGH THE INTERIOR DEPARTMENT'S APPROVAL PROCESS AFTER OUR ADVOCACY RAISED THE BAR FOR SUCH APPROVALS. -SECOND, IN FEBRUARY 2013, THE DEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR ADOPTED A NEW PLAN FOR THE NATIONAL PETROLEUM RESERVE-ALASKA ON ALASKA'S NORTH SLOPE. THE PLAN PROTECTS SEVERAL SPECIAL AREAS, INCLUDING TESHEKPUK LAKE AND THE COLVILLE RIVER, WHICH WE LITIGATED FOR YEARS TO PROTECT BECAUSE OF THEIR CRITICAL IMPORTANCE TO FISH, WILDLIFE, RECREATION, AND ALASKA NATIVE SUBSISTENCE. -THIRD, THE ARCTIC COUNCIL MINISTERS SIGNED A REGIONAL AGREEMENT ON OIL SPILL PREPAREDNESS AND RESPONSE IN MAY OF 2013. PROMOTING SUSTAINABLE FISHERIES BY REDUCING OVERFISHING AND BYCATCH AND PROTECTING FORAGE FISH AND OCEAN ECOSYSTEMS: WE CONTINUE TO PROMOTE PROTECTIONS OF FORAGE FISH, LIKE HERRING, WHICH ARE FOOD FOR LARGE FISH LIKE STRIPED BASS, BLUEFIN TUNA, AND SHARKS, AS WELL AS MARINE MAMMALS AND SEABIRDS. PROTECTIONS FOR RIVER HERRING: IN MARCH 2012, A DISTRICT COURT HELD THAT FEDERAL REGULATORS ERRED WHEN THEY DROPPED RIVER HERRING (WHICH SPAWN IN RIVERS BUT SPEND MOST OF THEIR LIVES AT SEA) FROM THE FISHERY PLAN COVERING ATLANTIC HERRING (WHICH SPEND THEIR ENTIRE LIVES IN THE OCEAN). THE COURT RULED THAT THE LAW REQUIRES THAT FISHERY PLANS COVER ALL STOCKS IN A FISHERY THAT ARE IN NEED OF CONSERVATION AND MANAGEMENT. IN AUGUST 2012, THE JUDGE SENT THE PLAN BACK TO BE REVISED TO ADDRESS RIVER HERRING AND IMPROVE BYCATCH MEASURES. OUR LITIGATION SPURRED THE NATIONAL MARINE FISHERIES SERVICE (NMFS) TO ELIMINATE A LOOPHOLE THAT WOULD HAVE ALLOWED INDUSTRIAL FISHING VESSELS, WHEN FISHING IN GROUNDFISH-CLOSED AREAS, TO DISCARD BYCATCH WITHOUT FIRST BRINGING THE BYCATCH ON BOARD FOR DOCUMENTATION BY FEDERAL OBSERVERS. IN JULY 2012, THE NEW ENGLAND COUNCIL EXTENDED THESE SAFEGUARDS TO ALL GROUNDFISH-CLOSED AREAS AND REQUIRED 100% OBSERVER COVERAGE AND TIGHTER DISCARDING LIMITS THROUGHOUT THE ENTIRE FISHERY. NMFS HAS PROPOSED A RULE TO INCORPORATE THESE SAFEGUARDS. THE 1ST CIRCUIT UPHELD SECTOR MANAGEMENT OF THE GROUNDFISH FISHERY IN NEW ENGLAND IN NOVEMBER 2012. UNDER SECTOR MANAGEMENT, FISHERMEN POOL THEIR CATCH AND MEET SCIENTIFICALLY BASED CATCH LIMITS, WHICH HAVE RESULTED IN REBOUNDING FISH POPULATIONS. IN APRIL 2013, MAINE ADOPTED A NEW LAW THAT WILL REQUIRE REMOVAL OF A BLOCKADE ACROSS A U.S.-CANADIAN BORDER RIVER TO PREVENT ALEWIVES (RIVER HERRING) FROM RETURNING TO THEIR HISTORIC SPAWNING HABITAT. THE BLOCKADE HAD BEEN ERECTED AT THE BEHEST OF SPORT FISHING GUIDES WHO VIEWED RIVER HERRING AS COMPETITORS FOR SMALLMOUTH BASS. IN JULY 2012, IN RESPONSE TO OUR LAWSUIT, THE EPA FOUND NO "SOUND SCIENTIFIC RATIONALE FOR EXCLUDING INDIGENOUS RIVER HERRING" FROM THE ST. CROIX RIVER AND DIRECTED MAINE TO RESTORE FULL RIVER PASSAGE. PROTECTIONS FOR CARIBBEAN PARROTFISH: IN MARCH 2013, THE NMFS PROPOSED TO LIMIT THE SIZE OF PARROTFISH CAUGHT IN FEDERAL WATERS IN THE CARIBBEAN IN AN EFFORT TO PREVENT PARROTFISH POPULATIONS FROM FALLING BELOW SUSTAINABLE LEVELS. THIS PROPOSAL WOULD HELP PROTECT CORAL REEFS SINCE PARROTFISH EAT ALGAE THAT SMOTHERS THE REEFS, BUT WE ARE IN COURT SEEKING TO REDUCE PARROTFISH CATCH FURTHER TO PROTECT THE REEFS. LANDMARK AGREEMENT TO PROTECT WHALES AND DOLPHINS FROM AIRGUN SURVEYS: DURING THE MIDST OF THE DEEPWATER HORIZON DISASTER, WE JOINED COLLEAGUES IN CHALLENGING HIGH-INTENSITY AIRGUN SURVEYS USED BY THE OIL AND GAS INDUSTRY IN THE GULF OF MEXICO. THE SEISMIC BLASTS PRODUCE NOISE ALMOST AS INTENSE AS DYNAMITE AND OCCUR AS OFTEN AS EVERY 10-12 SECONDS, BOMBARDING MARINE MAMMALS, WHICH DEPEND ON SOUND TO FEED, MATE, AND NAVIGATE. THE SETTLEMENT WILL PUT PROTECTIONS IN PLACE WHILE THE DEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR UNDERTAKES A PROGRAMMATIC ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW. THE SAFEGUARDS INCLUDE A PROHIBITION ON AIRGUN BLASTING IN BIOLOGICALLY IMPORTANT AREAS, MANDATORY SEPARATION DISTANCES BETWEEN BLASTS, USE OF LISTENING DEVICES TO LOCATE AND AVOID MARINE MAMMALS, AND RESEARCH INTO LESS HARMFUL ALTERNATIVES. PROTECTING FALSE KILLER WHALES FROM LONGLINES: IT TOOK THREE LAWSUITS TO PRODUCE THE BINDING PLAN TO REDUCE THE TAKE OF FALSE KILLER WHALES THAT WENT INTO EFFECT AT THE END OF FEBRUARY 2013. THE PLAN REQUIRES LONGLINES TO USE "WEAK HOOKS" THAT ARE STRONG ENOUGH TO HOLD AN AHI TUNA, THE FISHERY'S TARGET SPECIES, BUT WEAK ENOUGH TO ALLOW LARGER AND STRONGER FALSE KILLER WHALES TO PULL OUT THE HOOKS AND AVOID SERIOUS INJURY. PROTECTIONS FOR POINT REYES MARINE WILDERNESS: IN LATE NOVEMBER 2012, SECRETARY SALAZAR ALLOWED THE LEASE FOR A COMMERCIAL OYSTER FARM WITHIN THE POINT REYES NATIONAL SEASHORE TO EXPIRE ACCORDING TO ITS TERMS, AS CONGRESS HAD INTENDED WHEN IT DESIGNATED THE DRAKES ESTERO MARINE WILDERNESS. IN FEBRUARY 2013, A DISTRICT COURT REJECTED THE OYSTER COMPANY'S CHALLENGE, BUT THE 9TH CIRCUIT STAYED THAT DECISION PENDING APPEAL. WE PARTICIPATED AS FRIENDS OF THE COURT SUPPORTING THE SECRETARY'S DECISION. (NOTE THAT THE 9TH CIRCUIT AFFIRMED THE DISTRICT COURT DECISION IN THE FALL OF 2013.) SAFEGUARDING PUBLIC HEALTH: PROTECTING PEOPLE, PARTICULARLY THE MOST EXPOSED AND VULNERABLE, FROM ENVIRONMENTAL HAZARDS TO HEALTH REDUCING AIR POLLUTION THAT HARMS PUBLIC HEALTH: THE CLEAN AIR ACT MANDATES IMPROVEMENT IN AIR QUALITY TO INCORPORATE TECHNOLOGICAL ADVANCES IN POLLUTION CONTROL AND TO ENSURE PROTECTION OF EVERYONE, INCLUDING OUR MOST VULNERABLE POPULATIONS SUCH AS CHILDREN. HOWEVER, WITHOUT CITIZEN OVERSIGHT AND LAWSUITS, THOSE MANDATES WOULD BE NOTHING MORE THAN A PAPER TIGER. FOR FOUR DECADES, EARTHJUSTICE HAS BEEN THE ORGANIZATION THAT HAS FORCED EPA TO MEET ITS OBLIGATIONS TO REDUCE SMOG, SOOT, AND ACID RAIN POLLUTION AND TO PROTECT PEOPLE FROM HAZARDOUS AIR POLLUTION, OFTEN BY FORCING INDUSTRIES TO MAKE OVERDUE INVESTMENTS IN EFFECTIVE POLLUTION CONTROLS. EARTHJUSTICE'S AIR POLLUTION DOCKET SAVES LIVES AND SPARES PEOPLE CANCER, HEART AND LUNG DISEASE, AND ASTHMA ATTACKS, AMONG OTHER SERIOUS HEALTH PROBLEMS. IN ADDITION TO OBTAINING STRONG NATIONAL AIR POLLUTION STANDARDS, AS DESCRIBED BELOW, WE ARE CONTINUING TO WORK, AS WE HAVE FOR MORE THAN A DECADE, TO CLEAN UP THE AIR IN CALIFORNIA'S CENTRAL VALLEY, WHERE THE AIR IS SO POLLUTED OFFICIALS TELL CHILDREN TO STAY INSIDE ON DIRTY AIR DAYS. REDUCING HARMFUL AIR POLLUTION FROM SOOT: IN DECEMBER 2012, EARTHJUSTICE LITIGATION RESULTED IN NEW REGULATIONS THAT WILL SAVE LIVES AND SPARE THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE HEART AND LUNG DISEASE FROM SOOT POLLUTION. OUR LAWSUIT LED THE D.C. CIRCUIT TO CHASTISE THE BUSH ADMINISTRATION FOR ADOPTING POLLUTION LIMITS FOR AIRBORNE SOOT THAT WERE WEAKER THAN THE RECOMMENDATIONS OF EPA'S SCIENTIFIC ADVISORY PANEL. ANOTHER LAWSUIT FORCED EPA TO ADOPT THE REPLACEMENT STANDARDS AT YEAR'S END. POLLUTING INDUSTRIES HAVE CHALLENGED THE NEW REGULATIONS IN COURT, AND WE HAVE INTERVENED TO DEFEND THEM AT EPA'S SIDE. MEANWHILE, IN JANUARY 2013, THE D.C. CIRCUIT STRUCK DOWN WEAK AIR POLLUTION IMPLEMENTATION STANDARDS, HOLDING THAT THE MOST STRINGENT CLEAN-UP REQUIREMENTS MUST BE USED IN COMMUNITIES WITH THE WORST SOOT POLLUTION. OUR LITIGATION PRODUCED UPGRADED STANDARDS FOR ACID RAIN POLLUTION, AND IN A PAIR OF DECISIONS ISSUED IN JULY 2012, THE D.C. CIRCUIT REJECTED INDUSTRY CHALLENGES TO THE UPGRADED STANDARDS FOR SULFUR DIOXIDE AND NITROGEN OXIDES. THE SUPREME COURT REFUSED TO HEAR THE INDUSTRY CHALLENGES. WE ARE ALSO THE NATIONAL LEADERS IN HOLDING EPA TO THE CLEAN AIR ACT'S MANDATES TO PROTECT PEOPLE FROM HAZARDOUS AIR POLLUTANTS SUCH AS MERCURY, LEAD, AND BENZENE FROM POLLUTING INDUSTRIES. AFTER EPA FAILED TO ADOPT STANDARDS TO LIMIT EMISSIONS OF THESE EXTRAORDINARILY DANGEROUS AND OFTEN CARCINOGENIC POLLUTANTS, OUR LITIGATION COMPELLED EPA TO ADOPT STRONG STANDARDS RESTRICTING TOXIC AIR POLLUTION NOT ONLY FROM COAL-FIRED POWER PLANTS, BUT ALSO FROM LEAD SMELTERS, PAPER AND PULP MILLS, POLYVINYL CHLORIDE (PVC) PLANTS, AND MARINE VESSELS. THESE STANDARDS WILL SAVE THOUSANDS OF LIVES AND PREVENT THOUSANDS OF SERIOUS ILLNESSES EVERY YEAR.CASE SUMMARIES CONTINUED
FORM 990, PART IIIPROTECTING PEOPLE FROM TOXIC CHEMICALS AND PESTICIDES: EXPANDING THE PUBLIC'S RIGHT TO KNOW: OUR ADVOCACY IS EXPANDING THE PUBLIC'S RIGHT TO KNOW ABOUT CHEMICALS AND THE IMPACTS OF EXPOSURE TO THEM. EPA IS CRACKING DOWN ON OVERZEALOUS INDUSTRY CLAIMS TO TRADE SECRETS THAT HAVE BLOCKED PUBLIC ACCESS TO HEALTH STUDIES SHOWING ADVERSE EFFECTS FROM CHEMICALS THAT ARE CURRENTLY IN COMMERCIAL USE. ONE OF OUR LAWSUITS REVEALED INGREDIENTS IN THE DISPERSANTS AUTHORIZED FOR USE IN RESPONDING TO OIL SPILLS, AS WELL AS 80 HEALTH AND SAFETY STUDIES RELATED TO THE DISPERSANTS. IN RESPONSE TO OUR ADVOCACY, EPA HAS COMMITTED TO ADOPTING RULES THAT WILL REQUIRE DISCLOSURE OF FRACKING CHEMICALS AND TOXICITY TESTING FOR DISPERSANT CHEMICALS, AND NEW YORK HAS AGREED TO REQUIRE DISCLOSURE OF INGREDIENTS IN HOUSEHOLD CLEANERS. IN MAY 2013, A DISTRICT COURT REJECTED AN INDUSTRY CHALLENGE TO THE LISTING OF STYRENE, A PETROLEUM AND NATURAL GAS BYPRODUCT USED IN CONSUMER GOODS, AS REASONABLY ANTICIPATED TO BE A HUMAN CARCINOGEN. THE INDUSTRY CHALLENGE IS PART OF INDUSTRY RESISTANCE TO CLASSIFICATION AND DISSEMINATION OF THE HAZARDS OF DANGEROUS CHEMICALS TO THE PUBLIC. PROTECTING FARMWORKERS AND THEIR FAMILIES FROM PESTICIDE POISONINGS: LITIGATION THAT WE BEGAN IN 2004 BORE FRUIT THIS YEAR-LITERALLY APPLES, PEARS, AND OTHER FRUIT PRODUCED WITHOUT AZINPHOS-METHYL (AZM), AN EXTREMELY TOXIC PESTICIDE THAT HAS POISONED WORKERS AND THEIR FAMILIES EVER SINCE IT WAS ADAPTED FOR USE IN THE FIELDS AFTER WORLD WAR II (IT HAD ORIGINALLY BEEN DEVELOPED AS A NERVE GAS). AS OF SEPTEMBER 30, 2012, THIS PESTICIDE CAN NO LONGER BE SOLD IN THE U.S., WITH ALL USAGE BECOMING ILLEGAL IN 2013. HUMAN TESTING OF PESTICIDES: IN FEBRUARY 2013, EPA REVISED BUSH-ERA REGULATIONS THAT HAD ALLOWED UNETHICAL CHEMICAL INDUSTRY TESTING OF PESTICIDES ON PEOPLE TO PRODUCE STUDIES THAT WOULD SUPPORT WEAKER FEDERAL REGULATION OF THE PESTICIDES. OUR 2006 CHALLENGE TO THE BUSH STANDARDS FOR OFFENDING BOTH ETHICAL AND SCIENTIFIC STANDARDS PRODUCED A SETTLEMENT IN WHICH EPA AGREED TO REVISE THE STANDARDS. THE REVISED STANDARDS DO NOT ENTIRELY PROHIBIT TESTING PESTICIDES ON PEOPLE, BUT PREVENT EPA FROM RELYING ON SUCH TESTS CONDUCTED ON PREGNANT WOMEN AND CHILDREN OR THAT SIMILARLY RUN AFOUL OF ETHICAL NORMS OR STANDARDS OF SCIENTIFIC CREDIBILITY. PESTICIDES AND SALMON: FOR MORE THAN A DECADE, EARTHJUSTICE LITIGATION HAS PROTECTED ENDANGERED SALMON FROM TOXIC PESTICIDES AND HAS PUT IN PLACE BUFFERS AND OTHER TEMPORARY MEASURES TO KEEP THE PESTICIDES OUT OF SALMON STREAMS. CONDUCTING REVIEWS REQUIRED BY COURT ORDERS, THE NMFS HAS FOUND THAT MUCH MORE NEEDS TO BE DONE TO PROTECT IMPERILED SALMON AND STEELHEAD FROM 21 COMMONLY USED PESTICIDES, BUT EPA HAS RESISTED. WE ARE IN COURT PRESSING FOR FULL IMPLEMENTATION OF THE FISHERIES SERVICE'S PROTECTIONS, WHILE INDUSTRY HAS CHALLENGED SOME OF THOSE PROTECTIONS IN COURT WITH MODEST SUCCESS. MEANWHILE, THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES ISSUED A REPORT IN APRIL RECOMMENDING THAT EPA ACCOUNT FOR NON-LETHAL HARMS FROM PESTICIDES SUCH AS IMPAIRMENT OF LIFE FUNCTIONS AND IMPACTS TO FOOD SUPPLY AND HABITAT, AS WELL AS THE COMBINED EFFECTS OF EXPOSURE TO MULTIPLE PESTICIDES. THE FISHERIES SERVICE WILL BE REVISING ITS MITIGATION REQUIREMENTS ACCORDINGLY. PROGRESS IN SAFEGUARDING CLEAN AND PLENTIFUL WATER: CLEANING UP FLORIDA'S GREEN SLIME: OUR LITIGATION HAS LED EPA TO ADOPT HARD NUMERIC CAPS ON POLLUTION FROM MANURE, FERTILIZERS, AND SEWAGE THAT TRIGGERS TOXIC ALGAE OUTBREAKS IN FLORIDA WATERS. THE FIRST CAPS APPLICABLE TO FRESHWATER LAKES AND STREAMS WERE UPHELD BY A FEDERAL DISTRICT JUDGE IN FEBRUARY 2012. ON NOVEMBER 30, 2012, AFTER THE DISTRICT COURT REFUSED TO GIVE EPA MORE TIME, EPA PROPOSED CAPS FOR COASTAL, ESTUARY, AND MARINE WATERS AND CANALS, BUT ALSO APPROVED FLORIDA'S WEAKER RULE, WHICH EXEMPTS MANY WATERS FROM THE STRONGER EPA STANDARDS. WE ARE IN COURT OVER THE DUELING STANDARDS. WE HAVE LONG SOUGHT TO LIMIT POLLUTION INTO LAKE OKEECHOBEE. OUR SUCCESSFUL CLEAN WATER ACT ENFORCEMENT ACTION WAS DERAILED BY THE BUSH ADMINISTRATION'S ADOPTION OF A RULE EXEMPTING TRANSFERS OF WATER FROM THE ACT. WE AND SEVERAL STATES HAVE CHALLENGED THAT RULE IN BOTH THE DISTRICT COURT AND THE COURT OF APPEALS. THE 11TH CIRCUIT HELD THAT THE CASE BELONGS IN THE DISTRICT COURT. EPA THEN ASKED THE SUPREME COURT TO TAKE THE CASE. WE OPPOSED, AND ON OCTOBER 15, 2013, THE COURT TURNED DOWN THAT REQUEST. RESTORING MAUI STREAM FLOWS: IN AUGUST 2012, THE HAWAI'I SUPREME COURT ORDERED THE STATE WATER COMMISSION TO RECONSIDER THE FATE OF NA WAI 'EHA (THE FOUR GREAT WATERS), THIS TIME GIVING GREATER WEIGHT TO NATIVE HAWAIIANS' AND THE PUBLIC'S RIGHTS TO FLOWING STREAMS. AFTER A LENGTHY TRIAL AND MULTIPLE ROUNDS OF BRIEFING, THE HEARING EXAMINER HAD RECOMMENDED RESTORING MASSIVE AMOUNTS OF WATER TO ALL FOUR STREAMS, BUT THE COMMISSION FAILED TO FOLLOW THE RECOMMENDATION FOR THE TWO LARGER STREAMS. IN THIS NEXT ROUND, MORE WATER SHOULD BE LEFT IN THE STREAMS. CALIFORNIA'S RUSSIAN RIVER: IN OCTOBER 2012, WE REACHED A SETTLEMENT THAT WILL DRAMATICALLY SHRINK GRAVEL MINING OPERATIONS ON THE RUSSIAN RIVER IN NORTHERN CALIFORNIA AND SUBJECT THE MINING TO MONITORING, SCIENTIFIC REVIEW, AND REQUIREMENTS FOR SALMON HABITAT IMPROVEMENTS. STORMWATER POLLUTION IN WESTERN WASHINGTON: OUR PAST LITIGATION VICTORIES INVALIDATED THE STORMWATER PERMITS FOR MUNICIPALITIES IN WESTERN WASHINGTON AND LED TO THE ISSUANCE OF NEW PERMITS IN AUGUST 2012 THAT REQUIRE LOW-IMPACT DEVELOPMENT AS THE MOST ENVIRONMENTALLY PROTECTIVE METHOD FOR CONTROLLING STORMWATER RUNOFF FROM NEW DEVELOPMENT. WE HAVE INTERVENED TO DEFEND THE PERMITS IN THE FACE OF CHALLENGES FROM NUMEROUS LOCAL GOVERNMENTS. IN A SEPTEMBER 2012 DECISION IN ANOTHER LAWSUIT, A STATE COURT OF APPEALS REJECTED CLARK COUNTY'S WEAK DEVELOPMENT RULES THAT WOULD ALLOW MORE POLLUTED RUNOFF THAN ALLOWED UNDER STATEWIDE STANDARDS. A TOOL FOR LIMITING FACTORY FARM POLLUTION UPHELD: IN JANUARY 2013, A NORTH CAROLINA TRIAL COURT HELD THAT THE CLEAN WATER ACT APPLIES TO EXCREMENT, AMMONIA, AND OTHER POLLUTION BLOWN THROUGH VENTILATORS AT A FACTORY FARM HOUSING NEARLY 4 MILLION EGG-LAYING HENS INTO NEARBY STREAMS AND THE WETLANDS IN A NATIONAL WILDLIFE REFUGE. THE COURT REJECTED THE FARM'S ARGUMENT THAT THE ACT DOESN'T REACH POLLUTION THAT IS TRANSMITTED THROUGH THE AIR INTO WATER. CONCLUSION: EARTHJUSTICE LITIGATION CONTINUES TO BE THE ENGINE FOR REVERSING ILL-CONCEIVED POLICIES THAT GIVE AWAY PUBLIC RESOURCES AND SACRIFICE HUMAN LIVES AND HEALTH TO INDUSTRIAL EXCESSES. THE ORGANIZATION'S LITIGATION AND ADVOCACY HAS ALSO SPURRED FORWARD PROGRESS ON REGULATING CLIMATE POLLUTION, FAIRLY CONSIDERING AND MOVING TOWARD ALTERNATIVES TO FOSSIL FUELS, CURBING AIR POLLUTION THAT COSTS FAR TOO MANY LIVES EVERY YEAR, ENDING MOUNTAINTOP REMOVAL MINING, PROTECTING FORAGE FISH AND OCEAN ECOSYSTEMS, AND PROTECTING PEOPLE, COMMUNITIES, AND TREASURED WILDLANDS FROM FRACKING.CASE SUMMARIES CONTINUED
FORM 990, PART III001132 WYOMING ROADLESS 765.76 001146 CANYONLANDS 2477 INTERVENTION 388.23 001149 CO ROADLESS LEASING 177.65 001151 DEEP CREEK MTNS RS 2477 439.65 001163 INYO COUNTY, CA 2477 CASE 23.98 001164 JARBIDGE RS 2477 INTERVENTION 936.65 001167 MISSOURI BREAKS NM 2,758.76 001216 CENTRAL MAUI STREAMS RESTORATION 1,032.84 001221 MAKUA EIS 234,383.42 001252 24-FTAA FOIA 955.50 001307 CHUKCHI OCS LEASE SALE 193 1,584.16 001316 JUNEAU ACCESS PROJECT 105,821.01 001346 TONGASS ROADLESS EXEMPTION 1,827.24 001388 SIERRA FRAMEWORK CHALLENGE 200.45 001404 1999 HYDRO ESA 67.59 001406 BLM PLANS 33,240.40 001467 UPPER SNAKE BIOP CHALLENGE 283,224.29 001473 EVERGLADES 1,559.70 001510 COMPARABLE FUELS 14.95 001511 CSO BLUEPLAINS 119.16 001605 AZ STRIP PLAN 796.68 001698 BRICK KILNS DEADLINE 61,859.07 001703 SUNFLOWER RUS NEPA 1,034.06 001715 GLEN CANYON FLOWS 757.64 001723 GENETICALLY ENGINEERED SUGAR BEETS 1,234,915.77 001761 JARBIDGE - 2005 ROD 1,315.32 001768 HAZARDOUS WASTE GASIFICATION 256.45 001770 ROAN PLATEAU 15,607.20 001780 OZONE STANDARDS 367.95 001810 CARLSBAD CEC INTERVENTION 282.32 001819 PETROLEUM REFINERY NSPS 116.22 001850 WOLF DELISTING II 376,385.55 001859 IDAHO ROADLESS RULE 3,077.21 001862 STEAM BUFFER ZONE RULEM 95.56 001908 MONTGOMERY COUNTY MS4 1,095.51 001922 EPACT WWEC 28,268.01 001933 SWORDFISH LONGLINES 1,652.40 001936 UTAH WILDERNESS LEASE INTERVENTION 171.60 001938 SON OF FEMA 16,325.00 001962 SALMON BIOP INTERVENTION 793.20 001982 MONTANA DNRC CHP 301.54 001992 KEYSTONE I 164,347.60 001993 SALMON-CHALLIS TRAVEL PLAN 81,372.76 001999 LAHAINA INJECTION WELL 9,107.30 002001 01AVENAL POWER PLANT 1,039.94 002002 GULF LONGLINES & SEA TURTLES 2 29,155.91 002005 HAWAII FEED-IN TARIFFS 86.53 002008 OTTER CREEK COAL LEASE 1,040.82 002014 COAL PLANT ELGS 13,250.00 002017 PM2.5 NSR GRANDFATHERING INTER 572.71 002019 SHELL CHUKCHI SEA 2010 CLEAN A 431.22 002026 CLARK COUNTY AGREED ORDER 150.77 002027 GHOST SHIPS 723.68 002031 CLARK COUNTY ENFORCEMENT ACTION 11.27 002033 GHG ENDANGERMENT FINDING 55.64 002039 METHYL IODIDE DPR 397,816.44 002044 FOUR CORNERS PSD 1,217.35 002046 24NON-ROAD & AIRCRAFT GHGS CAA 268.97 002058 SJV 1-HOUR OZONE SIP 98,918.00 002059 FISHER CESA II 178,837.00 002065 PIKE SAN ISABEL MOTOR VEHICLE 192.78 002067 STANISLAUS TMP 132.47 002068 TEXAS POWER PLANTS 39,564.87 002071 STELLER SEA LION CONSULTATION 2,604.82 002073 CHLORPYRIFOS UNREASONABLE DELAY 742.72 002077 SALMON PESTICIDE BIOP DEFENSE 602.72 002078 SALMON PESTICIDE BIOP ENFORCEMENT 1,138.00 002079 WA BUILDING CODE PREEMPTION 59.44 002083 DIRECT HEATING EQUIPMENT 73.96 002088 GALLATIN WINTER USE 66.51 002090 LUMINANT POWER PLANT ENFORCEMENT 1,722.59 002091 COHO INTERVENTION 796.40 002095 LANDFILLS NSPS 16.44 002100 FEMA FOIA 9,833.80 002106 SHELL OIL SPILL PLANS 487.42 002108 TIERING TO ROAN EIS 55.72 002122 NO MORE WILDERNESS INTERVENTION 369.81 002125 RUSSIAN RIVER GRAVEL MINING 84.97 002131 WESTERN ENERGY ALLIANCE PROTEST 402.57 002147 WA TRIENNIAL WATER QUALITY STAND 157.26 002151 O&C LANDS INTERVENTION 1,594.20 002164 HAZE PLANS 2 136,601.00 002165 FOUR CORNERS PUC 2,400.00 002168 WASHINGTON REFINERIES' GHG RAC 4,341.22 002180 2011 CAA RTR DEADLINES 400.59 002185 ATLANTIC HERRING FMP AMENDMENT 168,246.07 002188 GOLD MINES 630.66 002209 COLORADO RES DEFENSE 132.88 002219 MTR SPRUCE VETO DEFENSE 169.92 002221 ENERGY STORAGE - CPUC 130.96 002222 NORTH BOUNDARY BISON INTERVENTION 2,419.70 002225 PERSISTENT BIOACCUMULATIVE TOXINS 93,006.10 002226 SEWAGE SLUDGE INCINERATORS 2,569.47 002232 MONTANA REGIONAL HAZE 2,472.22 002233 COLSTRIP TITLE V 2,400.00 002237 DEFINITION OF NONHAZARDOUS SOL 234.32 002238 SHELL BEAUFORT SEA OCS EXPLORATION 238.10 002243 SHELL CHUKCHI SEA OCS EXPLORATION 206.67 002244 SHELL KULLUK DRILLSHIP CLEAN A 1,079.55 002246 OCPI SKAGIT AMICUS 69.41 002250 NEVADA BART SIP 483.10 002259 FLAMING GORGE WATER PIPELINE 25.85 002267 AVISTA DECOUPLING 437.07 002268 PSE DECOUPLING 168.55 002273 SAN JUAN GENERATING STATION HA 2,556.33 002281 COASTAL PELAGIC SPECIES AMENDMENT 238.69 002283 : PM NAAQS DEADLINE 134,651.58 002289 IDAHO ANTIDEGRADATION 375.27 002290 DC MS4 2011 45.60 002300 WY FRACKING DISCLOSURE 2,560.05 002301 FERN HARDY HFRA TIMBER SALE 281.11 002302 WY WOLF DELISTING 561.20 002304 GRAND CANYON URANIUM WITHDRAWAL 2,606.60 002305 TAHOE HOMEWOOD 2,090.36 002308 MN REGIONAL HAZE SIP/FIP 362.56 002314 IS COOS BAY DREDGING PERMIT NM 1,966.76 002315 PRIMARY LEAD AIR TOXICS RISK A 327.44 002320 DIRECT HEATING EQUIPMENT II 10.80 002324 XL FOIA - LOBBYISTS WORK TYPE: 376.90 002333 SALMON BIOP INTERVENTION APP 369.04 002337 SECONDARY LEAD AIR TOXICS RISK 109.21 002338 INDUSTRIAL BOILERS II 819.30 002339 BISON-RELOCATION INTERVENTION 2,595.10 002344 CAL FRACKING 760.23 002353 MURRELET DELISTING INTERVENTION 997.70 002356 CPUC LTPP 2012 177.00 002361 AR REGIONAL HAZE 126.90 002366 PM2.5 IMPLEMENTATION GUIDANCE 10,771.90 002374 STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS AMICUS 90.40 002380 FALSE KILLER WHALE TRP DEADLINE 10,000.00 002393 PVC II 455.13 002396 UNCLASSIFIABLE OZONE DESIGNATION 1,268.19 002400 OZONE ATTAINMENT DELAY 2012 659.05 002405 REGIONAL HAZE 309 PROGRAM 1,541.24 002409 TAHOE TRAVEL MANAGEMENT 288.30 002417 OIL & GAS AIR RULES II 450.00 002421 NEB. REGIONAL HAZE SIP APPEAL 324.05 002428 COLSTRIP COAL ASH ENFORCEMENT 6,676.41 002432 CA BRODIFACOUM REEVALUATION 149.42 002434 STORMWATER PERMIT DEFENSE 156.06 002440 AEP NEW SOURCE REVIEW CONSENT 46,063.00 002441 CLEARWATER TRAVEL PLAN INTERVE 481.65 002450 OIL & GAS AIR TOXICS 375.00 002453 LEECO STACY BRANCH MINE 404 P 130.10 002465 CHROME PLATING AIR TOXICS RISK 502.32 002490 MONTANA LEGISLATIVE ADVOCACY 101.86 002535 OTTER CREEK MINING PERMIT 674.36SCHEDULE OF COURT AWARDED ATTORNEY FEES & COSTS

Schedule R IRS990ScheduleR

Form990 Schedule R Part II Form990ScheduleRPartII

Name Of Disregarded Entity NameOfDisregardedEntity

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Business Name Line1WASHINGTON FOREST LAW CENTERBusinessNameLine1

Address US AddressUS

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Address Line1615 SECOND STREET SUITE 360AddressLine1
CitySEATTLECity
StateWAState
ZIP Code98104ZIPCode
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
EIN911803140EIN
Primary ActivitiesPUBLIC INTEREST LAW FIRMPrimaryActivities
Legal Domicile StateCALegalDomicileState
Exempt Code Section501(C)(3)ExemptCodeSection
Public Charity Status11-IPublicCharityStatus

Direct Controlling Entity Name DirectControllingEntityName

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Business Name Line1EARTHJUSTICEBusinessNameLine1
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Controlled Org1ControlledOrg
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Receipt Of Int Ann Rents Royalties0ReceiptOfIntAnnRentsRoyalties
Gift Grant Or Cap Contr To Other Org0GiftGrantOrCapContrToOtherOrg
Gift Grant Or Cap Contr Fr Other Org0GiftGrantOrCapContrFrOtherOrg
Loans Or Guarantees To Other Org0LoansOrGuaranteesToOtherOrg
Loans Or Guarantees From Other Org0LoansOrGuaranteesFromOtherOrg
Dividends Related Organization0DividendsRelatedOrganization
Sale Of Assets To Other Org0SaleOfAssetsToOtherOrg
Purchase Of Assets From Other Org0PurchaseOfAssetsFromOtherOrg
Exchange Of Assets0ExchangeOfAssets
Rental Of Facilities To Other Orgs0RentalOfFacilitiesToOtherOrgs
Rental Of Facilities Fr Other Orgs0RentalOfFacilitiesFrOtherOrgs
Perform Of Services For Other Orgs0PerformOfServicesForOtherOrgs
Perform Of Services By Other Orgs0PerformOfServicesByOtherOrgs
Sharing Of Facilities0SharingOfFacilities
Sharing Of Paid Employees0SharingOfPaidEmployees
Reimbursement Paid To Other Org0ReimbursementPaidToOtherOrg
Reimbursement Paid By Other Org0ReimbursementPaidByOtherOrg
Other Transfer To Other Org0OtherTransferToOtherOrg
Other Transfer From Other Org0OtherTransferFromOtherOrg

Comments

Anonymous: no account or email. Up to 2,000 characters, at most one link. Comments are checked automatically; some wait for review.