NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER: Form 990, tax year 2021
View the entire original 990 at ProPublica ↗
- Organization
- NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER (EIN 85-0360664)
- Tax period
- 2021-01-01 to 2021-12-31
- Filed
- 2022-11-15
- IRS object ID
- 202223199349326642
- Schema version
- 2021v4.2
- Source
- Download XML · Original 990 at ProPublica
Every field in the e-filed return. Faint text is the IRS element name, for citing.
Return header ReturnHeader
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Return | 2022-11-15T17:05:42-06:00 | ReturnTs |
| Tax Period End | 2021-12-31 | TaxPeriodEndDt |
Preparer Firm PreparerFirmGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Preparer Firm EIN | 850455053 | PreparerFirmEIN |
Preparer Firm Name PreparerFirmName
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Business Name Line1 | SWAIN & GRIECO LLC | BusinessNameLine1Txt |
Preparer US Address PreparerUSAddress
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Address Line1 | 2050 BOTULPH ROAD SUITE A | AddressLine1Txt |
| City | SANTA FE | CityNm |
| State Abbreviation | NM | StateAbbreviationCd |
| ZIP | 87505 | ZIPCd |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Return Type | 990 | ReturnTypeCd |
| Tax Period Begin | 2021-01-01 | TaxPeriodBeginDt |
Filer Filer
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| EIN | 850360664 | EIN |
Business Name BusinessName
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Business Name Line1 | NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER | BusinessNameLine1Txt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Business Name Control | NEWM | BusinessNameControlTxt |
| Phone | 5059899022 | PhoneNum |
US Address USAddress
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Address Line1 | 1405 LUISA STREET 5 | AddressLine1Txt |
| City | SANTA FE | CityNm |
| State Abbreviation | NM | StateAbbreviationCd |
| ZIP | 87505 | ZIPCd |
Business Officer BusinessOfficerGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Person | DONNA HOUSE | PersonNm |
| Person Title | PRESIDENT | PersonTitleTxt |
| Phone | 5059899022 | PhoneNum |
| Signature | 2022-11-15 | SignatureDt |
| Discuss With Paid Preparer | Yes (1) | DiscussWithPaidPreparerInd |
Signing Officer SigningOfficerGrp
Person Full Name PersonFullName
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Person First | DONNA | PersonFirstNm |
| Person Last | HOUSE | PersonLastNm |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| SSN | 999009999 | SSN |
Preparer Person PreparerPersonGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Preparer Person | MICHAEL D SWAIN CPA | PreparerPersonNm |
| PTIN | P00120406 | PTIN |
| Phone | 5059883770 | PhoneNum |
Additional Filer Information AdditionalFilerInformation
Trusted Customer TrustedCustomerGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Trusted Customer | 3 | TrustedCustomerCd |
| Authentication Assurance Level | AAL1 | AuthenticationAssuranceLevelCd |
| Identity Assurance Level | IAL1 | IdentityAssuranceLevelCd |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Tax | 2021 | TaxYr |
| Build TS | 2022-09-23 18:48:47Z | BuildTS |
Form 990 IRS990
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Principal Officer | DONNA HOUSE | PrincipalOfficerNm |
US Address USAddress
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Address Line1 | 1405 LUISA STREET 5 | AddressLine1Txt |
| City | SANTA FE | CityNm |
| State Abbreviation | NM | StateAbbreviationCd |
| ZIP | 87505 | ZIPCd |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Gross Receipts | $1,060,054 | GrossReceiptsAmt |
| Group Return For Affiliates | 0 | GroupReturnForAffiliatesInd |
| Organization501c3 | Yes (X) | Organization501c3Ind |
| Website Address | NMENVIROLAW.ORG | WebsiteAddressTxt |
| Type Of Organization Corp | Yes (X) | TypeOfOrganizationCorpInd |
| Formation | 1987 | FormationYr |
| Legal Domicile State | NM | LegalDomicileStateCd |
| Activity Or Mission | ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION. | ActivityOrMissionDesc |
| Voting Members Governing Body | 6 | VotingMembersGoverningBodyCnt |
| Voting Members Independent | 6 | VotingMembersIndependentCnt |
| Total Employee | 13 | TotalEmployeeCnt |
| Total Volunteers | 8 | TotalVolunteersCnt |
| Total Gross UBI | $0 | TotalGrossUBIAmt |
| Net Unrelated Bus Txbl Incm | $0 | NetUnrelatedBusTxblIncmAmt |
| PY Contributions Grants | $1,161,823 | PYContributionsGrantsAmt |
| CY Contributions Grants | $1,039,500 | CYContributionsGrantsAmt |
| PY Program Service Revenue | $0 | PYProgramServiceRevenueAmt |
| CY Program Service Revenue | $8,858 | CYProgramServiceRevenueAmt |
| PY Investment Income | $29,032 | PYInvestmentIncomeAmt |
| CY Investment Income | $11,696 | CYInvestmentIncomeAmt |
| PY Other Revenue | $388 | PYOtherRevenueAmt |
| CY Other Revenue | $0 | CYOtherRevenueAmt |
| PY Total Revenue | $1,191,243 | PYTotalRevenueAmt |
| CY Total Revenue | $1,060,054 | CYTotalRevenueAmt |
| PY Grants And Similar Paid | $0 | PYGrantsAndSimilarPaidAmt |
| CY Grants And Similar Paid | $0 | CYGrantsAndSimilarPaidAmt |
| PY Benefits Paid To Members | $0 | PYBenefitsPaidToMembersAmt |
| CY Benefits Paid To Members | $0 | CYBenefitsPaidToMembersAmt |
| PY Salaries Comp Emp Bnft Paid | $761,283 | PYSalariesCompEmpBnftPaidAmt |
| CY Salaries Comp Emp Bnft Paid | $897,216 | CYSalariesCompEmpBnftPaidAmt |
| PY Total Prof Fndrsng Expns | $0 | PYTotalProfFndrsngExpnsAmt |
| CY Total Prof Fndrsng Expns | $0 | CYTotalProfFndrsngExpnsAmt |
| CY Total Fundraising Expense | $58,346 | CYTotalFundraisingExpenseAmt |
| PY Other Expenses | $302,517 | PYOtherExpensesAmt |
| CY Other Expenses | $316,806 | CYOtherExpensesAmt |
| PY Total Expenses | $1,063,800 | PYTotalExpensesAmt |
| CY Total Expenses | $1,214,022 | CYTotalExpensesAmt |
| PY Revenues Less Expenses | $127,443 | PYRevenuesLessExpensesAmt |
| CY Revenues Less Expenses | -$153,968 | CYRevenuesLessExpensesAmt |
| Total Assets BOY | $1,903,807 | TotalAssetsBOYAmt |
| Total Assets EOY | $1,644,813 | TotalAssetsEOYAmt |
| Total Liabilities BOY | $202,402 | TotalLiabilitiesBOYAmt |
| Total Liabilities EOY | $70,783 | TotalLiabilitiesEOYAmt |
| Net Assets Or Fund Balances BOY | $1,701,405 | NetAssetsOrFundBalancesBOYAmt |
| Net Assets Or Fund Balances EOY | $1,574,030 | NetAssetsOrFundBalancesEOYAmt |
| Mission | ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION. | MissionDesc |
| Significant New Program Srvc | 0 | SignificantNewProgramSrvcInd |
| Significant Change | 0 | SignificantChangeInd |
| Expense | $956,860 | ExpenseAmt |
| Revenue | $8,858 | RevenueAmt |
| Desc | NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER IS A NON-PROFIT, PUBLIC INTEREST LAW FIRM THAT PROVIDES FREE AND LOW-COST LEGAL SERVICES ON ENVIRONMENTAL MATTERS THROUGHOUT NEW MEXICO. FOUNDED IN 1987, THE LAW CENTER WORKS WITH COMMUNITY GROUPS, NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATIONS, ENVIRONMENTAL ORGANIZATIONS, TRIBES AND PUEBLOS, SEEKING TO PROTECT THE ENVIRONMENT. THE LAW CENTER'S MISSION IS TO PROTECT NEW MEXICO'S COMMUNITIES AND THEIR AIR, LAND, AND WATER IN THE FIGHT FOR ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE. THE MAIN PROGRAMS ARE COMMUNITY REPRESENTATION AND NATIVE AMERICAN COMMUNITY REPRESENTATION. SEE ATTACHED STATEMENT FOR STATUS OF CASES IN LITIGATION. | Desc |
| Total Program Service Expenses | $956,860 | TotalProgramServiceExpensesAmt |
| Described In Section501c3 | Yes (1) | DescribedInSection501c3Ind |
| Schedule B Required | Yes (1) | ScheduleBRequiredInd |
| Political Campaign Acty | 0 | PoliticalCampaignActyInd |
| Lobbying Activities | Yes (1) | LobbyingActivitiesInd |
| Subject To Proxy Tax | 0 | SubjectToProxyTaxInd |
| Donor Advised Fund | 0 | DonorAdvisedFundInd |
| Conservation Easements | 0 | ConservationEasementsInd |
| Collections Of Art | 0 | CollectionsOfArtInd |
| Credit Counseling | 0 | CreditCounselingInd |
| Donor Rstr Or Quasi Endowments | 0 | DonorRstrOrQuasiEndowmentsInd |
| Report Land Building Equipment | Yes (1) | ReportLandBuildingEquipmentInd |
| Report Investments Other Sec | Yes (1) | ReportInvestmentsOtherSecInd |
| Report Program Related Invst | 0 | ReportProgramRelatedInvstInd |
| Report Other Assets | 0 | ReportOtherAssetsInd |
| Report Other Liabilities | Yes (1) | ReportOtherLiabilitiesInd |
| Include FIN48 Footnote | Yes (1) | IncludeFIN48FootnoteInd |
| Independent Audit Fincl Stmt | Yes (1) | IndependentAuditFinclStmtInd |
| Consolidated Audit Fincl Stmt | 0 | ConsolidatedAuditFinclStmtInd |
| School Operating | 0 | SchoolOperatingInd |
| Foreign Office | 0 | ForeignOfficeInd |
| Foreign Activities | 0 | ForeignActivitiesInd |
| More Than5000 K To Org | 0 | MoreThan5000KToOrgInd |
| More Than5000 K To Individuals | 0 | MoreThan5000KToIndividualsInd |
| Professional Fundraising | 0 | ProfessionalFundraisingInd |
| Fundraising Activities | 0 | FundraisingActivitiesInd |
| Gaming Activities | 0 | GamingActivitiesInd |
| Operate Hospital | 0 | OperateHospitalInd |
| Grants To Organizations | 0 | GrantsToOrganizationsInd |
| Grants To Individuals | 0 | GrantsToIndividualsInd |
| Schedule J Required | 0 | ScheduleJRequiredInd |
| Tax Exempt Bonds | 0 | TaxExemptBondsInd |
| Engaged In Excess Benefit Trans | 0 | EngagedInExcessBenefitTransInd |
| PY Excess Benefit Trans | 0 | PYExcessBenefitTransInd |
| Loan Outstanding | 0 | LoanOutstandingInd |
| Grant To Related Person | 0 | GrantToRelatedPersonInd |
| Business Rln With Org Mem | 0 | BusinessRlnWithOrgMemInd |
| Business Rln With Fam Mem | 0 | BusinessRlnWithFamMemInd |
| Business Rln With35 Ctrl Ent | 0 | BusinessRlnWith35CtrlEntInd |
| Deductible Non Cash Contri | 0 | DeductibleNonCashContriInd |
| Deductible Art Contribution | 0 | DeductibleArtContributionInd |
| Terminate Operations | 0 | TerminateOperationsInd |
| Partial Liquidation | 0 | PartialLiquidationInd |
| Disregarded Entity | 0 | DisregardedEntityInd |
| Related Entity | 0 | RelatedEntityInd |
| Related Organization Ctrl Ent | 0 | RelatedOrganizationCtrlEntInd |
| Trnsfr Exmpt Non Chrtbl Rltd Org | 0 | TrnsfrExmptNonChrtblRltdOrgInd |
| Activities Conducted Prtshp | 0 | ActivitiesConductedPrtshpInd |
| Schedule O Required | Yes (1) | ScheduleORequiredInd |
| IRP Document | 10 | IRPDocumentCnt |
| IRP Document W2 G | 0 | IRPDocumentW2GCnt |
| Employee | 13 | EmployeeCnt |
| Employment Tax Returns Filed | Yes (1) | EmploymentTaxReturnsFiledInd |
| Unrelated Bus Incm Over Limit | 0 | UnrelatedBusIncmOverLimitInd |
| Foreign Financial Account | 0 | ForeignFinancialAccountInd |
| Prohibited Tax Shelter Trans | 0 | ProhibitedTaxShelterTransInd |
| Taxable Party Notification | 0 | TaxablePartyNotificationInd |
| Nondeductible Contributions | 0 | NondeductibleContributionsInd |
| Quid Pro Quo Contributions | 0 | QuidProQuoContributionsInd |
| Form8282 Property Disposed Of | 0 | Form8282PropertyDisposedOfInd |
| Rcv Fnds To Pay Prsnl Bnft Cntrct | 0 | RcvFndsToPayPrsnlBnftCntrctInd |
| Pay Premiums Prsnl Bnft Cntrct | 0 | PayPremiumsPrsnlBnftCntrctInd |
| Indoor Tanning Services | 0 | IndoorTanningServicesInd |
| Subj To Tax Rmnrtn Ex Prcht Pymt | 0 | SubjToTaxRmnrtnExPrchtPymtInd |
| Subject To Excs Tax Net Invst Inc | 0 | SubjectToExcsTaxNetInvstIncInd |
| Info In Schedule O Part VI | Yes (X) | InfoInScheduleOPartVIInd |
| Governing Body Voting Members | 6 | GoverningBodyVotingMembersCnt |
| Independent Voting Member | 6 | IndependentVotingMemberCnt |
| Family Or Business Rln | 0 | FamilyOrBusinessRlnInd |
| Delegation Of Mgmt Duties | 0 | DelegationOfMgmtDutiesInd |
| Change To Org Documents | 0 | ChangeToOrgDocumentsInd |
| Material Diversion Or Misuse | 0 | MaterialDiversionOrMisuseInd |
| Members Or Stockholders | Yes (1) | MembersOrStockholdersInd |
| Election Of Board Members | 0 | ElectionOfBoardMembersInd |
| Decisions Subject To Approva | 0 | DecisionsSubjectToApprovaInd |
| Minutes Of Governing Body | Yes (1) | MinutesOfGoverningBodyInd |
| Minutes Of Committees | Yes (1) | MinutesOfCommitteesInd |
| Officer Mailing Address | 0 | OfficerMailingAddressInd |
| Local Chapters | 0 | LocalChaptersInd |
| Form990 Provided To Gvrn Body | Yes (1) | Form990ProvidedToGvrnBodyInd |
| Conflict Of Interest Policy | Yes (1) | ConflictOfInterestPolicyInd |
| Annual Disclosure Covered Prsn | Yes (1) | AnnualDisclosureCoveredPrsnInd |
| Regular Monitoring Enfrc | Yes (1) | RegularMonitoringEnfrcInd |
| Whistleblower Policy | Yes (1) | WhistleblowerPolicyInd |
| Document Retention Policy | Yes (1) | DocumentRetentionPolicyInd |
| Compensation Process CEO | Yes (1) | CompensationProcessCEOInd |
| Compensation Process Other | Yes (1) | CompensationProcessOtherInd |
| Investment In Joint Venture | 0 | InvestmentInJointVentureInd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | NM | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| Own Website | Yes (X) | OwnWebsiteInd |
| Other Website | Yes (X) | OtherWebsiteInd |
| Upon Request | Yes (X) | UponRequestInd |
Books In Care Of Detail BooksInCareOfDetail
Business Name BusinessName
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Business Name Line1 | THE ORGANIZATION | BusinessNameLine1Txt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Phone | 5059899022 | PhoneNum |
US Address USAddress
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Address Line1 | 1405 LUISA STREET STE 5 | AddressLine1Txt |
| City | SANTA FE | CityNm |
| State Abbreviation | NM | StateAbbreviationCd |
| ZIP | 87505 | ZIPCd |
Form990 Part VII Section A Form990PartVIISectionAGrp (7 entries)
| TitleTitleTxt | Average Hours Per WeekAverageHoursPerWeekRt | Individual Trustee Or DirectorIndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd | OfficerOfficerInd | Reportable Comp From OrgReportableCompFromOrgAmt | Reportable Comp From Rltd OrgReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt | Other CompensationOtherCompensationAmt |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| DONNA HOUSE | ||||||
| PRESIDENT | 4.00 | Yes (X) | Yes (X) | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| RAMON PADILLA | ||||||
| VICE-PRESIDENT | 1.00 | Yes (X) | Yes (X) | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| JOHANA BENCOMO | ||||||
| SECRETARY | 1.00 | Yes (X) | Yes (X) | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| HARRY BROWNE | ||||||
| TREASURER | 1.00 | Yes (X) | Yes (X) | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| MICHAEL CASAUS | ||||||
| BOARD MEMBER | 1.00 | Yes (X) | $0 | $0 | $0 | |
| SUSANNE HOFFMAN-DOOLEY | ||||||
| BOARD MEMBER | 1.00 | Yes (X) | $0 | $0 | $0 | |
| VIRGINIA NECHOCHEA | ||||||
| EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR | 40.00 | Yes (X) | Yes (X) | $102,500 | $0 | $0 |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total Reportable Comp From Org | $102,500 | TotalReportableCompFromOrgAmt |
| Tot Reportable Comp Rltd Org | $0 | TotReportableCompRltdOrgAmt |
| Total Other Compensation | $0 | TotalOtherCompensationAmt |
| Indiv Rcvd Greater Than100 K | 1 | IndivRcvdGreaterThan100KCnt |
| Former Ofcr Employees Listed | 0 | FormerOfcrEmployeesListedInd |
| Total Comp Greater Than150 K | 0 | TotalCompGreaterThan150KInd |
| Compensation From Other Srcs | 0 | CompensationFromOtherSrcsInd |
| Cntrct Rcvd Greater Than100 K | 0 | CntrctRcvdGreaterThan100KCnt |
| Membership Dues | $48,049 | MembershipDuesAmt |
| All Other Contributions | $991,451 | AllOtherContributionsAmt |
| Total Contributions | $1,039,500 | TotalContributionsAmt |
Program Service Revenue ProgramServiceRevenueGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Desc | LEGAL FEES | Desc |
| Business | 541100 | BusinessCd |
| Total Revenue Column | $8,858 | TotalRevenueColumnAmt |
| Related Or Exempt Func Income | $8,858 | RelatedOrExemptFuncIncomeAmt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total Program Service Revenue | $8,858 | TotalProgramServiceRevenueAmt |
Investment Income InvestmentIncomeGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total Revenue Column | $11,696 | TotalRevenueColumnAmt |
| Exclusion | $11,696 | ExclusionAmt |
Total Revenue TotalRevenueGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total Revenue Column | $1,060,054 | TotalRevenueColumnAmt |
| Related Or Exempt Func Income | $8,858 | RelatedOrExemptFuncIncomeAmt |
| Unrelated Business Revenue | $0 | UnrelatedBusinessRevenueAmt |
| Exclusion | $11,696 | ExclusionAmt |
Comp Current Ofcr Directors CompCurrentOfcrDirectorsGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $102,500 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $87,125 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $15,375 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
Other Salaries And Wages OtherSalariesAndWagesGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $621,824 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $522,150 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $99,674 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
Pension Plan Contributions PensionPlanContributionsGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $13,216 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $11,578 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $755 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
| Fundraising | $883 | FundraisingAmt |
Other Employee Benefits OtherEmployeeBenefitsGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $101,612 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $68,947 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $27,204 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
| Fundraising | $5,461 | FundraisingAmt |
Payroll Taxes PayrollTaxesGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $58,064 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $58,064 | ProgramServicesAmt |
Fees For Services Lobbying FeesForServicesLobbyingGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $156 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $156 | ProgramServicesAmt |
Fees For Services Other FeesForServicesOtherGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $87,780 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $36,158 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $19,783 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
| Fundraising | $31,839 | FundraisingAmt |
Advertising AdvertisingGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $2,012 | TotalAmt |
| Management And General | $1,781 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
| Fundraising | $231 | FundraisingAmt |
Office Expenses OfficeExpensesGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $5,140 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $2,589 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $2,000 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
| Fundraising | $551 | FundraisingAmt |
Information Technology InformationTechnologyGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $60 | TotalAmt |
| Fundraising | $60 | FundraisingAmt |
Occupancy OccupancyGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $46,917 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $37,855 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $3,952 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
| Fundraising | $5,110 | FundraisingAmt |
Travel TravelGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $616 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $616 | ProgramServicesAmt |
Conferences Meetings ConferencesMeetingsGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $1,215 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $148 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $768 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
| Fundraising | $299 | FundraisingAmt |
Interest InterestGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $2,778 | TotalAmt |
| Management And General | $815 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
| Fundraising | $1,963 | FundraisingAmt |
Depreciation Depletion DepreciationDepletionGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $3,687 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $3,134 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $184 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
| Fundraising | $369 | FundraisingAmt |
Insurance InsuranceGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $3,612 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $1,592 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $1,869 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
| Fundraising | $151 | FundraisingAmt |
Other Expenses OtherExpensesGrp (4 entries)
| DescDesc | TotalTotalAmt | Program ServicesProgramServicesAmt | Management And GeneralManagementAndGeneralAmt | FundraisingFundraisingAmt |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| LEGAL DUES AND PUBLICAT | $95,747 | $95,747 | ||
| EQUIPMENT RENT AND MAIN | $24,844 | $17,376 | $5,285 | $2,183 |
| CREDIT CARD AND BANK FE | $13,122 | $3,664 | $7,988 | $1,470 |
| TELEPHONE AND INTERNET | $9,053 | $5,655 | $1,559 | $1,839 |
All Other Expenses AllOtherExpensesGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $20,067 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $4,306 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $9,824 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
| Fundraising | $5,937 | FundraisingAmt |
Total Functional Expenses TotalFunctionalExpensesGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $1,214,022 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $956,860 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $198,816 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
| Fundraising | $58,346 | FundraisingAmt |
Cash Non Interest Bearing CashNonInterestBearingGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| EOY | $1 | EOYAmt |
Savings And Temp Cash Invst SavingsAndTempCashInvstGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $1,478,325 | BOYAmt |
| EOY | $1,143,646 | EOYAmt |
Prepaid Expenses Defrd Charges PrepaidExpensesDefrdChargesGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $2,163 | BOYAmt |
| EOY | $10,482 | EOYAmt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Land Bldg Equip Cost Or Other Bss | $50,978 | LandBldgEquipCostOrOtherBssAmt |
| Land Bldg Equip Accum Deprec | $39,547 | LandBldgEquipAccumDeprecAmt |
Land Bldg Equip Basis Net LandBldgEquipBasisNetGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $10,094 | BOYAmt |
| EOY | $11,431 | EOYAmt |
Investments Other Securities InvestmentsOtherSecuritiesGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $413,225 | BOYAmt |
| EOY | $479,253 | EOYAmt |
Total Assets TotalAssetsGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $1,903,807 | BOYAmt |
| EOY | $1,644,813 | EOYAmt |
Accounts Payable Accr Expnss AccountsPayableAccrExpnssGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $741 | BOYAmt |
| EOY | $741 | EOYAmt |
Deferred Revenue DeferredRevenueGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $149,655 | BOYAmt |
Other Liabilities OtherLiabilitiesGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $52,006 | BOYAmt |
| EOY | $70,042 | EOYAmt |
Total Liabilities TotalLiabilitiesGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $202,402 | BOYAmt |
| EOY | $70,783 | EOYAmt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Organization Follows FASB117 | Yes (X) | OrganizationFollowsFASB117Ind |
No Donor Restriction Net Assets NoDonorRestrictionNetAssetsGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $1,385,341 | BOYAmt |
| EOY | $1,574,030 | EOYAmt |
Donor Restriction Net Assets DonorRestrictionNetAssetsGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $316,064 | BOYAmt |
| EOY | $0 | EOYAmt |
Total Net Assets Fund Balance TotalNetAssetsFundBalanceGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $1,701,405 | BOYAmt |
| EOY | $1,574,030 | EOYAmt |
Tot Liab Net Assets Fund Balance TotLiabNetAssetsFundBalanceGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $1,903,807 | BOYAmt |
| EOY | $1,644,813 | EOYAmt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Reconcilation Revenue Expnss | -$153,968 | ReconcilationRevenueExpnssAmt |
| Net Unrlzd Gains Losses Invst | $26,593 | NetUnrlzdGainsLossesInvstAmt |
| Other Changes In Net Assets | $0 | OtherChangesInNetAssetsAmt |
| Method Of Accounting Accrual | Yes (X) | MethodOfAccountingAccrualInd |
| Accountant Compile Or Review | 0 | AccountantCompileOrReviewInd |
| FS Audited | Yes (1) | FSAuditedInd |
FS Audited Basis FSAuditedBasisGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Separate Basis Fincl Stmt | Yes (X) | SeparateBasisFinclStmtInd |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Audit Committee | Yes (1) | AuditCommitteeInd |
| Federal Grant Audit Required | 0 | FederalGrantAuditRequiredInd |
Schedule A IRS990ScheduleA
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Public Organization170 | Yes (X) | PublicOrganization170Ind |
Gifts Grants Contri Rcvd170 GiftsGrantsContriRcvd170Grp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Current Tax Year Minus4 Years | $1,018,643 | CurrentTaxYearMinus4YearsAmt |
| Current Tax Year Minus3 Years | $1,043,633 | CurrentTaxYearMinus3YearsAmt |
| Current Tax Year Minus2 Years | $1,401,296 | CurrentTaxYearMinus2YearsAmt |
| Current Tax Year Minus1 Year | $1,161,823 | CurrentTaxYearMinus1YearAmt |
| Current Tax Year | $1,038,195 | CurrentTaxYearAmt |
| Total | $5,663,590 | TotalAmt |
Total Calendar Year170 TotalCalendarYear170Grp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Current Tax Year Minus4 Years | $1,018,643 | CurrentTaxYearMinus4YearsAmt |
| Current Tax Year Minus3 Years | $1,043,633 | CurrentTaxYearMinus3YearsAmt |
| Current Tax Year Minus2 Years | $1,401,296 | CurrentTaxYearMinus2YearsAmt |
| Current Tax Year Minus1 Year | $1,161,823 | CurrentTaxYearMinus1YearAmt |
| Current Tax Year | $1,038,195 | CurrentTaxYearAmt |
| Total | $5,663,590 | TotalAmt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Substantial Contributors Tot | $528,732 | SubstantialContributorsTotAmt |
| Public Support Total170 | $5,134,858 | PublicSupportTotal170Amt |
Gross Investment Income170 GrossInvestmentIncome170Grp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Current Tax Year Minus4 Years | $3,125 | CurrentTaxYearMinus4YearsAmt |
| Current Tax Year Minus3 Years | $9,375 | CurrentTaxYearMinus3YearsAmt |
| Current Tax Year Minus2 Years | $11,949 | CurrentTaxYearMinus2YearsAmt |
| Current Tax Year Minus1 Year | $29,032 | CurrentTaxYearMinus1YearAmt |
| Current Tax Year | $9,337 | CurrentTaxYearAmt |
| Total | $62,818 | TotalAmt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total Support | $5,726,408 | TotalSupportAmt |
| Public Support CY170 | 0.89670 | PublicSupportCY170Pct |
| Public Support PY170 | 0.90550 | PublicSupportPY170Pct |
| Thirty Thr Pct Suprt Tests CY170 | Yes (X) | ThirtyThrPctSuprtTestsCY170Ind |
Schedule B IRS990ScheduleB
Contributor Information ContributorInformationGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Contributor | RESTRICTED | ContributorNum |
Contributor Business Name ContributorBusinessName
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Business Name Line1 | RESTRICTED | BusinessNameLine1 |
Contributor US Address ContributorUSAddress
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Address Line1 | RESTRICTED | AddressLine1 |
| Address Line2 | RESTRICTED | AddressLine2 |
| City | RESTRICTED | City |
| State | RESTRICTED | State |
| ZIP Code | RESTRICTED | ZIPCode |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total Contributions | RESTRICTED | TotalContributionsAmt |
Schedule C IRS990ScheduleC
Total Direct Lobbying TotalDirectLobbyingGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Filing Organizations Total | $6,393 | FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt |
Total Lobbying Expend TotalLobbyingExpendGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Filing Organizations Total | $6,393 | FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt |
Other Exempt Purpose Expend OtherExemptPurposeExpendGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Filing Organizations Total | $1,207,629 | FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt |
Total Exempt Purpose Expend TotalExemptPurposeExpendGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Filing Organizations Total | $1,214,022 | FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt |
Lobbying Nontaxable Amount LobbyingNontaxableAmountGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Filing Organizations Total | $196,402 | FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt |
Grassroots Nontaxable GrassrootsNontaxableGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Filing Organizations Total | $49,101 | FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt |
Tot Lbbyng Grassroot Mns Non Tx TotLbbyngGrassrootMnsNonTxGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Filing Organizations Total | $0 | FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt |
Tot Lbby Expend Mns Lbbyng Non Tx TotLbbyExpendMnsLbbyngNonTxGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Filing Organizations Total | $0 | FilingOrganizationsTotalAmt |
Avg Lobbying Nontaxable Amount AvgLobbyingNontaxableAmountGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Current Year Minus3 | $182,347 | CurrentYearMinus3Amt |
| Current Year Minus2 | $187,773 | CurrentYearMinus2Amt |
| Current Year Minus1 | $181,380 | CurrentYearMinus1Amt |
| Current Year | $196,402 | CurrentYearAmt |
| Total | $747,902 | TotalAmt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Lobbying Ceiling | $1,121,853 | LobbyingCeilingAmt |
Avg Total Lobbying Expend AvgTotalLobbyingExpendGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Current Year Minus3 | $8,426 | CurrentYearMinus3Amt |
| Current Year Minus2 | $13,599 | CurrentYearMinus2Amt |
| Current Year Minus1 | $16,032 | CurrentYearMinus1Amt |
| Current Year | $6,393 | CurrentYearAmt |
| Total | $44,450 | TotalAmt |
Avg Grassroots Nontaxable AvgGrassrootsNontaxableGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Current Year Minus3 | $45,587 | CurrentYearMinus3Amt |
| Current Year Minus2 | $46,943 | CurrentYearMinus2Amt |
| Current Year Minus1 | $45,345 | CurrentYearMinus1Amt |
| Current Year | $49,101 | CurrentYearAmt |
| Total | $186,976 | TotalAmt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Grassroots Ceiling | $280,464 | GrassrootsCeilingAmt |
Schedule D IRS990ScheduleD
Buildings BuildingsGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Other Cost Or Other Basis | $3,495 | OtherCostOrOtherBasisAmt |
| Depreciation | $1,550 | DepreciationAmt |
| Book Value | $1,945 | BookValueAmt |
Equipment EquipmentGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Other Cost Or Other Basis | $33,003 | OtherCostOrOtherBasisAmt |
| Depreciation | $30,828 | DepreciationAmt |
| Book Value | $2,175 | BookValueAmt |
Other Land Buildings OtherLandBuildingsGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Other Cost Or Other Basis | $14,480 | OtherCostOrOtherBasisAmt |
| Depreciation | $7,169 | DepreciationAmt |
| Book Value | $7,311 | BookValueAmt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total Book Value Land Buildings | $11,431 | TotalBookValueLandBuildingsAmt |
Other Securities OtherSecuritiesGrp (2 entries)
| DescDesc | Book ValueBookValueAmt | Method ValuationMethodValuationCd |
|---|---|---|
| MUTUAL FUNDS | $417,561 | F |
| STOCKS | $61,692 | F |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total Book Value Securities | $479,253 | TotalBookValueSecuritiesAmt |
Other Liabilities Org OtherLiabilitiesOrgGrp (3 entries)
| DescDesc | AmtAmt |
|---|---|
| PAYROLL LIABILITIES | $26,364 |
| COMPENSATED ABSENSES PAYABLE | $41,416 |
| CLIENT TRUST LIABILITY | $2,262 |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total Liability | $70,042 | TotalLiabilityAmt |
| Footnote Text | Yes (X) | FootnoteTextInd |
| Total Rev Etc Audited Fincl Stmt | $1,082,983 | TotalRevEtcAuditedFinclStmtAmt |
| Net Unrealized Gains Invst | $26,593 | NetUnrealizedGainsInvstAmt |
| Revenue Not Reported | $26,593 | RevenueNotReportedAmt |
| Revenue Subtotal | $1,056,390 | RevenueSubtotalAmt |
| Other Revenues Not Included | $3,664 | OtherRevenuesNotIncludedAmt |
| Revenue Not Reported Fincl Stmt | $3,664 | RevenueNotReportedFinclStmtAmt |
| Total Revenue Per Form990 | $1,060,054 | TotalRevenuePerForm990Amt |
| Tot Expns Etc Audited Fincl Stmt | $1,210,358 | TotExpnsEtcAuditedFinclStmtAmt |
| Expenses Not Reported | $0 | ExpensesNotReportedAmt |
| Expenses Subtotal | $1,210,358 | ExpensesSubtotalAmt |
| Other Expenses Not Included | $3,664 | OtherExpensesNotIncludedAmt |
| Expenses Not Rpt Fincl Stmt | $3,664 | ExpensesNotRptFinclStmtAmt |
| Total Expenses Per Form990 | $1,214,022 | TotalExpensesPerForm990Amt |
Supplemental Information Detail SupplementalInformationDetail (3 entries)
| Form And Line ReferenceFormAndLineReferenceDesc | ExplanationExplanationTxt |
|---|---|
| PART X, LINE 2: | THE LAW CENTER HAS BEEN CLASSIFIED AS AN OTHER-THAN PRIVATE FOUNDATION AND IS TAX-EXEMPT UNDER SECTION 501(C)(3) OF THE INTERNAL REVENUE CODE, ALTHOUGH SUBJECT TO TAX ON INCOME FROM UNRELATED BUSINESS. ON JANUARY 1, 2009, THE LAW CENTER ADOPTED THE RECOGNITION REQUIREMENTS FOR UNCERTAIN INCOME TAX POSITIONS AS REQUIRED BY GENERALLY ACCEPTED ACCOUNTING PRINCIPALS, WITH NO CUMULATIVE EFFECT ADJUSTMENT REQUIRED. AS OF DECEMBER 31, 2021, TAX YEARS 2018 THROUGH 2020 REMAIN SUBJECT TO EXAMINATION BY MAJOR TAX JURISDICTIONS. |
| PART XI, LINE 4B - OTHER ADJUSTMENTS: | INVESTMENT FEES INCLUDED WITH REVENUES ON THE STATEMENT OF ACTIVITIES 3,664. |
| PART XII, LINE 4B - OTHER ADJUSTMENTS: | INVESTMENT FEES INCLUDED WITH REVENUES ON THE STATEMENT OF ACTIVITIES 3,664. |
Schedule O IRS990ScheduleO
Supplemental Information Detail SupplementalInformationDetail (13 entries)
| Form And Line ReferenceFormAndLineReferenceDesc | ExplanationExplanationTxt |
|---|---|
| FORM 990, PART VI, SECTION A, LINE 6 | MEMBERS PAY DUES TO SUPPORT THE LAW CENTER IN PROTECTING NEW MEXICO'S NATURAL ENVIRONMENT AND DIVERSE COMMUNITIES. IN RETURN FOR THEIR DUES, MEMBERS RECEIVE PUBLICATIONS REGARDING NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES AND UPDATED ENVIRONMENTAL NEWS VIA THE WEB SITE. |
| FORM 990, PART VI, SECTION B, LINE 11B | FORM 990 IS REVIEWED WITH THE FINANCE COMMITTEE PRIOR TO FILING. A COPY OF THE 990 IS PROVIDED TO EACH MEMBER OF THE GOVERNING BOARD. THE FINANCE COMMITTEE REPORTS ON THE SUBSTANCE OF THE FORM TO THE BOARD. |
| FORM 990, PART VI, SECTION B, LINE 12C | ALL MEMBERS OF THE GOVERNING BODY AND MANAGEMENT ARE KEENLY AWARE OF THE CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY. POTENTIAL CONFLICTS ARE DISCUSSED AT BOARD MEETINGS AND ANYONE WITH A POTENTIAL CONFLICT IS RECUSED. |
| FORM 990, PART VI, SECTION B, LINE 15 | THE ORGANIZATION CONDUCTS A REVIEW OF THE SALARIES PAID BY OTHER ORGANIZATIONS TO MAKE SURE THAT THE ORGANIZATION'S SALARIES ARE COMPARABLE FOR COMPARABLE POSITIONS. THE REVIEW IS CONDUCTED ON AN ANNUAL BASIS AS PART OF THE BUDGET PREPARATION PROCESS FOR THE FOLLOWING FISCAL YEAR. DUE TO THE TIME COMMITTMENT REQUIRED TO CONDUCT SALARY REVIEWS, TO OBTAIN THE INFORMATION NECESSARY TO CONDUCT SALARY REVIEWS, THE ORGANIZATION USUALLY PARTICIPATES IN ANNUAL SALARY INFORMATION SURVEYS SO THAT THE ORGANIZATION CAN RECEIVE COPIES OF THE RESULTS. COPIES OF THAT DOCUMENTATION IS RETAINED FOR SEVERAL YEARS. A LEVEL OF COMPENSATION FOR EACH STAFF POSITION IS PROPOSED FOR THE FOLLOWING FISCAL YEAR AND IS USUALLY PHRASED IN TERMS OF A PROPOSED RAISE OVER THE EXISTING SALARY FOR THAT POSITION. THAT PROPOSAL IS DISCUSSED WITH THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS DURING AN EXECUTIVE SESSION THAT IS HELD DURING THE BOARD MEETING AT WHICH THE ANNUAL BUDGET IS ADOPTED. THE DELIBERATIONS DURING ECECUTIVE SESSIONS ARE NOT DOCUMENTED. THE SALARY PACKAGE IS VOTED UPON BY THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS AT THAT MEETING AS PART OF THE BOARD'S APPROVAL OF THE BUDGET. THE APPROVAL IS DOCUMENTED IN THE MINUTES. |
| FORM 990, PART VI, SECTION C, LINE 19 | GOVERNING DOCUMENTS, CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY AND AUDITED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS ARE MADE AVAILABLE TO THE PUBLIC UPON REQUEST. |
| FORM 990 - PUBLIC INTEREST LAW FIRM STATUS OF CASES IN LITIGATION | NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER CASES IN LITIGATION DURING 2021 FISCAL YEAR (JANUARY 1, 2021 - DECEMBER 31, 2021) CASE #1 AMIGOS BRAVOS V. NEW MEXICO WATER QUALITY CONTROL COMMISSION NEW MEXICO COURT OF APPEALS, A-1-CA-37531 BACKGROUND: THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENT DEPARTMENT ("NMED") FILED ITS PETITION TO AMEND THE GROUND AND SURFACE WATER PROTECTION REGULATIONS (20.6.2 NMAC) ("PETITION") ON MAY 1, 2017, IN WHICH IT PROPOSED A NEW VARIANCE RULE FROM THE WATER QUALITY REGULATIONS. THE EXISTING VARIANCE RULE WAS LIMITED TO A FIVE-YEAR TERM, WITH A MANDATORY PUBLIC HEARING TO BE HELD FOR A VARIANCE RENEWAL OR EXTENSION. THE NEW RULE PROPOSED REMOVAL OF THE FIVE-YEAR TERM LIMIT, EXTENDING THE VARIANCE TERM TO "THE LIFE OF A FACILITY", OR IN OTHER WORDS, PERPETUITY. THE NEW RULE ALSO PROPOSED TO REMOVE THE MANDATORY PUBLIC HEARING FOR VARIANCE RENEWALS AND EXTENSIONS. THE COMMISSION HELD A PUBLIC RULEMAKING HEARING IN SANTA FE, NEW MEXICO ON NMED'S PETITION OVER THE COURSE OF FOUR DAYS, FROM NOVEMBER 14, 2017 THROUGH NOVEMBER 17, 2017. THE COMMISSION BEGAN DELIBERATIONS ON NMED'S PROPOSED VARIANCE RULE ON JULY 10, 2018. THE COMMISSION DECIDED TO ADOPT NMED'S PROPOSED VARIANCE RULE, REMOVING THE CURRENT FIVE-YEAR LIMIT ON VARIANCES AND THE MANDATORY PUBLIC HEARING HELD EVERY FIVE YEARS FOR VARIANCE RENEWALS AND MODIFICATIONS. THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER'S CLIENTS, AMIGOS BRAVOS AND GILA RESOURCES INFORMATION PROJECT (COLLECTIVELY, AB/GRIP), APPEALED THE COMMISSION'S NEWLY ADOPTED VARIANCE RULE WITH THE NEW MEXICO COURT OF APPEALS ON AUGUST 9, 2018. BRIEFING WAS COMPLETED IN 2020. ON AUGUST 31, 2021, THE COURT OF APPEALS UPHELD THE WQCC'S DECISION AND OUR CLIENTS CHOSE NOT TO PETITION THE STATE SUPREME COURT FOR CERTIORARI AND THE LAW CENTER CLOSED THE CASE. PUBLIC INTEREST: THIS CASE TOUCHES ON BOTH PROCEDURAL ISSUES WITH RULEMAKING PROCEEDINGS IN GENERAL, AND SUBSTANTIVE ISSUES CONCERNING VIOLATION OF THE NEW MEXICO WATER QUALITY ACT AND POLLUTION OF NEW MEXICO'S MOST PRECIOUS PUBLIC RESOURCE - GROUNDWATER. AB/GRIP'S PROCEDURAL CONCERNS WITH THE COMMISSION'S ADOPTION OF THE NEW VARIANCE RULE ARE: 1) THE COMMISSION'S FAILURE TO PROVIDE PUBLIC NOTICE OF ITS ACTION AND A CONCISE EXPLANATORY STATEMENT, AND 2) THE COMMISSION'S FAILURE TO FILE THE NEWLY ADOPTED RULE WITHIN FIFTEEN (15) DAYS OF THE RULE'S ADOPTION WITH THE STATE RECORDS ADMINISTRATOR. AB/GRIP'S SUBSTANTIVE CONCERNS WITH THE COMMISSION'S ADOPTION OF THE NEW VARIANCE RULE ARE THAT THE ISSUANCE OF VARIANCES "FOR THE LIFE OF A FACILITY" VIOLATES THE 1) NEW MEXICO WATER QUALITY ACT'S ("WATER QUALITY ACT OR "ACT") PURPOSE TO PREVENT AND ABATE GROUND WATER POLLUTION, 2) THE ACT'S REQUIREMENT THAT ABATEMENT OF GROUND WATER POLLUTION OCCUR WITHIN A REASONABLE PERIOD OF TIME, AND 3) THE ACT'S MANDATORY PUBLIC HEARING REQUIREMENTS FOR VARIANCE ISSUANCE, RENEWAL AND MODIFICATION PETITIONS. ADDITIONALLY, THE COMMISSION'S NEW VARIANCE RULE MAY BE AN UNLAWFUL DELEGATION OF AUTHORITY TO A CONSTITUENT AGENCY AND MAY EXCEED THE COMMISSION'S AUTHORITY UNDER THE ACT. AB/GRIP ARE ULTIMATELY CONCERNED THAT THE COMMISSION'S NEWLY ADOPTED VARIANCE RULE WOULD UNDO OVER THIRTY-SIX (36) YEARS OF GROUND WATER PROTECTION IN NEW MEXICO BY AUTHORIZING, THROUGH RULE, THE ISSUANCE OF LIFE-TIME VARIANCES, WHICH ALLOW INDUSTRIES TO POLLUTE OUR MOST PRECIOUS PUBLIC RESOURCE IN PERPETUITY. THE COMMISSION'S RADICAL SHIFT IN ITS INTERPRETATION AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE ACT'S PURPOSE AND VARIANCE PROVISION COMES AT A TIME WHEN IT IS MORE CRITICAL THAN EVER TO PROTECT NEW MEXICO'S SCARCE WATER RESOURCES. ATTORNEYS' FEES: THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER HAS NEITHER SOUGHT NOR RECOVERED ANY ATTORNEYS' FEES FROM AN OPPOSING PARTY IN THIS CASE. CASE #2 AQUIFER SCIENCE, LLC., V. SCOTT VERHINES, NEW MEXICO STATE ENGINEER. NEW MEXICO SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT CASE #CV-2014-07209 BACKGROUND: THIS CASE WAS TRIED IN THE NEW MEXICO DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT. IT WAS AN APPEAL FROM A DECISION OF THE NEW MEXICO STATE ENGINEER DENYING AN APPLICATION FOR WATER USE FROM THE AQUIFER SCIENCE COMPANY TO SUPPLY WATER TO A PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT ON ITS CAMPBELL RANCH PROPERTY. BY STATUTE, THIS WAS A TRIAL DE NOVO (ESSENTIALLY A "DO OVER") ON THE UNDERLYING ISSUES UPON WHICH THE STATE ENGINEER DETERMINED TO DENY THE WATER USE APPLICATION. THE COURT DECIDED IN FAVOR OF OUR CLIENTS BY DISMISSING THE APPEAL. THE DISTRICT COURT ALSO RULED THAT THE AQUIFER SCIENCE COMPANY AND THE STATE ENGINEER ARE JOINTLY AND SEVERALLY LIABLE TO OUR CLIENTS FOR THE EXPENSES THAT THEY INCURRED DURING THE LITIGATION (FOR EXPENSES SUCH AS COPYING, EXPERT WITNESSES, ETC., BUT NOT FOR ATTORNEYS' FEES). THE AQUIFER SCIENCE COMPANY AND THE STATE ENGINEER REQUESTED THAT THE DISTRICT COURT RECONSIDER ITS RULING ON OUR CLIENTS' COSTS, BUT THE DISTRICT COURT DID NOT CHANGE ITS RULINGS ON THOSE COSTS. THERE HAVE BEEN SEVERAL DEVELOPMENTS SINCE THAT RULING. FIRST, THE AQUIFER SCIENCE COMPANY APPEALED BOTH OF THE DISTRICT COURT'S RULINGS - THE RULING DENYING THE AQUIFER SCIENCE COMPANY'S APPLICATION AND THE RULING GRANTING OUR CLIENTS THEIR COSTS - TO THE STATE COURT OF APPEALS. THOSE APPEALS ARE PENDING. SECOND, THE STATE ENGINEER APPEALED THE DISTRICT COURT'S RULING GRANTING OUR CLIENTS THEIR COSTS AGAINST THE STATE ENGINEER. THIRD, WE AND OUR CLIENTS WERE ABLE TO REACH A SETTLEMENT WITH THE STATE ENGINEER. IT INVOLVES: 1) OUR CLIENTS DROPPING THEIR CLAIM FOR COSTS AGAINST THE STATE ENGINEER; 2) THE STATE ENGINEER MAKING A DECISION ABOUT WHETHER TO CLOSE THE GROUND WATER BASIN WHERE OUR CLIENTS' WELLS ARE LOCATED; 3) THE STATE ENGINEER DISMISSING ITS APPEAL TO THE STATE COURT OF APPEALS; AND 4) OUR CLIENTS REIMBURSING THE STATE ENGINEER (FOR A LIMITED AMOUNT) IF THE AQUIFER SCIENCE COMPANY HAS TO PAY OUR CLIENTS' COSTS AND THE AQUIFER SCIENCE COMPANY THEN IS ABLE TO REQUIRE THAT THE STATE ENGINEER PAY PART OF WHAT THE AQUIFER SCIENCE COMPANY HAD TO PAY OUR CLIENTS. ALL OF THE CONDITIONS OF THE SETTLEMENT HAVE BEEN FULFILLED EXCEPT THE LAST ONE BECAUSE THE ISSUE OF WHETHER THE AQUIFER SCIENCE COMPANY WILL HAVE TO PAY OUR CLIENTS THEIR COSTS IS STILL BEING LITIGATED IN THE STATE COURT OF APPEALS. PUBLIC INTEREST: THE PUBLIC INTEREST HERE IS IN PROTECTING THE WATER SUPPLIES OF PERSONS WHO OBTAIN WATER FROM THE SANDIA BASIN--WHICH THE STATE ENGINEER DECLARED TO BE CLOSED TO FURTHER DEVELOPMENT, AS ALL WATER RIGHTS WITHIN IT HAVE BEEN PREVIOUSLY ALLOCATED AND ARE USED. THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER REPRESENTS TWO GROUPS OF CITIZENS FROM AREAS ADJACENT TO THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT WHOSE USABLE WATER WOULD BE THREATENED BY AQUIFER SCIENCE, LLC BEING ALLOWED TO PUMP WATER FOR ITS DEVELOPMENT. THE CASE ALSO APPEARS TO BE A SPECULATIVE VENTURE FOR THE PROPONENTS OF THE DEVELOPMENT RATHER THAN AN ATTEMPT TO OBTAIN A WATER RIGHT THAT WOULD BE PUT TO BENEFICIAL USE. HERE, THE PURPOSE APPEARS TO BE TO UPGRADE THE VALUE OF THE PROPERTY WITH WATER RIGHT IN ORDER TO MAKE IT MARKETABLE. ATTORNEYS' FEES: THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER HAS NEITHER SOUGHT NOR RECOVERED ATTORNEYS' FEES FROM AN OPPOSING PARTY IN THIS CASE. |
| FORM 990 - PUBLIC INTEREST LAW FIRM STATUS OF CASES IN LITIGATION, CONTINUE | CASE #3 AUGUSTIN PLAINS RANCH, LLC V. TOM BLAINE, P.E. FORMERLY NEW MEXICO SEVENTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT, D-728-CV-XXX-XX-XXXX; NOW NEW MEXICO COURT OF APPEALS CASE #A-1-CA-38615. BACKGROUND: THE AUGUSTIN PLAINS RANCH, LLC ("APR") SUBMITTED A MATERIALLY IDENTICAL APPLICATION TO APPROPRIATE 54,000 ACRE FEET OF WATER ANNUALLY FROM THE SAN AGUSTIN BASIN FOR THE PURPOSES OF "MUNICIPAL AND "COMMERCIAL SALES" WITH THE NEW MEXICO OFFICE OF THE STATE ENGINEER. APR PREVIOUSLY SUBMITTED AN APPLICATION IN 2007 WITH THE OFFICE OF THE STATE ENGINEER THAT WAS ULTIMATELY DENIED BY THE STATE ENGINEER IN 2011. THAT DENIAL WAS UPHELD BY THE NEW MEXICO SEVENTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT IN 2012. APR FILED AN APPEAL OF THAT DECISION IN 2012 WITH THE COURT OF APPEALS, WHICH WAS ULTIMATELY DISMISSED. APR ALSO FILED A MATERIALLY IDENTICAL APPLICATION IN 2014. THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER REPRESENTS ABOUT 80 WATER USERS IN THE SAN AGUSTIN BASIN OPPOSING APR'S APPLICATION. THEY ARE: GLADYS BACA; ROBERT AND MONA BASSETT; PATTI BEARPAW; SUE BERRY-FOX; ANN BOULDEN; DONALD AND JOAN BROOKS; JACK BRUTON AND BRUTON RANCH, LLC; LISA BURROUGHS AND THOMAS BETRAS, JR.; CHARLES AND LUCY CLOYES; MICHAEL D. CODINI, JR.; RANDY COIL; JAMES AND JANET COLEMAN; TERRI COOK; THOMAS A. COOK; WILDWOOD HIGHLANDS LANDOWNERS ASSOCIATION AND ITS MEMBERS; RANDY COX; NANCY CROWLEY; TOM CSURILLA AND ELK RIDGE PASS DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, LLC AND TOP OF THE WORLD LAND COMPANY, LLC; ROGER AND JEANNE DAIGGER; MICHAEL AND ANN DANIELSON; BRYAN AND BEVERLEY DEES; JOHN AND EILEEN DODDS; LOUISE AND LEONARD DONAHE; PATRICIA EBERHARDT; ROY FARR; PAUL AND ROSE GEASLAND; GILA CONSERVATION COALITION, CENTER FOR BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY AND GILA WATERSHED ALLIANCE; MARY RAKESTRAW GREIERT; MICHAEL HASSON; DON AND CHERYL HASTINGS; GARY AND CAROL HEGG; PATRICIA HENRY; CATHERINE HILL; ERIC HOFSTETTER; SANDY HOW; M. IAN AND MARGREET JENNESS; AMOS LAFON; MARIE LEE; CLEDA LENHARDT; RICK AND PATRICIA LINDSEY; VICTORIA LINEHAN; OWEN LORENTZEN; MIKE LOYA; SONIA MACDONALD; ROBERT AND SUSAN MACKENZIE; DOUGLAS MARABLE; THEA MARSHALL; SAM AND KRISTIN MCCAIN; JEFF MCGUIRE; MICHAEL MIDEKE; KENNETH MROCZEK AND JANICE PRZYLBYL MROCZEK; PETER NAUMNIK; JOHN NAUMNIK; REGINA NAUMNIK; ROBERT NELSON; VERONIKA NELSON; WALTER AND DIANE OLMSTEAD; KARL PADGETT; MAX PADGET; LEO PADGETT; PATRICIA PADGETT; WANDA PARKER; RAY AND CAROL PITTMAN; JOHN PRESTON AND PATRICIA MURRAY PRESTON; DANIEL RAEL; STEPHANIE RANDOLPH; MARY KATHERINE RAY; KENNETH ROWE; KEVIN AND PRISCILLA RYAN; RAY AND KATHY SANSOM; CHRISTOPHER SCOTT SANSOM; JOHN AND BETTY SCHAEFER; SUSAN SCHUDARDT; JANICE SIMMONS; JIM SONNENBERG; ANNE SULLIVAN; MARGARET AND ROGER THOMPSON; GLORIA WEINRICH; JAMES WETZIG AND MAUREEN M. MACART; DONALD AND MARGARET WILTSHIRE; AND THE FOLLOWING TWO ASSOCIATIONS AND THEIR MEMBERS: HOMESTEAD LANDOWNERS ASSOCIATION AND ITS MEMBERS, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE FOLLOWING: JOSEPH AND JANET SIOMIAK, PATRICIA GERMAIN, BETTE DUGIE, JONATHAN BENEDICT, MICHAEL MURRAY, JOHN POHL, PARKER FILLION, BARBARA OWENS; AND ABBE SPRINGS HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION AND ITS MEMBERS, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE FOLLOWING: RAVEN REITSTETTER, NANCY CROWLEY, CHRIS AND HELEN DOSSETT, KRISTIN EKVALL, KENNETH AND DIANA FRY, ALBERT GOODMAN, WILLIAM GYSIN, JEFF MCGUIRE, ROZALYN MURPHY, JANICE SIMMONS, RONALD WILSON, PAUL G. KOTULA, KARL AND JANE MEARS, THOMAS AND LINDA PAMPINELLA, DAVID P. SMITH, CARMELA L. WARNER, LISA BURROUGHS, AND TOM BETRAS. THE OFFICE OF THE STATE ENGINEER HELD A HEARING ON APR'S 2014 APPLICATION ON DECEMBER 13, 2017. THE STATE ENGINEER DENIED APR'S APPLICATION PRIMARILY ON THE BASIS THAT IT WAS SPECULATIVE. APR FILED AN APPEAL OF THE STATE ENGINEER'S DENIAL WITH THE NEW MEXICO SEVENTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT ON OCTOBER 3, 2018. ON AUGUST 23, 2019, THE SEVENTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT AFFIRMED THE STATE ENGINEER'S DENIAL OF THE APR APPLICATION. APR HAS APPEALED THAT RULING TO THE NEW MEXICO COURT OF APPEALS. THE STATE COURT OF APPEALS OVERTURNED THE DISTRICT COURT DECISION REGARDING ONE OF ITS BASES FOR ITS DECISION. THE CLIENT GROUP WAS SPLIT UP WITH ANOTHER ATTORNEY, UNAFFILIATED WITH THE LAW CENTER, WHO FILED A PETITION FOR CERTIORARI TO THE NEW MEXICO SUPREME COURT. APR AND CATRON COUNTY FILED PETITIONS FOR CERTIORARI TO THE NEW MEXICO SUPREME COURT AS WELL. ON OCTOBER 28, 2022, THE SUPREME COURT DENIED ALL THREE PETITIONS FOR CERTIORARI, MEANING THAT THE CASE WILL BE RETURNED TO THE DISTRICT COURT FOR ADDITIONAL LITIGATION, LIKELY IN 2023. . PUBLIC INTEREST: GROUND WATER IN NEW MEXICO "BELONGS TO THE PUBLIC." NMSA 1978, 72-12-1 (2003). OUR STATE'S GROUND WATER DOES NOT BELONG TO THE OWNERS OF PRIVATE PROPERTY ABOVE GROUND WATER. ALTHOUGH INDIVIDUALS AND ENTITIES MAY USE GROUND WATER FOR "BENEFICIAL USE," SUBJECT TO APPROPRIATE AUTHORIZATION FROM THE STATE, ID., GROUND WATER IN NEW MEXICO IS A PUBLIC RESOURCE TO BE PROTECTED. ADDITIONALLY, THE CONSTITUTION DECLARES THAT "WATER AND OTHER NATURAL RESOURCES OF THIS STATE" ARE "OF FUNDAMENTAL IMPORTANCE TO THE PUBLIC INTEREST, HEALTH, SAFETY AND THE GENERAL WELFARE." N.M. CONST. ART. XX, 21. PUBLIC WATER IN NEW MEXICO IS HELD IN TRUST BY THE STATE FOR THE BENEFIT OF THE PUBLIC. NEW MEXICO V. G.E., 467 F.3D 1223, 1243 (10TH CIR. 2006). THIS CASE DEALS WITH THE PUBLIC INTEREST REGARDING GROUNDWATER APPROPRIATIONS, AS WELL AS THE PROTECTION OF TRADITIONAL WAYS OF LIFE IN RURAL NEW MEXICO. IF APR IS SUCCESSFUL AND ITS APPLICATION IS ULTIMATELY APPROVED, OVER 17 BILLION GALLONS OF WATER WILL BE TRANSPORTED OUT OF THE SAN AGUSTIN PLAINS, A TRADITIONAL RURAL COMMUNITY, TO THE GREATER ALBUQUERQUE METRO AREA FOR FURTHER DEVELOPMENT OF NEW MEXICO'S LARGEST CITY. ATTORNEYS' FEES: THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER HAS NEITHER SOUGHT NOR RECOVERED ANY ATTORNEYS' FEES FROM AN OPPOSING PARTY IN THIS CASE. |
| FORM 990 - PUBLIC INTEREST LAW FIRM STATUS OF CASES IN LITIGATION, CONTINUE | CASES #4, #5, #6, #7, AND #8 THE FOLLOWING FIVE CASES RELATE TO THE PROPOSED SANTOLINA DEVELOPMENT. CASE #4 JAVIER BENAVIDEZ, JAMES SANTIAGO MAESTAS, ROBERTO ROIBAL, SOUTHWEST ORGANIZING PROJECT, NEW MEXICO HEALTH EQUITY WORKING GROUP, AND PAJARITO VILLAGE ASSOCIATION V. BERNALILLO COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, AND ART DE LA CRUZ, WAYNE JOHNSON, DEBBIE O'MALLEY, MAGGIE HART STEBBINS, AND LONNIE TALBERT, BERNALILLO COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, AND CONSENSUS PLANNING, INC. AND WESTERN ALBUQUERQUE LAND HOLDINGS, LLC NEW MEXICO COURT OF APPEALS, A-1-CA-36979, FORMERLY SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT CASE D-202-CV-2015-04466 AND CASE D-202-CV-2015-05363, WHICH WERE CONSOLIDATED. CASE #5 JAVIER BENAVIDEZ, JAMES SANTIAGO MAESTAS, ROBERTO ROIBAL, SOUTHWEST ORGANIZING PROJECT, NEW MEXICO HEALTH EQUITY WORKING GROUP, AND PAJARITO VILLAGE ASSOCIATION V. BERNALILLO COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, AND ART DE LA CRUZ, WAYNE JOHNSON, DEBBIE O'MALLEY, MAGGIE HART STEBBINS, AND LONNIE TALBERT, BERNALILLO COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, AND CONSENSUS PLANNING, INC. AND WESTERN ALBUQUERQUE LAND HOLDINGS, LLC NEW MEXICO COURT OF APPEALS, A-1-CA-37051, FORMERLY SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT CASE D-202-CV-2015-04466 AND CASE D-202-CV-2015-05363, WHICH WERE CONSOLIDATED CASE #6 JAVIER BENAVIDEZ, JAMES SANTIAGO MAESTAS, ROBERTO ROIBAL, SOUTHWEST ORGANIZING PROJECT, NEW MEXICO HEALTH EQUITY WORKING GROUP, AND PAJARITO VILLAGE ASSOCIATION V. BERNALILLO COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, AND ART DE LA CRUZ, WAYNE JOHNSON, DEBBIE O'MALLEY, MAGGIE HART STEBBINS, AND LONNIE TALBERT, BERNALILLO COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, AND CONSENSUS PLANNING, INC. AND WESTERN ALBUQUERQUE LAND HOLDINGS, LLC NEW MEXICO COURT OF APPEALS, A-1-CA-37060, FORMERLY SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT CASE D-202-CV-2015-04466 AND CASE D-202-CV-2015-05363, WHICH WERE CONSOLIDATED CASE #7 SOUTHWEST ORGANIZING PROJECT, NEW MEXICO HEALTH EQUITY WORKING GROUP, PAJARITO VILLAGE ASSOCIATION, DANIEL RICHARD "RIP ANDERSON, MARCIA BEAUREGARD FERNANDEZ, SANTIAGO JAMES MAESTAS, ROD MAHONEY, ROBERTO ROIBAL, AND KRISTINE SUOZZI V. BERNALILLO COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AND THE INDIVIDUAL MEMBERS OF THE COUNTY COMMISSION, WAYNE JOHNSON, DEBBIE O'MALLEY, STEPHEN MICHAEL QUEZADA, MAGGIE HART STEBBINS, AND LONNIE TALBERT, AND WESTERN ALBUQUERQUE LAND HOLDINGS, LLC, AND CONSENSUS PLANNING, INC. NEW MEXICO SUPREME COURT, S-1-SC-39398, FORMERLY NEW MEXICO COURT OF APPEALS, A-1-CA-38717, FORMERLY NEW MEXICO SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT CASE D-202-CV-2017-07037 |
| FORM 990 - PUBLIC INTEREST LAW FIRM STATUS OF CASES IN LITIGATION, CONTINUE | CASE # 8 SOUTHWEST ORGANIZING PROJECT, PAJARITO VILLAGE ASSOCIATION, SOUTH VALLEY COALITION OF NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATIONS, CENTER FOR SOCIAL SUSTAINABLE SYSTEMS, SOUTH VALLEY REGIONAL ASSOCIATION OF ACEQUIAS, DANIEL RICHARD "RIP ANDERSON, MARCIA BEAUREGARD FERNANDEZ, SANTIAGO JAMES MAESTAS, ROD MAHONEY, ROBERTO ROIBAL, DR. VIRGINIA NECOCHEA, AND KRISTINE SUOZZI V. BERNALILLO COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AND THE INDIVIDUAL MEMBERS OF THE COUNTY COMMISSION, WAYNE JOHNSON, DEBBIE O'MALLEY, STEPHEN MICHAEL QUEZADA, MAGGIE HART STEBBINS, AND LONNIE TALBERT, AND WESTERN ALBUQUERQUE LAND HOLDINGS, LLC, AND CONSENSUS PLANNING, INC. NEW MEXICO SUPREME COURT, S-1-SC-39398, FORMERLY NEW MEXICO COURT OF APPEALS, A-1-CA-38742 AND CONSOLIDATED WITH A-1-CA-38717, FORMERLY NEW MEXICO SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT CASE D-202-CV-XXX-XX-XXXX BACKGROUND: THESE FIVE CASES ALL INVOLVE THE PROPOSED SANTOLINA DEVELOPMENT, WHICH IS A PROPOSED PLANNED COMMUNITY THAT, AT FULL BUILD OUT, WOULD BE HOME TO APPROXIMATELY 90,000 PEOPLE ON THE WEST MESA OF ALBUQUERQUE. EACH OF THE CASES WAS FILED IN THE NEW MEXICO SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT BY THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER ON BEHALF OF THE CLIENTS LISTED ABOVE FOR EACH CASE. THE CASES WERE FILED AGAINST THE BERNALILLO COUNTY (NEW MEXICO) BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, THE FIVE INDIVIDUAL MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, AND THE TWO COMPANIES PROMOTING THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT, CONSENSUS PLANNING, INC. AND WESTERN ALBUQUERQUE LAND HOLDINGS, LLC. IN CASES #4, #5, AND #6 THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER'S CLIENTS SOUGHT TO HAVE THE DISTRICT COURT REVIEW AND VACATE THE FOLLOWING FIVE DECISIONS MADE BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS PERTAINING TO THE PROPOSED SANTOLINA DEVELOPMENT: -THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS' DENIAL OF THE APPEAL FILED BY SEVERAL OF THE CLIENTS TO THE BOARD FROM A DETERMINATION OF THE BERNALILLO COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION (THE "PLANNING COMMISSION") RECOMMENDING THAT THE SANTOLINA LEVEL A MASTER PLAN BE APPROVED. -THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS' DENIAL OF THE APPEAL FILED BY SEVERAL OF THE CLIENTS TO THE BOARD FROM A DECISION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION APPROVING THE ZONE MAP AMENDMENT FOR THE PROPOSED SANTOLINA DEVELOPMENT. -THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS' APPROVAL OF THE ZONE MAP AMENDMENT FOR THE PROPOSED SANTOLINA DEVELOPMENT. -THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS' APPROVAL OF THE SANTOLINA LEVEL A MASTER PLAN. -THE BOARD'S APPROVAL OF THE LEVEL A DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE BOARD AND WESTERN ALBUQUERQUE LAND HOLDINGS, LLC. THESE CASES WERE FILED AND LITIGATED DURING 2015-2017. IN THE COURSE OF THAT LITIGATION, THE CASES (CASE #D-202-CV-2015-04466 AND CASE #D-202-CV-2015-05363) WERE CONSOLIDATED. IN THE CONSOLIDATED CASES, THE DISTRICT COURT ISSUED A MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER ON MAY 31, 2017, REVERSING THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS' DECISION APPROVING THE ZONE MAP AMENDMENT FOR THE PROPOSED SANTOLINA DEVELOPMENT. BERNALILLO COUNTY AND THE SANTOLINA DEVELOPERS FILED MOTIONS FOR RECONSIDERATION OF THE COURT'S RULING ON THE ZONE MAP AMENDMENT. THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER FILED A MOTION FOR CLARIFICATION OF THE EFFECT OF THE COURT'S ORDER ON THE SANTOLINA LEVEL A MASTER PLAN AND THE SANTOLINA LEVEL A DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT. THE DISTRICT COURT DENIED ALL THREE OF THOSE MOTIONS ON DECEMBER 19, 2017. THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER'S CLIENTS FILED A PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI OF THE DISTRICT COURT'S DECISION PERTAINING TO THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS' APPROVAL OF THE SANTOLINA LEVEL A MASTER PLAN AND LEVEL A DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT WITH THE NEW MEXICO COURT OF APPEALS ON JANUARY 16, 2018. THE COURT OF APPEALS GRANTED OUR PETITION ON APRIL 5, 2018, AND THE CASE WAS ASSIGNED CASE NO. A-1-CA-36979. BOTH THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS AND THE SANTOLINA DEVELOPERS FILED THEIR OWN APPEALS OF THE DISTRICT COURT DECISION WITH THE COURT OF APPEALS. (CASE NOS. A-1-CA-37060 AND A-1-CA-37051). BRIEFING WAS COMPLETED AT THE END OF 2018 FOR ALL THREE APPEALS/PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI. LATER, ALL THREE CASES WERE CONSOLIDATED UNDER THE CASE NO. A-1-CA-36979. THE COURT OF APPEALS ISSUED ITS DECISION IN THE THREE CONSOLIDATED CASES ON DECEMBER 23, 2020. IN ITS DECISION, THE COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED THE DISTRICT COURT'S THREE RULINGS - THE RULING INVALIDATING THE ZONE MAP AMENDMENT, THE RULING AFFIRMING THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS' APPROVAL OF THE LEVEL A MASTER PLAN, AND THE RULING AFFIRMING THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS' APPROVAL OF THE LEVEL A DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT. BOTH SIDES REQUESTED THAT THE STATE SUPREME COURT REVIEW THE COURT OF APPEALS' DECISIONS, BUT THE STATE SUPREME COURT DECLINED TO DO THAT IN AN ORDER ISSUED ON APRIL 16, 2021. BERNALILLO COUNTY HAS CONTINUED ITS PROCEEDINGS ON THE PROPOSED SANTOLINA DEVELOPMENT. ON JUNE 7, 2017, THE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION HELD A HEARING ON PROPOSED AMENDMENTS TO THE BOARD'S CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL FOR THE LEVEL A MASTER PLAN PROPOSED BY THE SANTOLINA DEVELOPERS. THE PLANNING COMMISSION VOTED TO APPROVE THE PROPOSED AMENDMENTS. THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER THEN FILED AN APPEAL OF THAT DECISION WITH THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS. THE BOARD HELD A PUBLIC HEARING ON THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S DECISION AND THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER'S APPEAL OF THAT DECISION ON AUGUST 15, 2017. THE BOARD VOTED TO ADOPT THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S DECISION AND APPROVE THE SANTOLINA DEVELOPERS' PROPOSED AMENDMENTS, THEREBY DEFERRING THE REQUIREMENT FOR A FULLY EXECUTED DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT WITH THE ALBUQUERQUE/BERNALILLO COUNTY WATER UTILITY AUTHORITY FROM LEVEL B TO LEVEL C PHASE OF DEVELOPMENT. IN AUGUST 25, 2021, THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS HELD A REHEARING OF THE CLIENT'S APPEAL OF THE DECISION TO APPROVE THE ZONE MAP AMENDMENT, PURSUANT TO THE DISTRICT COURT'S ORDER INVALIDATING THE ZONE MAP AMENDMENT. AT THAT HEARING, THE BOARD AGAIN VOTED TO APPROVE THE AMENDMENT. THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER'S CLIENTS AGAIN APPEALED THAT DECISION TO THE SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT, ASKING THE COURT TO REVIEW THREE DECISIONS: 1) THE BOARD'S DECISION TO DENY THE CLIENT'S APPEAL OF THE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION'S RECOMMENDATION TO APPROVE THE ZONE MAP AMENDMENT, 2) THE BOARD'S DECISION TO APPROVE THE ZONE MAP AMENDMENT, AND 3) THE BOARD'S DECISION TO APPROVE THE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION'S FINDINGS IN SUPPORT OF THE ZONE MAP AMENDMENT. DISTRICT COURT JUDGE BRICKHOUSE UPHELD THE DECISIONS OF THE BOARD AND THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER'S CLIENTS DECIDED NOT TO APPEAL THE DECISION TO THE COURT OF APPEALS. IN CASE #7, THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER SOUGHT TO PERSUADE THE NEW MEXICO SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT TO REVERSE THE FOLLOWING TWO DECISIONS OF THE BERNALILLO COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS: -THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS' DENIAL OF THE APPEAL FILED BY SEVERAL OF THE CLIENTS TO THE BOARD FROM A DETERMINATION OF THE BERNALILLO COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION (THE "PLANNING COMMISSION") RECOMMENDING THAT THE SANTOLINA LEVEL B MASTER PLAN BE APPROVED. -THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS' APPROVAL OF THE SANTOLINA LEVEL B MASTER PLAN. JUDGE NASH PRESIDING OVER THIS CASE RETIRED AT THE END OF 2018 AND JUDGE BRICKHOUSE WAS ASSIGNED. THE DISTRICT COURT ISSUED A MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER ON DECEMBER 23, 2019, AFFIRMING THE BOARD'S APPROVAL OF THE LEVEL B MASTER PLAN. THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER'S CLIENTS FILED A PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI OF THE DISTRICT COURT'S DECISION PERTAINING TO THE BOARD'S APPROVAL OF THE SANTOLINA LEVEL B MASTER PLAN WITH THE NEW MEXICO COURT OF APPEALS ON JANUARY 22, 2020. FOR CASE #8, BERNALILLO COUNTY STAFF INTRODUCED THE SANTOLINA LEVEL B DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT, WHICH SERVES TO CODIFY AND IMPLEMENT THE SANTOLINA LEVEL B MASTER PLAN, AT THE BOARD'S OCTOBER 23, 2018 "ADMINISTRATIVE MEETING". AT THE BOARD'S NOVEMBER 13, 2018 "ADMINISTRATIVE MEETING" PUBLIC COMMENT PERTAINING TO THE SANTOLINA LEVEL B DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT WAS RECEIVED BY THE BOARD, WITH THE BOARD ULTIMATELY VOTING 3-2 IN FAVOR OF APPROVING THE SANTOLINA LEVEL B DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT. |
| FORM 990 - PUBLIC INTEREST LAW FIRM STATUS OF CASES IN LITIGATION, CONTINUE | THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER SOUGHT TO PERSUADE THE NEW MEXICO SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT TO REVERSE THE BOARD'S APPROVAL OF THE SANTOLINA LEVEL B DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT ON DECEMBER 12, 2018. JUDGE FRANCHINI ISSUED AN AMENDED ORDER DISMISSING THE APPEAL ON JANUARY 13, 2020. THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER'S CLIENTS FILED A PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI OF THE DISTRICT COURT'S DISMISSAL WITH THE NEW MEXICO COURT OF APPEALS ON FEBRUARY 4, 2020. THIS CASE WAS CONSOLIDATED BY THE COURT OF APPEALS WITH CASE #7 AND ON APRIL 20, 2022 THE COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED THE DECISIONS OF THE DISTRICT COURT. THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER'S CLIENTS FILED A PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE NEW MEXICO SUPREME COURT ON MAY 24, 2022. UNFORTUNATELY THAT PETITION WAS DENIED ON AUGUST 8, 2022 AND A MANDATE HAS BEEN FILED IN THE DISTRICT COURT, WHICH WILL RESULT IN THE CASE CLOSURE OF CASES #7 AND #8. PUBLIC INTEREST: THERE ARE SEVERAL PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUES AT STAKE IN THIS LITIGATION. THE FIRST IS WHERE THE WATER WILL COME FROM FOR THE PROPOSED SANTOLINA DEVELOPMENT. THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER'S CLIENTS ARE PARTICULARLY CONCERNED ABOUT THIS ISSUE BECAUSE THEY FEAR THAT USE OF WATER FOR THE PROPOSED SANTOLINA DEVELOPMENT WILL REDUCE THE WATER THAT IS AVAILABLE FOR OTHER USERS IN THE ALBUQUERQUE AREA, WHICH IS WHERE EACH OF THE INDIVIDUAL CLIENTS IS LOCATED. THE SECOND PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUE IS WHETHER THE PROPOSED SANTOLINA DEVELOPMENT WILL LEAD TO SIGNIFICANT INCREASES IN TRAFFIC FROM THE WEST SIDE OF ALBUQUERQUE TO CENTRAL ALBUQUERQUE, THEREBY CAUSING SIGNIFICANT POLLUTION ON THE ROADS THAT CONNECT ALBUQUERQUE TO THE WEST SIDE. THE THIRD PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUE IS WHETHER THE CHILDREN FROM THE PROPOSED SANTOLINA DEVELOPMENT WILL EXACERBATE OVERCROWDING THAT ALREADY EXISTS IN THE ALBUQUERQUE PUBLIC SCHOOL DISTRICT SCHOOLS THAT SERVE STUDENTS ON THE WEST SIDE OF ALBUQUERQUE. THE FOURTH PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUE IS WHETHER THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE PROPOSED SANTOLINA DEVELOPMENT WILL CAUSE INCREASES IN TAXES FOR TAXPAYERS ELSEWHERE IN BERNALILLO COUNTY. FINALLY, THE FIFTH PUBLIC INTEREST ISSUE CONCERNS THE PROCEDURE FOLLOWED BY THE BERNALILLO COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS. THE BOARD TREATED ITS PROCEEDINGS AS LEGISLATIVE PROCEEDINGS DESPITE THE LAW THAT INDICATES THAT THEY WERE QUASI-JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS, IN WHICH PARTICIPANTS HAVE DUE PROCESS RIGHTS. ATTORNEYS' FEES: THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER HAS NEITHER SOUGHT NOR RECOVERED ANY ATTORNEYS' FEES FROM AN OPPOSING PARTY IN ANY OF THESE THREE CASES. CASE # 10 NUCLEAR WATCH NEW MEXICO V. UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY, LOS ALAMOS NATIONAL SECURITY, LLC, AND THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENT DEPARTMENT UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW MEXICO CASE #1:16-CV-0043-JCH- SCY. BACKGROUND: IN 2005, THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENT DEPARTMENT ("NMED") ENTERED INTO A CONSENT ORDER WITH THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, WHICH WAS AT THAT TIME THE SOLE OPERATOR OF THE LOS ALAMOS NATIONAL LABORATORY ("THE LABORATORY"), ON BEHALF OF THE UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY, CONCERNING REQUIREMENTS FOR THE REMEDIATION OF TOXIC WASTE BURIED IN UNLINED PITS AND TRENCHES (SO-CALLED LEGACY WASTE) FROM THE MAKING OF NUCLEAR EXPLOSIVES AND RELATED WAR-TIME ACTIVITIES. UNDER THE CURRENT ADMINISTRATION, THE HAZARDOUS WASTE BUREAU OF THE NMED ALLOWED NUMEROUS MANDATORY DEADLINES FOR VARIOUS ASPECTS OF THE REMEDIATION PROCESS TO EXPIRE OR BE EXTENDED OUTSIDE THE TERMS REQUIRED UNDER THE CONSENT ORDER. THE 2005 CONSENT ORDER, THE STATE HAZARDOUS WASTE ACT ("HWA") AND THE FEDERAL RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT ("RCRA") REQUIRED THAT THOSE DEADLINES BE MET AND IMPOSED PENALTIES FOR FAILURE TO MEET THOSE DEADLINES. IN JUNE, 2016, THE NMED AND THE CURRENT OPERATORS OF THE LABORATORY (51% CONTINUING UNDER THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, THE REST DIVIDED AMONG BECHTEL, AECOM, AND ANOTHER COMPANY TO FORM A CONSORTIUM OPERATOR CALLED LANS OR LOS ALAMOS NATIONAL SECURITY, LLC) ENTERED INTO A NEW CONSENT ORDER THAT VITIATED ALL OF THE DEADLINES IN THE ORIGINAL ORDER AND PUT THE CONSORTIUM AND THE DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY IN CONTROL OF SETTING ALL FUTURE REMEDIATION DEADLINES. NUCLEAR WATCH NEW MEXICO SUED TO RESTORE AND ENFORCE THE CONSENT ORDER AND TO ENFORCE RCRA AND THE STATE HWA. THE LAWSUIT ALSO SEEKS TO IMPOSE PENALTIES - WHICH CONTINUE TO ACCRUE, BUT AT THE TIME OF FILING WERE APPROXIMATELY $275,000,000. THE CASE WAS FILED IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW MEXICO. THE DISTRICT COURT CONSIDERED THE MERITS OF THE CASE ON CROSS MOTIONS FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT FILED BY ALL PARTIES. ON THE BASIS OF THOSE MOTIONS, THE DISTRICT COURT DENIED OUR CLAIM THAT THE CONSENT ORDER SHOULD BE RESTORED AND ENFORCED, BUT REFUSED TO DISMISS OUR CLAIM THAT THE DEFENDANTS SHOULD HAVE TO PAY THE PENALTIES THAT HAVE ACCRUED. THE CASE WAS SETTLED IN MARCH 2022 AND THE CASE WAS DISMISSED. PUBLIC INTEREST: THIS CASE INVOLVES ENFORCEMENT OF RCRA AND THE HWA WHICH ARE INTENDED TO PROTECT OCCUPATIONAL AND PUBLIC HEALTH AND SAFETY BY ASSURING PROPER DISPOSAL AND REMEDIATION OF DISPOSAL SITES INVOLVING THE STORAGE OF HAZARDOUS WASTE. ATTORNEYS' FEES: THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER HAS SOUGHT ATTORNEY'S FEES AND COSTS UNDER RCRA IN THIS CASE. HOWEVER, FILING FOR SUCH FEES WOULD NOT TAKE PLACE IF THE CASE IS DISMISSED. IF THE CASE GOES FORWARD, FILING FOR FEES UNDER THE PROVISIONS OF THE FEDERAL STATUTE WOULD TAKE PLACE AT THE END OF THE CASE AND BE DETERMINED BY THE COURT. ALTERNATIVELY, ANY RECOVERY OF ATTORNEYS FEES COULD BE PART OF A SETTLEMENT OF THE CASE, AND WE AND OUR CLIENT ARE CURRENTLY ENGAGED IN SETTLEMENT NEGOTIATIONS WITH THE DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY. IN SUMMER, 2022, THE LAW CENTER AND OUR CLIENTS SUCCESSFULLY NEGOTIATED A SETTLEMENT WITH THE DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY THAT INCLUDED RECOVERY OF SOME ATTORNEYS' FEES FOR THE LAW CENTER. THIS CASE IS NOW RESOLVED AND CLOSED. |
| FORM 990 - PUBLIC INTEREST LAW FIRM STATUS OF CASES IN LITIGATION, CONTINUE | CASE #11 STATE OF NEW MEXICO, EX REL. OFFICE OF THE STATE ENGINEER V. H GRAY NEW MEXICO COURT OF APPEALS, A-1-CA-37258, FORMERLY THIRD JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT CASE #CV-96-888 THIS CASE WAS TRIED IN SANTA FE BY THE WATER JUDGE FOR THE NEW MEXICO DISTRICT COURT FOR THE THIRD JUDICIAL DISTRICT, AND A DISPOSITION FAVORABLE TO OUR CLIENTS WAS ACHIEVED. IT IS CURRENTLY UNDER APPEAL IN THE NEW MEXICO COURT OF APPEALS ON AN APPEAL FILED BY THE NEW MEXICO COPPER COMPANY AND WILLIAM FROST AND HARRIS GRAY. THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER HAS FILED A CROSS-APPEAL IN THE MATTER. BACKGROUND: THIS IS A PROCEEDING TO DETERMINE THE EXTENT OF WATER RIGHTS BELONGING TO THE NEW MEXICO COPPER COMPANY [NMCC]. AS THE RIGHTS CLAIMED ARE WITHIN THE LOWER RIO GRANDE, THE ADJUDICATION TAKES PLACE AS PART OF THE FIXING OF ALL WATER RIGHTS WITHIN THAT AREA. OUR POSITION IN THE MATTER WAS VINDICATED BY THE COURT'S DECISION LIMITING THE WATER RIGHTS OF THE CLAIMANTS. HOWEVER, THE WATER RIGHTS CLAIMANTS HAVE APPEALED, AND WE RESPONDED WITH CROSS APPEALS. THE NEW MEXICO COURT OF APPEALS SET ORAL ARGUMENT IN THIS MATTER FOR APRIL 1, 2021, AND THE LAW CENTER HIRED OUTSIDE COUNSEL TO HANDLE THAT ORAL ARGUMENT. THE COURT OF APPEALS ISSUED ITS DECISION IN SEPTEMBER 2021, PARTIALLY REVERSING AND REMANDING. A PRETRIAL HEARING WAS HELD ON JANUARY 6, 2022 AND BRIEFING ON THE REMAND ISSUES WAS SUBMITTED FEBRUARY 28, 2022. ORAL ARGUMENT WAS HELD ON JUNE 16, 2022 AND A DECISION IS PENDING IN DISTRICT COURT. PUBLIC INTEREST: THE PUBLIC INTEREST IN THIS CASE IS IN PROTECTING THE WATER SUPPLIES FOR PEOPLE LIVING IN THE TOWN OF HILLSBORO, NEW MEXICO. NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER REPRESENTS THESE PROTESTERS. THEY ARE A GROUP OF CITIZENS WHO ARE MEMBERS OF THE PERCHA-ANIMAS WATERSHED ASSOCIATION AND A DOMESTIC WATER USERS ASSOCIATION IN THE TOWN OF HILLSBORO, NEW MEXICO. THEY ARE CONCERNED THAT IF THE TOTAL WATER RIGHTS CLAIMED BY THE NMCC IS ALLOCATED TO IT, THEIR WATER SUPPLIES WILL BE COMPROMISED. THEIR INTENTION IN THIS LITIGATION IS TO LIMIT THE NMCC WATER RIGHTS TO NO MORE THAN THE NEW MEXICO OFFICE OF THE STATE ENGINEER OFFERED TO NMCC BASED UPON PROVEN BENEFICIAL USE. ATTORNEYS' FEES: THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER HAS NEITHER SOUGHT NOR RECOVERED ATTORNEYS' FEES FROM AN OPPOSING PARTY IN THIS CASE. CASE #12 SOUTHWEST ORGANIZING PROJECT, ESTHER ABEYTA, AND STEVEN ABEYTA. V. ALBUQUERQUE- BERNALILLO COUNTY AIR QUALITY CONTROL BOARD NEW MEXICO COURT OF APPEALS CASE # A-1-CA-36398. BACKGROUND: THIS IS AN APPEAL OF THE ALBUQUERQUE-BERNALILLO COUNTY AIR QUALITY CONTROL BOARD'S DECISION TO AFFIRM THE ISSUANCE OF AN AIR POLLUTION PERMIT BY THE CITY OF ALBUQUERQUE ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH DEPT. ("EHD"). THE EHD GRANTED AN AIR POLLUTION PERMIT TO HONSTEIN PETROLEUM PRODUCTS, LLC ("HONSTEIN") FOR A BULK PETROLEUM FACILITY LOCATED IN THE SAN JOSE NEIGHBORHOOD IN ALBUQUERQUE. THE SAN JOSE NEIGHBORHOOD IS PREDOMINANTLY LATINO AND WORKING CLASS. THE HONSTEIN FACILITY WAS ALSO LOCATED IN A RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD LESS THAN 100 FEET FROM OCCUPIED RESIDENCES. SAN JOSE ALSO HAS A DISPROPORTIONATE NUMBER OF AIR POLLUTION SOURCES, I.E., INDUSTRIAL OPERATIONS, LOCATED IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD. ON BEHALF OF OUR CLIENTS SOUTHWEST ORGANIZING PROJECT ("SWOP"), ESTHER ABEYTA, AND STEVEN ABEYTA, WE CHALLENGED THE BOARD'S DECISION BASED ON THE BOARD'S MISINTERPRETATION OF THE NEW MEXICO AIR QUALITY CONTROL ACT AND ITS REFUSAL TO CONSIDER QUALITY OF LIFE IMPACTS FROM THE EHD'S PERMITTING DECISION. SWOP'S CHALLENGE SEEKS TO REQUIRE THE EHD TO TAKE INTO ACCOUNT THE CUMULATIVE IMPACTS OF MULTIPLE AIR POLLUTION SOURCES AND THOSE SOURCES' IMPACT ON PUBLIC HEALTH WHEN CONSIDERING AIR POLLUTION PERMITS. THE NEW MEXICO COURT OF APPEALS ISSUED ITS DECISION ON OCTOBER 15, 2020. OUR CLIENTS DECIDED NOT TO PURSUE THIS CASE FURTHER AND WE CLOSED THE CASE IN FEBRUARY, 2021. PUBLIC INTEREST: THE PUBLIC INTEREST REPRESENTED IN THIS CASE IS THE PUBLIC'S RIGHT TO HAVE PUBLIC HEALTH AND CUMULATIVE IMPACTS CONSIDERED WHEN LOCAL AIR POLLUTION AGENCIES ISSUE AIR POLLUTION PERMITS. ATTORNEYS' FEES: THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER HAS NEITHER RECEIVED NOR SOUGHT ATTORNEYS' FEES IN THIS CASE. CASE #13 UNITED STATES V. CURRY UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW MEXICO CASE #1:10-CF-01251. BACKGROUND: CONCERNED CITIZENS FOR NUCLEAR SAFETY IS AN INTERVENING DEFENDANT IN THIS MATTER. THE PLAINTIFF IS THE UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY WHICH OVERSEES LOS ALAMOS NATIONAL LABORATORY (LANL), WHICH IS CURRENTLY OPERATED BY INTERVENING PLAINTIFF LOS ALAMOS NATIONAL SECURITY, LLC. THE PRINCIPAL DEFENDANT IS THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENT DEPARTMENT. CONCERNED CITIZENS FOR NUCLEAR SAFETY LITIGATED THE ISSUE OF PERMISSIVE INTERVENTION IN THE CASE AND WAS GRANTED THAT STATUS ON JULY 25, 2011. THE PARTIES OTHER THAN OUR CLIENT HAVE ENTERED INTO A SETTLEMENT OF THIS CASE, WHICH IS PENDING THE DECISION ON AN APPEAL OF PERMIT DP-1132, ON WHICH THE SETTLEMENT TERMS ARE CONTINGENT. LITIGATION CONTINUES RELATED TO DP-1132; HOWEVER, THE LAW CENTER IS NOT REPRESENTING CCNS IN THOSE PROCEEDINGS. INSTEAD, THE LAW CENTER CONTINUES TO MONITOR THE STATUS OF THE FEDERAL CASE UNTIL THE STATE PROCEEDINGS ARE RESOLVED. PUBLIC INTEREST: THE PUBLIC INTEREST INVOLVED IN THIS MATTER IS IN THE ADEQUATE CLEAN UP OF THE POLLUTION CAUSED BY LANL. CONCERNED CITIZENS FOR NUCLEAR SAFETY INCLUDES MEMBERS OF THE PUEBLO COMMUNITIES LIVING AROUND THE LANL SITE, AS WELL AS PEOPLE WHO LIVE DOWNSTREAM AND DOWNWIND OF THE FACILITY. PROPER, ADEQUATE AND COMPLETE CLEAN-UP OF THE WEAPONS BUILDING LEGACY WASTE IS AN ABIDING INTEREST OF MANY MEMBERS OF THESE COMMUNITIES. WHILE CCNS, AS AN INTERVENING DEFENDANT, HAS NO BASIS FOR WINNING THIS CASE, BY BEING "ON BOARD" IT HAS A SEAT AT THE TABLE IN THE PROCESS OF NEGOTIATED SETTLEMENT. THIS PROVIDES AN OPPORTUNITY TO STRIVE FOR A SETTLEMENT THAT WILL ASSURE ADEQUATE CLEAN-UP OF THE LANL WEAPONS BUILDING LEGACY WASTE. ATTORNEYS' FEES: THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER HAS NEITHER SOUGHT NOR RECOVERED ATTORNEYS' FEES IN THIS MATTER. |
| FORM 990 - PUBLIC INTEREST LAW FIRM STATUS OF CASES IN LITIGATION, CONTINUE | CASE #15 TURNER RANCH PROPERTIES L.P., ET AL. V. NEW MEXICO WATER QUALITY CONTROL COMMISSION NEW MEXICO COURT OF APPEALS, NO. A-1-CA-38478 BACKGROUND: NEW MEXICO COPPER CORPORATION (N.M. COPPER CORP.) SEEKS TO REOPEN AND OPERATE THE COPPER FLAT MINE, LOCATED NEAR THE TOWN OF HILLSBORO, IN SIERRA COUNTY, NEW MEXICO. THE MINE OPERATED FOR ABOUT THREE MONTHS IN 1980, BUT HAS BEEN INACTIVE SINCE THEN. ON MARCH 31, 2011, N.M. COPPER CORP. SUBMITTED TO THE N.M. ENVIRONMENT DEPARTMENT (DEPARTMENT) AN APPLICATION FOR A MODIFICATION OF THE EXISTING GROUNDWATER DISCHARGE PERMIT FOR THE MINE OPERATION. ON JANUARY 31, 2018, THE DEPARTMENT FORMALLY ISSUED A PUBLIC NOTICE ANNOUNCING ITS DECISION TO PROPOSE APPROVAL OF THE DISCHARGE PERMIT. THE DEPARTMENT RECEIVED REQUESTS FOR HEARING FROM SEVERAL PARTIES, AND IT DECIDED TO HOLD A PUBLIC HEARING. FROM SEPTEMBER 24, 2018 THROUGH SEPTEMBER 28, 2018, THE DEPARTMENT HELD A PUBLIC HEARING ON THE PROPOSED DISCHARGE PERMIT IN TRUTH OR CONSEQUENCES. ON BEHALF OF ITS CLIENTS, TURNER RANCH PROPERTIES L.P. AND HILLSBORO PITCHFORK RANCH LLC, THE LAW CENTER PARTICIPATED IN THE HEARING AS A PARTY, PRESENTING THE TESTIMONY OF FOUR WITNESSES. THE LAW CENTER GENERALLY OPPOSED THE PERMIT, AND ADVOCATED FOR STRONGER PERMIT CONDITIONS. ON DECEMBER 19, 2018, IN THE FINAL WEEKS OF THE TERM OF THE PREVIOUS GOVERNOR, THE DEPARTMENT ISSUED THE PERMIT. THE LAW CENTER, ON BEHALF OF THE RANCHES AND THE GILA RESOURCES INFORMATION PROJECT (GRIP), APPEALED THE PERMIT TO THE N.M. WATER QUALITY CONTROL COMMISSION. THE LAW CENTER BRIEFED AND ARGUED THE APPEAL IN THE SUMMER OF 2019. ON SEPTEMBER 10, 2019, SUMMARILY AND WITH LITTLE ANALYSIS, THE COMMISSION UPHELD THE PERMIT. ON OCTOBER 10, 2019, THE LAW CENTER, AGAIN ON BEHALF OF THE RANCHES AND GRIP, APPEALED THE COMMISSION'S DECISION TO THE NEW MEXICO COURT OF APPEALS. DURING 2020, THE MATTER WAS FULLY BRIEFED. THE COURT OF APPEALS ISSUED A DECISION IN MAY, 2022, AFFIRMING THE WQCC'S DECISION. ON BEHALF OF OUR CLIENTS, THE LAW CENTER FILED A PETITION FOR CERTIORARI WITH THE NEW MEXICO SUPREME COURT, BUT THAT PETITION WAS DENIED IN AUGUST, 2022. BECAUSE ALL APPEALS IN THIS MATTER HAVE BEEN EXHAUSTED, THE LAW CENTER CLOSED THE CASE IN SEPTEMBER 2022. PUBLIC INTEREST: THE PROPOSED MINE COULD HAVE A VERY SERIOUS ADVERSE EFFECT ON LOCAL WATER RESOURCES, BY BOTH POLLUTING AND DEPLETING GROUND AND SURFACE WATER. THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER REPRESENTS TWO RANCHES LOCATED ADJACENT TO THE MINE SITE, AS WELL AS A LOCAL ENVIRONMENTAL COMMUNITY ORGANIZATION. THE RANCHES CONTAIN SENSITIVE ECOSYSTEMS, INCLUDING LAS ANIMAS CREEK, CAVE CREEK, AND THE AVANT PASTURE. THE RANCHES ARE HOME TO NUMEROUS MAMMAL, BIRD, AND FISH SPECIES, INCLUDING NATIVE RIO GRANDE CUTTHROAT TROUT, ELK, MULE DEER, COUES WHITETAIL DEER, QUAIL, AND OTHER GAME SPECIES. THEY ARE ALSO HOME TO STANDS OF RARE ARIZONA SYCAMORE TREES. IN ADDITION TO BUFFALO AND CATTLE RANCHING, THE RANCHES ARE WIDELY USED FOR RECREATION, INCLUDING HUNTING, FISHING, HIKING, MOUNTAIN BIKING, AND GAME VIEWING. THE CASE ALSO FURTHERS THE PUBLIC INTEREST IN CHALLENGING THE RATHER CAVALIER AND POORLY-REASONED DECISIONS OF BOTH THE DEPARTMENT AND THE COMMISSION IN APPROVING THE PERMIT. ATTORNEYS' FEES: THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER HAS NEITHER SOUGHT NOR RECOVERED ANY ATTORNEYS' FEES FROM AN OPPOSING PARTY IN THIS CASE. CASE #16 SOUTHWEST ORGANIZING PROJECT, ET AL V. U.S. DEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCE U.S. DISTRICT COURT, DISTRICT OF NEW MEXICO, 1:20-CV-00098-KK-JFR BACKGROUND: ON FEBRUARY 4, 2020, THE LAW CENTER ON BEHALF OF ITS CLIENTS (SOUTHWEST ORGANIZING PROJECT, NEW MEXICO VOICES FOR CHILDREN, THREE INDIVIDUALS, AND THREE NEW MEXICO STATE LEGISLATORS) FILED A RCRA CITIZEN SUIT AGAINST THE U.S. AIR FORCE IN THE U.S. DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF NEW MEXICO FOR CLEANUP OF A JET FUEL SPILL FROM THE BULK FUELS FACILITY AT KIRTLAND AIR FORCE BASE. THE UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE AIR FORCE FILED A MOTION TO DISMISS, AND THE COURT HEARD ORAL ARGUMENT ON JULY 21, 2020. THE COURT GRANTED THE U.S. MOTION TO DISMISS IN MARCH 2021. OUR CLIENTS DECIDED NOT TO PURSUE ANY APPEALS AND THIS CASE IS CLOSED. PUBLIC INTEREST: THE PUBLIC INTEREST IN THIS CASE WAS TO PROTECT ALBUQUERQUE MUNICIPAL DRINKING WATER SUPPLIES FROM PETROCHEMICAL POLLUTION CAUSED BY THE AIR FORCE. ATTORNEYS' FEES: THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER HAS NEITHER SOUGHT NOR RECOVERED ANY ATTORNEYS' FEES FROM AN OPPOSING PARTY IN THIS CASE. CASE #17 NEW MEXICO CATTLE GROWERS' ASSOC. V. UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY U.S. DISTRICT COURT, DISTRICT OF NEW MEXICO, 1:19-CV-00988-RB-SCY BACKGROUND: THE U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY AND THE U.S. ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS ISSUED A FINAL RULE DEFINING WATERS OF THE UNITED STATES (WOTUS), OR THE SO-CALLED "NAVIGABLE WATER PROTECTION RULE", ON JANUARY 23, 2020. ON BEHALF OF ITS CLIENTS, AMIGOS BRAVOS, GILA RESOURCES INFORMATION PROJECT (GRIP), AND THE NEW MEXICO ACEQUIA ASSOCIATION, THE LAW CENTER APPEALED THE FINAL RULE IN JUNE 2020 TO THE U.S. DISTRICT COURT, DISTRICT OF NEW MEXICO. THE LAW CENTER IS ALSO DISPUTING N.M. CATTLE GROWERS' CHALLENGE TO THE RULE AS BEYOND EPA JURISDICTION. IN AUGUST 2021, FEDERAL DISTRICT COURTS VACATED THE 2020 "NAVIGABLE WATER PROTECTION RULE" NULLIFYING IT NATIONWIDE. ON DECEMBER 7, 2021 THE EPA AND THE USACE PUBLISHED A NEW PROPOSED RULE TO REVISE THE DEFINITION OF "WATERS OF THE US" IN THE FEDERAL REGISTER. NMELC SUBMITTED COMMENTS ON BEHALF OF AMIGOS BRAVOS, GRIP, AND NMAA, ON FEBRUARY 7, 2022. WE ARE WAITING TO SEE WHETHER THE PLAINTIFFS NEW MEXICO CATTLE GROWERS ASSOCIATION WILL FILE A NEW APPEAL OF THE DEFINITION OF "WATERS OF THE U.S. OR AMEND ITS COMPLAINT IN THE CURRENT CASE. PUBLIC INTEREST: HOW "WATERS OF THE U.S." IS DEFINED IS CRITICAL TO WHICH WATERS ARE PROTECTED IN NEW MEXICO. BECAUSE NEW MEXICO DOES NOT REGULATE SURFACE WATER DISCHARGES BY STATE LAW, SURFACE WATER PROTECTIONS ARE ADMINISTERED BY THE U.S. EPA. EPA MUST ABIDE BY ITS OWN REGULATIONS AND DURING THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION, THE EPA PROMULGATED REGULATIONS THAT WOULD HAVE EFFECTIVELY LEFT 90% OF NEW MEXICO SURFACE WATER UNPROTECTED FROM POLLUTING DISCHARGES. ATTORNEYS' FEES: THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER HAS NEITHER SOUGHT NOR RECOVERED ANY ATTORNEYS' FEES FROM AN OPPOSING PARTY IN THIS CASE. |
| FORM 990 - PUBLIC INTEREST LAW FIRM STATUS OF CASES IN LITIGATION, CONTINUE | CASE #18 STATE OF COLORADO V. ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY TENTH CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE UNITED STATES, 20-1238 BACKGROUND: ON BEHALF OF ITS CLIENTS, AMIGOS BRAVOS, GILA RESOURCES INFORMATION PROJECT (GRIP), AND THE NEW MEXICO ACEQUIA ASSOCIATION, THE LAW CENTER SUBMITTED AN AMICUS BRIEF IN THE UNITED STATES TENTH CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS, ON AUGUST 18, 2020, ON APPEAL OF U.S. DISTRICT COURT (D. COLO.) GRANT OF MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION. IN MARCH, 2021, THE TENTH CIRCUIT REVERSED THE U.S. DISTRICT COURT AND VACATED THE MATTER. THIS CASE IS NOW CLOSED. PUBLIC INTEREST: SEE, NEW MEXICO CATTLE GROWERS' ASSOC. V. UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, U.S. DISTRICT COURT, DISTRICT OF NEW MEXICO, 1:19-CV-00988-RB-SCY, ABOVE. ATTORNEYS' FEES: THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER HAS NEITHER SOUGHT NOR RECOVERED ANY ATTORNEYS' FEES FROM AN OPPOSING PARTY IN THIS CASE. CASE #19 NEW MEXICO V. UNITED STATES AIR FORCE U.S. DISTRICT COURT, DISTRICT OF NEW MEXICO, 1:19-CV-00178-MV-JFR BACKGROUND: IN AN ACTION BY THE STATE OF NEW MEXICO AGAINST THE U.S. AIR FORCE, THE LAW CENTER PREPARED AND FILED AN AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF IN THE U.S. DISTRICT COURT (D.N.M.) ON BEHALF OF THREE NEW MEXICO STATE LEGISLATORS (SENATOR MIMI STEWART, SENATOR ANTOINETTE SEDILLO LOPEZ, AND REPRESENTATIVE ANDRES ROMERO) ON DECEMBER 30, 2019, SUPPORTING NEW MEXICO'S RESPONSE TO THE U.S. CROSS MOTION TO DISMISS ON JURISDICTIONAL ISSUES. THE CASE HAS SINCE BEEN TRANSFERRED TO A U.S. DISTRICT COURT MULTI-DISTRICT PANEL, AND ALL PENDING MOTIONS HAVE BEEN DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE. CONSEQUENTLY, THE LAW CENTER WILL RE-FILE THE AMICUS BRIEF AT THE APPROPRIATE TIME. PUBLIC INTEREST: CANNON & HOLLOMAN AIR FORCE BASE PFAS AND PFOS ISSUE. ATTORNEYS' FEES: THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER HAS NEITHER SOUGHT NOR RECOVERED ANY ATTORNEYS' FEES FROM AN OPPOSING PARTY IN THIS CASE. CASE #20 JOHN D'ANTONIO, NEW MEXICO STATE ENGINEER V. ACEQUIA DE ANTON CHICO, ET AL. NEW MEXICO FOURTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT CASE NO. D-412-CV-2020-00413 BACKGROUND: THE LAW CENTER IS REPRESENTING FOUR DIFFERENT ACEQUIA ASSOCIATIONS TO CHALLENGE THE STATE ENGINEER'S AUTHORITY TO REISSUE A FINAL DECISION AFTER ISSUING A DECISION REGARDING A WATER TRANSFER. THE ACEQUIAS ORIGINALLY PROTESTED THE APPLICATION OF STRICKLING RANCH PARTNERS, A TEXAS-BASED COMPANY, TO CHANGE THE POINT OF DIVERSION AND PLACE OF USE OF WATER WHICH WOULD CEASE THE DIVERSION OF WATER FROM THE WEST PECOS DITCH CURRENTLY USED FOR IRRIGATION AND ALLOW WATER TO BE USED BY THE COMPANY, NEGATIVELY IMPACTING TRADITIONAL WATER USERS IN PECOS AND ANTON CHICO. THE APPEAL WAS FILED IN THE NEW MEXICO FOURTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT IN DECEMBER 2020. THE PARTIES ARE CONDUCTING DISCOVERY AND ARE ENGAGED IN SETTLEMENT DISCUSSIONS. A TRIAL IS SCHEDULED IN OCTOBER 2021. PRIOR TO TRIAL, THE PARTIES WERE ABLE TO RESOLVE THE MATTER AND IN JUNE, 2022, THE STATE ENGINEER ISSUED A FINAL PERMIT REFLECTING THE PARTIES' SETTLEMENT TERMS. THIS CASE HAS BEEN CLOSED. PUBLIC INTEREST: THE PUBLIC INTEREST IN THIS MATTER IS PROTECTING TRADITIONAL WATER USES, I.E., ACEQUIA IRRIGATION, FROM WATER GRABS TO BE USED FOR INDUSTRIAL OPERATIONS. ATTORNEYS' FEES: THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER HAS NEITHER SOUGHT NOR RECOVERED ANY ATTORNEYS' FEES FROM AN OPPOSING PARTY IN THIS CASE. CASE #21 SANTA BARBARA MARTINEZTOWN NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION V. CITY OF ALBUQUERQUE NEW MEXICO SECOND JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT CASE NO. D-202-CV-2018-04504 BACKGROUND: THE SANTA BARBARA MARTINEZTOWN NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION IS CHALLENGING THE DISCRIMINATORY ZONING ESTABLISHED IN MARTINEZTOWN THAT HAS ALLOWED FOR INCOMPATIBLE AND DETRIMENTAL LAND USES THAT GO AGAINST RESIDENTS' DESIRES TO KEEP MARTINEZTOWN A TRADITIONAL VILLAGE. THE LAW CENTER IS WORKING WITH THE NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION AND THE NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL SEEKING TO CHANGE THE MARTINEZTOWN COMMUNITY'S ZONING TO RESIDENTIAL, AND ASKING THE CITY OF ALBUQUERQUE TO BUFFER THESE NEIGHBORHOODS FROM INCONGRUENT USES AND PROVIDE PROTECTIONS THAT OTHER HISTORICAL NEIGHBORHOODS IN ALBUQUERQUE HAVE BEEN GRANTED. THE NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION IS CURRENTLY IN NEGOTIATIONS WITH THE CITY TO RESOLVE THIS MATTER, AND LITIGATION DEADLINES HAVE BEEN STAYED PENDING THE OUTCOME OF NEGOTIATIONS. PUBLIC INTEREST: THIS CASE ADDRESSES THE DISPARATE TREATMENT WITH REGARDS TO ZONING PROTECTIONS OF A PREDOMINANTLY COMMUNITY OF COLOR COMPARED WITH A SIMILARLY SITUATED COMMUNITY THAT IS PREDOMINANTLY WHITE. ATTORNEYS' FEES: THE NEW MEXICO ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CENTER HAS NEITHER SOUGHT NOR RECOVERED ANY ATTORNEYS' FEES FROM AN OPPOSING PARTY IN THIS CASE. |
Comments