FAIRNESS CENTER INC: Form 990, tax year 2020
View the entire original 990 at ProPublica ↗
- Organization
- FAIRNESS CENTER INC (EIN 46-4482738)
- Tax period
- 2020-10-01 to 2021-09-30
- Filed
- 2022-08-12
- IRS object ID
- 202222249349301302
- Schema version
- 2020v4.2
- Source
- Download XML · Original 990 at ProPublica
Every field in the e-filed return. Faint text is the IRS element name, for citing.
Return header ReturnHeader
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Return | 2022-08-12T08:19:14-05:00 | ReturnTs |
| Tax Period End | 2021-09-30 | TaxPeriodEndDt |
Preparer Firm PreparerFirmGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Preparer Firm EIN | 231909723 | PreparerFirmEIN |
Preparer Firm Name PreparerFirmName
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Business Name Line1 | MCKONLY & ASBURY LLP | BusinessNameLine1Txt |
Preparer US Address PreparerUSAddress
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Address Line1 | 415 FALLOWFIELD ROAD | AddressLine1Txt |
| City | CAMP HILL | CityNm |
| State Abbreviation | PA | StateAbbreviationCd |
| ZIP | 17011 | ZIPCd |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Return Type | 990 | ReturnTypeCd |
| Tax Period Begin | 2020-10-01 | TaxPeriodBeginDt |
Filer Filer
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| EIN | 464482738 | EIN |
Business Name BusinessName
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Business Name Line1 | THE FAIRNESS CENTER INC | BusinessNameLine1Txt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Business Name Control | FAIR | BusinessNameControlTxt |
| Phone | 8442931001 | PhoneNum |
US Address USAddress
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Address Line1 | PO BOX 54597 | AddressLine1Txt |
| City | OKLAHOMA CITY | CityNm |
| State Abbreviation | OK | StateAbbreviationCd |
| ZIP | 73118 | ZIPCd |
Business Officer BusinessOfficerGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Person | NATHAN J MCGRATH | PersonNm |
| Person Title | PRESIDENT & GENERAL COUNSEL | PersonTitleTxt |
| Phone | 8442931001 | PhoneNum |
| Signature | 2022-08-11 | SignatureDt |
| Discuss With Paid Preparer | Yes (1) | DiscussWithPaidPreparerInd |
Signing Officer SigningOfficerGrp
Person Full Name PersonFullName
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Person First | NATHAN | PersonFirstNm |
| Person Last | MCGRATH | PersonLastNm |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| SSN | 999009999 | SSN |
Preparer Person PreparerPersonGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Preparer Person | GARY J DUBAS | PreparerPersonNm |
| PTIN | P00252339 | PTIN |
| Phone | 7177617910 | PhoneNum |
| Preparation | 2022-08-11 | PreparationDt |
| Self Employed | Yes (X) | SelfEmployedInd |
Additional Filer Information AdditionalFilerInformation
Trusted Customer TrustedCustomerGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Trusted Customer | 2 | TrustedCustomerCd |
| Authentication Assurance Level | AAL1 | AuthenticationAssuranceLevelCd |
| Identity Assurance Level | IAL1 | IdentityAssuranceLevelCd |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Tax | 2020 | TaxYr |
| Build TS | 2022-09-23 18:48:47Z | BuildTS |
Form 990 IRS990
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Principal Officer | NATHAN J MCGRATH | PrincipalOfficerNm |
US Address USAddress
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Address Line1 | 500 NORTH THIRD STREET SUITE 600B | AddressLine1Txt |
| City | HARRISBURG | CityNm |
| State Abbreviation | PA | StateAbbreviationCd |
| ZIP | 171011167 | ZIPCd |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Gross Receipts | $2,830,354 | GrossReceiptsAmt |
| Group Return For Affiliates | 0 | GroupReturnForAffiliatesInd |
| Organization501c3 | Yes (X) | Organization501c3Ind |
| Website Address | WWW.FAIRNESSCENTER.ORG | WebsiteAddressTxt |
| Type Of Organization Corp | Yes (X) | TypeOfOrganizationCorpInd |
| Formation | 2014 | FormationYr |
| Legal Domicile State | OK | LegalDomicileStateCd |
| Activity Or Mission | THE FAIRNESS CENTER, INC. IS AUTHORIZED TO CONDUCT LITIGATION AS A (A) LEGAL SERVICES ORGANIZATION; (B) HUMAN AND CIVIL RIGHTS DEFENSE ORGANIZATION; (C) PUBLIC INTEREST LAW FIRM; AND (D) ORGANIZATION ATTEMPTING TO ACHIEVE CHARITABLE GOALS THROUGH INSTITUTION OF LITIGATION AS A PLAINTIFF. | ActivityOrMissionDesc |
| Voting Members Governing Body | 3 | VotingMembersGoverningBodyCnt |
| Voting Members Independent | 2 | VotingMembersIndependentCnt |
| Total Employee | 11 | TotalEmployeeCnt |
| Total Volunteers | 2 | TotalVolunteersCnt |
| Total Gross UBI | $0 | TotalGrossUBIAmt |
| Net Unrelated Bus Txbl Incm | $0 | NetUnrelatedBusTxblIncmAmt |
| PY Contributions Grants | $1,802,664 | PYContributionsGrantsAmt |
| CY Contributions Grants | $2,801,596 | CYContributionsGrantsAmt |
| PY Program Service Revenue | $20,922 | PYProgramServiceRevenueAmt |
| CY Program Service Revenue | $25,868 | CYProgramServiceRevenueAmt |
| PY Investment Income | $0 | PYInvestmentIncomeAmt |
| CY Investment Income | $840 | CYInvestmentIncomeAmt |
| PY Other Revenue | $0 | PYOtherRevenueAmt |
| CY Other Revenue | $2,050 | CYOtherRevenueAmt |
| PY Total Revenue | $1,823,586 | PYTotalRevenueAmt |
| CY Total Revenue | $2,830,354 | CYTotalRevenueAmt |
| PY Grants And Similar Paid | $0 | PYGrantsAndSimilarPaidAmt |
| CY Grants And Similar Paid | $0 | CYGrantsAndSimilarPaidAmt |
| PY Benefits Paid To Members | $0 | PYBenefitsPaidToMembersAmt |
| CY Benefits Paid To Members | $0 | CYBenefitsPaidToMembersAmt |
| PY Salaries Comp Emp Bnft Paid | $1,109,611 | PYSalariesCompEmpBnftPaidAmt |
| CY Salaries Comp Emp Bnft Paid | $1,323,251 | CYSalariesCompEmpBnftPaidAmt |
| PY Total Prof Fndrsng Expns | $0 | PYTotalProfFndrsngExpnsAmt |
| CY Total Prof Fndrsng Expns | $0 | CYTotalProfFndrsngExpnsAmt |
| CY Total Fundraising Expense | $72,254 | CYTotalFundraisingExpenseAmt |
| PY Other Expenses | $571,883 | PYOtherExpensesAmt |
| CY Other Expenses | $668,082 | CYOtherExpensesAmt |
| PY Total Expenses | $1,681,494 | PYTotalExpensesAmt |
| CY Total Expenses | $1,991,333 | CYTotalExpensesAmt |
| PY Revenues Less Expenses | $142,092 | PYRevenuesLessExpensesAmt |
| CY Revenues Less Expenses | $839,021 | CYRevenuesLessExpensesAmt |
| Total Assets BOY | $1,273,827 | TotalAssetsBOYAmt |
| Total Assets EOY | $2,132,562 | TotalAssetsEOYAmt |
| Total Liabilities BOY | $75,784 | TotalLiabilitiesBOYAmt |
| Total Liabilities EOY | $95,498 | TotalLiabilitiesEOYAmt |
| Net Assets Or Fund Balances BOY | $1,198,043 | NetAssetsOrFundBalancesBOYAmt |
| Net Assets Or Fund Balances EOY | $2,037,064 | NetAssetsOrFundBalancesEOYAmt |
| Info In Schedule O Part III | Yes (X) | InfoInScheduleOPartIIIInd |
| Mission | THE FAIRNESS CENTER, INC. IS AUTHORIZED TO CONDUCT LITIGATION AS A (A) LEGAL SERVICES ORGANIZATION; (B) HUMAN AND CIVIL RIGHTS DEFENSE ORGANIZATION; (C) PUBLIC INTEREST LAW FIRM; AND (D) ORGANIZATION ATTEMPTING TO ACHIEVE CHARITABLE GOALS THROUGH INSTITUTION OF LITIGATION AS A PLAINTIFF. | MissionDesc |
| Significant New Program Srvc | 0 | SignificantNewProgramSrvcInd |
| Significant Change | 0 | SignificantChangeInd |
| Expense | $1,380,855 | ExpenseAmt |
| Revenue | $25,868 | RevenueAmt |
| Desc | LEGAL SERVICES; THE FAIRNESS CENTER, INC. PROVIDES LEGAL SERVICES TO THOSE HURT BY PUBLIC SECTOR UNION OFFICIALS. SEE SCHEDULE O FOR A DESCRIPTION OF CASES LITIGATED AND THE RATIONALE FOR THE DETERMINATION THAT THE LITIGATION BENEFITS THE PUBLIC GENERALLY. | Desc |
| Total Program Service Expenses | $1,380,855 | TotalProgramServiceExpensesAmt |
| Described In Section501c3 | Yes (1) | DescribedInSection501c3Ind |
| Schedule B Required | Yes (1) | ScheduleBRequiredInd |
| Political Campaign Acty | 0 | PoliticalCampaignActyInd |
| Lobbying Activities | 0 | LobbyingActivitiesInd |
| Subject To Proxy Tax | 0 | SubjectToProxyTaxInd |
| Donor Advised Fund | 0 | DonorAdvisedFundInd |
| Conservation Easements | 0 | ConservationEasementsInd |
| Collections Of Art | 0 | CollectionsOfArtInd |
| Credit Counseling | 0 | CreditCounselingInd |
| Donor Rstr Or Quasi Endowments | 0 | DonorRstrOrQuasiEndowmentsInd |
| Report Land Building Equipment | Yes (1) | ReportLandBuildingEquipmentInd |
| Report Investments Other Sec | 0 | ReportInvestmentsOtherSecInd |
| Report Program Related Invst | 0 | ReportProgramRelatedInvstInd |
| Report Other Assets | 0 | ReportOtherAssetsInd |
| Report Other Liabilities | Yes (1) | ReportOtherLiabilitiesInd |
| Include FIN48 Footnote | Yes (1) | IncludeFIN48FootnoteInd |
| Independent Audit Fincl Stmt | Yes (1) | IndependentAuditFinclStmtInd |
| Consolidated Audit Fincl Stmt | 0 | ConsolidatedAuditFinclStmtInd |
| School Operating | 0 | SchoolOperatingInd |
| Foreign Office | 0 | ForeignOfficeInd |
| Foreign Activities | 0 | ForeignActivitiesInd |
| More Than5000 K To Org | 0 | MoreThan5000KToOrgInd |
| More Than5000 K To Individuals | 0 | MoreThan5000KToIndividualsInd |
| Professional Fundraising | 0 | ProfessionalFundraisingInd |
| Fundraising Activities | 0 | FundraisingActivitiesInd |
| Gaming Activities | 0 | GamingActivitiesInd |
| Operate Hospital | 0 | OperateHospitalInd |
| Grants To Organizations | 0 | GrantsToOrganizationsInd |
| Grants To Individuals | 0 | GrantsToIndividualsInd |
| Schedule J Required | Yes (1) | ScheduleJRequiredInd |
| Tax Exempt Bonds | 0 | TaxExemptBondsInd |
| Engaged In Excess Benefit Trans | 0 | EngagedInExcessBenefitTransInd |
| PY Excess Benefit Trans | 0 | PYExcessBenefitTransInd |
| Loan Outstanding | 0 | LoanOutstandingInd |
| Grant To Related Person | 0 | GrantToRelatedPersonInd |
| Business Rln With Org Mem | 0 | BusinessRlnWithOrgMemInd |
| Business Rln With Fam Mem | 0 | BusinessRlnWithFamMemInd |
| Business Rln With35 Ctrl Ent | 0 | BusinessRlnWith35CtrlEntInd |
| Deductible Non Cash Contri | Yes (1) | DeductibleNonCashContriInd |
| Deductible Art Contribution | 0 | DeductibleArtContributionInd |
| Terminate Operations | 0 | TerminateOperationsInd |
| Partial Liquidation | 0 | PartialLiquidationInd |
| Disregarded Entity | 0 | DisregardedEntityInd |
| Related Entity | 0 | RelatedEntityInd |
| Related Organization Ctrl Ent | 0 | RelatedOrganizationCtrlEntInd |
| Trnsfr Exmpt Non Chrtbl Rltd Org | 0 | TrnsfrExmptNonChrtblRltdOrgInd |
| Activities Conducted Prtshp | 0 | ActivitiesConductedPrtshpInd |
| Schedule O Required | Yes (1) | ScheduleORequiredInd |
| IRP Document | 8 | IRPDocumentCnt |
| IRP Document W2 G | 0 | IRPDocumentW2GCnt |
| Backup Wthld Compliance | Yes (1) | BackupWthldComplianceInd |
| Employee | 11 | EmployeeCnt |
| Employment Tax Returns Filed | Yes (1) | EmploymentTaxReturnsFiledInd |
| Unrelated Bus Incm Over Limit | 0 | UnrelatedBusIncmOverLimitInd |
| Foreign Financial Account | 0 | ForeignFinancialAccountInd |
| Prohibited Tax Shelter Trans | 0 | ProhibitedTaxShelterTransInd |
| Taxable Party Notification | 0 | TaxablePartyNotificationInd |
| Nondeductible Contributions | 0 | NondeductibleContributionsInd |
| Quid Pro Quo Contributions | 0 | QuidProQuoContributionsInd |
| Form8282 Property Disposed Of | 0 | Form8282PropertyDisposedOfInd |
| Rcv Fnds To Pay Prsnl Bnft Cntrct | 0 | RcvFndsToPayPrsnlBnftCntrctInd |
| Pay Premiums Prsnl Bnft Cntrct | 0 | PayPremiumsPrsnlBnftCntrctInd |
| Indoor Tanning Services | 0 | IndoorTanningServicesInd |
| Subj To Tax Rmnrtn Ex Prcht Pymt | 0 | SubjToTaxRmnrtnExPrchtPymtInd |
| Subject To Excs Tax Net Invst Inc | 0 | SubjectToExcsTaxNetInvstIncInd |
| Info In Schedule O Part VI | Yes (X) | InfoInScheduleOPartVIInd |
| Governing Body Voting Members | 3 | GoverningBodyVotingMembersCnt |
| Independent Voting Member | 2 | IndependentVotingMemberCnt |
| Family Or Business Rln | 0 | FamilyOrBusinessRlnInd |
| Delegation Of Mgmt Duties | 0 | DelegationOfMgmtDutiesInd |
| Change To Org Documents | 0 | ChangeToOrgDocumentsInd |
| Material Diversion Or Misuse | 0 | MaterialDiversionOrMisuseInd |
| Members Or Stockholders | 0 | MembersOrStockholdersInd |
| Election Of Board Members | 0 | ElectionOfBoardMembersInd |
| Decisions Subject To Approva | 0 | DecisionsSubjectToApprovaInd |
| Minutes Of Governing Body | Yes (1) | MinutesOfGoverningBodyInd |
| Minutes Of Committees | Yes (1) | MinutesOfCommitteesInd |
| Officer Mailing Address | 0 | OfficerMailingAddressInd |
| Local Chapters | 0 | LocalChaptersInd |
| Form990 Provided To Gvrn Body | Yes (1) | Form990ProvidedToGvrnBodyInd |
| Conflict Of Interest Policy | Yes (1) | ConflictOfInterestPolicyInd |
| Annual Disclosure Covered Prsn | Yes (1) | AnnualDisclosureCoveredPrsnInd |
| Regular Monitoring Enfrc | Yes (1) | RegularMonitoringEnfrcInd |
| Whistleblower Policy | Yes (1) | WhistleblowerPolicyInd |
| Document Retention Policy | Yes (1) | DocumentRetentionPolicyInd |
| Compensation Process CEO | Yes (1) | CompensationProcessCEOInd |
| Compensation Process Other | 0 | CompensationProcessOtherInd |
| Investment In Joint Venture | 0 | InvestmentInJointVentureInd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | AR | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | CA | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | CO | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | CT | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | FL | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | GA | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | IL | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | KS | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | KY | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | ME | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | MD | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | MA | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | MI | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | MN | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | MS | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | NH | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | NJ | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | NM | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | NY | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | ND | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | OH | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | PA | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | RI | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | TN | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | VA | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | WV | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| States Where Copy Of Return Is Fld | WI | StatesWhereCopyOfReturnIsFldCd |
| Upon Request | Yes (X) | UponRequestInd |
Books In Care Of Detail BooksInCareOfDetail
Business Name BusinessName
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Business Name Line1 | MCGILL POWER BELL AND ASSOCIATES LLP | BusinessNameLine1Txt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Phone | 8148273657 | PhoneNum |
US Address USAddress
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Address Line1 | 128 E CENTRAL AVE STE B | AddressLine1Txt |
| City | TITUSVILLE | CityNm |
| State Abbreviation | PA | StateAbbreviationCd |
| ZIP | 16354 | ZIPCd |
Form990 Part VII Section A Form990PartVIISectionAGrp (4 entries)
| TitleTitleTxt | Average Hours Per WeekAverageHoursPerWeekRt | Individual Trustee Or DirectorIndividualTrusteeOrDirectorInd | OfficerOfficerInd | Reportable Comp From OrgReportableCompFromOrgAmt | Reportable Comp From Rltd OrgReportableCompFromRltdOrgAmt | Other CompensationOtherCompensationAmt | Highest Compensated EmployeeHighestCompensatedEmployeeInd |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NATHAN J MCGRATH | |||||||
| PRESIDENT & GENERAL COUNSEL | 50.00 | Yes (X) | Yes (X) | $232,658 | $0 | $19,428 | |
| MICHAEL CARNUCCIO | |||||||
| TREASURER AND TRUSTEE | 2.00 | Yes (X) | Yes (X) | $0 | $0 | $0 | |
| AARON D MARTIN | |||||||
| SECRETARY AND TRUSTEE | 2.00 | Yes (X) | Yes (X) | $0 | $0 | $0 | |
| JUSTIN T MILLER | |||||||
| LITIGATION COUNSEL | 40.00 | $105,518 | $0 | $14,593 | Yes (X) | ||
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total Reportable Comp From Org | $338,176 | TotalReportableCompFromOrgAmt |
| Tot Reportable Comp Rltd Org | $0 | TotReportableCompRltdOrgAmt |
| Total Other Compensation | $34,021 | TotalOtherCompensationAmt |
| Indiv Rcvd Greater Than100 K | 2 | IndivRcvdGreaterThan100KCnt |
| Former Ofcr Employees Listed | 0 | FormerOfcrEmployeesListedInd |
| Total Comp Greater Than150 K | Yes (1) | TotalCompGreaterThan150KInd |
| Compensation From Other Srcs | 0 | CompensationFromOtherSrcsInd |
| Cntrct Rcvd Greater Than100 K | 0 | CntrctRcvdGreaterThan100KCnt |
| All Other Contributions | $2,801,596 | AllOtherContributionsAmt |
| Noncash Contributions | $299,807 | NoncashContributionsAmt |
| Total Contributions | $2,801,596 | TotalContributionsAmt |
Program Service Revenue ProgramServiceRevenueGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Desc | NON-CLIENT LEGAL FEES | Desc |
| Business | 541100 | BusinessCd |
| Total Revenue Column | $25,868 | TotalRevenueColumnAmt |
| Related Or Exempt Func Income | $25,868 | RelatedOrExemptFuncIncomeAmt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total Program Service Revenue | $25,868 | TotalProgramServiceRevenueAmt |
Investment Income InvestmentIncomeGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total Revenue Column | $840 | TotalRevenueColumnAmt |
| Exclusion | $840 | ExclusionAmt |
Other Revenue Misc OtherRevenueMiscGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Desc | OTHER REVENUE | Desc |
| Business | 900099 | BusinessCd |
| Total Revenue Column | $2,050 | TotalRevenueColumnAmt |
| Exclusion | $2,050 | ExclusionAmt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Other Revenue Total | $2,050 | OtherRevenueTotalAmt |
Total Revenue TotalRevenueGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total Revenue Column | $2,830,354 | TotalRevenueColumnAmt |
| Related Or Exempt Func Income | $25,868 | RelatedOrExemptFuncIncomeAmt |
| Unrelated Business Revenue | $0 | UnrelatedBusinessRevenueAmt |
| Exclusion | $2,890 | ExclusionAmt |
Comp Current Ofcr Directors CompCurrentOfcrDirectorsGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $294,083 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $232,450 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $52,515 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
| Fundraising | $9,118 | FundraisingAmt |
Other Salaries And Wages OtherSalariesAndWagesGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $899,487 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $760,312 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $109,351 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
| Fundraising | $29,824 | FundraisingAmt |
Other Employee Benefits OtherEmployeeBenefitsGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $48,986 | TotalAmt |
| Management And General | $48,986 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
Payroll Taxes PayrollTaxesGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $80,695 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $57,174 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $20,671 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
| Fundraising | $2,850 | FundraisingAmt |
Fees For Services Legal FeesForServicesLegalGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $45,388 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $1,518 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $40,605 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
| Fundraising | $3,265 | FundraisingAmt |
Fees For Services Accounting FeesForServicesAccountingGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $64,626 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $2,161 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $57,816 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
| Fundraising | $4,649 | FundraisingAmt |
Fees For Services Other FeesForServicesOtherGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $68,422 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $2,288 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $61,212 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
| Fundraising | $4,922 | FundraisingAmt |
Office Expenses OfficeExpensesGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $42,460 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $20,300 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $20,545 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
| Fundraising | $1,615 | FundraisingAmt |
Occupancy OccupancyGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $101,474 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $50,737 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $50,737 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
Travel TravelGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $105,094 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $54,657 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $40,402 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
| Fundraising | $10,035 | FundraisingAmt |
Depreciation Depletion DepreciationDepletionGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $37,526 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $18,763 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $18,763 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
Insurance InsuranceGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $9,447 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $7,085 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $2,362 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
Other Expenses OtherExpensesGrp (4 entries)
| DescDesc | TotalTotalAmt | Program ServicesProgramServicesAmt | Management And GeneralManagementAndGeneralAmt | FundraisingFundraisingAmt |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SUBSCRIPTIONS AND MEMBE | $108,104 | $93,771 | $8,357 | $5,976 |
| LITIGATION | $72,180 | $72,180 | ||
| COMMUNICATIONS | $9,813 | $7,459 | $2,354 | |
| BANK CHARGES | $3,548 | $3,548 |
Total Functional Expenses TotalFunctionalExpensesGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total | $1,991,333 | TotalAmt |
| Program Services | $1,380,855 | ProgramServicesAmt |
| Management And General | $538,224 | ManagementAndGeneralAmt |
| Fundraising | $72,254 | FundraisingAmt |
Cash Non Interest Bearing CashNonInterestBearingGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $1,141,688 | BOYAmt |
| EOY | $158,362 | EOYAmt |
Savings And Temp Cash Invst SavingsAndTempCashInvstGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| EOY | $1,794,825 | EOYAmt |
Prepaid Expenses Defrd Charges PrepaidExpensesDefrdChargesGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $17,965 | BOYAmt |
| EOY | $30,696 | EOYAmt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Land Bldg Equip Cost Or Other Bss | $219,459 | LandBldgEquipCostOrOtherBssAmt |
| Land Bldg Equip Accum Deprec | $77,968 | LandBldgEquipAccumDeprecAmt |
Land Bldg Equip Basis Net LandBldgEquipBasisNetGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $109,436 | BOYAmt |
| EOY | $141,491 | EOYAmt |
Other Assets Total OtherAssetsTotalGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $4,738 | BOYAmt |
| EOY | $7,188 | EOYAmt |
Total Assets TotalAssetsGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $1,273,827 | BOYAmt |
| EOY | $2,132,562 | EOYAmt |
Accounts Payable Accr Expnss AccountsPayableAccrExpnssGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $75,784 | BOYAmt |
| EOY | $90,684 | EOYAmt |
Other Liabilities OtherLiabilitiesGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $0 | BOYAmt |
| EOY | $4,814 | EOYAmt |
Total Liabilities TotalLiabilitiesGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $75,784 | BOYAmt |
| EOY | $95,498 | EOYAmt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Organization Follows FASB117 | Yes (X) | OrganizationFollowsFASB117Ind |
No Donor Restriction Net Assets NoDonorRestrictionNetAssetsGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $1,198,043 | BOYAmt |
| EOY | $2,037,064 | EOYAmt |
Total Net Assets Fund Balance TotalNetAssetsFundBalanceGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $1,198,043 | BOYAmt |
| EOY | $2,037,064 | EOYAmt |
Tot Liab Net Assets Fund Balance TotLiabNetAssetsFundBalanceGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| BOY | $1,273,827 | BOYAmt |
| EOY | $2,132,562 | EOYAmt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Reconcilation Revenue Expnss | $839,021 | ReconcilationRevenueExpnssAmt |
| Other Changes In Net Assets | $0 | OtherChangesInNetAssetsAmt |
| Info In Schedule O Part XII | Yes (X) | InfoInScheduleOPartXIIInd |
| Method Of Accounting Accrual | Yes (X) | MethodOfAccountingAccrualInd |
| Accountant Compile Or Review | 0 | AccountantCompileOrReviewInd |
| FS Audited | Yes (1) | FSAuditedInd |
FS Audited Basis FSAuditedBasisGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Separate Basis Fincl Stmt | Yes (X) | SeparateBasisFinclStmtInd |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Audit Committee | 0 | AuditCommitteeInd |
| Federal Grant Audit Required | 0 | FederalGrantAuditRequiredInd |
Schedule A IRS990ScheduleA
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Public Organization170 | Yes (X) | PublicOrganization170Ind |
Gifts Grants Contri Rcvd170 GiftsGrantsContriRcvd170Grp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Current Tax Year Minus4 Years | $1,291,800 | CurrentTaxYearMinus4YearsAmt |
| Current Tax Year Minus3 Years | $1,566,789 | CurrentTaxYearMinus3YearsAmt |
| Current Tax Year Minus2 Years | $1,825,258 | CurrentTaxYearMinus2YearsAmt |
| Current Tax Year Minus1 Year | $1,802,664 | CurrentTaxYearMinus1YearAmt |
| Current Tax Year | $2,801,596 | CurrentTaxYearAmt |
| Total | $9,288,107 | TotalAmt |
Total Calendar Year170 TotalCalendarYear170Grp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Current Tax Year Minus4 Years | $1,291,800 | CurrentTaxYearMinus4YearsAmt |
| Current Tax Year Minus3 Years | $1,566,789 | CurrentTaxYearMinus3YearsAmt |
| Current Tax Year Minus2 Years | $1,825,258 | CurrentTaxYearMinus2YearsAmt |
| Current Tax Year Minus1 Year | $1,802,664 | CurrentTaxYearMinus1YearAmt |
| Current Tax Year | $2,801,596 | CurrentTaxYearAmt |
| Total | $9,288,107 | TotalAmt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Substantial Contributors Tot | $3,585,141 | SubstantialContributorsTotAmt |
| Public Support Total170 | $5,702,966 | PublicSupportTotal170Amt |
Gross Investment Income170 GrossInvestmentIncome170Grp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Current Tax Year | $840 | CurrentTaxYearAmt |
| Total | $840 | TotalAmt |
Other Income170 OtherIncome170Grp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Current Tax Year | $2,050 | CurrentTaxYearAmt |
| Total | $2,050 | TotalAmt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total Support | $9,290,997 | TotalSupportAmt |
| Gross Receipts Rltd Activities | $97,315 | GrossReceiptsRltdActivitiesAmt |
| Public Support CY170 | 0.61380 | PublicSupportCY170Pct |
| Public Support PY170 | 0.58600 | PublicSupportPY170Pct |
| Thirty Thr Pct Suprt Tests CY170 | Yes (X) | ThirtyThrPctSuprtTestsCY170Ind |
Form990 Schedule A Part VI Form990ScheduleAPartVIGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Form And Line Reference | SCHEDULE A, PART II, LINE 10, EXPLANATION OF OTHER INCOME: | FormAndLineReferenceDesc |
| Explanation | OTHER REVENUE - 2020 AMOUNT: $ 2,050. | ExplanationTxt |
Schedule B IRS990ScheduleB
Contributor Information ContributorInformationGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Contributor | RESTRICTED | ContributorNum |
Contributor Business Name ContributorBusinessName
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Business Name Line1 | RESTRICTED | BusinessNameLine1 |
Contributor US Address ContributorUSAddress
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Address Line1 | RESTRICTED | AddressLine1 |
| Address Line2 | RESTRICTED | AddressLine2 |
| City | RESTRICTED | City |
| State | RESTRICTED | State |
| ZIP Code | RESTRICTED | ZIPCode |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total Contributions | RESTRICTED | TotalContributionsAmt |
Schedule D IRS990ScheduleD
Leasehold Improvements LeaseholdImprovementsGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Other Cost Or Other Basis | $37,601 | OtherCostOrOtherBasisAmt |
| Depreciation | $7,551 | DepreciationAmt |
| Book Value | $30,050 | BookValueAmt |
Equipment EquipmentGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Other Cost Or Other Basis | $173,392 | OtherCostOrOtherBasisAmt |
| Depreciation | $68,535 | DepreciationAmt |
| Book Value | $104,857 | BookValueAmt |
Other Land Buildings OtherLandBuildingsGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Other Cost Or Other Basis | $8,466 | OtherCostOrOtherBasisAmt |
| Depreciation | $1,882 | DepreciationAmt |
| Book Value | $6,584 | BookValueAmt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total Book Value Land Buildings | $141,491 | TotalBookValueLandBuildingsAmt |
Other Liabilities Org OtherLiabilitiesOrgGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Desc | OTHER LIABILITIES | Desc |
| Amt | $4,814 | Amt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total Liability | $4,814 | TotalLiabilityAmt |
| Footnote Text | Yes (X) | FootnoteTextInd |
| Total Rev Etc Audited Fincl Stmt | $2,830,354 | TotalRevEtcAuditedFinclStmtAmt |
| Revenue Not Reported | $0 | RevenueNotReportedAmt |
| Revenue Subtotal | $2,830,354 | RevenueSubtotalAmt |
| Revenue Not Reported Fincl Stmt | $0 | RevenueNotReportedFinclStmtAmt |
| Total Revenue Per Form990 | $2,830,354 | TotalRevenuePerForm990Amt |
| Tot Expns Etc Audited Fincl Stmt | $1,991,333 | TotExpnsEtcAuditedFinclStmtAmt |
| Expenses Not Reported | $0 | ExpensesNotReportedAmt |
| Expenses Subtotal | $1,991,333 | ExpensesSubtotalAmt |
| Expenses Not Rpt Fincl Stmt | $0 | ExpensesNotRptFinclStmtAmt |
| Total Expenses Per Form990 | $1,991,333 | TotalExpensesPerForm990Amt |
Supplemental Information Detail SupplementalInformationDetail
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Form And Line Reference | PART X, LINE 2: | FormAndLineReferenceDesc |
| Explanation | THE ORGANIZATION HAS BEEN RECOGNIZED BY THE INTERNAL REVENUE SERVICE (IRS) AS A TAX-EXEMPT ORGANIZATION UNDER SECTION 501(C)(3) OF THE INTERNAL REVENUE CODE (THE CODE) AND IS EXEMPT FROM FEDERAL INCOME TAXES ON RELATED INCOME PURSUANT TO SECTION 501(A) OF THE CODE. THE ORGANIZATION ADHERES TO THE PROVISIONS OF ASC 740, INCOME TAXES (ASC 740). ASC 740 ESTABLISHES RULES FOR RECOGNIZING AND MEASURING TAX POSITIONS TAKEN IN AN INCOME TAX RETURN, INCLUDING DISCLOSURES OF UNCERTAIN TAX POSITIONS (UTPS). ASC 740 MANDATES THAT COMPANIES EVALUATE ALL MATERIAL INCOME TAX POSITIONS FOR PERIODS THAT REMAIN OPEN UNDER APPLICABLE STATUTES OF LIMITATION, AS WELL AS POSITIONS EXPECTED TO BE TAKEN IN FUTURE RETURNS. THE UTP RULES THEN IMPOSE A RECOGNITION THRESHOLD ON EACH TAX POSITION. AN ORGANIZATION CAN RECOGNIZE AN INCOME TAX BENEFIT ONLY IF THE POSITION HAS A "MORE LIKELY THAN NOT" (I.E., MORE THAN 50 PERCENT) CHANCE OF BEING SUSTAINED ON THE TECHNICAL MERITS. FOR THE YEARS ENDED SEPTEMBER 30, 2021 AND 2020, THE ORGANIZATION HAS TAKEN NO MATERIAL TAX POSITIONS ON ITS APPLICABLE TAX FILINGS THAT DO NOT MEET THE "MORE LIKELY THAN NOT" THRESHOLD. AS A RESULT, NO AMOUNT FOR UTPS HAS BEEN INCLUDED IN THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS. MANAGEMENT BELIEVES IT IS NOT SUBJECT TO INCOME TAX EXAMINATIONS FOR YEARS PRIOR TO 2018. | ExplanationTxt |
Schedule J IRS990ScheduleJ
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Form990 Of Other Organizations | Yes (X) | Form990OfOtherOrganizationsInd |
| Compensation Survey | Yes (X) | CompensationSurveyInd |
| Board Or Committee Approval | Yes (X) | BoardOrCommitteeApprovalInd |
| Severance Payment | 0 | SeverancePaymentInd |
| Supplemental Nonqual Rtr Plan | 0 | SupplementalNonqualRtrPlanInd |
| Equity Based Comp Arrngm | 0 | EquityBasedCompArrngmInd |
| Comp Based On Revenue Of Flng Org | 0 | CompBasedOnRevenueOfFlngOrgInd |
| Comp Bsd On Rev Related Orgs | 0 | CompBsdOnRevRelatedOrgsInd |
| Comp Bsd Net Earns Flng Org | 0 | CompBsdNetEarnsFlngOrgInd |
| Comp Bsd Net Earns Rltd Orgs | 0 | CompBsdNetEarnsRltdOrgsInd |
| Any Non Fixed Payments | 0 | AnyNonFixedPaymentsInd |
| Initial Contract Exception | 0 | InitialContractExceptionInd |
Rltd Org Officer Trst Key Empl RltdOrgOfficerTrstKeyEmplGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Person | NATHAN J MCGRATH | PersonNm |
| Title | PRESIDENT & GENERAL COUNSEL | TitleTxt |
| Base Compensation Filing Org | $232,658 | BaseCompensationFilingOrgAmt |
| Compensation Based On Rltd Orgs | $0 | CompensationBasedOnRltdOrgsAmt |
| Bonus Filing Organization | $0 | BonusFilingOrganizationAmount |
| Bonus Related Organizations | $0 | BonusRelatedOrganizationsAmt |
| Other Compensation Filing Org | $0 | OtherCompensationFilingOrgAmt |
| Other Compensation Rltd Orgs | $0 | OtherCompensationRltdOrgsAmt |
| Deferred Compensation Flng Org | $7,032 | DeferredCompensationFlngOrgAmt |
| Deferred Comp Rltd Orgs | $0 | DeferredCompRltdOrgsAmt |
| Nontaxable Benefits Filing Org | $12,396 | NontaxableBenefitsFilingOrgAmt |
| Nontaxable Benefits Rltd Orgs | $0 | NontaxableBenefitsRltdOrgsAmt |
| Total Compensation Filing Org | $252,086 | TotalCompensationFilingOrgAmt |
| Total Compensation Rltd Orgs | $0 | TotalCompensationRltdOrgsAmt |
| Comp Report Prior990 Filing Org | $0 | CompReportPrior990FilingOrgAmt |
| Comp Report Prior990 Rltd Orgs | $0 | CompReportPrior990RltdOrgsAmt |
Schedule M IRS990ScheduleM
Securities Publicly Traded SecuritiesPubliclyTradedGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Non Cash Checkbox | Yes (X) | NonCashCheckboxInd |
| Contribution | 1 | ContributionCnt |
| Noncash Contributions Rpt F990 | $299,807 | NoncashContributionsRptF990Amt |
| Method Of Determining Revenues | MARKET VALUE | MethodOfDeterminingRevenuesTxt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Any Property That Must Be Held | 0 | AnyPropertyThatMustBeHeldInd |
| Review Process Unusual NC Gifts | 0 | ReviewProcessUnusualNCGiftsInd |
| Third Parties Used | 0 | ThirdPartiesUsedInd |
Supplemental Information Detail SupplementalInformationDetail
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Form And Line Reference | PART I, COLUMN (B): | FormAndLineReferenceDesc |
| Explanation | THE NUMBER REPORTED IN PART 1, LINE 9(B) IS THE NUMBER OF CONTRIBUTIONS. | ExplanationTxt |
Schedule O IRS990ScheduleO
Supplemental Information Detail SupplementalInformationDetail (12 entries)
| Form And Line ReferenceFormAndLineReferenceDesc | ExplanationExplanationTxt |
|---|---|
| PART III, LINE 4A | THE FAIRNESS CENTER DETERMINES WHICH CASES TO ACCEPT BASED ON THE ISSUES INVOLVED, THE IMPACT FOR THE LITIGANT, AND THE PUBLIC INTEREST, AND NOT BASED ON ANY EXPECTATION OF FINANCIAL AWARD OR BENEFIT FOR THE FAIRNESS CENTER. GREGORY J. HARTNETT, ELIZABETH M. GALASKA, ROBERT G. BROUGH, JR., AND JOHN M. CRESS V. PENNSYLVANIA STATE EDUCATION ASSOCIATION, HOMER-CENTER EDUCATION ASSOCIATION, TWIN VALLEY EDUCATION ASSOCIATION, ELLWOOD AREA EDUCATION ASSOCIATION, HOMER-CENTER SCHOOL DISTRICT, TWIN VALLEY SCHOOL DISTRICT, ELLWOOD CITY AREA SCHOOL DISTRICT, CHARLES KOREN, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS THE SUPERINTENDENT OF THE HOMER-CENTER SCHOOL DISTRICT, ROBERT PLEIS, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS THE SUPERINTENDENT OF THE TWIN VALLEY SCHOOL DISTRICT, AND JOE MANCINI, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS THE SUPERINTENDENT OF THE ELLWOOD CITY AREA SCHOOL DISTRICT. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDED FREE LEGAL SERVICES TO FOUR PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC-SCHOOL TEACHERS LOCATED ACROSS PENNSYLVANIA IN THEIR CHALLENGE TO UNITED STATES SUPREME COURT PRECEDENT PERMITTING EXTRACTING OF AGENCY FEES IN VIOLATION OF THE FIRST AMENDMENT, AS APPLIED TO THE STATES THROUGH THE FOURTEENTH AMENDMENT. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THE CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SOUGHT TO CLARIFY OR EXPAND UPON UNION NONMEMBERS' CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND TO PROVIDE PROTECTION TO UNION NONMEMBER PUBLIC EMPLOYEES FROM HAVING THEIR MONEY USED IN CONNECTION WITH CAUSES THEY DO NOT SUPPORT. ADDITIONALLY, THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE A SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANTS IN THAT IT SOUGHT A RULING APPLICABLE ACROSS THE COUNTRY, WHERE SIMILAR ARRANGEMENTS ABOUND. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANTS REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM NOMINAL DAMAGES AND A RETURN OF FUNDS UNCONSTITUTIONALLY SEIZED FROM THEM. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT HAVE WARRANTED REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE IT WOULD NOT HAVE BEEN FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. WHILE THE IMPACT IS SIGNIFICANT, THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE WERE RELATIVELY SMALL FOR INDIVIDUAL PLAINTIFFS. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFFS' OPERATIVE COMPLAINT RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO FEDERAL LAW. HOWEVER, NO ATTORNEYS' FEES WERE SOUGHT BY PLAINTIFFS IN THIS MATTER. IN RE ERIK GAGNE AND BARRY WALLETT. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDES LEGAL SERVICES TO CONNECTICUT PUBLIC EMPLOYEES WHO HAVE BEEN SUBJECTED TO HARASSMENT AND DISPARAGING MESSAGES POSTED ON UNION BULLETIN BOARDS AT THEIR PLACE OF PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT BY CERTAIN UNION MEMBERS BECAUSE OF THE PUBLIC EMPLOYEE PLAINTIFFS' DECISION TO NOT BE UNION MEMBERS. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SEEKS TO PROTECT PUBLIC EMPLOYEES WHO EXERCISE THEIR RIGHT TO NOT JOIN A UNION FROM ILLEGAL HARASSMENT AND DISCRIMINATION. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANTS IN THAT IT SEEKS A RULING WHICH PROHIBITS THE UNION AND EMPLOYER FROM PERMITTING THE HARASSMENT OF A PUBLIC EMPLOYEE FOR EXERCISING THEIR RIGHT NOT TO BE A UNION MEMBER AND AN ORDER THAT THE UNION AND EMPLOYER MUST NOTIFY EMPLOYEES OF THEIR RIGHT TO NOT BE A MEMBER OF A PUBLIC-SECTOR UNION. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANTS REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE NO FINANCIAL BENEFIT FROM THE LITIGATION. THE RELIEF SOUGHT IS AN ORDER TO REMOVE OFFENDING MESSAGES, PREVENT THE POSTING OF FUTURE MESSAGES, AND REQUIRE THE UNION AND EMPLOYER TO INFORM EMPLOYEES OF THEIR RIGHT TO NOT BE A MEMBER OF A PUBLIC-SECTOR UNION. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT WARRANT REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE IT WOULD NOT HAVE BEEN FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES AND ATTORNEYS' FEES HAVE NOT BEEN REQUESTED. MARK KIDDO, JOAN HORDUSKY, MIKE DZURKO, CHRISTINE ARNONE, JENNIE CLAY, MADELYN GROOVER, MELISSA GUZOWSKI, AND JEFF GRANGER V. AMERICAN FEDERATION OF STATE, COUNTY AND MUNICIPAL EMPLOYEES, LOCAL 2206; AND ERIE WATER WORKS. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDES LEGAL SERVICES TO CITY OF ERIE PUBLIC EMPLOYEES WHOSE UNION BREACHED ITS DUTY OF FAIR REPRESENTATION TO BARGAINING UNIT MEMBERS WHEN THE LABOR UNION CONCEALED THE TERMS OF A PROPOSED FINAL OFFER FOR A COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AGREEMENT AND INDUCED THE BARGAINING UNIT TO RATIFY AN ALTERNATIVE OFFER. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SEEKS TO EXPAND OR CLARIFY THE RIGHTS OF COLLECTIVE BARGAINING UNIT MEMBERS WHEN A COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AGREEMENT IS PRESENTED TO BARGAINING UNIT MEMBERS AND RATIFIED BY THE LABOR UNION IN BAD FAITH. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANTS IN THAT IT SEEKS A RULING WHICH FURTHER DEFINES A UNION'S DUTY OF FAIR REPRESENTATION TO BARGAINING UNIT MEMBERS. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, LITIGANTS REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM POSSIBLY RECOVERY OF LOSS OF WAGES AND BENEFITS. THE RELIEF SOUGHT IS DAMAGES TO PLAINTIFFS REPRESENTING THE LOSS OF WAGES AND BENEFITS INCURRED AS A RESULT OF THE UNION'S MISREPRESENTATION. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT WARRANT REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE ARE RELATIVELY SMALL FOR INDIVIDUAL PLAINTIFFS AND IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFFS' OPERATIVE COMPLAINT HAS RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS. HOWEVER, A REQUEST FOR ATTORNEYS' FEES IS NOT YET RIPE AS THIS MATTER IS STILL ONGOING. JANE LADLEY AND CHRISTOPHER MEIER V. PENNSYLVANIA STATE EDUCATION ASSOCIATION ("PSEA"). THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDES LEGAL SERVICES TO PLAINTIFF SCHOOLTEACHERS WHO WERE RELIGIOUS OBJECTORS DENIED THEIR RIGHT TO FUND CHARITIES OF THEIR CHOICE. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SEEKS TO CLARIFY OR EXPAND UPON UNION NONMEMBERS' CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND TO PROTECT TWO UNION NONMEMBER EMPLOYEES FROM HAVING THEIR MONEY USED IN CONNECTION WITH CAUSES THEY DO NOT SUPPORT. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANTS IN THAT IT SEEKS A RULING APPLICABLE ACROSS PENNSYLVANIA, THROUGHOUT WHICH THE UNION'S POLICY OPERATES. BASED ON THE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANTS REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM NOMINAL DAMAGES AND A RETURN OF FUNDS UNCONSTITUTIONALLY SEIZED. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT WARRANT REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. WHILE THE IMPACT IS SIGNIFICANT, THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE ARE RELATIVELY SMALL FOR INDIVIDUAL PLAINTIFFS. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFFS' OPERATIVE COMPLAINT HAS RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO FEDERAL LAW. HOWEVER, A REQUEST FOR ATTORNEYS' FEES IS NOT YET RIPE AS THIS MATTER IS STILL ONGOING. OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR V. LINDSEY WANNER AND THE FAIRNESS CENTER. THE FAIRNESS CENTER REQUESTED PUBLIC RECORDS FROM THE GOVERNOR'S OFFICE PURSUANT TO PENNSYLVANIA'S RIGHT-TO-KNOW LAW RELATING TO THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE GOVERNOR'S EXECUTIVE ORDER WHICH CREATED A PATHWAY TO UNIONIZE HOMECARE WORKERS. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THE CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT IT SOUGHT TO SCRUTINIZE THE WORK PERFORMED BY GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS IMPLEMENTING AN EXECUTIVE ORDER WHICH COULD POTENTIALLY UNIONIZE AN ENTIRELY NEW CLASS OF PENNSYLVANIA WORKERS. THE LITIGATION HAS SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANTS IN THAT IT SEEKS A RULING ALLOWING FOR ACCESS TO NONPRIVILEGED, PUBLIC RECORDS CONCERNING THE GOVERNOR'S COMMUNICATIONS WITH LABOR UNIONS. THE LITIGATION DOES NOT WARRANT REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. |
| PART III, LINE 4A CONTINUED | WHILE THE IMPACT IS SIGNIFICANT, THERE ARE NO FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE IN THE LITIGATION. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES AND HAS NOT REQUESTED ATTORNEYS' FEES. LINDA MISJA V. PENNSYLVANIA STATE EDUCATION ASSOCIATION. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDES LEGAL SERVICES TO A PUBLIC SCHOOLTEACHER, A RELIGIOUS OBJECTOR DENIED HER RIGHT TO FUND A CHARITY OF HER CHOICE. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THE CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SEEKS TO CLARIFY OR EXPAND UPON UNION NONMEMBERS' CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND TO PROVIDE PROTECTION TO UNION NONMEMBER EMPLOYEES FROM HAVING THEIR MONEY USED IN CONNECTION WITH CAUSES THEY DID NOT SUPPORT. ADDITIONALLY, THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE A SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANT IN THAT IT SEEKS A RULING APPLICABLE ACROSS PENNSYLVANIA, THROUGHOUT WHICH THE UNION'S POLICY OPERATES. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANT REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM NOMINAL DAMAGES AND A RETURN OF FUNDS UNCONSTITUTIONALLY SEIZED. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT HAVE WARRANTED REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. WHILE THE IMPACT IS SIGNIFICANT, THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE FOR THE PLAINTIFF ARE RELATIVELY SMALL. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFF'S OPERATIVE COMPLAINT HAS RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO FEDERAL LAW. HOWEVER, A REQUEST FOR ATTORNEYS' FEES IS NOT YET RIPE AS THIS MATTER IS STILL ONGOING. JAMES R. WILLIAMS V. PENNSYLVANIA STATE EDUCATION ASSOCIATION. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDES LEGAL SERVICES TO A PUBLIC SCHOOLTEACHER, A RELIGIOUS OBJECTOR DENIED HIS RIGHT TO FUND A CHARITY OF HIS CHOICE. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THE CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SEEKS TO CLARIFY OR EXPAND UPON UNION NONMEMBERS' CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND TO PROVIDE PROTECTION TO UNION NONMEMBER EMPLOYEES FROM HAVING THEIR MONEY USED IN CONNECTION WITH CAUSES THEY DO NOT SUPPORT. ADDITIONALLY, THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE A SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANT IN THAT IT SEEKS A RULING APPLICABLE ACROSS PENNSYLVANIA, THROUGHOUT WHICH THE UNION'S POLICY OPERATES. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANT REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM NOMINAL DAMAGES AND A RETURN OF FUNDS UNCONSTITUTIONALLY SEIZED. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT HAVE WARRANTED REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. WHILE THE IMPACT IS SIGNIFICANT, THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE FOR THE PLAINTIFF WERE RELATIVELY SMALL. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFFS' OPERATIVE COMPLAINT HAS RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO FEDERAL LAW. HOWEVER, A REQUEST FOR ATTORNEYS' FEES IS NOT YET RIPE AS THIS MATTER IS STILL ONGOING. CORY YEDLOSKY; WILLIAM WEYANDT; AND CHRIS TAYLOR V. PENNSYLVANIA STATE CORRECTIONS OFFICERS ASSOCIATION, LOCAL SCI-HUNTINGDON; DOUGLAS CLARK, IN HIS OFFICIAL AND PERSONAL CAPACITIES; BRYAN PERONI, IN HIS OFFICIAL AND PERSONAL CAPACITIES; AND PENNSYLVANIA STATE CORRECTIONS OFFICERS ASSOCIATION. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDES LEGAL SERVICES TO THREE PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC EMPLOYEES WHO SEEK ANSWERS RELATED TO TENS OF THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS OF THEIR PUBLIC-SECTOR UNION'S FUNDS THAT WERE EXPENDED IN VIOLATION OF UNION RULES. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THE CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SEEKS TO CLARIFY THE RIGHTS THAT UNION MEMBERS HAVE TO HOLD UNIONS ACCOUNTABLE FOR FOLLOWING RULES REGARDING THE HANDLING OF MEMBER DUES. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANTS IN THAT IT SEEKS A RULING WHICH FURTHER DEFINES A UNION'S DUTY TO BARGAINING UNIT MEMBERS IN THE HANDLING OF UNION MEMBERS' FUNDS. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANTS REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION ASIDE FROM RETURN OF FUNDS TAKEN FROM UNION MEMBERS BUT EXPENDED IN VIOLATION OF THE UNION'S RULES. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT WARRANT REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE ARE RELATIVELY SMALL FOR INDIVIDUAL PLAINTIFFS AND IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFFS' OPERATIVE COMPLAINT HAS RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS. HOWEVER, A REQUEST FOR ATTORNEYS' FEES IS NOT YET RIPE AS THIS MATTER IS STILL ONGOING. MIRIAM FULTZ; DARLEEN DALTO; LUCINDA RADAKER; LACEY BAINBRIDGE; CAROL SHANER; JASON KOHUTE; KURTIS COATES; LISA SOUTHERS; BRITTANY ZAPPASODI; SCOTT CARTER; DEBRA KERSTETTER; ASHLEY CLUCK; BLAINE CHAPMAN; AND BARBARA RICHTER V. AMERICAN FEDERATION OF STATE, COUNTY AND MUNICIPAL EMPLOYEES, COUNCIL 13; THOMAS W. WOLF, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS GOVERNOR OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA; MICHAEL NEWSOME, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS SECRETARY OF THE PENNSYLVANIA OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION; AND BRIAN T. LYMAN, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITIES AS CHIEF ACCOUNTING OFFICER FOR THE COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA AND DEPUTY SECRETARY FOR THE OFFICE OF COMPTROLLER OPERATIONS. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDES LEGAL SERVICES TO PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC EMPLOYEES WHO RESIGNED FROM THEIR PUBLIC-SECTOR UNION AND SOUGHT TO CEASE PAYING UNION DUES TO THAT UNION THEY NO LONGER SUPPORTED. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SEEKS TO CLARIFY OR EXPAND UPON PUBLIC EMPLOYEES' CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND TO PROVIDE PROTECTION TO PUBLIC EMPLOYEES WHO SEEK TO RESIGN THEIR UNION MEMBERSHIP AND/OR SEEK TO END FINANCIAL SUPPORT OF A UNION IN ORDER TO AVOID HAVING THEIR MONEY USED IN CONNECTION WITH CAUSES THEY DO NOT SUPPORT. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANT IN THAT IT SEEKS A RULING WIDELY APPLICABLE ACROSS PENNSYLVANIA, THROUGHOUT WHICH THE UNION'S POLICY OPERATES. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANTS REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM NOMINAL DAMAGES AND A RETURN OF FUNDS UNCONSTITUTIONALLY SEIZED. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT WARRANT REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE FOR THE PLAINTIFFS ARE RELATIVELY SMALL AND IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. |
| PART III, LINE 4A CONTINUED | THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFFS' OPERATIVE COMPLAINT RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS. HOWEVER, A REQUEST FOR ATTORNEYS' FEES IS NOT YET RIPE AS THIS MATTER IS STILL ONGOING. SANDRA SMITH V. SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL UNION, LOCAL 668; MICHAEL NEWSOME, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS SECRETARY OF THE PENNSYLVANIA OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION; AND BRIAN T. LYMAN, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITIES AS CHIEF ACCOUNTING OFFICER FOR THE COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA AND DEPUTY SECRETARY FOR THE OFFICE OF COMPTROLLER OPERATIONS. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDES LEGAL SERVICES TO A PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC EMPLOYEE WHO RESIGNED FROM HER PUBLIC-SECTOR UNION AND SOUGHT TO CEASE PAYING UNION DUES TO THAT UNION SHE NO LONGER SUPPORTED. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SEEKS TO CLARIFY OR EXPAND UPON PUBLIC EMPLOYEES' CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND TO PROVIDE PROTECTION TO PUBLIC EMPLOYEES WHO SEEK TO RESIGN THEIR UNION MEMBERSHIP AND/OR SEEK TO END FINANCIAL SUPPORT OF A UNION IN ORDER TO AVOID HAVING THEIR MONEY USED IN CONNECTION WITH CAUSES THEY DO NOT SUPPORT. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANT IN THAT IT SEEKS A RULING WIDELY APPLICABLE ACROSS PENNSYLVANIA, THROUGHOUT WHICH THE UNION'S POLICY OPERATES. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANT REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM NOMINAL DAMAGES AND A RETURN OF FUNDS UNCONSTITUTIONALLY SEIZED. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT HAVE WARRANTED REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. WHILE THE IMPACT IS SIGNIFICANT, THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE FOR THE PLAINTIFF WERE RELATIVELY SMALL. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFF'S OPERATIVE COMPLAINT RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO FEDERAL LAW. HOWEVER, NO ATTORNEYS' FEES WERE SOUGHT BY PLAINTIFF IN THIS MATTER. MELANIE RORABAUGH V. SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL UNION, LOCAL 668; MICHAEL NEWSOME, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS SECRETARY OF THE PENNSYLVANIA OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION; AND BRIAN T. LYMAN, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITIES AS CHIEF ACCOUNTING OFFICER FOR THE COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA AND DEPUTY SECRETARY FOR THE OFFICE OF COMPTROLLER OPERATIONS. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDED LEGAL SERVICES TO A PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC EMPLOYEE WHO RESIGNED FROM HER PUBLIC-SECTOR UNION AND SOUGHT TO CEASE PAYING UNION DUES TO THAT UNION SHE NO LONGER SUPPORTED. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SOUGHT TO CLARIFY OR EXPAND UPON PUBLIC EMPLOYEES' CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND TO PROVIDE PROTECTION TO PUBLIC EMPLOYEES WHO SEEK TO RESIGN THEIR UNION MEMBERSHIP AND/OR SEEK TO END FINANCIAL SUPPORT OF A UNION IN ORDER TO AVOID HAVING THEIR MONEY USED IN CONNECTION WITH CAUSES THEY DO NOT SUPPORT. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANT IN THAT IT SOUGHT A RULING WIDELY APPLICABLE ACROSS PENNSYLVANIA, THROUGHOUT WHICH THE UNION'S POLICY OPERATES. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANT REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM NOMINAL DAMAGES AND A RETURN OF FUNDS UNCONSTITUTIONALLY SEIZED. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT HAVE WARRANTED REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. WHILE THE IMPACT IS SIGNIFICANT, THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE FOR THE PLAINTIFF WERE RELATIVELY SMALL. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFF'S OPERATIVE COMPLAINT RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO FEDERAL LAW. HOWEVER, NO ATTORNEYS' FEES WERE SOUGHT BY PLAINTIFF IN THIS MATTER. BRADLEY BARLOW V. SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL UNION, LOCAL 668; MICHAEL NEWSOME, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS SECRETARY OF THE PENNSYLVANIA OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION; AND BRIAN T. LYMAN, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITIES AS CHIEF ACCOUNTING OFFICER FOR THE COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA AND DEPUTY SECRETARY FOR THE OFFICE OF COMPTROLLER OPERATIONS. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDES LEGAL SERVICES TO A PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC EMPLOYEE WHO RESIGNED FROM HIS PUBLIC-SECTOR UNION AND SOUGHT TO CEASE PAYING UNION DUES TO THAT UNION HE NO LONGER SUPPORTED. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SEEKS TO CLARIFY OR EXPAND UPON PUBLIC EMPLOYEES' CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND TO PROVIDE PROTECTION TO PUBLIC EMPLOYEES WHO SEEK TO RESIGN THEIR UNION MEMBERSHIP AND/OR SEEK TO END FINANCIAL SUPPORT OF A UNION IN ORDER TO AVOID HAVING THEIR MONEY USED IN CONNECTION WITH CAUSES THEY DO NOT SUPPORT. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANT IN THAT IT SEEKS A RULING WIDELY APPLICABLE ACROSS PENNSYLVANIA, THROUGHOUT WHICH THE UNION'S POLICY OPERATES. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANT REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM NOMINAL DAMAGES AND A RETURN OF FUNDS UNCONSTITUTIONALLY SEIZED. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT WARRANT REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. WHILE THE IMPACT IS SIGNIFICANT, THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE FOR THE PLAINTIFF ARE RELATIVELY SMALL. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFF'S OPERATIVE COMPLAINT RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO FEDERAL LAW. HOWEVER, A REQUEST FOR ATTORNEYS' FEES IS NOT YET RIPE AS THIS MATTER IS STILL ONGOING. FRANCES BIDDISCOMBE V. SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL UNION, LOCAL 668; MICHAEL NEWSOME, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS SECRETARY OF THE PENNSYLVANIA OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION; AND BRIAN T. LYMAN, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITIES AS CHIEF ACCOUNTING OFFICER FOR THE COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA AND DEPUTY SECRETARY FOR THE OFFICE OF COMPTROLLER OPERATIONS. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDES LEGAL SERVICES TO A PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC EMPLOYEE WHO RESIGNED FROM HER PUBLIC-SECTOR UNION AND SOUGHT TO CEASE PAYING UNION DUES TO THAT UNION SHE NO LONGER SUPPORTED. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SEEKS TO CLARIFY OR EXPAND UPON PUBLIC EMPLOYEES' CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND TO PROVIDE PROTECTION TO PUBLIC EMPLOYEES WHO SEEK TO RESIGN THEIR UNION MEMBERSHIP AND/OR SEEK TO END FINANCIAL SUPPORT OF A UNION IN ORDER TO AVOID HAVING THEIR MONEY USED IN CONNECTION WITH CAUSES THEY DO NOT SUPPORT. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANT IN THAT IT SEEKS A RULING WIDELY APPLICABLE ACROSS PENNSYLVANIA, THROUGHOUT WHICH THE UNION'S POLICY OPERATES. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANT REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM NOMINAL DAMAGES AND A RETURN OF FUNDS UNCONSTITUTIONALLY SEIZED. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT WARRANT REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. WHILE THE IMPACT IS SIGNIFICANT, THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE FOR THE PLAINTIFF ARE RELATIVELY SMALL. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFF'S OPERATIVE COMPLAINT RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO FEDERAL LAW. HOWEVER, A REQUEST FOR ATTORNEYS' FEES IS NOT YET RIPE AS THIS MATTER IS STILL ONGOING. |
| PART III, LINE 4A CONTINUED | DOLLY BERNARD V. THE PUBLIC EMPLOYEES FEDERATION, AFL-CIO; MICHAEL N. VOLFORTE, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS DIRECTOR OF THE GOVERNOR'S OFFICE OF EMPLOYEE RELATIONS; THOMAS P. DINAPOLI, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS THE NEW YORK STATE COMPTROLLER. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDED LEGAL SERVICES TO A NEW YORK PUBLIC EMPLOYEE WHO RESIGNED FROM HER PUBLIC-SECTOR UNION AND SOUGHT TO CEASE PAYING UNION DUES TO THAT UNION SHE NO LONGER SUPPORTED. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SOUGHT TO CLARIFY OR EXPAND UPON PUBLIC EMPLOYEES' CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND TO PROVIDE PROTECTION TO PUBLIC EMPLOYEES WHO SEEK TO RESIGN THEIR UNION MEMBERSHIP AND/OR SEEK TO END FINANCIAL SUPPORT OF A UNION TO AVOID HAVING THEIR MONEY USED IN CONNECTION WITH CAUSES THEY DO NOT SUPPORT. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANT IN THAT IT SOUGHT A RULING WIDELY APPLICABLE ACROSS NEW YORK STATE VIA CHALLENGES TO CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF NEW YORK'S PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT STATUTE. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANT REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM NOMINAL DAMAGES AND A RETURN OF FUNDS UNCONSTITUTIONALLY SEIZED. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT HAVE WARRANTED REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. WHILE THE IMPACT IS SIGNIFICANT, THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE FOR THE PLAINTIFF WERE RELATIVELY SMALL. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFF'S OPERATIVE COMPLAINT RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO FEDERAL LAW. ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS WERE OBTAINED IN THIS MATTER. DONNA YANOSKI V. SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL UNION, HEALTHCARE PA; MICHAEL NEWSOME, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS SECRETARY OF THE PENNSYLVANIA OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION; AND BRIAN T. LYMAN, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITIES AS CHIEF ACCOUNTING OFFICER FOR THE COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA AND DEPUTY SECRETARY FOR THE OFFICE OF COMPTROLLER OPERATIONS. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDED LEGAL SERVICES TO A PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC EMPLOYEE WHO RESIGNED FROM HER PUBLIC-SECTOR UNION AND SOUGHT TO CEASE PAYING UNION DUES TO THAT UNION SHE NO LONGER SUPPORTED. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SOUGHT TO CLARIFY OR EXPAND UPON PUBLIC EMPLOYEES' CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND TO PROVIDE PROTECTION TO PUBLIC EMPLOYEES WHO SEEK TO RESIGN THEIR UNION MEMBERSHIP AND/OR SEEK TO END FINANCIAL SUPPORT OF A UNION IN ORDER TO AVOID HAVING THEIR MONEY USED IN CONNECTION WITH CAUSES THEY DO NOT SUPPORT. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANT IN THAT IT SOUGHT A RULING WIDELY APPLICABLE ACROSS PENNSYLVANIA, THROUGHOUT WHICH THE UNION'S POLICY OPERATES. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANT REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM NOMINAL DAMAGES AND A RETURN OF FUNDS UNCONSTITUTIONALLY SEIZED. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT HAVE WARRANTED REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. WHILE THE IMPACT IS SIGNIFICANT, THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE FOR THE PLAINTIFF ARE RELATIVELY SMALL. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFF'S OPERATIVE COMPLAINT RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO FEDERAL LAW. HOWEVER, NO ATTORNEYS' FEES WERE SOUGHT BY PLAINTIFF IN THIS MATTER. HECTOR REYES V. LAW ENFORCEMENT EMPLOYEES BENEVOLENT ASSOCIATION; KENNETH WYNDER, JR., IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS PRESIDENT OF THE LAW ENFORCEMENT EMPLOYEES BENEVOLENT ASSOCIATION; BILL DE BLASIO, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS MAYOR OF NEW YORK CITY; NEIL MATTHEW, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE NEW YORK CITY FINANCIAL INFORMATION SERVICE AGENCY, OFFICE OF PAYROLL ADMINISTRATION; RENEE CAMPION, IN HER OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS COMMISSIONER OF THE NEW YORK CITY OFFICE OF LABOR RELATIONS; FRANK J. MILAZZO, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS POLICE CHIEF FOR THE NEW YORK CITY DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION POLICE. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDES LEGAL SERVICES TO A NEW YORK PUBLIC EMPLOYEE WHO SOUGHT TO RESIGN FROM HIS PUBLIC-SECTOR UNION AND TO CEASE PAYING UNION DUES TO THAT UNION HE NO LONGER SUPPORTED. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SEEKS TO CLARIFY OR EXPAND UPON PUBLIC EMPLOYEES' CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND TO PROVIDE PROTECTION TO PUBLIC EMPLOYEES WHO SEEK TO RESIGN THEIR UNION MEMBERSHIP AND/OR SEEK TO END FINANCIAL SUPPORT OF A UNION TO AVOID HAVING THEIR MONEY USED IN CONNECTION WITH CAUSES THEY DO NOT SUPPORT. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANT IN THAT IT SEEKS A RULING WIDELY APPLICABLE ACROSS NEW YORK STATE VIA CHALLENGES TO CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF NEW YORK'S PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT STATUTE. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANT REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM NOMINAL DAMAGES AND A RETURN OF FUNDS UNCONSTITUTIONALLY SEIZED. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT HAVE WARRANTED REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. WHILE THE IMPACT IS SIGNIFICANT, THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE FOR THE PLAINTIFF WERE RELATIVELY SMALL. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFF'S OPERATIVE COMPLAINT RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO FEDERAL LAW. ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS WERE OBTAINED IN THIS MATTER. WAYNE WONG V. TRANSPORT WORKERS UNION, LOCAL 100, AFL-CIO; TONY UTANO, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS THE PRESIDENT OF TRANSPORT WORKERS UNION, LOCAL 100, AFL-CIO; METROPOLITAN TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY; METROPOLITAN TRANSIT AUTHORITY-NEW YORK CITY TRANSIT; ROBERT E. FORAN, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS THE CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER OF THE METROPOLITAN TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDED LEGAL SERVICES TO A NEW YORK PUBLIC EMPLOYEE WHO SOUGHT TO RESIGN FROM HIS PUBLIC-SECTOR UNION AND TO CEASE PAYING UNION DUES TO THAT UNION HE NO LONGER SUPPORTED. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SOUGHT TO CLARIFY OR EXPAND UPON PUBLIC EMPLOYEES' CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND TO PROVIDE PROTECTION TO PUBLIC EMPLOYEES WHO SEEK TO RESIGN THEIR UNION MEMBERSHIP AND/OR SEEK TO END FINANCIAL SUPPORT OF A UNION TO AVOID HAVING THEIR MONEY USED IN CONNECTION WITH CAUSES THEY DO NOT SUPPORT. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANT IN THAT IT SOUGHT A RULING WIDELY APPLICABLE ACROSS NEW YORK STATE VIA CHALLENGES TO CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF NEW YORK'S PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT STATUTE. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANT REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM NOMINAL DAMAGES AND A RETURN OF FUNDS UNCONSTITUTIONALLY SEIZED. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT HAVE WARRANTED REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. WHILE THE IMPACT IS SIGNIFICANT, THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE FOR THE PLAINTIFF WERE RELATIVELY SMALL. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFF'S OPERATIVE COMPLAINT RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO FEDERAL LAW. ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS WERE OBTAINED IN THIS MATTER. EDWARD MENDEZ AND HORTENCIA GARCIA V. DISTRICT COUNCIL 37, AMERICAN FEDERATION OF STATE, COUNTY AND MUNICIPAL EMPLOYEES, AFL-CIO; LOCAL 983, AMERICAN FEDERATION OF STATE, COUNTY AND MUNICIPAL EMPLOYEES, AFL-CIO; CITY OF NEW YORK. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDED LEGAL SERVICES TO TWO NEW YORK PUBLIC EMPLOYEES WHO SOUGHT TO RESIGN FROM THEIR PUBLIC-SECTOR UNIONS, TO CEASE PAYING UNION DUES TO THE UNIONS THEY EACH NO LONGER SUPPORTED, AND TO CHALLENGE THE UNION'S AUTHORITY UNDER STATE LAW TO ACT AS THEIR EXCLUSIVE REPRESENTATIVE. |
| PART III, LINE 4A CONTINUED | THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SOUGHT TO CLARIFY OR EXPAND UPON PUBLIC EMPLOYEES' CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS, TO PROVIDE PROTECTION TO PUBLIC EMPLOYEES WHO SEEK TO RESIGN THEIR UNION MEMBERSHIP AND/OR SEEK TO END FINANCIAL SUPPORT OF A UNION TO AVOID HAVING THEIR MONEY USED IN CONNECTION WITH CAUSES THEY DO NOT SUPPORT, AND TO CHALLENGE EXCLUSIVE REPRESENTATION UNDER NEW YORK LAW. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANTS IN THAT IT SOUGHT A RULING WIDELY APPLICABLE ACROSS NEW YORK STATE VIA CHALLENGES TO CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF NEW YORK'S PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT STATUTE. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANTS REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM NOMINAL DAMAGES AND A RETURN OF FUNDS UNCONSTITUTIONALLY SEIZED. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT HAVE WARRANTED REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. WHILE THE IMPACT IS SIGNIFICANT, THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE FOR THE PLAINTIFF WERE RELATIVELY SMALL. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFF'S OPERATIVE COMPLAINT RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO FEDERAL LAW. ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS WERE OBTAINED IN THIS MATTER. PENNY GUSTAFSON V. AMERICAN FEDERATION OF STATE, COUNTY, AND MUNICIPAL EMPLOYEES, COUNCIL 13; AMERICAN FEDERATION OF STATE, COUNTY, AND MUNICIPAL EMPLOYEES, DISTRICT COUNCIL 83; AND AMERICAN FEDERATION OF STATE, COUNTY, AND MUNICIPAL EMPLOYEES, LOCAL 2047. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDES LEGAL SERVICES TO A PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC EMPLOYEE WHOSE RIGHTS WERE VIOLATED DUE TO AFSCME'S FAILURE TO FAIRLY REPRESENT HER DURING A WORKPLACE INVESTIGATION AND SUBSEQUENT GRIEVANCE PROCEEDING. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SEEKS TO EXPAND OR CLARIFY THE RIGHTS OF COLLECTIVE BARGAINING UNIT MEMBERS TO FAIR REPRESENTATION. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANT IN THAT IT SEEKS A RULING THAT WOULD FURTHER DEFINE A UNION'S DUTY OF FAIR REPRESENTATION TO BARGAINING UNIT MEMBERS. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANT REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM NOMINAL DAMAGES AND MINIMAL BACKPAY. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT WARRANT REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. WHILE THE IMPACT IS SIGNIFICANT, THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE FOR THE PLAINTIFF ARE RELATIVELY SMALL. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFF'S OPERATIVE COMPLAINT RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO STATE LAW. HOWEVER, A REQUEST FOR ATTORNEYS' FEES IS NOT YET RIPE AS THIS MATTER IS STILL ONGOING. MATTHEW KRAWCZYK V. NEW YORK STATE UNITED TEACHERS; SOLVAY TEACHERS ASSOCIATION; BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THE SOLVAY UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT; SOLVAY UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT; JAY TINKLEPAUGH, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS SUPERINTENDENT OF THE SOLVAY UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDED LEGAL SERVICES TO A NEW YORK PUBLIC EMPLOYEE WHO SOUGHT TO CEASE PAYING UNION DUES TO THE UNIONS HE NO LONGER SUPPORTED. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SOUGHT TO CLARIFY OR EXPAND UPON PUBLIC EMPLOYEES' CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND TO PROVIDE PROTECTION TO PUBLIC EMPLOYEES WHO SEEK TO RESIGN THEIR UNION MEMBERSHIP AND/OR SEEK TO END FINANCIAL SUPPORT OF A UNION TO AVOID HAVING THEIR MONEY USED IN CONNECTION WITH CAUSES THEY DO NOT SUPPORT. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANT IN THAT IT SOUGHT A RULING WIDELY APPLICABLE ACROSS NEW YORK STATE VIA CHALLENGES TO CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF NEW YORK'S PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT STATUTE. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANTS REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM NOMINAL DAMAGES AND A RETURN OF FUNDS UNCONSTITUTIONALLY SEIZED. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT HAVE WARRANTED REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. WHILE THE IMPACT IS SIGNIFICANT, THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE FOR THE PLAINTIFF WERE RELATIVELY SMALL. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFF'S OPERATIVE COMPLAINT RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO FEDERAL LAW. ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS WERE OBTAINED IN THIS MATTER. AMBER WELCH V. CIVIL SERVICE EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION, INC., LOCAL 1000, AFSCME, AFL-CIO; CIVIL SERVICE EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION, INC., LOCAL 1000 AFSCME/AFL-CIO, CITY OF SYRACUSE UNIT 7801-00 OF LOCAL 834; CITY OF SYRACUSE. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDES LEGAL SERVICES TO A NEW YORK PUBLIC EMPLOYEE WHO SOUGHT TO RESIGN FROM HER PUBLIC-SECTOR UNION, TO CEASE PAYING UNION DUES TO THE UNION SHE NO LONGER SUPPORTED, AND TO CHALLENGE THE UNION'S AUTHORITY UNDER STATE LAW TO ACT AS HER EXCLUSIVE REPRESENTATIVE. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SEEKS TO CLARIFY OR EXPAND UPON PUBLIC EMPLOYEES' CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS, TO PROVIDE PROTECTION TO PUBLIC EMPLOYEES WHO SEEK TO RESIGN THEIR UNION MEMBERSHIP AND/OR SEEK TO END FINANCIAL SUPPORT OF A UNION TO AVOID HAVING THEIR MONEY USED IN CONNECTION WITH CAUSES THEY DO NOT SUPPORT, AND TO CHALLENGE EXCLUSIVE REPRESENTATION UNDER NEW YORK LAW. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANT IN THAT IT SEEKS A RULING WIDELY APPLICABLE ACROSS NEW YORK STATE VIA CHALLENGES TO CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF NEW YORK'S PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT STATUTE. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANTS REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM NOMINAL DAMAGES AND A RETURN OF FUNDS UNCONSTITUTIONALLY SEIZED. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT HAVE WARRANTED REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. WHILE THE IMPACT IS SIGNIFICANT, THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE FOR THE PLAINTIFF WERE RELATIVELY SMALL. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFF'S OPERATIVE COMPLAINT RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO FEDERAL LAW. HOWEVER, NO ATTORNEYS' FEES WERE SOUGHT BY PLAINTIFF IN THIS MATTER. CHRIS TAYLOR V. PENNSYLVANIA STATE CORRECTIONS OFFICERS ASSOCIATION. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDES LEGAL SERVICES TO A PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC EMPLOYEE WHOSE RIGHTS WERE VIOLATED DUE TO HIS UNION'S REFUSAL TO PROVIDE FAIR REPRESENTATION TO CERTAIN EMPLOYEES IN THE BARGAINING UNIT. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SEEKS TO EXPAND OR CLARIFY THE RIGHTS OF COLLECTIVE BARGAINING UNIT MEMBERS TO FAIR REPRESENTATION. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANT IN THAT IT SEEKS A RULING THAT WOULD FURTHER DEFINE A UNION'S DUTY OF FAIR REPRESENTATION TO BARGAINING UNIT MEMBERS. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANT REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE NO FINANCIAL BENEFIT FROM THE LITIGATION. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT WARRANT REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. WHILE THE IMPACT IS SIGNIFICANT, THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE FOR THE PLAINTIFF ARE RELATIVELY SMALL. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. |
| PART III, LINE 4A CONTINUED | PLAINTIFF'S OPERATIVE COMPLAINT RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO STATE LAW. HOWEVER, A REQUEST FOR ATTORNEYS' FEES IS NOT YET RIPE AS THIS MATTER IS STILL ONGOING. DAVID PERROTTI V. PENNSYLVANIA STATE EDUCATION ASSOCIATION; AND ABINGTON HEIGHTS EDUCATION ASSOCIATION. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDED LEGAL SERVICES TO A PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC EMPLOYEE WHO RESIGNED FROM HIS PUBLIC-SECTOR UNION AND SOUGHT TO CEASE PAYING UNION DUES TO THAT UNION HE NO LONGER SUPPORTED. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SOUGHT TO CLARIFY OR EXPAND UPON PUBLIC EMPLOYEES' CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND TO PROVIDE PROTECTION TO PUBLIC EMPLOYEES WHO SEEK TO RESIGN THEIR UNION MEMBERSHIP AND/OR SEEK TO END FINANCIAL SUPPORT OF A UNION IN ORDER TO AVOID HAVING THEIR MONEY USED IN CONNECTION WITH CAUSES THEY DO NOT SUPPORT. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANT IN THAT IT SOUGHT A RULING WIDELY APPLICABLE ACROSS PENNSYLVANIA, THROUGHOUT WHICH THE UNION'S POLICY OPERATES. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANT REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM NOMINAL DAMAGES. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT HAVE WARRANTED REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. WHILE THE IMPACT IS SIGNIFICANT, THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE FOR THE PLAINTIFF WERE RELATIVELY SMALL. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFF'S OPERATIVE COMPLAINT RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO FEDERAL LAW. ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS WERE OBTAINED IN THIS MATTER. GERALDINE MCGRAW V. SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL UNION, HEALTHCARE PA, CTW, CLC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDES LEGAL SERVICES TO A PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC EMPLOYEE WHOSE RIGHTS WERE VIOLATED DUE TO MISREPRESENTATIONS BY UNION OFFICIALS AND WHO RESIGNED FROM HER PUBLIC-SECTOR UNION AND SOUGHT TO CEASE PAYING UNION DUES TO THAT UNION SHE NO LONGER SUPPORTED. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SEEKS TO EXPAND OR CLARIFY THE RIGHTS OF COLLECTIVE BARGAINING UNIT MEMBERS TO FAIR REPRESENTATION AND TO DETERMINE ENFORCEABILITY OF PURPORTED CONTRACTS THAT LIMIT THE RIGHTS OF PUBLIC EMPLOYEES WHO SEEK TO END FINANCIAL SUPPORT OF A UNION. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANT IN THAT IT SEEKS A RULING WHICH FURTHER DEFINES A UNION'S DUTY OF FAIR REPRESENTATION TO BARGAINING UNIT MEMBERS. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANT REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM NOMINAL DAMAGES AND RECOVERY OF UNION DUES WRONGFULLY PAID. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT HAVE WARRANTED REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE FOR THE PLAINTIFF WERE RELATIVELY SMALL. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFF'S OPERATIVE COMPLAINT RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO STATE LAW. HOWEVER, NO ATTORNEYS' FEES WERE SOUGHT BY PLAINTIFF IN THIS MATTER. ALAN WISNEWSKI V. SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL UNION, HEALTHCARE PA, CTW, CLC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDES LEGAL SERVICES TO A PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC EMPLOYEE WHOSE RIGHTS WERE VIOLATED DUE TO THE UNION'S BREACH OF CONTRACT AND BREACH OF ITS DUTY OF FAIR REPRESENTATION. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SEEKS TO EXPAND OR CLARIFY THE RIGHTS OF COLLECTIVE BARGAINING UNIT MEMBERS TO FAIR REPRESENTATION AND ENFORCEMENT OF CONTRACTUAL RIGHTS. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANT IN THAT IT SEEKS A RULING WHICH FURTHER DEFINED A UNION'S DUTY OF FAIR REPRESENTATION TO BARGAINING UNIT MEMBERS. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANT REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM NOMINAL DAMAGES AND RECOVERY OF UNION DUES WRONGFULLY PAID. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT WARRANT REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE FOR THE PLAINTIFF ARE RELATIVELY SMALL AND IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFF'S OPERATIVE COMPLAINT RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO STATE LAW. HOWEVER, A REQUEST FOR ATTORNEYS' FEES IS NOT YET RIPE AS THIS MATTER IS STILL ONGOING. RAYMOND MICHIELINI V. INTERNATIONAL BROTHERHOOD OF ELECTRICAL WORKERS, LOCAL 589, LI, NY; LONG ISLAND RAIL ROAD COMPANY. THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS PROVIDING LEGAL SERVICES TO A NEW YORK PUBLIC EMPLOYEE WHOSE FEDERAL CONSTITUTIONAL AND STATUTORY RIGHTS WERE VIOLATED DUE TO DEFENDANTS' CONCERTED CONDUCT IN DEDUCTING UNION DUES FROM HIS WAGES AFTER HIS UNION MEMBERSHIP RESIGNATION, IN FAILING TO RECOGNIZE OR HONOR HIS UNION MEMBERSHIP RESIGNATION, AND BY RETALIATING AGAINST HIM BY UNLAWFULLY ALTERING THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF HIS EMPLOYMENT. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SEEKS TO EXPAND OR CLARIFY THE RIGHTS OF COLLECTIVE BARGAINING UNIT MEMBERS WHO SEEK TO RESIGN THEIR UNION MEMBERSHIP AND/OR SEEK TO END FINANCIAL SUPPORT OF A UNION TO AVOID HAVING THEIR MONEY USED IN CONNECTION WITH CAUSES THEY DO NOT SUPPORT, AS WELL AS THOSE WHO ARE SUBJECTED TO RETALIATION FOR EXERCISING THEIR CONSTITUTIONAL AND STATUTORY RIGHTS. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANT REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM BACK PAY, NOMINAL DAMAGES, AND RECOVERY OF UNION DUES WRONGFULLY PAID. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT WARRANT REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE FOR THE PLAINTIFF ARE RELATIVELY SMALL AND IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFF'S OPERATIVE COMPLAINT RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO FEDERAL LAW. HOWEVER, A REQUEST FOR ATTORNEYS' FEES IS NOT YET RIPE AS THIS MATTER IS STILL ONGOING. LYNNE GARCIA V. NEW YORK STATE UNITED TEACHERS; BOCES EDUCATORS OF EASTERN SUFFOLK, AFT LOCAL 3037, NYSUT LOCAL 22-220; BOARD OF COOPERATIVE EDUCATIONAL SERVICES OF THE FIRST SUPERVISORY DISTRICT OF SUFFOLK COUNTY. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDED LEGAL SERVICES TO A NEW YORK PUBLIC EMPLOYEE WHO SOUGHT TO CEASE PAYING UNION DUES TO THE UNIONS SHE NO LONGER SUPPORTED AS WELL AS A REFUND OF UNION DUES DEDUCTED FROM HER WAGES AFTER HER UNION MEMBERSHIP RESIGNATION. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SOUGHT TO CLARIFY OR EXPAND UPON PUBLIC EMPLOYEES' CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND TO PROVIDE PROTECTION TO PUBLIC EMPLOYEES WHO SEEK TO RESIGN THEIR UNION MEMBERSHIP AND/OR SEEK TO END FINANCIAL SUPPORT OF A UNION TO AVOID HAVING THEIR MONEY USED IN CONNECTION WITH CAUSES THEY DO NOT SUPPORT. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANT IN THAT IT SOUGHT A RULING WIDELY APPLICABLE ACROSS NEW YORK STATE VIA CHALLENGES TO CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF NEW YORK'S PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT STATUTE. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANT REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM NOMINAL DAMAGES AND A RETURN OF FUNDS UNCONSTITUTIONALLY SEIZED. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT HAVE WARRANTED REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. WHILE THE IMPACT IS SIGNIFICANT, THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE FOR THE PLAINTIFF WERE RELATIVELY SMALL. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. |
| PART III, LINE 4A CONTINUED | PLAINTIFF'S OPERATIVE COMPLAINT RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO STATE LAW. HOWEVER, A REQUEST FOR ATTORNEYS' FEES IS NOT YET RIPE AS THIS MATTER IS STILL ONGOING. ROBIN WHEATLEY V. NEW YORK STATE UNITED TEACHERS; NEW HARTFORD EMPLOYEES UNION; NEW HARTFORD CENTRAL SCHOOL DISTRICT. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDES LEGAL SERVICES TO A NEW YORK PUBLIC EMPLOYEE WHO SOUGHT TO CEASE PAYING UNION DUES TO THE UNIONS SHE NO LONGER SUPPORTED, AS WELL AS A REFUND OF UNION DUES UNLAWFULLY DEDUCTED FROM HER WAGES AFTER HER UNION MEMBERSHIP RESIGNATION. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SEEKS TO CLARIFY OR EXPAND UPON PUBLIC EMPLOYEES' CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND TO PROVIDE PROTECTION TO PUBLIC EMPLOYEES WHO SEEK TO RESIGN THEIR UNION MEMBERSHIP AND/OR SEEK TO END FINANCIAL SUPPORT OF A UNION TO AVOID HAVING THEIR MONEY USED IN CONNECTION WITH CAUSES THEY DO NOT SUPPORT. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANT IN THAT IT SEEKS A RULING WIDELY APPLICABLE ACROSS NEW YORK STATE VIA CHALLENGES TO CERTAIN PROVISIONS OF NEW YORK'S PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT STATUTE. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANT REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM NOMINAL DAMAGES AND A RETURN OF FUNDS UNCONSTITUTIONALLY SEIZED. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT HAVE WARRANTED REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. WHILE THE IMPACT IS SIGNIFICANT, THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE FOR THE PLAINTIFF WERE RELATIVELY SMALL. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFF'S OPERATIVE COMPLAINT RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO FEDERAL LAW. HOWEVER, A REQUEST FOR ATTORNEYS' FEES IS NOT YET RIPE AS THIS MATTER IS STILL ONGOING. ALLEN KNABB V. UFCW, LOCAL 1776KS; WENDELL W. YOUNG, IV, IN HIS INDIVIDUAL AND OFFICIAL CAPACITIES; UFCW, PA WINE AND SPIRITS COUNCIL; MICHAEL NEWSOME, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS SECRETARY OF THE PENNSYLVANIA OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION; BRIAN T. LYMAN, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITIES AS CHIEF ACCOUNTING OFFICER FOR THE COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA AND DEPUTY SECRETARY FOR THE OFFICE OF COMPTROLLER OPERATIONS. THE FAIRNESS CENTER PROVIDES LEGAL SERVICES TO A PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC EMPLOYEE WHO RESIGNED FROM HIS PUBLIC-SECTOR UNION AND SOUGHT TO CEASE PAYING UNION DUES TO THAT UNION HE NO LONGER SUPPORTED. THE FAIRNESS CENTER'S ROLE IN THIS CASE IS REPRESENTATIVE OF A BROAD PUBLIC INTEREST IN THAT THE CASE SEEKS TO CLARIFY OR EXPAND UPON PUBLIC EMPLOYEES' CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND TO PROVIDE PROTECTION TO PUBLIC EMPLOYEES WHO SEEK TO RESIGN THEIR UNION MEMBERSHIP AND/OR SEEK TO END FINANCIAL SUPPORT OF A UNION IN ORDER TO AVOID HAVING THEIR MONEY USED IN CONNECTION WITH CAUSES THEY DO NOT SUPPORT. THE LITIGATION WOULD HAVE SUBSTANTIAL IMPACT BEYOND THE INTEREST OF THE LITIGANT IN THAT IT SEEKS A RULING WIDELY APPLICABLE ACROSS PENNSYLVANIA, THROUGHOUT WHICH THE UNION'S POLICY OPERATES. BASED ON THE OPERATIVE COMPLAINT, THE LITIGANT REPRESENTED BY THE FAIRNESS CENTER WOULD RECEIVE LITTLE FINANCIAL BENEFIT, IF ANY, FROM THE LITIGATION, ASIDE FROM NOMINAL DAMAGES AND A RETURN OF FUNDS UNCONSTITUTIONALLY SEIZED. THE LITIGATION WOULD NOT WARRANT REPRESENTATION FROM PRIVATE SOURCES BECAUSE IT WOULD NOT BE FINANCIALLY BENEFICIAL TO A PRIVATE LAW FIRM TO TAKE THE CASE. WHILE THE IMPACT IS SIGNIFICANT, THE FINANCIAL AMOUNTS AT STAKE FOR THE PLAINTIFF ARE RELATIVELY SMALL. THE MISSION OF THE FAIRNESS CENTER IS MADE POSSIBLE BY THE GENEROUS SUPPORT OF ITS DONORS, GRANTS FROM CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS, AND THE GENERAL PUBLIC. THE FAIRNESS CENTER WILL NOT ACCEPT FEES FOR SERVICES. PLAINTIFF'S OPERATIVE COMPLAINT RESERVED THE RIGHT TO REQUEST THAT THE COURT AWARD REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES AND COSTS PURSUANT TO STATE LAW. HOWEVER, A REQUEST FOR ATTORNEYS' FEES IS NOT YET RIPE AS THIS MATTER IS STILL ONGOING. |
| FORM 990, PART VI, SECTION B, LINE 11B | THE FORM 990 IS REVIEWED (APPROVED) BY THE PRESIDENT AND GENERAL COUNSEL AND IS PROVIDED TO THE BOARD FOR INPUT PRIOR TO FILING. THE BOARD RATIFIES THE FILED RETURN AT A LATER DATE. |
| FORM 990, PART VI, SECTION B, LINE 12C | CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY IS REVIEWED AND MONITORED ANNUALLY AND ALL THE FAIRNESS CENTER, INC. OFFICERS AND MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES MUST SIGN THE CONFLICT OF INTEREST DISCLOSURE ON AN ANNUAL BASIS. |
| FORM 990, PART VI, SECTION B, LINE 15A | THE ORGANIZATION'S INDEPENDENT TRUSTEES REVIEWED COMPARABLE DATA IN SETTING THE PRESIDENT'S COMPENSATION AND EVALUATING HIS PERFORMANCE. |
| FORM 990, PART VI, SECTION C, LINE 19 | THE ORGANIZATION PROVIDES THE GOVERNING DOCUMENTS, CONFLICT OF INTEREST POLICY, AND FINANCIAL STATEMENTS UPON REQUEST. |
| PART XII, LINE 2C | THE ORGANIZATION'S PRESIDENT/GENERAL COUNSEL AND VICE PRESIDENT/CORPORATE COUNSEL ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR THE OVERSIGHT OF THE AUDIT AND SELECTION OF AN INDEPENDENT ACCOUNTANT. THE AUDITED FINANCIALS AND INDEPENDENT ACCOUNTANT SELECTION ARE PRESENTED TO THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES FOR FINAL APPROVAL. |
Comments