OVERFLOW THRIFT STORE INC

Reduce your risk when donating: see where the money actually goes.

Cite this

Plain text OVERFLOW THRIFT STORE INC. furp.org, nonprofit organization profile, tax years 2018–2025. https://furp.org/org/overflow-thrift-store-inc-472945323. Retrieved 2026-11-03.

APA furp.org. (n.d.). OVERFLOW THRIFT STORE INC [Nonprofit organization profile; tax years 2018–2025]. Retrieved November 3, 2026, from https://furp.org/org/overflow-thrift-store-inc-472945323

MLA “OVERFLOW THRIFT STORE INC.” furp.org, tax years 2018–2025, https://furp.org/org/overflow-thrift-store-inc-472945323. Accessed 3 Nov. 2026.

Retrieved 2026-11-03; covers tax years 2018–2025. Data: furp.org, CC BY 4.0.

2025 · Form 990 · revenue $2.6M · expenses $2.0M · assets $4.4M

EIN
47-2945323
Address
202 S DUFF AVE, AMES, IA 50010-6642
Website
www.overflowthriftstore.org
NTEE code
P29
Exempt type
501(c)(3): charitable, religious, educational, scientific or literary (corporation)
Ruling date
July 2015 (when the IRS recognized its exemption)
IRS status
Exempt (unconditional) (IRS Business Master File) IRS data ↗
Tax-deductible donations
Yes: listed in IRS Publication 78 (public charity) Pub 78 ↗
Foundation status
Public charity, 509(a)(2)
Cross-check
ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer

Mission

To accept and resell donations to give profits to the poor, provide value minded shoppers a place to shop, and provides opportunities to volunteer to serve the needy

Each tax year counts once: when a return was amended, only the latest return for that period is used below (superseded returns stay listed, greyed, under Finances).

People paid by the organization

None of the 12 people listed on these returns reported compensation from the organization. They are listed below.

Officers and directors, no compensation reported

12 people listed on the returns with $0 (or no amount) in every compensation column: current people first. Hours are as filed on the latest return each person appears on.

NameLatest titleYearsHrs/wk (latest)CompensationOrganizations
Tami Hicks President2018-2025 5 $0 reported 1
Michael Sulc Secretary2018-2025 5 $0 reported 1
Matt Swanson Treasurer2018-2025 5 $0 reported 1
Mike Shupp Director2022-2025 5 $0 reported 1
Mike Haverdink Vice President2023-2025 5 $0 reported 1
Marnie Johansen Director2023-2025 5 $0 reported 1
Aaron Fopma Director2023-2025 5 $0 reported 1
Kevin Geis Director2023-2025 5 $0 reported 1
Kim Schwartz Director2024-2025 5 $0 reported 1
Diana Henning (former) Director2022 5 $0 reported 1
Cathy Twito (former) Vice President2018-2020 5 $0 reported 1
Joe Lawlor (former) Director2018 5 $0 reported 1

People by year

2025 · 9 people listed · none paid · 64 employees · 150 volunteers
NameTitleHrs/wkFrom orgFrom relatedOtherTotalOrgs
Tami Hicks President5 $0$0$0 $01
Michael Sulc Secretary5 $0$0$0 $01
Matt Swanson Treasurer5 $0$0$0 $01
Mike Shupp Director5 $0$0$0 $01
Mike Haverdink Vice President5 $0$0$0 $01
Marnie Johansen Director5 $0$0$0 $01
Aaron Fopma Director5 $0$0$0 $01
Kevin Geis Director5 $0$0$0 $01
Kim Schwartz Director5 $0$0$0 $01
2024 · 9 people listed · none paid · 37 employees · 150 volunteers
NameTitleHrs/wkFrom orgFrom relatedOtherTotalOrgs
Tami Hicks President5 $0$0$0 $01
Michael Sulc Secretary5 $0$0$0 $01
Matt Swanson Treasurer5 $0$0$0 $01
Mike Shupp Director5 $0$0$0 $01
Mike Haverdink Vice President5 $0$0$0 $01
Marnie Johansen Director5 $0$0$0 $01
Aaron Fopma Director5 $0$0$0 $01
Kevin Geis Director5 $0$0$0 $01
Kim Schwartz Director5 $0$0$0 $01
2023 · 8 people listed · none paid · 27 employees · 150 volunteers
NameTitleHrs/wkFrom orgFrom relatedOtherTotalOrgs
Tami Hicks President5 $0$0$0 $01
Michael Sulc Secretary5 $0$0$0 $01
Matt Swanson Treasurer5 $0$0$0 $01
Mike Shupp Director5 $0$0$0 $01
Mike Haverdink Director5 $0$0$0 $01
Marnie Johansen Director5 $0$0$0 $01
Aaron Fopma Director5 $0$0$0 $01
Kevin Geis Director5 $0$0$0 $01
2022 · 5 people listed · none paid · 27 employees · 150 volunteers
NameTitleHrs/wkFrom orgFrom relatedOtherTotalOrgs
Tami Hicks President5 $0$0$0 $01
Michael Sulc Secretary5 $0$0$0 $01
Matt Swanson Treasurer5 $0$0$0 $01
Diana Henning Director5 $0$0$0 $01
Mike Shupp Director5 $0$0$0 $01
2021 · 3 people listed · none paid · 22 employees
NameTitleHrs/wkFrom orgFrom relatedOtherTotalOrgs
Tami Hicks President5 $0$0$0 $01
Michael Sulc Secretary5 $0$0$0 $01
Matt Swanson Treasurer5 $0$0$0 $01
2020 · 4 people listed · none paid · 0 employees
NameTitleHrs/wkFrom orgFrom relatedOtherTotalOrgs
Tami Hicks President5 $0$0$0 $01
Cathy Twito Vice President5 $0$0$0 $01
Michael Sulc Secretary5 $0$0$0 $01
Matt Swanson Treasurer5 $0$0$0 $01
2018 · 5 people listed · none paid · 0 employees
NameTitleHrs/wkFrom orgFrom relatedOtherTotalOrgs
Tami Hicks President5 $0$0$0 $01
Cathy Twito Vice President5 $0$0$0 $01
Michael Sulc Secretary5 $0$0$0 $01
Matt Swanson Treasurer5 $0$0$0 $01
Joe Lawlor Director5 $0$0$0 $01

Highest-paid independent contractors

No independent contractors reported.

Who gave

Contributor names are not public for this form type.

Public charities filing Form 990 or 990-EZ report large donors on Schedule B, but the IRS withholds their names and addresses from public copies. Private foundations (990-PF) are different: their contributors are public.

Finances

Newest first. Each filing: its name on one row, its figures on the row beneath. Greyed filings are superseded by a later return for the same period and are left out everywhere else on this page.

RevenueExpensesAssetsNet assetsContributionsProgram revenueOfficer payEmployeesVolunteers
2025 · Form 990 period ending 2025-12-31 · view filing · original 990 ↗
$2,611,055$2,031,517 $4,383,136$1,286,370 $146,341$2,381,301 $064150
2024 · Form 990 period ending 2024-12-31 · view filing · original 990 ↗
$1,938,110$1,567,690 $2,703,052$706,832 $272,674$1,581,492 $037150
2023 · Form 990 period ending 2023-12-31 · view filing · original 990 ↗
$1,176,493$1,118,627 $575,506$336,412 $40,904$1,126,901 $027150
2022 · Form 990 period ending 2022-12-31 · view filing · original 990 ↗
$1,040,004$965,118 $521,600$278,546 $41,550$998,234 $027150
2021 · Form 990 period ending 2021-12-31 · view filing · original 990 ↗
$892,857$850,994 $470,741$203,660 $93,723$798,973 $022-
2020 · Form 990 period ending 2020-12-31 · view filing · original 990 ↗
$582,456$687,480 $443,546$161,797 $79,547$502,743 $00-
2018 · Form 990 period ending 2018-12-31 · view filing · original 990 ↗
$372,926$316,856 $164,522$158,275 $13,295$359,530 $00-

Funders of this organization

5 grantors reported grants to this organization, $235,684 in all, tax years 2017 to 2024. Exact: the grantor wrote this organization's EIN. Fuzzy: the grantor wrote only a name (foundations' 990-PF has no EIN field), matched to the same or a near-identical name in the same state; the name as filed is shown. From the latest return for each grantor and year, so amended returns aren't counted twice. CSV

GrantorTypeMatchYears givenGrantsTotalLatest yearLatest year's amountGrants
PAYPAL CHARITABLE GIVING FUND DAF sponsor Exact 2021-2024 4$192,694 2024$29,096
show
SERVANT FOUNDATION DAF sponsor Exact 2023 1$25,000 2023$25,000
show
PRAIRIE MEADOWS RACE TRACK & CASINO INC Public charity Exact 2018, 2022 2$11,780 2022$6,780
show
COMMUNITY FDN OF GREATER DES MOINES DAF sponsor Exact 2017 1$6,000 2017$6,000
show
AMAZONSMILE FOUNDATION Private foundation Fuzzy filed as “OVERFLOW THRIFT STORE INC” 2020-2023 4$210 2023$74
show

Nearby + Similar BETA

Organizations like this one: what they do and who they are linked to

Same category: NTEE code and revenue

Ranked without any AI: same NTEE code first, then the same NTEE group; then revenue within 2x, 5x or 10x; then the same state; then similar name and mission text. Same state only · More (100)

OrganizationStateNTEELatest revenueLatest expensesTop-paid titleTop payWhy similar
3 WAY THRIFT STORE INCCAP29 $4,841,315$4,575,933 Treasurer$0 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x, similar name
ASBURY THRIFT STORE INCALP29 $1,348,458$1,370,078 TREASURER$0 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x, similar name
HARVEST THRIFT STOREOHP29 $1,862,574$1,536,456 PRESIDENT$0 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x
FIRST WEST THRIFT STORELAP29 $3,590,229$3,634,235 Director$0 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x
PARK AVENUE THRIFT INCOKP29 $2,178,175$2,065,043 Director$0 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x
THRIFTOLOGY INCOHP29 $3,981,340$3,399,569 Chairman$0 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x
ADELANTE THRIFT INCKSP29 $2,126,656$2,107,595 CHAIR PERSON$0 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x
ANN ARBOR PTO THRIFT SHOP INCMIP29 $1,505,528$1,505,408 Member-at-Large until May 2025$0 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x
ST VINCENT DE PAUL THRIFT STORE OF DALLASTXP29 $3,597,974$3,204,712 Director of Sto$101,170 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x
COUNTRY CLOSET THRIFT SHOP INCOHP29 $1,530,520$1,145,673 BOARD CHAIR$0 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x
TEN UP MINISTRIES THRIFT STOREWVP29 $4,728,665$5,160,257 PRESIDENT$200,298 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x
BOYS & GIRLS CLUB THRIFT STORE OF DETROIT LAKESMNP29 $2,997,207$2,867,995 DIRECTOR$0 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x
GOOD NEIGHBORS THRIFT SHOP INCTNP29 $1,483,075$1,313,505 President$0 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x
ISLAND THRIFTWAP29 $1,326,074$1,129,259 PRESIDENT$0 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x
THE CLOTHES LESS TRAVELED THRIFT SHOP INCGAP29 $1,992,705$1,971,835 Executive Dir.$75,700 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x
EAST COOPER HOME STORE INCSCP29 $1,647,408$1,647,408 Treasurer$0 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x
GUARDIAN ANGEL THRIFTNCP29 $5,000,894$4,677,410 DIRECTOR$0 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x
DESERT THRIFT SHOP INCAZP29 $2,151,331$3,782,637 President$0 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x
GOLDEN GOOSE THRIFT SHOPAZP29 $2,429,727$2,439,074 Director$0 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x
PHILADELPHIA AIDS THRIFTPAP29 $2,237,808$2,129,959 EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR$68,000 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x
HAND UP INCGAP29 $2,207,749$1,928,888 Executive Director$69,242 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x
EPHRATA RE-UZIT STORESPAP29 $3,653,205$2,753,974 DIRECTOR$3,679 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x
ST TERESA MINISTRIES INCKYP29 $1,509,180$982,690 PRESIDENT$0 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x
CHATHAM PTA THRIFT SHOP INCNCP29 $1,738,717$1,716,623 DIRECTOR$0 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x
ST VINCENT DE PAUL SOCIETY OF LAKE MILLSWIP29 $1,346,201$1,036,730 PRESIDENT$0 Same NTEE code P29, revenue within 2x

Who funds organizations like this

Grantors that funded the 100 most similar organizations. Ranked by total given to them. Foundations (990-PF) and donor-advised fund sponsors only. Same matching as Funders above (by EIN, or by name for foundations).

GrantorTypeTotal givenGrantsOrganizations fundedYearsWhich ones
WORLD VISION DAF sponsor$3,860,8106 12015–2019 OK TO SHARE MINISTRY INC
FIDELITY INVESTMENTS CHARITABLE GIFT FUND DAF sponsor$2,505,21046 152016–2024 WELLSPRING INC; HELP CENTER INC; AMERICAN HOME FURNISHINGS HALL OF FAME FOUNDATION INC; WITH LOVE OREGON and 11 more
ONE VALLEY COMMUNITY FOUNDATION DAF sponsor$1,262,8407 12015–2025 HELP CENTER INC
STEPHEN KNIGHT POND FOUNDATION Private foundation$795,0005 12022–2024 AMERICAN HOME FURNISHINGS HALL OF FAME FOUNDATION INC
NATIONAL CHRISTIAN CHARITABLE FOUNDATION DAF sponsor$773,38828 92012–2024 LIGHTHOUSE THRIFT STORE; ADELANTE THRIFT INC; SEEDS OF MUSTARD MINISTRIES CORPORATION; WITH LOVE OREGON and 5 more
AMERICAN ONLINE GIVING FOUNDATION INC DAF sponsor$633,46330 82019–2025 WITH LOVE OREGON; CENTRAL FURNITURE RESCUE; SOCIETY OF ST VINCENT DE PAUL DIST COUNCIL OF LAFAYETTE INDIANA INC; WELLSPRING INC and 4 more
THE CALIFORNIA ENDOWMENT Private foundation$608,89710 12016–2024 NEIGHBORHOOD INDUSTRIES
ASSETS UNDER MOVEMENT DAF sponsor$400,0001 12023–2023 NEIGHBORHOOD INDUSTRIES
NATIONAL PHILANTHROPIC TR DAF sponsor$389,6007 22016–2023 WITH LOVE OREGON; WELLSPRING INC
VANGUARD CHARITABLE ENDOWMENT PROGRAM DAF sponsor$261,50018 62020–2024 HAND UP INC; FORT WAYNE SOCIETY OF ST VINCENT DEPAUL INC; MERCY MALL OF VIRGINIA; WELLSPRING INC and 2 more
THE COMMUNITY FOUNDATION FOR GREATER ATLANTA INC DAF sponsor$250,0002 12020–2022 HELP CENTER INC
DONOR ADVISED CHARITABLE GIVING DAF sponsor$232,54918 92014–2024 WELLSPRING INC; LA PUENTE ENTERPRISES INC; THE CLOTHES LESS TRAVELED THRIFT SHOP INC; BAY AREA FURNITURE BANK and 5 more
JAMES IRVINE FOUNDATION Private foundation$225,0002 12021–2024 NEIGHBORHOOD INDUSTRIES
COMMUNITY FOUNDATION FOR THE FOX VALLEY REGION INC DAF sponsor$223,8005 12019–2024 ST VINCENT DE PAUL COUNCIL OF NEENAH-MENASHA INC
JEWISH COMMUNITY FOUNDATION OF DAF sponsor$222,0004 12021–2024 AMERICAN HOME FURNISHINGS HALL OF FAME FOUNDATION INC

The full list · all similar organizations

Where the money went

Every expense line on each return, biggest first: Form 990 Part IX (with its program, management and fundraising columns), 990-EZ Part I, or 990-PF Part I. Event marks lines the organization itself describes as events. “Events” in each summary adds those lines, conferences and meetings, and the direct costs of fundraising events. Unusual is not the same as improper. Many of these patterns have ordinary explanations. Check the filing.

2025 · Form 990 · $2,031,517 spent · pay $971,745 · grants $0 · events $0
LineAs describedTotalProgramManagementFundraisingShare
Other salaries and wages $849,477$764,529$84,948- 41.8%
Other (as described)Contributions $321,041$321,041-- 15.8%
All other expenses $264,287$219,532$44,755- 13.0%
Interest $164,721$148,249$16,472- 8.1%
Depreciation and depletion $101,165-$101,165- 5.0%
Other (as described)Rent $94,433$84,990$9,443- 4.6%
Payroll taxes $79,472$71,525$7,947- 3.9%
Other (as described)Credit card fees $50,081$50,081-- 2.5%
Other (as described)Moving Expenses $45,474$40,927$4,547- 2.2%
Other employee benefits $42,796$38,516$4,280- 2.1%
Insurance $15,292-$15,292- 0.8%
Fees: accounting $3,278-$3,278- 0.2%
Total$2,031,517100%

View the filing

2024 · Form 990 · $1,567,690 spent · pay $663,601 · grants $0 · events $0
LineAs describedTotalProgramManagementFundraisingShare
Other salaries and wages $566,740$510,066$56,674- 36.2%
Other (as described)Contributions $215,687$215,687-- 13.8%
All other expenses $198,556$146,340$27,338$24,878 12.7%
Other (as described)Rent $178,861$157,398$21,463- 11.4%
Interest $135,089$113,469$21,620- 8.6%
Depreciation and depletion $66,960-$66,960- 4.3%
Other (as described)Property Tax $57,878-$57,878- 3.7%
Other employee benefits $49,028$44,125$4,903- 3.1%
Payroll taxes $47,833$43,050$4,783- 3.1%
Other (as described)Credit card fees $31,528$31,528-- 2.0%
Insurance $16,668-$16,668- 1.1%
Fees: accounting $2,862-$2,862- 0.2%
Total$1,567,690100%

View the filing

2023 · Form 990 · $1,118,627 spent · pay $490,324 · grants $0 · events $0
LineAs describedTotalProgramManagementFundraisingShare
Other salaries and wages $434,467$391,020$43,447- 38.8%
Other (as described)Rent $187,652$165,134$22,518- 16.8%
Other (as described)Contributions $172,178$172,178-- 15.4%
All other expenses $161,085$117,407$22,484$21,194 14.4%
Other (as described)Property Tax $44,585-$44,585- 4.0%
Payroll taxes $36,635$32,972$3,663- 3.3%
Other (as described)Board Costs $30,886-$30,886- 2.8%
Other employee benefits $19,222$17,300$1,922- 1.7%
Insurance $12,458-$12,458- 1.1%
Depreciation and depletion $11,701-$11,701- 1.0%
Interest $6,820-$6,820- 0.6%
Fees: accounting $938-$938- 0.1%
Total$1,118,627100%

View the filing

2022 · Form 990 · $965,118 spent · pay $416,130 · grants $0 · events $0
LineAs describedTotalProgramManagementFundraisingShare
Other salaries and wages $416,130$374,517$41,613- 43.1%
Other (as described)Rent $221,146$194,608$26,538- 22.9%
Other (as described)Contributions $161,364$161,364-- 16.7%
All other expenses $89,988$70,495$19,493- 9.3%
Other (as described)Utilities $27,547$24,792$2,755- 2.9%
Other (as described)Credit card fees $18,926$18,926-- 2.0%
Interest $13,795-$13,795- 1.4%
Depreciation and depletion $9,757-$9,757- 1.0%
Insurance $6,265-$6,265- 0.6%
Fees: accounting $200-$200- 0.0%
Total$965,118100%

View the filing

2021 · Form 990 · $850,994 spent · pay $366,210 · grants $0 · events $0
LineAs describedTotalProgramManagementFundraisingShare
Other salaries and wages $332,721$299,449$33,272- 39.1%
Occupancy $232,912$205,027$27,885- 27.4%
Other (as described)Charitable support $115,998$115,998-- 13.6%
Other (as described)Utilities $34,906$31,415$3,491- 4.1%
Payroll taxes $33,489$30,140$3,349- 3.9%
Other (as described)Supplies $30,135$27,477$2,658- 3.5%
All other expenses $25,962$23,366$2,596- 3.1%
Other (as described)Credit card fees $15,223$15,223-- 1.8%
Depreciation and depletion $9,777-$9,777- 1.1%
Information technology $6,609$5,948$661- 0.8%
Insurance $4,919-$4,919- 0.6%
Interest $4,323-$4,323- 0.5%
Advertising and promotion $3,820$3,820-- 0.4%
Fees: accounting $200-$200- 0.0%
Total$850,994100%

View the filing

2020 · Form 990 · $687,480 spent · pay $278,904 · grants $0 · events $0
LineAs describedTotalProgramManagementFundraisingShare
Other salaries and wages $259,084$233,176$25,908- 37.7%
Occupancy $207,501$186,751$20,750- 30.2%
Other (as described)Charitable support $79,254$79,254-- 11.5%
Other (as described)Supplies $30,517$27,465$3,052- 4.4%
Other (as described)Utilities $27,458$24,712$2,746- 4.0%
All other expenses $21,299$19,169$2,130- 3.1%
Payroll taxes $19,820$17,838$1,982- 2.9%
Other (as described)Shipping/Freight $13,215$11,893$1,322- 1.9%
Depreciation and depletion $9,416-$9,416- 1.4%
Insurance $8,520-$8,520- 1.2%
Interest $5,820-$5,820- 0.8%
Information technology $3,063$2,757$306- 0.4%
Advertising and promotion $2,313$2,313-- 0.3%
Fees: accounting $200-$200- 0.0%
Total$687,480100%

View the filing

2018 · Form 990 · $316,856 spent · pay $95,943 · grants $0 · events $0
LineAs describedTotalProgramManagementFundraisingShare
Occupancy $97,634$87,871$9,763- 30.8%
Other salaries and wages $89,125$80,212$8,913- 28.1%
Other (as described)Charitable support $61,687$61,687-- 19.5%
All other expenses $22,688$20,750$1,938- 7.2%
Other (as described)Utilities $15,436$13,892$1,544- 4.9%
Other (as described)Supplies $7,655$6,890$765- 2.4%
Payroll taxes $6,818$6,136$682- 2.2%
Depreciation and depletion $6,691-$6,691- 2.1%
Other (as described)Vehicle repair $5,786$5,207$579- 1.8%
Insurance $2,242-$2,242- 0.7%
Advertising and promotion $844$844-- 0.3%
Fees: accounting $250-$250- 0.1%
Total$316,856100%

View the filing

Federal grants and contracts

Awards from USAspending.gov to a recipient with this organization's name and zip code. Obligations by federal fiscal year (October to September); each award links to its page on usaspending.gov.

Fiscal yearGrants and other assistanceContractsAwards
2021$0$01
2020$9,000$03
Largest awards · 1 shown
YearAgencyKindProgramDescriptionObligated
2020Small Business AdministrationGrant or other assistanceECONOMIC INJURY DISASTER LOAN EMERGENCY ADVANCE 59.072ECONOMIC INJURY DISASTER GRANT$9,000

State business registration

The same business name in the same state, from the state’s official registry data.

Comments

Anonymous: no account or email. Up to 2,000 characters, at most one link. Comments are checked automatically; some wait for review.