FURP.ORG / PUBLIC DATA EXPLORER

CITY ISLAND THEATER GROUP

Cite this

Plain text CITY ISLAND THEATER GROUP. furp.org, nonprofit organization profile, tax years 2017–2019. https://furp.org/org/city-island-theater-group-134048438. Retrieved 2026-10-22.

APA furp.org. (n.d.). CITY ISLAND THEATER GROUP [Nonprofit organization profile; tax years 2017–2019]. Retrieved October 22, 2026, from https://furp.org/org/city-island-theater-group-134048438

MLA “CITY ISLAND THEATER GROUP.” furp.org, tax years 2017–2019, https://furp.org/org/city-island-theater-group-134048438. Accessed 22 Oct. 2026.

Retrieved 2026-10-22; covers tax years 2017–2019. Data: furp.org, CC BY 4.0.

2019 · Form 990EZ · revenue $72K · expenses $73K · assets $58K

EIN
13-4048438
Address
PO BOX 45, BRONX, NY 10464-0045
NTEE code
A65
Exempt type
501(c)(3): charitable, religious, educational, scientific or literary (association)
Ruling date
May 1999 (when the IRS recognized its exemption)
IRS status
Exempt (unconditional) (IRS Business Master File) IRS data ↗
Tax-deductible donations
Yes: listed in IRS Publication 78 (public charity) Pub 78 ↗
Foundation status
Public charity supported by the public (170(b)(1)(a)(vi))
Principal officer
pamela johnston (its 2025 Form 990-N)
Form 990-N e-postcards
1 filed, 2025 (organizations with gross receipts normally $50,000 or less file this instead of a full Form 990) IRS data ↗
Cross-check
ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer

Mission

The City Island Theater Group will provide community theater on City Island by producing live performing arts events intended to attract and include members, performers and audiences of all ages. We produce at least 3 productions a year.

Each tax year counts once: when a return was amended, only the latest return for that period is used below (superseded returns stay listed, greyed, under Finances).

People paid by the organization

None of the 7 people listed on these returns reported compensation from the organization. They are listed below.

Officers and directors, no compensation reported

7 people listed on the returns with $0 (or no amount) in every compensation column: current people first. Hours are as filed on the latest return each person appears on.

NameLatest titleYearsHrs/wk (latest)CompensationOrganizations
Nick Sala President2017-2019 10 $0 reported 1
Carol McCabe Vice-President2017-2019 8 $0 reported 1
Elizabeth Paldino Treasurer2017-2019 10 $0 reported 1
Mary McIntyre Marketing Director2017-2019 8 $0 reported 1
Susan Rauh Secretary2017-2019 8 $0 reported 1
Amanda Livingston-Martin Board Member2019 6 $0 reported 1
Amanda Johnson Board Member2019 6 $0 reported 1

People by year

2019 · 7 people listed · none paid
NameTitleHrs/wkFrom orgFrom relatedOtherTotalOrgs
Nick Sala President10 $0-$0 $01
Carol McCabe Vice-President8 $0-$0 $01
Elizabeth Paldino Treasurer10 $0-$0 $01
Mary McIntyre Marketing Director8 $0-$0 $01
Susan Rauh Secretary8 $0-$0 $01
Amanda Livingston-Martin Board Member6 $0-$0 $01
Amanda Johnson Board Member6 $0-$0 $01
2018 · 5 people listed · none paid
NameTitleHrs/wkFrom orgFrom relatedOtherTotalOrgs
Nick Sala President10 $0-$0 $01
Carol McCabe Vice President10 $0-$0 $01
Elizabeth Paldino Treasurer10 $0-$0 $01
Mary McIntyre Marketing Director5 $0-$0 $01
Susan Rauh Secretary5 $0-$0 $01
2017 · 5 people listed · none paid
NameTitleHrs/wkFrom orgFrom relatedOtherTotalOrgs
Nick Sala President10 $0-$0 $01
Carol McCabe Vice President10 $0-$0 $01
Elizabeth Paldino Treasurer10 $0-$0 $01
Mary McIntyre Marketing Director5 $0-$0 $01
Susan Rauh Secretary5 $0-$0 $01

Highest-paid independent contractors

No independent contractors reported.

Who gave

Contributor names are not public for this form type.

Public charities filing Form 990 or 990-EZ report large donors on Schedule B, but the IRS withholds their names and addresses from public copies. Private foundations (990-PF) are different: their contributors are public.

Finances

Newest first. Each filing: its name on one row, its figures on the row beneath. Greyed filings are superseded by a later return for the same period and are left out everywhere else on this page.

RevenueExpensesAssetsNet assetsContributionsProgram revenueOfficer payEmployeesVolunteers
2019 · Form 990EZ period ending 2019-12-31 · view filing · original 990 ↗
$72,153$73,043 $58,376$58,376 $15,050- ---
2018 · Form 990EZ period ending 2018-12-31 · view filing · original 990 ↗
$29,435$35,451 $67,446$67,446 $368$29,067 ---
2017 · Form 990EZ period ending 2017-12-31 · view filing · original 990 ↗
$58,792$39,841 $73,462$73,462 $17,877$40,915 ---

Funders of this organization

1 grantor reported grants to this organization, $33 in all, tax years 2020 to 2023. Exact: the grantor wrote this organization's EIN. Fuzzy: the grantor wrote only a name (foundations' 990-PF has no EIN field), matched to the same or a near-identical name in the same state; the name as filed is shown. From the latest return for each grantor and year, so amended returns aren't counted twice. CSV

GrantorTypeMatchYears givenGrantsTotalLatest yearLatest year's amountGrants
AMAZONSMILE FOUNDATION Private foundation Fuzzy filed as “CITY ISLAND THEATER GROUP” 2020-2023 4$33 2023$16
show

Similar organizations

Ranked without any AI: same NTEE code first, then the same NTEE group; then revenue within 2x, 5x or 10x; then the same state; then similar name and mission text. Same state only · More (100)

OrganizationStateNTEELatest revenueLatest expensesTop-paid titleTop payWhy similar
ARTISTREE COMMUNITY THEATER INCNYA65 $63,281$56,526 Executive Dir.$7,500 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
CREATIVE THEATRE GROUP INCNYA65 $93,403$60,949 President$0 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
BIG ART GROUP INCNYA65 $57,711$60,661 Artistic Director/Board President$0 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
AMERICAN BARD THEATER COMPANYNYA65 $56,537$62,249 President$0 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
FLYING CARPET THEATER INCNYA65 $52,829$68,539 PRESIDENT$3,100 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
BLACK THEATRE TROUPE OF UPSTATE NY INCNYA65 $64,834$29,687 Assistant Artistic Director$0 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
VALATIE COMMUNITY THEATRE INCNYA65 $52,539$45,238 PRESIDENT$0 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
L ATELIER THEATRE NY INCNYA65 $95,920$102,088 PRESIDENT$0 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
PROJECT Y THEATRE INCNYA65 $61,132$73,609 SECRETARY$845 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
KAIROS ITALY THEATER NON-PROFIT INCNYA65 $80,137$78,063 President$0 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
NORWICH THEATER COMPANY INCNYA65 $64,702$61,190 TRUSTEE$0 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
EGG & SPOON THEATRE COLLECTIVE INCNYA65 $80,658$84,464 Artistic Director$4,050 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
ELMIRA LITTLE THEATRE INCNYA65 $94,128$90,925 President$0 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
COVEY THEATER COMPANYNYA65 $77,840$76,988 President$0 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
GHOSTLIGHT PLAYERS INCNYA65 $52,562$56,833 President$0 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
SUPERGEOGRAPHIC ENSEMBLE THEATRENYA65 $72,636$55,051 CHAIRPERSON$0 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
PENNSYLVANIA YANKEE THEATRE COMPANY INCNYA65 $61,944$39,550 President$0 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
29TH STREET REPERTORY THEATRE INCNYA65 $65,054$61,889 ARTISTIC CO-DIR.$0 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
STOLEN CHAIR THEATRE COMPANY INCNYA65 $53,330$54,274 Treasurer$1,800 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
MANHATTAN ENSEMBLE THEATRE INCNYA65 $94,925$90,544 PRESIDENT & TREASURE$16,234 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
SOCIETY THEATRE COLLECTIVE INCNYA65 $79,978$67,823 Director$7,617 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
EDUCATIONAL THEATER OF NEW YORKNYA65 $65,313$63,597 Treasurer$5,000 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
WHAT WILL THE NEIGHBORS SAYNYA65 $75,088$76,650 Co-Artistic Director$5,500 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
UP IN ONE PRODUCTIONS INCNYA65 $62,000$55,481 PRESIDENT/TREASURER$0 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state
STISSING THEATRE GUILD INCNYA65 $53,644$12,173 PRESIDENT$0 Same NTEE code A65, revenue within 2x, same state

Who funds organizations like this

Grantors that funded the 100 most similar organizations. Ranked by total given to them. Foundations (990-PF) and donor-advised fund sponsors only. Same matching as Funders above (by EIN, or by name for foundations).

GrantorTypeTotal givenGrantsOrganizations fundedYearsWhich ones
DONOR ADVISED CHARITABLE GIVING DAF sponsor$743,55022 62014–2024 INTERNATIONAL THEATRE AND LITERACY PROJECT INC; METTAWEE THEATRE CO INC; POLARIS PRODUCTIONS; CHESTER THEATRE GROUP OF THE BLACK RIVER PLAYHOUSE and 2 more
FIDELITY INVESTMENTS CHARITABLE GIFT FUND DAF sponsor$446,55014 72018–2024 INTERNATIONAL THEATRE AND LITERACY PROJECT INC; ACTON COMMUNITY CENTER INC; MELODY MUSICAL THEATER GROUP; FGP NYC and 3 more
THE COMMUNITY FOUNDATION FOR GREATER ATLANTA INC DAF sponsor$408,00011 12014–2024 FLYING CARPET THEATER INC
HARRISON FAMILY FOUNDATION INC Private foundation$300,0002 12016–2017 BELT THEATER COMPANY
CONRAD PREBYS FOUNDATION Private foundation$202,9352 12023–2023 COMMON GROUND THEATRE
COMMUNITY FOUNDATION OF ORANGE COUNTY DAF sponsor$202,5007 12018–2024 DENIZEN THEATRE INC
SERVANT FOUNDATION DAF sponsor$100,0004 12019–2022 PURE CREATIVE ARTS
COMMUNITY FOUNDATION OF GRAND FORKS EAST GRAND FORKS AND REGION DAF sponsor$98,9878 12012–2023 GREATER GRAND FORKS COMMUNITY THEATRE
COMMUNITY FOUNDATION OF SARASOTA COUNTY INC DAF sponsor$88,9074 12016–2023 THEATER ODYSSEY INC
ROCHESTER AREA COMMUNITY FOUNDATION DAF sponsor$83,7026 32020–2023 PENNSYLVANIA YANKEE THEATRE COMPANY INC; DEEP ARTS INC; COMPANY THEATRE
PAYPAL CHARITABLE GIVING FUND DAF sponsor$80,8968 32018–2024 WOODSHILL INC; THE GHENT PLAYHOUSE INC; BRAVE NEW WORLD REPERTORY THEATRE
ROBERT WOOD JOHNSON FOUNDATION Private foundation$73,75010 12010–2021 FLYING CARPET THEATER INC
WINSTON FOUNDATION INC Private foundation$67,0002 12020–2022 CLUTCH PRODUCTIONS INC
THE LUZERNE FOUNDATION DAF sponsor$65,0002 12017–2020 PURE CREATIVE ARTS
FORGOOD INC DAF sponsor$52,1346 32017–2022 ZEUSS THIGH LTD; MIDDLETON PLAYERS THEATER INC; GREATER GRAND FORKS COMMUNITY THEATRE

The full list · all similar organizations

Where the money went

Every expense line on each return, biggest first: Form 990 Part IX (with its program, management and fundraising columns), 990-EZ Part I, or 990-PF Part I. Event marks lines the organization itself describes as events. “Events” in each summary adds those lines, conferences and meetings, and the direct costs of fundraising events. Unusual is not the same as improper. Many of these patterns have ordinary explanations. Check the filing.

2019 · Form 990EZ · $73,043 spent · pay $0 · grants $0 · events $0
LineAs describedTotalShare
Other expenses (detail on Schedule O) $50,714 69.4%
Occupancy, rent, utilities, maintenance $9,000 12.3%
Printing, publications, postage $7,829 10.7%
Fees to independent contractors $5,500 7.5%
Total$73,043100%

View the filing

2018 · Form 990EZ · $35,451 spent · pay $0 · grants $0 · events $0
LineAs describedTotalShare
Other expenses (detail on Schedule O) $18,151 51.2%
Occupancy, rent, utilities, maintenance $9,787 27.6%
Printing, publications, postage $5,913 16.7%
Fees to independent contractors $1,600 4.5%
Total$35,451100%

View the filing

2017 · Form 990EZ · $39,841 spent · pay $0 · grants $0 · events $0
LineAs describedTotalShare
Other expenses (detail on Schedule O) $18,800 47.2%
Occupancy, rent, utilities, maintenance $11,677 29.3%
Printing, publications, postage $5,404 13.6%
Fees to independent contractors $3,960 9.9%
Total$39,841100%

View the filing