JUDITH L CHIARA CHARITABLE FUND INC: Form 990PF, tax year 2012

View the entire original 990 at ProPublica ↗

Organization
JUDITH L CHIARA CHARITABLE FUND INC (EIN 31-1577990)
Tax period
2012-11-01 to 2013-10-31
Filed
2014-02-26
IRS object ID
201410579349100206
Schema version
2012v2.3
Source
Download XML · Original 990 at ProPublica

Every field in the e-filed return. Faint text is the IRS element name, for citing.

Return header ReturnHeader

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Timestamp2014-02-26T15:13:20-06:00Timestamp
Tax Period End Date2013-10-31TaxPeriodEndDate

Preparer Firm PreparerFirm

Preparer Firm Business Name PreparerFirmBusinessName

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Business Name Line1LCS TAX LLCBusinessNameLine1

Preparer Firm US Address PreparerFirmUSAddress

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Address Line1595 MADISON AVENUE - 16TH FLOORAddressLine1
CityNEW YORKCity
StateNYState
ZIP Code10022ZIPCode
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Return Type990PFReturnType
Tax Period Begin Date2012-11-01TaxPeriodBeginDate

Filer Filer

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
EIN311577990EIN

Name Name

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Business Name Line1Judith L Chiara Charitable Fund IncBusinessNameLine1
Business Name Line2c/o Levin Capital StrategiesBusinessNameLine2
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
In Care Of Name% LCS TAX LLCInCareOfName
Name ControlJUDINameControl
Phone2122590849Phone

US Address USAddress

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Address Line1595 Madison Avenue - 16th FloorAddressLine1
Address Line2SuiteAddressLine2
CityNew YorkCity
StateNYState
ZIP Code10022ZIPCode

Officer Officer

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
NameJOHN T BEATYName
TitlePRESIDENTTitle
Phone2122590849Phone
Date Signed2014-02-26DateSigned
Authorize Third PartytrueAuthorizeThirdParty

Preparer Preparer

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Phone2122590849Phone
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Tax Year2012TaxYear
Build TS2015-12-30 17:16:21ZBuildTS

Form 990-PF IRS990PF

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Exempt PFXExemptPF
FMV Assets EOY11481531FMVAssetsEOY
Method Of Accounting CashXMethodOfAccountingCash

Analysis Of Revenue And Expenses AnalysisOfRevenueAndExpenses

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Contri Received Rev And Expnss0ContriReceivedRevAndExpnss
Dividends Rev And Expnss290714DividendsRevAndExpnss
Dividends Net Invst Incm290714DividendsNetInvstIncm
Net Gain Sale Assets Rev And Expnss402534NetGainSaleAssetsRevAndExpnss
Gross Sales Price1528203GrossSalesPrice
Capital Gain Net Incm Net Invst Incm402534CapitalGainNetIncmNetInvstIncm
Total Revenue And Expenses693248TotalRevenueAndExpenses
Total Net Investment Income693248TotalNetInvestmentIncome
Comp Ofcr Dir Trst Rev And Expnss0CompOfcrDirTrstRevAndExpnss
Accounting Fees Rev And Expnss9375AccountingFeesRevAndExpnss
Accounting Fees Net Invst Incm0AccountingFeesNetInvstIncm
Accounting Fees Adj Net Incm0AccountingFeesAdjNetIncm
Accounting Fees Dsbrs Chrtbl Prps0AccountingFeesDsbrsChrtblPrps
Other Prof Fees Rev And Expnss58403OtherProfFeesRevAndExpnss
Other Prof Fees Net Invst Incm58403OtherProfFeesNetInvstIncm
Taxes Rev And Expnss19500TaxesRevAndExpnss
Other Expenses Rev And Expnss888OtherExpensesRevAndExpnss
Other Expenses Net Invst Incm38OtherExpensesNetInvstIncm
Tot Opr Expenses Rev And Expnss88166TotOprExpensesRevAndExpnss
Tot Opr Expenses Net Invst Incm58441TotOprExpensesNetInvstIncm
Tot Opr Expenses Adj Net Incm0TotOprExpensesAdjNetIncm
Tot Opr Expenses Dsbrs Chrtbl Prps0TotOprExpensesDsbrsChrtblPrps
Contri Gifts Paid Rev And Expnss605000ContriGiftsPaidRevAndExpnss
Contri Gifts Paid Dsbrs Chrtbl Prps605000ContriGiftsPaidDsbrsChrtblPrps
Total Expenses Rev And Expnss693166TotalExpensesRevAndExpnss
Total Expenses Net Invst Incm58441TotalExpensesNetInvstIncm
Total Expenses Adj Net Incm0TotalExpensesAdjNetIncm
Total Expenses Dsbrs Chrtbl Prps605000TotalExpensesDsbrsChrtblPrps
Excess Of Revenue Over Expenses82ExcessOfRevenueOverExpenses
Net Investment Income634807NetInvestmentIncome

Balance Sheets BalanceSheets

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Cash BOY1385499CashBOY
Cash EOY1054894CashEOY
Cash EOYFMV1054894CashEOYFMV
Investments Corp Stock BOY6053124InvestmentsCorpStockBOY
Investments Corp Stock EOY6383812InvestmentsCorpStockEOY
Investments Corp Stock EOYFMV8865577InvestmentsCorpStockEOYFMV
Other Assets BOY1504630OtherAssetsBOY
Other Assets EOY1504630OtherAssetsEOY
Other Assets EOYFMV1561060OtherAssetsEOYFMV
Total Assets BOY8943253TotalAssetsBOY
Total Assets EOY8943336TotalAssetsEOY
Total Assets EOYFMV11481531TotalAssetsEOYFMV
Total Liabilities EOY0TotalLiabilitiesEOY
Org That Do Not Follow SFAS117XOrgThatDoNotFollowSFAS117
Capital Stock BOY18045602CapitalStockBOY
Capital Stock EOY8943253CapitalStockEOY
Retained Earnings BOY-9102349RetainedEarningsBOY
Retained Earnings EOY83RetainedEarningsEOY
Total Net Assets BOY8943253TotalNetAssetsBOY
Total Net Assets EOY8943336TotalNetAssetsEOY
Total Liabilities Net Assets BOY8943253TotalLiabilitiesNetAssetsBOY
Total Liabilities Net Assets EOY8943336TotalLiabilitiesNetAssetsEOY

Changes In Net Assets Fund Balances ChangesInNetAssetsFundBalances

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total Net Assets Fund Balances BOY8943253TotalNetAssetsFundBalancesBOY
Excess Of Revenue Over Expenses82ExcessOfRevenueOverExpenses
Other Increases1OtherIncreases
Subtotal8943336Subtotal
Total Net Assets Fund Balances EOY8943336TotalNetAssetsFundBalancesEOY

Capital Gains And Losses CapitalGainsAndLosses

Capital Gains And Losses Info CapitalGainsAndLossesInfo (2 entries)

Description Of AssetDescriptionOfAssetHow AcquiredHowAcquiredGross Sales PriceGrossSalesPriceCost Or Other BasisCostOrOtherBasisGain Or LossGainOrLossGains Minus Excess Or LossesGainsMinusExcessOrLosses
PUBLICLY TRADED SECURITIESP1259509897944361565361565
PUBLICLY TRADED SECURITIESP2686942277254096940969
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Capital Gain Net Income402534CapitalGainNetIncome

Qlfy Und Sect4940e For Reduced Tax QlfyUndSect4940eForReducedTax

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Liable For4942 TaxfalseLiableFor4942Tax
Qualifying Distributions Year1685000QualifyingDistributionsYear1
Noncharitable Assets Year110498490NoncharitableAssetsYear1
Distribution Ratio Year10.065247DistributionRatioYear1
Qualifying Distributions Year2682865QualifyingDistributionsYear2
Noncharitable Assets Year210331211NoncharitableAssetsYear2
Distribution Ratio Year20.066097DistributionRatioYear2
Qualifying Distributions Year3878510QualifyingDistributionsYear3
Noncharitable Assets Year39590548NoncharitableAssetsYear3
Distribution Ratio Year30.091602DistributionRatioYear3
Qualifying Distributions Year41042337QualifyingDistributionsYear4
Noncharitable Assets Year49168518NoncharitableAssetsYear4
Distribution Ratio Year40.113687DistributionRatioYear4
Qualifying Distributions Year5933326QualifyingDistributionsYear5
Noncharitable Assets Year513620725NoncharitableAssetsYear5
Distribution Ratio Year50.068522DistributionRatioYear5
Total Distribution Ratio0.405155TotalDistributionRatio
Average Distribution Ratio0.081031AverageDistributionRatio
Net Noncharitable Assets10819993NetNoncharitableAssets
Adjusted Noncharitable Assets876755AdjustedNoncharitableAssets
One Percent Net Investment Income6348OnePercentNetInvestmentIncome
Adj Nonchrtbl Assets And One883103AdjNonchrtblAssetsAndOnePct
Qualifying Distributions605000QualifyingDistributions

Excise Tax Based On Investment Incm ExciseTaxBasedOnInvestmentIncm

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Investment Income Excise Tax12696InvestmentIncomeExciseTax
Subtotal12696Subtotal
Tax Based On Investment Income12696TaxBasedOnInvestmentIncome
Est Tax Payments And Overpayment7550EstTaxPaymentsAndOverpayment
Total Credits And Payments7550TotalCreditsAndPayments
Penalty For Underpayment128PenaltyForUnderpayment
Tax Due5274TaxDue

Statements Regarding Activities StatementsRegardingActivities

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Legislative Political ActivitiesfalseLegislativePoliticalActivities
More Than100 SpentfalseMoreThan100Spent
Form1120 POL FiledfalseForm1120POLFiled
Activities Not Prev ReportedfalseActivitiesNotPrevReported
Changes To Articles Or BylawsfalseChangesToArticlesOrBylaws
Unrelated Bus Income Over1000falseUnrelatedBusIncomeOver1000
Termination EtcfalseTerminationEtc
Requirements Of Sect508etrueRequirementsOfSect508e
At Least5000 In AssetstrueAtLeast5000InAssets
States Filed WithNYStatesFiledWith
Form990 PF Filed With AGtrueForm990PFFiledWithAG
Private Operating FoundationfalsePrivateOperatingFoundation
New Substantial ContributorsfalseNewSubstantialContributors
Interest In Controlled EntityfalseInterestInControlledEntity
Applicable Insurance ContractfalseApplicableInsuranceContract
Comply With Public Inspection RqrtrueComplyWithPublicInspectionRqr

Books In Care Of Business Name BooksInCareOfBusinessName

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Business Name Line1LCS TAX LLCBusinessNameLine1
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Books In Care Of Phone Number2122590849BooksInCareOfPhoneNumber

Books In Care Of US Address BooksInCareOfUSAddress

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Address Line1595 MADISON AVENUEAddressLine1
CityNEW YORKCity
StateNYState
ZIP Code10022ZIPCode

Statements Regarding Acty4720 StatementsRegardingActy4720

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Sale Or Exchange With Dsqfly PersonfalseSaleOrExchangeWithDsqflyPerson
Borrow Or Lend With Dsqfly PersonfalseBorrowOrLendWithDsqflyPerson
Furnished Goods With Dsqfly PersonfalseFurnishedGoodsWithDsqflyPerson
Pay Compensation To Dsqfly PersonfalsePayCompensationToDsqflyPerson
Transfer Assets To Dsqfly PersonfalseTransferAssetsToDsqflyPerson
Payment To Government OfficalfalsePaymentToGovernmentOffical
Uncorrected Prior ActsfalseUncorrectedPriorActs
Undistributed Income Prior YearsfalseUndistributedIncomePriorYears
Business HoldingsfalseBusinessHoldings
Jeopardy InvestmentsfalseJeopardyInvestments
Uncorrected Jeopardy InvestmentsfalseUncorrectedJeopardyInvestments
Influence LegislationfalseInfluenceLegislation
Influence ElectionfalseInfluenceElection
Grants To IndividualsfalseGrantsToIndividuals
Grants To OrganizationsfalseGrantsToOrganizations
Noncharitable PurposefalseNoncharitablePurpose
Rcv Funds To Pay Prsnl Bnft ContractfalseRcvFundsToPayPrsnlBnftContract
Pay Premiums Prsnl Bnft ContractfalsePayPremiumsPrsnlBnftContract
Prohibited Tax Shelter TransactnfalseProhibitedTaxShelterTransactn

Ofcr Dir Trustees Key Employee Info OfcrDirTrusteesKeyEmployeeInfo

Ofcr Dir Trustees Or Key Employee OfcrDirTrusteesOrKeyEmployee (3 entries)

Address Line1USAddress/AddressLine1CityUSAddress/CityStateUSAddress/StateZIP CodeUSAddress/ZIPCodeTitleTitleAvg Hours Per Wk Devoted To PositionAvgHoursPerWkDevotedToPositionCompensationCompensationContri To Empl Benefit Plans EtcContriToEmplBenefitPlansEtcExpense Account Other AllowancesExpenseAccountOtherAllowances
MR JOHN T BEATY
595 Madison Avenue - 16th FloorNew YorkNY1002200000
MR JEROME MANNING
595 Madison Avenue - 16th FloorNew YorkNY1002200000
MR ROBERT BERNHARD
595 Madison Avenue - 16th FloorNew YorkNY1002200000

Summary Of Direct Charitable Acty SummaryOfDirectCharitableActy

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Description1N/ADescription1
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Sum Of Program Related InvestmentsSumOfProgramRelatedInvestments

Minimum Investment Return MinimumInvestmentReturn

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Avg Monthly FMV Of Securities9865472AvgMonthlyFMVOfSecurities
Avg Monthly Cash Balances1119292AvgMonthlyCashBalances
FMV All Other Noncharitable Assets0FMVAllOtherNoncharitableAssets
Total FMV Of Unused Assets10984764TotalFMVOfUnusedAssets
Acquisition Indebtedness0AcquisitionIndebtedness
Adj Total FMV Of Unused Assets10984764AdjTotalFMVOfUnusedAssets
Cash Deemed Charitable164771CashDeemedCharitable
Net Noncharitable Assets10819993NetNoncharitableAssets
Minimum Investment Return541000MinimumInvestmentReturn

Distributable DistributableAmount

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Minimum Investment Return541000MinimumInvestmentReturn
Tax Based On Investment Income12696TaxBasedOnInvestmentIncome
Total Tax12696TotalTax
Distributable Amount Before Adj528304DistributableAmountBeforeAdj
Distributable Amount Before Ded528304DistributableAmountBeforeDed
Distributable Amount As Adjusted528304DistributableAmountAsAdjusted

Qualifying Distributions QualifyingDistributions

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Expenses And Contributions605000ExpensesAndContributions
Program Related Investments Total0ProgramRelatedInvestmentsTotal
Amounts Paid Acq Charitable Assets0AmountsPaidAcqCharitableAssets
Amounts Set Aside Suitability Test0AmountsSetAsideSuitabilityTest
Amounts Set Aside Cash Distri Test0AmountsSetAsideCashDistriTest
Qualifying Distributions605000QualifyingDistributions
Adj Qualifying Distributions605000AdjQualifyingDistributions

Undistributed Income UndistributedIncome

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Distributable Amount As Adjusted528304DistributableAmountAsAdjusted
Undistributed Income Prior Year0UndistributedIncomePriorYear
Prior Year12010PriorYear1
Prior Year22009PriorYear2
Prior Year32008PriorYear3
Total For Prior Years0TotalForPriorYears
Excess Distri Carryover Year5262256ExcessDistriCarryoverYear5
Excess Distri Carryover Year4585897ExcessDistriCarryoverYear4
Excess Distri Carryover Year3411067ExcessDistriCarryoverYear3
Excess Distri Carryover Year2193394ExcessDistriCarryoverYear2
Excess Distri Carryover Year1180185ExcessDistriCarryoverYear1
Total Excess Distri Carryover1632799TotalExcessDistriCarryover
Qualifying Distributions605000QualifyingDistributions
Applied To Year10AppliedToYear1
Applied To Current Year528304AppliedToCurrentYear
Remaining Distri From Corpus76696RemainingDistriFromCorpus
Total Corpus1709495TotalCorpus
Prior Year Undistributed Income0PriorYearUndistributedIncome
Taxable Amount10TaxableAmount1
Taxable Amount20TaxableAmount2
Undistributed Income CY0UndistributedIncomeCY
Excess Distri Cyov From Year5262256ExcessDistriCyovFromYear5
Excess Distri Cyov To Next Year1447239ExcessDistriCyovToNextYear
Excess From Year4585897ExcessFromYear4
Excess From Year3411067ExcessFromYear3
Excess From Year2193394ExcessFromYear2
Excess From Year1180185ExcessFromYear1
Excess From Current Year76696ExcessFromCurrentYear
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Private Operating FoundationsPrivateOperatingFoundations

Supplementary Information SupplementaryInformation

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Contributing ManagerNONEContributingManager
Shareholder ManagerNONEShareholderManager
Only Contributes To PreselectedXOnlyContributesToPreselected

Grant Or Contri Paid During Year GrantOrContriPaidDuringYear (8 entries)

Address Line1RecipientUSAddress/AddressLine1CityRecipientUSAddress/CityStateRecipientUSAddress/StateZIP CodeRecipientUSAddress/ZIPCodeRecipient RelationshipRecipientRelationshipPurpose Of Grant Or ContributionPurposeOfGrantOrContributionAmountAmount
EXPONENTS INC
151 WEST 26TH STREET 3RD FLOORNEW YORKNY10001NONEUNRESTRICTED$425,000
MADEIRA SCHOOL
8328 GEORGETOWN PIKEMCLEANVA22102NONEUNRESTRICTED$10,000
COUNCIL ON HEMISPHERIC AFFAIRS
1250 CONNECTICUT AVENUEWASHINGTONDC20036NONEUNRESTRICTED$30,000
UNION STATION HOMELESS SERVICES
235 EAST HOLLY STREETPASADENACA91101NONEUNRESTRICTED$25,000
TEAMWORK FOUNDATION
478 GERARD AVENUEBRONXNY10451NONEUNRESTRICTED$55,000
VASSAR COLLEGE
124 RAYMOND AVENUEPOUGHKEEPSIENY12604NONEUNRESTRICTED$5,000
CHILDREN OF BELLEVUE
462 FIRST AVENUENEW YORKNY10016NONEUNRESTRICTED$50,000
HOUSING SYMPHONY ORCHESTRA
51 WEST 86TH STREETNEW YORKNY10024NONEUNRESTRICTED$5,000
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Tot Grant Or Contri Paid During Year605000TotGrantOrContriPaidDuringYear

Analysis Income Producing Acty AnalysisIncomeProducingActy

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Fees Contracts From Govt AgenciesFeesContractsFromGovtAgencies
Membership Dues And AssessmentsMembershipDuesAndAssessments

Int On Savings And Temp Cash Invst IntOnSavingsAndTempCashInvst

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Exclusion Code14ExclusionCode

Dividends And Int From Sec Part VII DividendsAndIntFromSecPartVII

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Exclusion Code14ExclusionCode
Exclusion$290,714ExclusionAmount
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Net Rental Incm Re Debt Fincd PropNetRentalIncmReDebtFincdProp
Net Rntl Incm Re Not Debt Fincd PropNetRntlIncmReNotDebtFincdProp
Net Rental Incm Personal PropertyNetRentalIncmPersonalProperty

Other Investment Income Part VII OtherInvestmentIncomePartVII

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Exclusion Code19ExclusionCode

Gain Sales Assets Oth Than Invntry GainSalesAssetsOthThanInvntry

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Exclusion Code18ExclusionCode
Exclusion$402,534ExclusionAmount
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Net Income Loss From Special EventsNetIncomeLossFromSpecialEvents
Gross Profit Loss Sales Of InvntryGrossProfitLossSalesOfInvntry

Subtotals Part XVIA SubtotalsPartXVIA

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Exclusion$693,248ExclusionAmount
FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Total Part XVIA693248TotalPartXVIA

Trnsfr Tr Rln With Noncharitable EO TrnsfrTrRlnWithNoncharitableEO

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Trnsfr Of Cash To Noncharitable EOfalseTrnsfrOfCashToNoncharitableEO
Trnsfr Oth Assets Noncharitable EOfalseTrnsfrOthAssetsNoncharitableEO
Sales Or Exchanges Of AssetsfalseSalesOrExchangesOfAssets
Purchase Assets Noncharitable EOfalsePurchaseAssetsNoncharitableEO
Rental Of Facilities EtcfalseRentalOfFacilitiesEtc
Reimbursement ArrangementsfalseReimbursementArrangements
Loans Or Loan GuaranteesfalseLoansOrLoanGuarantees
Performance Of Services EtcfalsePerformanceOfServicesEtc
Sharing Of Facilities EtcfalseSharingOfFacilitiesEtc
Relationships Noncharitable E OsfalseRelationshipsNoncharitableEOs

Accounting Fees Schedule AccountingFeesSchedule

Accounting Fees AccountingFees

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
CategoryACCOUNTING FEESCategory
Amount$9,375Amount

Depreciation Schedule DepreciationSchedule

Investments Corp Bonds Schedule InvestmentsCorpBondsSchedule

Investments Corp Bonds InvestmentsCorpBonds

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
Name Of BondSEE SCHEDULE ATTACHED - ZZJCFDNameOfBond

Investments Corp Stock Schedule InvestmentsCorpStockSchedule

Investments Corp Stock InvestmentsCorpStock (2 entries)

Name Of StockNameOfStockEOY Book ValueEOYBookValueEOYFMVEOYFMV
SEE SCHEDULE ATTACHED - ZZJCFD42790036365954
SEE SCHEDULE ATTACHED - ZZJCFN21048092499623

Investments Other Schedule2 InvestmentsOtherSchedule2

Investments Other InvestmentsOther (2 entries)

Category Or ItemCategoryOrItemListed At Cost Or FMVListedAtCostOrFMV
APCO LIQUIDATING TRUSTAT COST
MB ABSOLUTE RETURN - TAX BASISAT COST

Land Etc Schedule2 LandEtcSchedule2

Other Assets Schedule OtherAssetsSchedule

Other Assets OtherAssets (3 entries)

DescriptionDescriptionBOY Book ValueBOYBookValueEOY Book ValueEOYBookValueEOYFMVEOYFMV
APCO LIQUIDATING TRUST10201020
MB ABSOLUTE RETURN - TAX BASIS4361043610
MUTUAL FUNDS - ZZJCFDN146000014600001561060

Other Expenses Schedule OtherExpensesSchedule

Other Expenses OtherExpenses (3 entries)

DescriptionDescriptionRevenue And Expenses Per BooksRevenueAndExpensesPerBooksNet Investment IncomeNetInvestmentIncome
FILING FEES750
BANK FEES100
ADR FEES3838

Other Increases Schedule OtherIncreasesSchedule

Other Increases OtherIncreases

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
DescriptionROUNDINGDescription
Amount$1Amount

Other Professional Fees Schedule OtherProfessionalFeesSchedule

Other Professional Fees OtherProfessionalFees

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
CategoryINVESTMENT ADVISORY FEESCategory
Amount$58,403Amount
Net Investment Income58403NetInvestmentIncome

Taxes Schedule TaxesSchedule

Taxes Taxes

FieldValueIRS element (for citing)
CategoryFEDERAL TAXESCategory
Amount$19,500Amount

Comments

Anonymous: no account or email. Up to 2,000 characters, at most one link. Comments are checked automatically; some wait for review.