CHARLES AND PATRICIA ROCKWOOD FAMILY FOUNDATION: Form 990PF, tax year 2018
View the entire original 990 at ProPublica ↗
- Organization
- CHARLES AND PATRICIA ROCKWOOD FAMILY FOUNDATION (EIN 46-4085906)
- Tax period
- 2018-01-01 to 2018-12-31
- Filed
- 2019-12-17
- IRS object ID
- 201913519349100601
- Schema version
- 2018v3.1
- Source
- Download XML · Original 990 at ProPublica
Every field in the e-filed return. Faint text is the IRS element name, for citing.
Return header ReturnHeader
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Return | 2019-12-17T10:40:23-05:00 | ReturnTs |
| Tax Period End | 2018-12-31 | TaxPeriodEndDt |
Preparer Firm PreparerFirmGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Preparer Firm EIN | 455202354 | PreparerFirmEIN |
Preparer Firm Name PreparerFirmName
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Business Name Line1 | KRUPPA NELSON & KOVNER PLLC | BusinessNameLine1Txt |
Preparer US Address PreparerUSAddress
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Address Line1 | 8122 DATAPOINT DRIVE SUITE 250 | AddressLine1Txt |
| City | SAN ANTONIO | CityNm |
| State Abbreviation | TX | StateAbbreviationCd |
| ZIP | 78229 | ZIPCd |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Return Type | 990PF | ReturnTypeCd |
| Tax Period Begin | 2018-01-01 | TaxPeriodBeginDt |
Filer Filer
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| EIN | 464085906 | EIN |
Business Name BusinessName
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Business Name Line1 | THE CHARLES & PATRICIA ROCKWOOD FAMILY FOUNDATION | BusinessNameLine1Txt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Business Name Control | CHAR | BusinessNameControlTxt |
US Address USAddress
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Address Line1 | 6004 POINT COMANCHE | AddressLine1Txt |
| City | SAN ANTONIO | CityNm |
| State Abbreviation | TX | StateAbbreviationCd |
| ZIP | 78257 | ZIPCd |
Business Officer BusinessOfficerGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Person | PETER ROCKWOOD | PersonNm |
| Person Title | CFO | PersonTitleTxt |
| Phone | 2103858277 | PhoneNum |
| Signature | 2019-04-02 | SignatureDt |
| Discuss With Paid Preparer | Yes (true) | DiscussWithPaidPreparerInd |
Preparer Person PreparerPersonGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Preparer Person | MARK H NELSON CPA | PreparerPersonNm |
| PTIN | P00366214 | PTIN |
| Phone | 2106945945 | PhoneNum |
| Preparation | 2019-12-17 | PreparationDt |
Filing Security Information FilingSecurityInformation
IP Address IPAddress
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| I Pv4 Address | 24.73.249.54 | IPv4AddressTxt |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| IP | 2019-12-17 | IPDt |
| IP Tm | 10:47:32 | IPTm |
| Federal Original Submission Id | 7064832019351wnp3owv | FederalOriginalSubmissionId |
| Federal Original Submission Id | 2019-12-17 | FederalOriginalSubmissionIdDt |
| Filing License Type | P | FilingLicenseTypeCd |
| At Submission Creation Device Id | 0B7FE204997BE5DA8D62896025EDCE2BDE4310DB | AtSubmissionCreationDeviceId |
| At Submission Filing Device Id | 0B7FE204997BE5DA8D62896025EDCE2BDE4310DB | AtSubmissionFilingDeviceId |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Tax | 2018 | TaxYr |
| Build TS | 2020-04-17 16:48:07Z | BuildTS |
Form 990-PF IRS990PF
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Organization501c3 Exempt PF | Yes (X) | Organization501c3ExemptPFInd |
| FMV Assets EOY | $55,280 | FMVAssetsEOYAmt |
| Method Of Accounting Cash | Yes (X) | MethodOfAccountingCashInd |
Analysis Of Revenue And Expenses AnalysisOfRevenueAndExpenses
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Contri Rcvd Rev And Expnss | $2,500 | ContriRcvdRevAndExpnssAmt |
| Schedule B Not Required | Yes (X) | ScheduleBNotRequiredInd |
| Total Rev And Expnss | $2,500 | TotalRevAndExpnssAmt |
| Total Net Invst Incm | $0 | TotalNetInvstIncmAmt |
| Accounting Fees Rev And Expnss | $530 | AccountingFeesRevAndExpnssAmt |
| Accounting Fees Chrtbl Prps | $530 | AccountingFeesChrtblPrpsAmt |
| Tot Opr Expenses Rev And Expnss | $530 | TotOprExpensesRevAndExpnssAmt |
| Tot Opr Expenses Net Invst Incm | $0 | TotOprExpensesNetInvstIncmAmt |
| Tot Opr Expenses Dsbrs Chrtbl | $530 | TotOprExpensesDsbrsChrtblAmt |
| Contri Paid Rev And Expnss | $1,995 | ContriPaidRevAndExpnssAmt |
| Contri Paid Dsbrs Chrtbl | $1,995 | ContriPaidDsbrsChrtblAmt |
| Total Expenses Rev And Expnss | $2,525 | TotalExpensesRevAndExpnssAmt |
| Total Expenses Net Invst Incm | $0 | TotalExpensesNetInvstIncmAmt |
| Total Expenses Dsbrs Chrtbl | $2,525 | TotalExpensesDsbrsChrtblAmt |
| Excess Revenue Over Expenses | -$25 | ExcessRevenueOverExpensesAmt |
| Net Investment Income | $0 | NetInvestmentIncomeAmt |
| Adjusted Net Income | $0 | AdjustedNetIncomeAmt |
Form990 PF Balance Sheets Form990PFBalanceSheetsGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Cash BOY | $55,305 | CashBOYAmt |
| Cash EOY | $55,280 | CashEOYAmt |
| Cash EOYFMV | $55,280 | CashEOYFMVAmt |
| Total Assets BOY | $55,305 | TotalAssetsBOYAmt |
| Total Assets EOY | $55,280 | TotalAssetsEOYAmt |
| Total Assets EOYFMV | $55,280 | TotalAssetsEOYFMVAmt |
| Total Liabilities BOY | $0 | TotalLiabilitiesBOYAmt |
| Total Liabilities EOY | $0 | TotalLiabilitiesEOYAmt |
| Org Does Not Follow SFAS117 | Yes (X) | OrgDoesNotFollowSFAS117Ind |
| Capital Stock BOY | $55,305 | CapitalStockBOYAmt |
| Capital Stock EOY | $55,280 | CapitalStockEOYAmt |
| Tot Net Ast Or Fund Balances BOY | $55,305 | TotNetAstOrFundBalancesBOYAmt |
| Tot Net Ast Or Fund Balances EOY | $55,280 | TotNetAstOrFundBalancesEOYAmt |
| Total Liabilities Net Ast BOY | $55,305 | TotalLiabilitiesNetAstBOYAmt |
| Total Liabilities Net Ast EOY | $55,280 | TotalLiabilitiesNetAstEOYAmt |
Chg In Net Assets Fund Balances ChgInNetAssetsFundBalancesGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Tot Net Ast Or Fund Balances BOY | $55,305 | TotNetAstOrFundBalancesBOYAmt |
| Excess Revenue Over Expenses | -$25 | ExcessRevenueOverExpensesAmt |
| Subtotal | $55,280 | SubtotalAmt |
| Tot Net Ast Or Fund Balances EOY | $55,280 | TotNetAstOrFundBalancesEOYAmt |
Qlfy Und Sect4940e Reduced Tax QlfyUndSect4940eReducedTaxGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Liable Section4942 Tax | false | LiableSection4942TaxInd |
| Adjusted Qlfy Distri Yr1 | $3,122 | AdjustedQlfyDistriYr1Amt |
| Net Vl Noncharitable Assets Yr1 | $54,475 | NetVlNoncharitableAssetsYr1Amt |
| Distribution Yr1 | 0.057311 | DistributionYr1Rt |
| Adjusted Qlfy Distri Yr2 | $4,050 | AdjustedQlfyDistriYr2Amt |
| Net Vl Noncharitable Assets Yr2 | $57,551 | NetVlNoncharitableAssetsYr2Amt |
| Distribution Yr2 | 0.070372 | DistributionYr2Rt |
| Adjusted Qlfy Distri Yr3 | $4,520 | AdjustedQlfyDistriYr3Amt |
| Net Vl Noncharitable Assets Yr3 | $61,796 | NetVlNoncharitableAssetsYr3Amt |
| Distribution Yr3 | 0.073144 | DistributionYr3Rt |
| Adjusted Qlfy Distri Yr4 | $2,998 | AdjustedQlfyDistriYr4Amt |
| Net Vl Noncharitable Assets Yr4 | $60,204 | NetVlNoncharitableAssetsYr4Amt |
| Distribution Yr4 | 0.049797 | DistributionYr4Rt |
| Adjusted Qlfy Distri Yr5 | $5 | AdjustedQlfyDistriYr5Amt |
| Net Vl Noncharitable Assets Yr5 | $13,789 | NetVlNoncharitableAssetsYr5Amt |
| Distribution Yr5 | 0.000363 | DistributionYr5Rt |
| Total Distribution | 0.250987 | TotalDistributionRt |
| Average Distribution | 0.050197 | AverageDistributionRt |
| Net Vl Noncharitable Assets | $54,451 | NetVlNoncharitableAssetsAmt |
| Adj Net Vl Noncharitable Assets | $2,733 | AdjNetVlNoncharitableAssetsAmt |
| Adj Nonchrtbl Net Invst Incm Pct | $2,733 | AdjNonchrtblNetInvstIncmPctAmt |
| Qualifying Distributions | $2,525 | QualifyingDistributionsAmt |
Excise Tax Based On Invst Incm ExciseTaxBasedOnInvstIncmGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Investment Income Excise Tax | $0 | InvestmentIncomeExciseTaxAmt |
| Tax Under Section511 | $0 | TaxUnderSection511Amt |
| Subtitle A Tax | $0 | SubtitleATaxAmt |
| Tax Based On Investment Income | $0 | TaxBasedOnInvestmentIncomeAmt |
Statements Regarding Acty StatementsRegardingActyGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Legislative Political Acty | false | LegislativePoliticalActyInd |
| More Than100 Spent | false | MoreThan100SpentInd |
| Form1120 POL Filed | false | Form1120POLFiledInd |
| Activities Not Previously Rpt | false | ActivitiesNotPreviouslyRptInd |
| Changes To Articles Or Bylaws | false | ChangesToArticlesOrBylawsInd |
| Unrelated Bus Incm Over Limit | false | UnrelatedBusIncmOverLimitInd |
| Organization Dissolved Etc | false | OrganizationDissolvedEtcInd |
| Section508e Rqr Satisfied | false | Section508eRqrSatisfiedInd |
| At Least5000 In Assets | Yes (true) | AtLeast5000InAssetsInd |
| Org Report Or Register State | TX | OrgReportOrRegisterStateCd |
| Form990 PF Filed With Atty Gen | Yes (true) | Form990PFFiledWithAttyGenInd |
| Private Operating Foundation | false | PrivateOperatingFoundationInd |
| New Substantial Contributors | false | NewSubstantialContributorsInd |
| Own Controlled Entity | false | OwnControlledEntityInd |
| Donor Advised Fund | false | DonorAdvisedFundInd |
| Comply With Public Insp Rqr | Yes (true) | ComplyWithPublicInspRqrInd |
| Individual With Books | PETER ROCKWOOD | IndividualWithBooksNm |
| Phone | 2103858277 | PhoneNum |
Location Of Books US Address LocationOfBooksUSAddress
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Address Line1 | 6004 POINT COMANCHE | AddressLine1Txt |
| City | SAN ANTONIO | CityNm |
| State Abbreviation | TX | StateAbbreviationCd |
| ZIP | 78257 | ZIPCd |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Foreign Accounts Question | false | ForeignAccountsQuestionInd |
Statements Regarding Acty4720 StatementsRegardingActy4720Grp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Sale Or Exch Disqualified Prsn | false | SaleOrExchDisqualifiedPrsnInd |
| Brrw Or Lend Disqualified Prsn | false | BrrwOrLendDisqualifiedPrsnInd |
| Furn Goods Disqualified Prsn | false | FurnGoodsDisqualifiedPrsnInd |
| Pay Comp Disqualified Prsn | false | PayCompDisqualifiedPrsnInd |
| Transfer Ast Disqualified Prsn | false | TransferAstDisqualifiedPrsnInd |
| Payment To Government Official | false | PaymentToGovernmentOfficialInd |
| Uncorrected Prior Acts | false | UncorrectedPriorActsInd |
| Undistributed Income PY | false | UndistributedIncomePYInd |
| Undistr Incm Sect4942a2 Not App | false | UndistrIncmSect4942a2NotAppInd |
| Business Holdings | false | BusinessHoldingsInd |
| Jeopardy Investments | false | JeopardyInvestmentsInd |
| Uncorrected PY Jeopardy Invst | false | UncorrectedPYJeopardyInvstInd |
| Influence Legislation | false | InfluenceLegislationInd |
| Influence Election | false | InfluenceElectionInd |
| Grants To Individuals | false | GrantsToIndividualsInd |
| Grants To Organizations | false | GrantsToOrganizationsInd |
| Noncharitable Purpose | false | NoncharitablePurposeInd |
| Rcv Fnds To Pay Prsnl Bnft Cntrct | false | RcvFndsToPayPrsnlBnftCntrctInd |
| Pay Premiums Prsnl Bnft Cntrct | false | PayPremiumsPrsnlBnftCntrctInd |
| Prohibited Tax Shelter Trans | false | ProhibitedTaxShelterTransInd |
| Subj To Tax Rmnrtn Ex Prcht Pymt | false | SubjToTaxRmnrtnExPrchtPymtInd |
Officer Dir Trst Key Empl Info OfficerDirTrstKeyEmplInfoGrp
Officer Dir Trst Key Empl OfficerDirTrstKeyEmplGrp (9 entries)
| Address Line1USAddress/AddressLine1Txt | CityUSAddress/CityNm | State AbbreviationUSAddress/StateAbbreviationCd | ZIPUSAddress/ZIPCd | TitleTitleTxt | Average Hrs Per Wk Devoted To PosAverageHrsPerWkDevotedToPosRt | CompensationCompensationAmt | Employee Benefit ProgramEmployeeBenefitProgramAmt | Expense Account Other AllwncExpenseAccountOtherAllwncAmt |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PETER ROCKWOOD | ||||||||
| 6004 POINT COMANCHE | SAN ANTONIO | TX | 78257 | CFO | 8.00 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| CHARLES A ROCKWOOD JR | ||||||||
| 105 VIA FINITA | SAN ANTONIO | TX | 78229 | CHAIRMAN OF BD | 0.00 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| VIRGINIA SAVAGE | ||||||||
| 9536 FAWN DRIVE | BOERNE | TX | 78006 | PRESIDENT | 0.00 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| PAUL ROCKWOOD | ||||||||
| 26575 KARSCH ROAD | BOERNE | TX | 78006 | VP | 0.00 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| MARK ROCKWOOD | ||||||||
| 14114 SAGE TRAIL | SAN ANTONIO | TX | 78231 | VP | 0.00 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| DAVID ROCKWOOD | ||||||||
| 2101 PLUMBROOK DRIVE | AUSTIN | TX | 78746 | SECR | 1.00 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| STEPHEN ROCKWOOD | ||||||||
| 370 W HORSESHOE RD | TALLAHASSEE | FL | 32317 | VP | 0.00 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| ANDREW ROCKWOOD | ||||||||
| 13 ROYAL OAKS | FREDERICKSBURG | TX | 78624 | VP | 0.00 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| JEFFREY ROCKWOOD | ||||||||
| 5801 OTTENHOME | AUSTIN | TX | 78738 | TREAS | 0.00 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Comp Of Hghst Pd Empl Or NONE | NONE | CompOfHghstPdEmplOrNONETxt |
| Other Employee Paid Over50k | 0 | OtherEmployeePaidOver50kCnt |
| Comp Of Hghst Pd Cntrct Or NONE | NONE | CompOfHghstPdCntrctOrNONETxt |
Summary Of Direct Chrtbl Acty SummaryOfDirectChrtblActyGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Description1 | NA | Description1Txt |
| Expenses1 | $0 | Expenses1Amt |
Sum Of Program Related Invst SumOfProgramRelatedInvstGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Description1 | NA | Description1Txt |
| Expenses1 | $0 | Expenses1Amt |
Minimum Investment Return MinimumInvestmentReturnGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Average Monthly FMV Of Sec | $0 | AverageMonthlyFMVOfSecAmt |
| Average Monthly Cash Balances | $55,280 | AverageMonthlyCashBalancesAmt |
| FMV All Other Noncharitable Ast | $0 | FMVAllOtherNoncharitableAstAmt |
| Total FMV Of Unused Assets | $55,280 | TotalFMVOfUnusedAssetsAmt |
| Acquisition Indebtedness | $0 | AcquisitionIndebtednessAmt |
| Adjusted Total FMV Of Unused Ast | $55,280 | AdjustedTotalFMVOfUnusedAstAmt |
| Cash Deemed Charitable | $829 | CashDeemedCharitableAmt |
| Net Vl Noncharitable Assets | $54,451 | NetVlNoncharitableAssetsAmt |
| Minimum Investment Return | $2,723 | MinimumInvestmentReturnAmt |
Distributable Amount DistributableAmountGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum Investment Return | $2,723 | MinimumInvestmentReturnAmt |
| Distributable Before Adj | $2,723 | DistributableBeforeAdjAmt |
| Distributable Before Ded | $2,723 | DistributableBeforeDedAmt |
| Distributable As Adjusted | $2,723 | DistributableAsAdjustedAmt |
Qualifying Distri Part XII QualifyingDistriPartXIIGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Expenses And Contributions | $2,525 | ExpensesAndContributionsAmt |
| Qualifying Distributions | $2,525 | QualifyingDistributionsAmt |
| Adjusted Qualifying Distri | $2,525 | AdjustedQualifyingDistriAmt |
Undistributed Income UndistributedIncomeGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Distributable As Adjusted | $2,723 | DistributableAsAdjustedAmt |
| Excess Distribution Cyov Yr3 | $881 | ExcessDistributionCyovYr3Amt |
| Excess Distribution Cyov Yr2 | $1,172 | ExcessDistributionCyovYr2Amt |
| Excess Distribution Cyov Yr1 | $398 | ExcessDistributionCyovYr1Amt |
| Total Excess Distribution Cyov | $2,451 | TotalExcessDistributionCyovAmt |
| Qualifying Distributions | $2,525 | QualifyingDistributionsAmt |
| Applied To Current Year | $2,525 | AppliedToCurrentYearAmt |
| Excess Distri Cyov App CY Corpus | $198 | ExcessDistriCyovAppCYCorpusAmt |
| Excess Distribution Cyov App CY | $198 | ExcessDistributionCyovAppCYAmt |
| Total Corpus | $2,253 | TotalCorpusAmt |
| Undistributed Income CY | $0 | UndistributedIncomeCYAmt |
| Excess Distri Cyov To Next Yr | $2,253 | ExcessDistriCyovToNextYrAmt |
| Excess From Year3 | $683 | ExcessFromYear3Amt |
| Excess From Year2 | $1,172 | ExcessFromYear2Amt |
| Excess From Year1 | $398 | ExcessFromYear1Amt |
Supplementary Information SupplementaryInformationGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Contributing Manager | NA | ContributingManagerNm |
| Shareholder Manager | NA | ShareholderManagerNm |
| Only Contri To Preselected | Yes (X) | OnlyContriToPreselectedInd |
Grant Or Contribution Pd Dur Yr GrantOrContributionPdDurYrGrp (2 entries)
| Address Line1RecipientUSAddress/AddressLine1Txt | CityRecipientUSAddress/CityNm | State AbbreviationRecipientUSAddress/StateAbbreviationCd | ZIPRecipientUSAddress/ZIPCd | Recipient Foundation StatusRecipientFoundationStatusTxt | Grant Or Contribution PurposeGrantOrContributionPurposeTxt | AmtAmt |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EPILEPSY FOUNDATION OF CENTRAL SO | ||||||
| 8601 VILLAGE DR STE 220 | SAN ANTONIO | TX | 78217 | PC | TO ASSIST IN THE RESEARCH OF EPILEPSY | $1,795 |
| FRIENDS OF THE LIBRARY OF TEXAS | ||||||
| 201 E 26TH STREET | BRYAN | TX | 77803 | PC | TO PROMOTE READING | $200 |
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Total Grant Or Contri Pd Dur Yr | $1,995 | TotalGrantOrContriPdDurYrAmt |
| Total Grant Or Contri Apprv Fut | $0 | TotalGrantOrContriApprvFutAmt |
Trnsfr Trans Rln Nonchrtbl EO TrnsfrTransRlnNonchrtblEOGrp
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Trnsfr Of Cash To Nonchrtbl EO | false | TrnsfrOfCashToNonchrtblEOInd |
| Trnsfr Other Asset Nonchrtbl EO | false | TrnsfrOtherAssetNonchrtblEOInd |
| Sales Or Exchanges Of Assets | false | SalesOrExchangesOfAssetsInd |
| Purchase Of Assets Nonchrtbl EO | false | PurchaseOfAssetsNonchrtblEOInd |
| Rental Of Facilities Oth Assets | false | RentalOfFacilitiesOthAssetsInd |
| Reimbursement Arrangements | false | ReimbursementArrangementsInd |
| Loans Or Loan Guarantees | false | LoansOrLoanGuaranteesInd |
| Performance Of Services Etc | false | PerformanceOfServicesEtcInd |
| Sharing Of Facilities Etc | false | SharingOfFacilitiesEtcInd |
| Relationships Nonchrtbl EO | false | RelationshipsNonchrtblEOInd |
Accounting Fees Schedule AccountingFeesSchedule
Accounting Fees Detail AccountingFeesDetail
| Field | Value | IRS element (for citing) |
|---|---|---|
| Category | KRUPPA NELSON & KOVNER | CategoryTxt |
| Amt | $530 | Amt |
| Net Investment Income | $0 | NetInvestmentIncomeAmt |
| Adjusted Net Income | $0 | AdjustedNetIncomeAmt |
| Disbursements Charitable Prps | $530 | DisbursementsCharitablePrpsAmt |
Comments